Added: 4 years ago
From: universalmusicgroup
Views: 191,127
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (509)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • lots of people hate america. i personally dont care. i talked to people from all over the world and there are dickheads everywhere. america has cool people. but also stupid ones. just like every other country. before you voice your opinion. look at yourself and those around you.

  • bravo, encore.

  • Opdat wij niet vergeten!

  • mooi gezegd :) kort maar krachtig..

  • I love this song.

    9/11 was not just an attack on america but an attack on the west and our beliefs. I love the fact that when america was attack the other nato country's rallied behind the states.

  • America attack'd themselves.

  • yeah true :)

  • Beautiful....pouring out the pain we all felt on that terrible day in ways we all felt but few could so express....so sad for all whose fundamentalist beliefs so harm the fragility of life

  • Here's plague,disease but worse

    heres man and stupidity

  • i think that song's not about the USA . It's about the september 11th. If USA was a small country we've never seen that video... And I don't mind about your nationality, I think that if you are open minded and possitive it doesn't matter where do you live....I enjoy the song, live 're good band!

  • the song was written before 9/11. it just happened to fit, so it was used as such.

  • People... I got a response to a comment I made a week ago. The response was sincere, short, intelligent and level. It reminded me that we gotta listen to each other, tolerance and compassion. I don't expect you to agree or even like it, but, the other way is ......................overcome­.

  • America an experiment gone wrong? Gee why are we number 1 in so many areas then? You want to see an experiment gone wrong try looking at Palestine or the Sudan for that matter. If you can't make it here then you're fucked.

  • Well said..... i'm not american and i can see that obviously you guys do more right than wrong.

  • @mojomarshaman77 thank you for seein that.

  • See thats exactly what you guys think, outside america many people dislike you, america wants to conquer the world.

  • oke ma nederland is gewoon nice

  • i´m so glad that i born and raised in the netherlands and not in america.

  • I love the world, the world doesnt return the favor. we escape, we run, such is the nature of humanity. Don't get me wrong we are fu**ed up, the world is. We just are a lightning rod for blame. Our ignorance is from being beaten down and trying to escape. If u beat a dog would it not hate u? If u are mad at this video ur the ignorant one for being totally ignorant to a fellow humans pain. America, the fu**ed up experiment when you want to blame some 1 look in a mirror thatt goes for us Aericans

  • MAN IS STUPID, MAN IS IGNORANT, WE ARE JUST SPREAD INTO DIFFERENT SIN AREAS. we are your greedy. People came to America for wealth and freedom so one can see why there is coruption. Luckly i was fortunate enough for a father who remembered why we came to America. My fathers family came to escape the USSR from Lithuania. My family knew the Royal family and we got there asses out of there. We are the result of the worlds sins. we are the Escape route. From religius prosicution, genocide, YOU

  • hell ireland try to tell me that u have a clean slate, same with Russia, U.K., France, Croatia, Italy, Lithuania, none of us can say one country is bad. Spain you had the inquisition, Russia you had czars, U.K. u can't talk at all UR US UK. America is a testiment of all the worlds sins because we are all of ur people who wanted to start over includeing ur trash. I am Native American, Lithuanian, Irish, British, hell i have a little African. When u insult America u insult yourselves.

  • free of this curse i am athiest and the local cristian population hates my refusal to submit, but NO COUNTRY CAN EVER POINT FINGERS WE ARE ALL HUMAN, WE ARE ALL IGNORANT!

  • America is an experiment gone wrong, but when push comes to shove we relay on the fact that we all have a right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. Most of us are stupid but we all understand this rule anyone who trys to subdue this universal right we tend to act brash. Really we try to blame other countries because we cant handle ourselves. Ignorence, violence, crime, all we cant handle because we try to install our beliefs into others includeing ourselves. North is better but not

  • I agree with the Europeans on the topic of an idiotic America, yes most of us are ignorant assholes. I myself am from America and to let the world know America is corupt, stupid, and a cultural wasteland, but death is death. One cannot make death right or wrong because of were it happens. For all you other countries think of a painful tradgedy in your countries. For instance Chernoble, holocost all terrible tradgeties that i wont even think about compareing this to but this is our horrible event

  • Everyone who cares about 9/11 victims should see the movie "Loose Change" and realise that the official story doesn't add up. The movie can be watched for free on YouTube. Wake up people!

  • its not an aprroval for the things that terrorist groups do

  • look thats the fault of a american they think they are everything.(not all americans)

    and that troubles the terrorist groups guitarnublet. btw i am european.

  • I am agreeing with you on that, I am from europe aswell.

  • 09/11/01 -RIP,never forget.

  • I care much for this music. I care a lot for the victims of this cowardly attack. I do not care however for the religious babble and american 'we-will-survive-because-we-ar­e-the-greatest-nation-in-the-w­orld'-attitude inadvertedly tied to it. Beautiful song.

  • Watching the end saying 'imagine world peace' made me laugh cynically. America has been involved in what...90%+ of all armed conflicts in the world, be it directly or indirectly since its founding. Remember, when you point a finger there's four pointing back at you. I see what little hope I had when America voted Obama crushed by the comments I read here. Looks like the mentality change I hoped for in Americans isnt due any time soon. Sad.

  • I agree with yu, it's sad that American's have these twisted ideas of what they're doing is good for the world.

  • We will survive because we are ONE of the greatest nations in this world!

    We will survive because we are rich with the MANY cultures that contribute to the greatness of our country!

    Do not discard everyone just because there are a few bad apples in the bunch!

    Diversity is a beautiful thing!!

    Btw...I AM PROUD TO BE AN AMERICAN but I do believe, "an eye for an eye does make everyone blind!"

  • America is sadly a case of a few good apples in the bunch. Americans in general are full of an unhealthy, almost sickening and unjust patriotism. Yes, you may be the richest and most powerful nation in the world, but on a moral and social level you have a lot to learn. Obama can't change that, only the Americans themselves can. Too bad a lot of people have their had up the behind too far to see it. Also, props for responding in a civil manner to my critisism!

  • I am an American, born and raised, I have to say that I agree with all you have stated. In the age of nations we are the toddler., and, as such, we must grow ... But this SONG is not the platform for this debate. Your statement is not welcome on this track. We are open, we listen.. But our hurt is our own, again, this is NOT the platform for that.

  • Your words couldn't be more true. I am however not the the person who made this the platform for this debate. That does not take away that I was a part in keeping it that way. My apologies, thank you for your kind response. My faith in the world has been somewhat restored through the medium that had pretty much destroyed it.

  • LIVE is amazing!♥

  • RIP this is the most emotive song ever.........it is my funeral song!!

  • bellissima canzone__scoperta grazie al telefilm "the Shied"

  • People of the light will always defeat the people of the darkness. Good bye bin laden and all your diseased followers.

  • peace will never be achieved. ever. every generation has been fighting for it since the beginning of time. just too many conflicting personalities. nobody will ever realize we are people. different beliefs, different ways of life, but still part of the same human race. ahh, this world is sad.

    RIP to all the victims of 9/11. I will never forget this awful day and my condolences to everyone who lost someone on this terrible day. Senseless loss of life for nothing. It still angers me deeply.

  • i have another version of this that aired during the fundraising showing footage of emergency workers trying to help but looking stunned. It was haunting. I watched with stunned silence even though I was working but when i heard this i bawled.  I realized this is what it must have been like when things like Pearl Harbour happened or JFK was assinated because my generation had never seen such thing

    Canada lost 24 people from our country.

  • 8 years on... RIP all 9/11 victims, god bless

  • 8 years on... RIP all 9/11 victims, god bless from the uk! xxxxxxxx

  • Remember all who were lost that day, and the families of those who were lost. They need our love and prayers, especially today.

    Also think about our soldiers, sailors, airmen, and Marines who are fighting over in Iraq and Afghanistan, so that we can overcome the troubles our country is facing.

    God bless America, and thank you Live for putting out this song of hope! =D

  • and honestly with the events that took place on this day.. 8 years ago.. i would think way to many people were in shock to listen to a song that just came out... but it will always be here.... and we will always be able to relate it to this.... awesome song....

  • it was originally meant for this is just happened to come out around the same time....

  • hate to tell you, but bush and his cohorts were the only ones railing against us for he benefit of haliburton and blackwater.

  • peace. imagine peace. an eye for an eye makes the whole world blind.

  • Eight years have passed, and we still have not progressed to a place where we can put asside petty diffrences for the common good of others. May you open your eyes to the light that is around you. The future can be bright if we work together

  • This song was, in the darkest of all ironies, released on Sept 11, 2001. The fact that it was played on the radio on the same day of the horrific attack made the song and the events inseparable. Hardly something you'd listen to on a casual basis.

  • How about the 2800 people that died?

  • Ed with hair, strange

  • Sept 11 is an insult to the tecnology of the aviation industry.

    Insults Boeing 767 modern aircraft sophistication.

    Insults the invention of the blackbox tecnology.

    Insults THE LAWS OF GRAVITY.

    Insults the Building Materials used in the construction of Twin Towers.

  • I love this song, it sends emotions through my body every time i hear it. No thoughts of politics tat would ruin it!

  • this its one of the best songs i ever hear in my live, anyone now if this song won something a vma,grammy anything because its a beautiful song

  • The only problem is people like Bush that try to make us scared of other HUMAN BEINGS. We all look different and we all tend to think slightly different, but we all have a common knowledge!! That knowledge is what can save or destroy us. Make the decision to accept our differences and we may be able to find peace! Heroes are only those who willingly sacrifice their lives to promote things that are for the betterment of mankind and not at the direction or whim of others. THAT IS SACRIFICE!

  • your facking right

  • Blaming bush doesnt solve anything or justify anything, So why waste your time. Everyone knows in the back of their head that you can't blame something like that you blame one 1 person. As good as it makes you feel to be able to push blame on someone so we have someone to be angry at, You know its not true or atleast someday you will. Im not pro bush or any president we have had recently honestly, but they were elected and to think they want anything bad to happen is ignorant and childish.

  • A president of the USA dont need to be evil to be incredible harmful, he just need to be stupid and chose the wrong persons for the spots of big responsability.

  • Yeah! Obama is worse than Bush..LOL

  • Obama the Deceiver

  • y ihate u americanans nfukn knobs oneday ur fuked up opinion wont mean a god damned thing

  • Obama is you president you ignorant prick. Bush was a one of the worst presidents in history look at the facts.

  • yeah, let's bless him for 9-11, iraq, afghanistan and the economic crisis. ;-).

    i'm not saying someone else could prevent 9-11. But the eye for an eye reaction of bush is proven to be a wrong one.

  • Bush sucks

  • one word...AWSOME!!!!!!!

  • Hey badgirl, isn't this a kickass song?

  • we were always free to choose, never free enough to find. it's such a beautiful song.

  • The Bible actually says that peace will be brought by a man who claims to be the Messiah and/or who is worshipped as a Messiah.

  • Please upload this in HD:

    All you need is Love; and I love this music and Video.

  • In memorial of 9/11 casualties.

    R.I.P.

  • lol obama. his religiomn did this

  • i love his voice so much

  • never world peace,

    it's so wrong we hate people that we even don't know!

    we áll are overcome,

    overcome with hate.

    yes my english is crap, dutch!

  • It's the message that matters.

  • hm maybe you are very right

    but we don't always understand the message and then it cán go wrong

    but we'll see it in the following years

    maybe we just have to live how we wíll live?

  • You're right.

    People have hate to each other since the beginning of the humanity,. :S

  • that's to bad isn't it?

    maybe we have to show óur good sides

    and live with love

    even for people who you don't like, because maybe you get well to each other in time, like I did!

    but it's still strange that we have hate!

    have a nice week!

    (oh my english is crap.)

  • Live is epic. people= shit, so no world peace, btw

  • i can't Imagen world peace.

    But this song it nearly makes me cry

  • i know what u mean dude, it makes me cry too

  • Não existe, paz conquistada na guerra, só ódio...

    Quando chegamos ao mundo, nascemos da mesma forma, sem religiões, visão política, dinheiro, raça, nada que nos faça diferentes. Mas herdamos o ódio e a intolerancia, que muitas vezes não compreendemos, só nos ensinam. Quero e vou ensinar pra minha filha, que belo, perfeito e verdadeiro é conviver com a diferença, exercer a tolerancia... chega de olho por olho...e ela vai ser feliz!

  • world peace is never gonna happen.

    America has its own will.

    Not the people but the army and bosses of government. There's hope with Obama but it there will never be a day there will be no bombs exploding anywhere on earth.

    Beautiful song. respect for family of victims of 9/11

  • I have an idea...I am going to start something where I want everyone to on 9/11/09 at 9:11 am watch this youtube video...please tell your friends!

  • This is a wonderful video and yet I wonder if people are really hearing it? Not just just listening. As I read the comments, I still see the same anger, the same hate, and the same battles and ugliness towards people. This is the reason all this happened in 9/11...!! When will we ever learn???

  • you are so f*cking right.

    It just isn't fair that people hate people they don't even know!

    Sorry for my English, i'm dutch ;)

  • IRAN you are doing it!~ im so proud! god you are heroes of the world! please god protect them PROTECT THE IRAN FREEDOM FIGHTERS! amen

  • so long ago and still i'm not getting it out of my head

    many people has died there for nothing!

    why tell me why are people so crazy to do this

    don't they know the people on the building have children ho they left here

    many people can not sleep because it's following them!

    the people on the building who survived it are true hero's for me

    just have a moment of silence please for the

    people who died there

    2 minutes silence on 11/9/2009

    please do it ;) (L)

  • Okay...but it still says something about his personality for having been there as a mature 40 year old man.

  • Last I checked he was the President...I wasn't

  • yet another reason why you don't FUCK with live.

    10/10

  • AMEN

  • Por que será que não conseguimos ter paz nesse mundo?

  • Got to hell!

  • just what are u saying , G

  • Every American should watch this music video on September 11

  • an remember that there were about 3000 persons that die in the 11S, and more than 600000 that die in Irak, more than 90% civil casualties. Remember that you have been manipulated through fear and pain to make far more fear and pain to this world.

  • Definitely the best song ever performed by Live

  • To whoever gave me that negative, I have just one question : Is what I said wrong?

  • using the pain of thousands of deaths to promote your political vision.

  • Eddie is beautiful <3

  • Best song ever

  • Teun ik mis je nog

  • everytime I listen this song I feel like crying but its of the most beautiful song I ever heard

  • Comment removed

  • (dutch people) 2:01 Teunie ik mis je nog

    Haha.

    Great song ;).

  • beautiful song!

    xje-

  • for the dutch ppl: 2:02 'teunie ik mis je nog'

  • for the dutch ppl: 2:02 'teunie ik mis je nog'

    AWESOME SONG

  • haha jij hebt cker dat tv progamma gekeken laatst:P

    great song!!

    respect(L)

  • je kan het ook checken op uitzendinggemist toch

  • the most beautifully song ever!

  • it brings back all the memories, the feeling i had at that time.. Horrible, Just horrible. Al the pictures and movies.. Its hard to forget. Love the song

  • man he looks fucking stupid with hair lol good song though

  • wauw this is a good song i have been working on the 4th floor in the twins i have lost a lot of friends that day

  • Comment removed

  • I like this version of the video better than the version I have on their "Best Of" collection.

  • This is Soo sad it make me cry

    a beautifull song

    its is a good song

  • This is so sad this song it make me cry but he is rait ...... I raid the thinks the say and this is tru .... The only thing we heve to fear is Fear itself ....

  • The line in the beginning saying all people are created equal kinda lets shimmer through that later on they're not any more. This could be the worst hidden separatist remark I've ever seen, or a plain unfortunate choice of words. Amazing touching song either way.

  • I think you're looking in way to deep into this, dont you think?

    people are created equal. full stop. I think that's all they mean to say...

  • Live is one of my all time favorite bands!! Their music has so much meaning. I love every song from Live. I would have to say that this song&Lightning Crashes are my two FAVORITE songs from Live! Those two songs are the most powerful songs they have! !

  • good song makes the people thinking

  • one of the greatest songs on earth !!!

  • Comment removed

  • how can they turn planes flying into some tower into fighting for oil and money in iraq?

    plz tell me

  • they push people to follow primary feelings, like pain, fear and hate. They are cynics, therefore, they only care about themselves. They are so narrow minded that equate their egoism to just focus in money and power. They consider themselves better, because they rule the world telling people what to think.

  • pretty good mate

  • Good song. Peace to all. And I mean ALL.

  • i have no problem with the usa but u were sending money to the ira through its amercian fund raising party that killed hundreds of kids women men young and old frm the uk but bnow u know the pain of having your loved ones blown to bits my thoughts are with the familys

  • the UVF were no better than the IRA

  • simply beautiful!!!!

  • can someone do a piano tutorial for this??? PLZ!!!! someone!!!

  • this song is anti bombing people shut up all of u

  • get a life -.-

  • this video was good

    looking for friends qP

  • Fuck man this song is gread and sooo sed the think you see in the Clip I love it

  • goo song

  • right.. because one atomic bomb is going to end america...

    dumbass..

  • Yeah that bomb on japan came out of nowere and no reason eh?

    Pearl harbor?...hello?

  • fuck u ass hole

  • 2:35 DAI LAMA, SAVE TIBET.

  • Good song.

    Amerika sees this terrible thing, and they do the same things in other countries, will they never learn.

    This no excuse for murders, war, guantanamo bay and things like that.

    let the world leaders grow up, en stop all the war and murder over the world.

    RIP al the people that died at 9-11, and the wars after 9-11.

  • I thought the point of this video was simple and brilliant... That we should all do our best to get over ourselves, and do more for each other...

  • VS is one peace ego

  • in reference to MLK, he never condoned violence, the quote came from him trying to explain why African Americans would riot...he was merely expressing the cause of that violence, not condoning, im trying to do the same here. God Bless

  • my friends, though i too feel for those lost in September 11, thousands more have died at your country's search for dominance and 'freedom' in the world, as you call it. It was MLK who once said, 'violence in the language of the oppressed'. Islam is only a medium through which these terrorists vented theyre anger at the constant abuse in their lands by the US,the western world. I have seen what US arrogance can do in a country, look closely, there are many 'ground zeros' around the world. Peace

  • First, MLK, whom you quoted, never advocated violence. Second, where's the blame for those who twisted Islam to serve their means? What about the oppressive governments throughout the Middle East? Don't they have some blame? I know we're not completely innocent, but your blame America stance is too simplistic.

  • jrod112278 i agree partly with your answer, things are not usually as black and white, but proportionally speaking the US has had far more weight in these problems then these repressive govts you speak of. Half of them were American backed, the pre 1979 Iranian govts, Saddam Hussein was hugely backed by the US during the Iranian-Iraqi war (a war to get iran back after its revolution) etc. Im not saying its all the US'fault, but you have to admit it has pulled alot of that weight upon itself

  • If you live in the United States then you will have no idea what the world thinks of you.

  • Artwork

  • Best song ever, I've used it for ALL of my projects for school. I even played it for a book report.... I try to incorperate this song in my daily life. I've watched it 73 times today because I forgot my Ipod....

  • You are right, it is a good song, but 73 times in one day?

  • beautiful. This is really beautiful. This piano... Incredible feelings.

  • One of the best songs ever, with a great message too.

  • My favorite song.

  • Most "terrorists" do not kill for a love of causing terror. They do so out of anger, fear and misguidance. Religion, by itself, is not the problem. It's the radical views of certain individuals that warp the teachings and manipulate the frail minds of angry youths. Many Americans judge without knowing what it's like to live a life in constant fear...to see your own siblings slaughtered by those that were sent to "protect" you. As Ghandi and MLK said, "An eye for an eye leaves everyone blind."

  • well said dark spiritus it is those who want to use religon to control others for there own means my grandfather was lucky enough to meet the great ghandi all we want is a place for our kids to sleep and food it is the rich who profit from war and the poor who die for them peace man