Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (588)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • UNDERRATED.

  • This my favorite performance of the season!

  • I LOVE HER SHE SHOULD'VE WON SHE'S AMAZING

  • it's a shame she didnt win..

  • wow it's been almos a year since this perfomrance, time is going by quick

  • I really like her outfit :)

  • legit this was the best season of american idol

  • @Tay12cross15 definitely.

  • haley is my fav

  • This will forever be my favorite studio version out of all of Haley's performances (& trust me I have them all on my ipod).

  • i wsa so mad when scooty won cuz i hate his voice and i thought haley should have won

  • She kinda reminds me of Jennette McCurdy. Idunno why xD

  • Where is this girls album??????

  • @bonypurrito Single in March and album in May! Keep an eye out...it will be amazing. She has been working hard in the studio ever since idol, so it's going to be really good!

  • She is an amazing singer and performer. The only thing that messed her up in this performance were the background singers. It was like she didnt have the moment to do what she does best. It was like she kept looking at them tosaty on key with her. She is awesome and she is going to do awesome things

  • Comment removed

  • When it came down to the top 3, I voted for Scotty, Lauren, and Haley. Don't bash or deny their talent, they're all wonderful. Sometimes I felt confused by Haley because throughout the competition I never could tell what kind of artist she wanted to be. Idol was a good experience for her, I look forward to checking out her album.

  • @gusandlulu American Idol did a different theme each week and fortunately the show had one artist who's talent is eclectic and profound enough to cross genre's. Haley knew what she was doing; you would think Randy, a judge, could figure it out. American Idol has never had a voice as beautiful as well as diverse as Haley's or a total package musician like Casey. That said, the top 13 were all terrific and give Scotty and Lauren their due. I hope they have great careers.

  • @sabanitas12 Ditto for me. Thank you.

  • Comment removed

  • @lizabth247 if you don't like her, go away!

  • Comment removed

  • @lizabth247 Let me guess, you're one of the 13 year old girls that kept voting for Scotty and Lauren while letting the real talent like Haley, James, and Casey get sent home.

  • Comment removed

  • @lizabth247 Why in HEL are you listening to this video if you don't like Haley, that doesn't make any sense. I don't like Scotty and I will never go to his videos to watch him or talk bad about him, I think he shouldn't have won, THIS is the real winner right here and just time will prove it because real talent can't hide

  • Comment removed

  • @lizabth247 I listen to Haley's videos everyday because her voice relaxes me while I'm working but you said you just come to this video to "troll" to get people's angry comment, OMG that just proves that you have nothing better to do with your time. Grow up and get a book and read a little, that might help you. Good luck to you in finding something productive to do with your time, this is the last time a waste my time in answering YOU.

  • Comment removed

  • @lizabth247

    You can be 19 and still be a child. You can read books and still be ignorant. You're proof of that.

  • @LookingAtYouFool Oh sweetie. You have no idea about who I really am. It's good to be childish, and I am an intelligent person. :) I am sorry that our opinions differ and I'm truly sorry if I somehow insulted you.

  • She is so pretty!!!

    I'm so in love with her!!

  • You really got a hold on ME! <3

  • Gordon Ramsey on Randy Jackson's left @ 1:33..

  • She's got amazing vocal skills.

  • I miss her curls.

  • does she have any original songs?

  • @gbblondie22

    Haley's first single to be released March 1st. Might debut on Idol. Album "by May." She is known to have co-writing credits on five songs. Said to have recorded more than two dozen. Her father may have been the guest referred to in this producers tweet: "Putting the finishing touches on this Haley Reinhart record with some special guest help!" Tweets by other producers/writers indicate they're very pleased/excited. In Nov, she released a holiday duet with Casey Abrams.

  • @gbblondie22 no yet, but she is working, i think her first single is going to be released on march 1 2012...

  • @karenZmusic

    The release date of her single has been pushed back to sometime in March. We did learn its name, "Free." She performed it before an audience of students at the Grammy Museum earlier this week. They've been tight-lipped but one declared herself a new fan on Twitter the next day and promised that everyone will love the song (she declined to provide any details).

  • @HaleyFansDotCom yes, I know it (I'm a real halien)

  • Comment removed

  • I just realized,.. she should'a sang Etta James in the show,.. any one would have been great :))

  • @KEVINtingzon93

    When asked in May if there was a song she would like to perform on the Idol tour that she did not do on the show, Haley said, "At Last." Quote: "It kind of got me through high school...It was just one of those songs that really expanded my views and my musical direction." Haley singing At Last: v=23fy3LxjPFs

  • This video was the turning point for Haley... she stayed out of the bottom 3 and the next week she closed the show with a stunning Bennie & The Jets! I became a fan after this performance, then voted for her the rest of the way! Haley is really special and I expect great things from her. If her single coming out MARCH 1 is anything like this it's gonna be awesome

  • press 8(10000000X).. u will never get bored.. :)

  • 1:42 - 1:48 >> EARGASMIC!!!!! how can possibly a human being do that crazy thing.... u just simply awesome Haley.. n Y U HAVE SUCH A BEAUTIFUL LEG???!!!!

  • I love the song, I love the way she grunts... and definitly, I love her legs xd

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • damn shes fine

  • When Haley says her album will have a "retro Motown" feel with hip-hop beats I hope it is something like this where her voice is front-and-center because there are few singers that can hold their own with her. btw, Haley's first single will be out March 1st.

  • SHE JUST KILLED THESE GREAT SONG

  • @efecios220 in a good or bad way??!!!

  • She was moving like that on purpose people -_-

  • My God ! This women....lol she kills me every time ! ; )

  • And love this song

  • She looks pretty with straight hair

  • *sighs* i still loving coming back to this video. for me, this was the moment when i became a major supporter of haley. prior to this performance, for some reason i just didn't quite get while everyone loved her besides her being incredibly gorgeous (i'm not blind lol). this was the game changer for me and i'm so glad i realized the error of my ways. she was robbed. yet another idol contestant for me to add to my list of being robbed :/

  • That last note that she hit with all those runs...WOW!!! She should've won on that alone! But I can't wait for her first single in march!

  • @chemalejub WORD!!!

  • It must have taken SO long to straighten her hair!

  • She reminds me of Mariah Carey in this one

  • I hold you haley!

  • OMG she sings perfectly give me the chills

  • Fuck the fat country bitch I can't believe Haley was voted off before her her voice is so generic, can we say sympathy votes people need to remember it's not a popularity contest its a singing contest and Lauren Alaina didn't have half the voice Haley has

  • @123molly3211 I agree lauren has half the talent

  • @AlvaroTalaveraH half? su much less!

  • @123molly3211

    hey! God almighty! what the fuck is wrong with u? "fuck that fat country bitch?" what are you, 7 years old? I love Haley but why the hate towards Lauren? it wasnt Lauren's fault Haley got voted off. you are a pathetic loser. Grow up! and say what you want about Lauren but I'd bet everything I own on that fact that she can sing WAY better than YOUR dumb ass. how about it? post a video of YOU singing and lets see who says what about you. hate-filled asshole. HALEY RULES!

  • @123molly3211 ...Let me get this across first...I love Ms. Haley Reinhart and she should have won AI walking away because she is just a more versatile and over all much better singer than anyone else that was on the show. What you said about Lauren though is rather stupid. For one she is only 16 while Haley is 4 years older and Haley has a ton more experience because of her parents. Lauren will get better and lovelier as she gets older but Haley will still be better!

  • Jessica Rabbit is real

  • @karenZmusic The original had 433,278 was taken down early on. It was in the first batch of her videos taken down for licensing or copyright problems.

  • OMG JUST 269473 VIEWS?!?

  • I became a Halien after this performance. So unique. That growl is irresistible. Nothing like the show's ever had before.

  • i know a girl that goes to my school who is cousins with Hayley :3

  • Lmfao, she looks awkward when she tries to walk and sing.

    BUT, her voice is amazing, so i guess it doesn't matter, lol.

  • In my opinion, she looks better without straight hair, but she's always beautiful !!!

  • Looks like she has problems walking and singing at the same time... lol. Other than that she did great.

  • Haley Reinhart, we were sitting right there for you've really got a hold on me,stunning so proud of you Haley! Beautiful was crazy good even with the ear piece problem you rolled like a pro! Fuck the rolled like a pro you rolled like Haley and we will never forget the heart and soul you put into the old school covers! Haley Reinhart work your ass off! Stay sweetass lovin Haley Keep that thick skin and don't kiss ass to long! We are just waiting for 19 and Hollywood 2FTHISUP! fans control thedeal

  • Love all those runs she does with her voice, it sounds great and it doesn't sound as overdone as some artists lol

  • What I don't understand is how this didn't come down to her and Casey Abrams and how they couldn't decide and let them both win

  • WHY THE HELLL DIDNT SHE WIN!!!! she was won of my favorites america wat the hell is your problem first Casey then Pia now Haley!!!! It turned into Country Idol after that!!!! This is some BS america learn how to vote and appreciate talent before you put your vote in!!

  • What a performance, her voice is amazing. WOW

    And her looks don´t spoil anything either.

    One of the best singers in the world.

    She is going to be be BIG.

    Can´t wait to see her perform live.

    Go Haley, go rule the world :-)

  • She is amazing(: im jealous

  • dem legs...

  • Haley Reinhart we were there! WE WERE STUNNED BY THIS PERFORMANCE! DICK CLARK WAS PROUD! MOTHER WENT WENT TOO SCHOOL WITH DICK CLARK! UTICA NEW YORK! SEEN 1000s of concerts! NEVER FORGET THIS HALEY! WE HAVE SEEN AND HEARD IT ALL!( SPENT TONS OF MONEY!) HALEY NO MATTER HAPPENS YOUR AI RUN WAS THE FUNNEST, COOLEST,BIG TALENT EVER! CAN'T WAIT TIL YOUR TICKETS ON SALE! 4 A NEWB HALEY MAKES TODAYS STARS LOOK LAME!( KEEP GIVING THE LAME ASS 2000-2011 STARS YOUR MONEY! HALEY R YOU ARE GETTING PAID! LYA

  • JLo is fucking jealous of her ahahhaha

  • 1:32 JLo the auto tune queen must be thinking.. "Why can't i sing like her.."

  • I've never had an interest in buying any music from any contestant on any singing show, except for Haley. In fact, she is the only contestant whose name I remember, lol. But to be fair, the only reason I remember her name is because she is the best singer on any of these shows, ever. Period.

  • Did Haley get a record deal yet ? I cannot wait to hear more from her..

  • @TZJ09

    She is signed and working on a album comming out first quarter next year. She did a Christmas duet with Casey Abrams, type (Haley Reinhart Baby its Cold Outside) in youtube. It is cute, warm, fuzzy and sexy. Its on her VEVO channel as well if you can get that in the UK.

  • I LOVE THIS GIRL!

  • Im so glad she got a record deal!! im proud of her she deserved to win

  • NEVER FORGET THIS HALEY REINHART! SO GOOD HALEY! WHAT A AMAZING YOUNG LADY!!!!!!!!! THIS WAS SO GOOD AND SWEET! SO PROUD OF YOU HALEY! WHAT AN AMAZING YOUNG LADY!!!!!!! LOVE YOU HALEY!

  • I love this so much, she looks better with curly hair though

  • Wow she looks WAY prettier with her hair that way... This is my favorite performance of hers, and I've actually never watched and liked anyone's AI performance as much as I do this one...=D

  • love love love and what an ending..

  • keep it going Haley,

  • Oh my Good ..... I LOVE her sooooo much !!!!! She is very beautiful and she has an amazing voice !!! .... Greetings from Greece !

  • Go buy Haley and Casey's duel "Baby it's Cold Outside" on Itunes!

  • Legs <3

  • UGH I LOVE THAT SHES CURVY AND WOMANLY! SHIT ABOUT TIME WE SEE A REAL WOMAN.. SMOKIN HOT NOT SOME TWIG trotting around the stage.. shes sooo fierce and im lovin it. GET IT GIRL!!! DO THE DAMN THING!

  • @ihugtrees321 she's way shorter than she looks too XD

  • @ihugtrees321 You can be a twig and still be a real woman... some people are just naturally skinny.

    That being said, Haley is flawless.

  • man. haley is AWESOME. one of the sexiest voices ever!

  • Yea! Hales have a new official channel ----> HaleyReinhartVEVO

  • her album is coming out in may 2012...heard its expected to hav quite a few hit singles

  • All I can say is Haley deserved to win. Not Scottie. He's good, but Haleys better. Simple as that. But either way, for me, Haley never lost.(: -33

  • Reminds me of the great Sam Brown

  • short shorts <3

  • she sounds like gaga in some parts !!

  • i would hold her forever.

  • wow...great voice...great looks...and GREAT LEGS IN THOSE SHORTS!

    GO HALEY!! YOUR MY AMERICAN IDOL!

  • i hate that douche scottie, he cant even fucking sing!!!!! He doesnt deserve to win, Haley does....

  • sexxxxxxxxxxxyyyyyyyy.

  • Worst travesty of American Idol, Haley, hands down, the best singer ever on American Idol. This time the fans got it wrong.

  • look at those legs - omg lol shes a honey

  • since this performance, i know she will b big

  • how come this video has no suggestions? is it just me?

  • Comment removed

  • my goodness she's got some nice thick thighs ;)

  • The back up singers ruined it. She practically had to sing herself hoarse because they were drowning her out. -___-

  • i like "grrrrrrr" in her voice

  • that comment was from my friend i left my account on at his house:P

  • Really American Idol? really? (Seth Myers, Tina Fey, Amy Poehler voices)

  • @CANADAMOOSE22 pfft... & yur from the same country as me huh... I've been here since near day 1 ... yur pathetic w/that comment clean up yur act ...

  • OOOOOOOOOOOOOOO nice legs when do they open????????????

  • @CANADAMOOSE22 for you? never.

  • @CANADAMOOSE22 perv

  • fata asta e unica.nobody has such a voice like this girl.but this type of shows really don't give the 1 place for the best.that boy is a shit and he wins..why??I don't know..maybe his mum works for j.lo..

  • @kary2119 please just give up the fact that he won yes I admit Haley was my favorite but whoever won, won!

  • @smyley1994 except winning isnt winning anymore when it comes to idol. just ask lee dwyze and kris allen. they "won' idol but got they butts kicked on the charts, radio, tv and every other outlet by the runner ups. haley will debut with a good album. sell a million copies. go to the Grammys and put her mark on music. scotty and lauren wont. just flash in the pans like Jordin sparks and taylor hicks,

  • @tybell50 hell yeah Haley forever!

  • hailey is naturally beautiful and very talented.....but......that straight hair just makes me melt :P never met her, and she already broke my heart :(

  • #TeamHaley !!! I absolutely LOVE this girl! F#% chills, she leaves me ice cold! *sighs* -3 -3

  • The single best performance on idol ever.

  • CHIIIIIIIIIIIIIILS!!!!!!!!!!!!­! My hairs are LITERALLY standing on end!!! :O

  • Are you f*cking kidding me?! First of all, why didnt she win? Second of all, why didn't I watch this season?!

    Love this girl!

  • @bikinifishing america likes country music.

  • @bikinifishing i didn't watch this season because i know no one good would win and all the best singers would come in third place or less

  • @bikinifishing lol, you seriously missed OUT.

  • @bikinifishing im asking my self the same thing just found Haley had to get offteh floor every time

  • Its interesting because at the beginning I didn't really think she was much, but as she continued to make it through, she got way better.

  • Leggy

  • the only reason that she didnt win, was that j lo was jealous of her :O

  • @DuctTapeStuffGirl who won?

  • @IVANNA848 scotty mcrerry ( I think thts how to spell it) hes from nc :D

  • JLO Look at 1:32 "Oh crap she is owning this... Even I couldn't do it this good!" JLO, sorry, but Haley owns at everythang.

  • The ONLY reason I watched IDOL for the first time........she has been signed to a record label and an album should be out next year.........rock on Haley

  • this is my favorite studio version. oh man. haaaaaaaaaaaaaley you reallly got a hold on me.

  • haleys the best idol ever :D

  • 2 things!

    - Check out Haleys New Video posted by PierceAbrams (aka Casey Abrams)

    Haley - jazz Club - New Orleans

    11 min of perfection

    -- and Vote for Haley at idolheaded poll (one vote per person)

  • I think this is one of Haley's most underrated performances of the season... she is SO good in this! Her itunes recording is awesome as well

  • Legs

  • haley should be in the judges' stool JLO audition pls.

  • the cover of this song is amazing

  • the cover of this song is amazing

  • I really want to feel her hair right now LOL

  • HALEY!!!@@!!!

  • If I could sing (and improv) like Haley the Powerhouse, I would NEVER shut up!