Its a fine recording....he's singing Puccini for Godsakes not Mozart...if you want to hear real sliding around then opt for the Carreras recording of this....but I like that recording also......
To my ear it sounds to me as if he is sliding a little too much around.I think this piece deserves operatic treatment( of course) but there is simply too much portamento for my liking. Seems to be more Mellochi method rather than Bel Canto in style, not best suited to his voice . I have much respect for Roberto and his previous work but with great sincerity I feel he has gone off track with this recording.
1 silly guy ! It's perfectly sung and it's exactly the style necessary for this aria, bravo Roberto (again !) !
guilhem32 2 months ago
große Alagna. Er war wirklich, wie er selbst einmal sagte Pavarotti, einer der größten Stimmen unserer Zeit. wunderbar
mitegive 5 months ago
Its a fine recording....he's singing Puccini for Godsakes not Mozart...if you want to hear real sliding around then opt for the Carreras recording of this....but I like that recording also......
peacocktravels 1 year ago
yeah and that's tooo tooo slow.
brandistocker 2 years ago
To my ear it sounds to me as if he is sliding a little too much around.I think this piece deserves operatic treatment( of course) but there is simply too much portamento for my liking. Seems to be more Mellochi method rather than Bel Canto in style, not best suited to his voice . I have much respect for Roberto and his previous work but with great sincerity I feel he has gone off track with this recording.
purpletenor 2 years ago