So what Is It? - Red Dwarf - BBC comedy

[SavageSaboteur01]

This is probably my 2nd favourite scene from Red Dwarf, beaten only by the next scene.

[Truestory411]

was look at a list of suggested videos and saw this one saying "so what is it?" then the one below it which said "it's a banana" !

[AbhiB]

2 people still don't know what it is

[Campernicus]

I'd love to watch this without that horrid laugh-track.

[beato123]

@Campernicus It was filmed in front of an audience up until series 7.

[unstableordinance]

@Campernicus Its a live audience, that their performing in front of, u know that right?

[thatsmrlistersir]

<3

[richardjuk]

Cracks me up when Lister says "Someone punch him out!"

[paranoidandroidRH]

I searched this thinking of Stasis Leak. xD

[ShroudedFury]

Oh someone punch him out!!!

Best one liner ever lol

[jwlbailey]

@ShroudedFury Completely agree

[ThomasTrue]

Only joking.

[SolsburyHill22]

imagine if this happened in reality

[knaan163]

shame on the bbc for putting adverts in their videos

[PhyOSPhyOS]

@knaan163 Shame on the BBC for putting adverts in THEIR videos, that THEY created, with THEIR money, and which you enjoy for free? Shame on you.

[knaan163]

@PhyOSPhyOS hey man the bbc is not for profit, they shouldnt show ads - what the fuck do you care anyway

[PhyOSPhyOS]

@knaan163 So what if it's not for profit? The UK government pays for it, with taxpayer's money. If they use ads, its cost decreases considerably and therefore less money is spent on it, and more on other (more important) things. What the hell do you care that there are ads, anyway.

[knaan163]

@PhyOSPhyOS it's unethical and takes longer, its just how i feel. Fuck off

[PhyOSPhyOS]

@knaan163 Unethical? You're hilarious. What are you, 12? Look up the word "ethics", because you don't know what it means.

"It's just how I feel" Good for you. Pay them so they remove ads, then. "Fuck off" Oh, sorry, apparently you're the only one who can say what he thinks. If you don't want replies, don't post comments in a first place.

[knaan163]

@PhyOSPhyOS STOP SENDING ME MESSAGES. I'm waiting for an important email and I keep receiving these irritating notifications with you arguing the toss over a really insignificant comment. Now go away, fuck off

[PhyOSPhyOS]

@knaan163 "I'm waiting for an important email" Sure.

Your comment wasn't just insignificant, it was also stupid.

"Now go away, fuck off" Nope. Welcome to the internet.

[knaan163]

@PhyOSPhyOS I was waiting to see if I'd got a job you utter utter fuckwit. Stop dissecting my sentences as well, you fucking pretentious twat. I hate the advertising industry okay? They're on the whole morally bankrupt, talentless and tactless. I think they're a sad reminder of the materialistic society which we live in. And don't fucking dissect another sentence - it's easy, it just puts you in a bad light and makes me more irritated

[PhyOSPhyOS]

@knaan163 You take Youtube comments too seriously.

[knaan163]

@PhyOSPhyOS so do you apparently, or you wouldn't have replied to my initial comment and started all this bullshit.

[PhyOSPhyOS]

@knaan163 I don't`care about the comments, I care about what you think. The BBC provides content, and ads are necessary. You want to remove the ads (which you can skip) and yet you want to watch the video, quite selfish. "It's unethical", quite stupid. Again, check the definition for "ethics" because you don't know what it means.

[knaan163]

@PhyOSPhyOS why do you care what I think? It was such a mild comment anyway. It's not like I said 'I hate the BBC' My point is that no one pays attention to the adverts - also I can't help my hatred towards the advertising industry, I think it's a morally bankrupt industry, and it's therefore unethical for a non profit group like the bbc to get involved with them. Besides, I'd be happy to pay more taxes to remove the adverts, thats the point: we pay more to get better quality shit.

[knaan163]

@Pedanticvictory I regret the anger in those comments, I was having a very bad day

[Pedanticvictory]

@PhyOSPhyOS You are being ridiculous

[Mehuge]

best show ever

[Werewolfpokemon]

Two people don't know what it is.

So what is it?

I've never seen one before, no-one has...

[Agui007]

They don't make comedies like that anymore nooooooooooooooo way!

[frezblade]

2 ppl r stuck in a white hole

[Baterine]

For years I have this damn scene stuck in my head over and over again

[LauraDxiaojie]

So what is it then? hehe!

I notice this isn't the only episode where the Cat asks what is it :D

[leftcoast67]

Hey wait a minute? I missed the conversation???

[fakeknife87]

The Truely Best Show From The BBC

[Hollandvancewright]

@fakeknife87 Besides the IT Crowd.

[Colp2]

@Hollandvancewright Noo, this beats the IT Crowd by about 2000 times ;)

IT Crowd = Decent

Red Dwarf = Brilliant

[Hollandvancewright]

@Colp2 I saw season 4 of the IT Crowd, and it's not as funny as the first couple of seasons, so "Red Dwarf = Brilliant".

[paperbea]

So what is it?

[andreaxou]

I love Cat!

[Mount5nowdon]

Cat also says what is it? in series two. Excellent everytime.

[giygasattack]

I love how an IQ of 12,000 still isn't enough to understand what the smeg Rimmer's on about.

[AtheistBrit]

"Oh someone punch him out!"

[Rayzorsharp24]

I love this scene, I know this word for word I've seen it so much!

[MrKingkopite]

Red Dwarf SE4 EP4 White Hole

[VengeanceEthaniel]

I started watching this just now and i remembered this scene and it made me chuckle because i remember what Lister is going to say about CAT and i haven't even got to that part yet lol.

[TauLord1218]

what's the name of this episode?

[RisingDampChamp]

@TauLord1218 White Hole

[MrKoiking1]

@TauLord1218 are you lord of tau as in warhammer 40k

[Hardysamnin]

My fave scene from any episode.

[LeoLex07]

Only joking lol

[Hyperactiveandmad]

Ive never seen one before, no-one has.

[DarkDestiny8000]

"White-hole-spewing-time-engin­es-dead-air-supply-low-advice-­please."

"Excuse me?"

XDDD

[MarxistKnight]

Me and my sister rofl so hard when we watch this scene!

"So what is it?"

"Oh someone punch him out!"

[himynameismick]

So what is it?

Brilliant!

[PROTEK123]

Thats a felt ripper.. its off he table into someones drink lol ...........

[renoo27]

"Oh someone punch him out!" Hahaha.

[BillSwordfish]

So what is it?

[LeoLex07]

A white hole?

[logandarklighter]

I think we've experienced this moment before.

[kingoli123123123]

posibley the greatist show ever!!!!

[BubuGaldwin]

@kingoli123123123 sorry, can't agree... because it is a best show ever!

[Edd731]

hehe such a great show.

[beriking]

i love cat xD

[YayForCake]

We have entered an endless recursion of time...

Heh, clever clever.

[alanb4]

so what is it?

[Indulged1]

The backwards world was the best when the cat went for a dump!.

[JoeyPsych]

yeah, defenitly 1 of my favo episodes

[JAMESLCLARK76]

what is it lol

[smarmyalbatross]

lol! "so, what is it?" pmsl

[spaake]

So who is it?

[DeViLiNaHaLo]

I think we've experienced this period of time before sir

[spaake]

Every age, y'age, every generation.

[spaake]

I bet you did, i bet you did... ^^

Greetings

[Drez26]

only joking

[fudgelad]

it didnt get many laughs on set cos most people were confused

[ficklefiend]

Or perhaps they had to film it in random little bits out of sequence then edit it like this?

[niknarnevets]

so what is it only joking

[Razorrack125]

"So what is it?" : )

[umbrellafox]

get out of this one smeghead

[umbrellafox]

so what is it?

(sorry could not resist)

[odin6616]

Someone punch him out!

[Drez26]

I think we exeperienced this period of time before, sir

[Jut187]

so what is it?

[warlockuk]

A _white_ hole?

[jackoadeetayo1]

so what is it?

[MeDigitalProxy]

the best

[DrLilo]

So that thing's spewing time? *hat on* Back into the universe *point*?

[Drez26]

So what is it?

[smivadeefan]

Abahaha! That was great xD

[cargo2oo]

one of the finest RD episodes of all time

[jbmass06]

My favourite RD episode :p

[Rubba5]

Although Talie Toaster works, albeit when you don't want it to.

[SnuggleShinobi]

I think we've just encountered the middle of this conversation!

[AModernMajorGeneral]

My very favortive Red Dwarf clip!!!!!

[someonelikethemoon]

So what is it?

[V1L3]

I believe we've experienced this period of time before.

[Surochan]

Only joking :D

[SiressW]

And this one.

[Drez26]

so what is it?

[darkmessenger84]

Someone punch him out!

[Drez26]

I think we just experienced the middle of this conversation

[CYBERDOODY]

@someonelikethemoon Someone punch him out!

[MistXGames]

@someonelikethemoon only joking

[cornishphilosopher]

@someonelikethemoon will someone punch 'im out!

[domobot123]

i love!!! 1:32 to 1:36 LMAO great episode love it XD

[SloeDaddy]

Great routine! There's another part of this episode where the crew is pestered by a talking toaster. The Red Dwarf writers predicting the computer phenomenon of of "nag ware." "Would you like some toast?" "No! And I don't want to restart my computer, Either!" (Repeat 40 or 50 times, or the length of a work day) whichever is more).

Could you please post this routine as well?