Cute story. Excellent graphics, better than any 3d stuff I can come up with. However, though I understand the need for a simplistic story, it seemed too simplistic for the length.
wow thats not short at all :O but its a 5/5!!! it was like watching a movie :D i have my own little silly short series, anybody can click to my page and watch some if they want x]
I cant say it was "short", but it was amazing. Specially, the story was peppered very well. I dont like to watch boring animations, but I really want know how it will end. And thats the reason, why peoples spend 12 minutes with watching. ^_^
good video! my names Alexandra, kinda feelin bored if any1 wants to join me on cam or wana chat i will be signed on at __ PLAY-CAM...dot...COM __ my user ID there is Alexandra_clzttjggnomp chat soon xx its FR33 to j0in! mwah
I think that andy was the one of whom they thought had died. So he can see dead people or something. Anhowy, great animation. Must have taken a long time.
Please check out my latest 3D short film titled "Red Roses" ,which are using Snow Patrol_Chasing Cars as the theme song and give ur comments & responses.
I love the animation and the story..but I don't understand the ending with Miguel. I know that Miguel is a ghost, but I became a little lost...I would love to understand the deal with that kid.
We are inviting entries for the Tube2SL Youtube Film Producer 2007 contest. See your film on the big screen in the virtual world of Second Life (TM) for the run up to and during the event. One lucky winner will receive 25,000L$, the title of Tube2SL Film Producer 2007 and their winning film broadcast four times daily in our Tube2SL virtual cinema complex for the remainder of 2007.
For more details visit the Tube2SL Youtube channel
The characters are ugly. The "moral" is okay, I guess. I agree with DrCarter2001: the miraculous birth isn't neccesary. And the parents weren't around. The screenwriter could've explained like the parents were busy and their abandonship added to Claude's attitude. Overall, ***1/2. (stars)
I agree with one of the earlier comments, that Claude's change of heart seemed a little too abrupt. However, I loved the style, the animation was beautiful. I'm extremely impressed, well done!
The story/message is good and the animation is great, but the execution is a bit rough. I don't really buy Claude's corruption (where were the parents in all this?) and his redemption is much too quick. Plus it drags at points -- it feels like it should either be much shorter with more summary, or much longer to build the suspense and demonstrate the changes in Claude's personality. Plus I don't see how Andy's fetal death and "miraculous" birth ties in.
thought it simplistic : you are sad. you get given a book. everything is alright. yeah, that works! art work very good though, just needs a better story line to do it justice.
I once had a cat called Claude, I didn't like him because he was always leaving a stinky mess behind the couch, I don't like this Cluade either, he's mean!
What's a meanie! But great animation and interesting story.
Beautifully rendered animation. Story appeared to be a summarised, truncated version of a classic. To the dunderheads: Miguel is a ghost (as is the dog in the final act) and he is finally at peace. His brother - presumably a bully as a child - feels the weight of guilt lift from his shoulders as his dead brother finally forgives him.
im confused... was the guy with gray around the eyes at the end with the dog dead...or is the guy in the tux a vampire...like when the mean brother got scared in the graveyard... vampire scared him right?
I think the animation from this film was excellent, but the story line was very poorly done. it had too many twists. for example, the exact same dog comes to the new pair of brothers which means the dog would die and the two brothers would be mad at eachother again. just very confusing
what was the title of the book ??
blissfulll1 11 months ago
sow sweet i love it ^^
sleepingforestx3 11 months ago
I dont get it? What happened?
MikoyCreator 1 year ago
What software did you use?
derDenker1992 1 year ago
thumbs up if u think claude looks like "chucky the killer doll" at 4:27
patrickn16 1 year ago
/watch?v=yIPyrl2CwKw
ManHeartless 1 year ago
fuck u claude ... ur such an ass
amgaaaaad 1 year ago
@datxcod Well I believe this was originally in Spanish. It'd probably sound better with the original dub.
nikedmondson 1 year ago
good work n lovely story
MultiNoor11 1 year ago
Great job! I really liked.
IRIARTE invites you to stop by his channel to see the animation.
Will thank you very much!
IRIarteVEDA 1 year ago
i loved it so much =')
emmy2482010 1 year ago
Cute story. Excellent graphics, better than any 3d stuff I can come up with. However, though I understand the need for a simplistic story, it seemed too simplistic for the length.
ZetteSue 1 year ago
wow this is really amazing.
matsuo19 1 year ago
niceee +10
fliker44 2 years ago
very touching. A beutiful story:)
Yourway87 2 years ago
great short movie !
llxlpandalxll 2 years ago
i swear to god when they were trying to scare him i thought they were gonna kill him. omg.
kawaiicup 2 years ago
It's a short film for goodness sakes! The story must be wrapped up succinctly.
- miraculous birth: vast difference in brothers
- ghost child: guiding spirit
- mourning brother: dues of Claude's descent
- Claude meeting Miguel: Facing his own dark side (thus the evil glare)
Vampire? Where did that come from? Doesn't anyone have an imagination anymore except what came from the latest cinema pulp?
GatorScientist 2 years ago
Es genial... Muy bueno.
lukkas1759 2 years ago
i dont say this for alot of youtube videos but that was really really good i really enjoyed it give yourself a pat on the back
riggerrogger101 2 years ago
sniff* sniff its so beautiful and touching. i always wanted a twn brother. unfortunately maybe i need to wait for my next life.
ZackeryFiles 2 years ago
= ( aww... is beautifull
DarkCrow1303 2 years ago 5
Great job! nice story
puttepossu2 2 years ago 2
congratulation!
jujafon 2 years ago 2
Beautiful
XSefProductionX 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
i made an awesome 3d fighting animation, you can see it on my channel
omuleanu 2 years ago
damnz very nice!!
G60ForceTEST 2 years ago
Omg it's amaze!
lauruzas 2 years ago
wow thats not short at all :O but its a 5/5!!! it was like watching a movie :D i have my own little silly short series, anybody can click to my page and watch some if they want x]
B4bi3grl 2 years ago
I cant say it was "short", but it was amazing. Specially, the story was peppered very well. I dont like to watch boring animations, but I really want know how it will end. And thats the reason, why peoples spend 12 minutes with watching. ^_^
FOXSUSENKO 2 years ago
very good !!! that must have took hours to make that movie!! im giving you a 5 star for such a good work
rinkelin123 2 years ago
wow that dude talks too much
UploadPancakesHere 2 years ago
nice story ... nice characters ... nice scene modeling ...
cosminmagdas 2 years ago
goot thing
VesaHaxhikadriu 2 years ago
Nice, but a wee bit too much narration...
mikeyinhollywood 2 years ago
I think that's the point......
NoahsPWNS 2 years ago
Thats so amazing! Me and my friend think it should be a movie
beebop97 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
♥ O___O ♥
zonissan 3 years ago
a animação tá legal, o trabalho foi super cool... mas a história está de mata.. podre, podre, podre...
smaboy 3 years ago
Very cute. I love that Miguel has the dead dog at the end, too. (;
But I'm a little confused. Is it implying that Miguel's brother abused him to death?
DazeWolf 3 years ago
irgendwie finde ich die Geschichte blöd...
flocke303 3 years ago
what is so nice about it ? I was expecting something to happen, maybe a little twist or some unpredictable event, but nothing..
shamelesmaeil 3 years ago
thtwas really good i dont know why but it scared me a little..?
xghost0fyoux560 3 years ago
wow for a simple children's-like animation that was really intense , well written story
mattN808 3 years ago
This was simple yet phenomenal at the same time, a truly touching story.
eeryjaguar 3 years ago
very deep story and very good realization.
touching, amazing
Zelle10 3 years ago
beautiful
danleonhart1011 3 years ago
Awesome video. Loved the story, narration and animation.
MonAfriqueProduction 3 years ago
very awsome! kinda sad, but incredible!
skaterpunktop3 3 years ago
Beautiful
reesey1029 3 years ago
Wow!!!
splendorpower 3 years ago
very nice
beautiful
cowsunleashed 3 years ago
that`s great!
dumardude 3 years ago
Beautiful movie. I almost cried.
Very, very good!
mstl95 3 years ago
that was an amazing film :) (super sweet)
theres a short film contest i heard about yesterday, shoot me a message if you want the link
RockGodessss 3 years ago
faz feito mesmo?
teamquickblade 3 years ago
did u make this?
gerbillover20 3 years ago
love it
canoai 3 years ago 2
cool
tredzy 3 years ago
Nice video!
FilmTraum 3 years ago
beautiful
twinkiefly 3 years ago
Very nice movie! I loved it! Simply amazing.
benboyleman 3 years ago 2
wow que chido film
flazhcomic 3 years ago
very nice short film, i loved it
joekid365 3 years ago
This movie is really amazing and very touching and i loved it.
TheUpwoods 3 years ago
Really good!!!! I love it!
catmaniac8x 3 years ago 2
very nice production!
dekonstrux 3 years ago
wut's the moral lesson?
faigamel 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
good video! my names Alexandra, kinda feelin bored if any1 wants to join me on cam or wana chat i will be signed on at __ PLAY-CAM...dot...COM __ my user ID there is Alexandra_clzttjggnomp chat soon xx its FR33 to j0in! mwah
imotionfx45 3 years ago
Wow that was amazing to say the least!
FaLLeN67821 3 years ago
if any bitch puts this down, then those sorry suns of a bitch can go to hell!
Off-courts! c'est un film merveielleux!
totacs 3 years ago
Dios te bendiga todavia hay gente con corazon
GEN-123TV
fxstudioz28 3 years ago
VERY GOOD!
computersguy13 3 years ago
wow, that was beautiful. and if any bitch puts this down, then those sorry suns of a bitch can go to hell
ManOfBarf 3 years ago
wondeful job, very touching since im going through a similar situation that is quite paiful.
lonelyheart 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
tow words B.S.
hamzeeco 4 years ago
That's 2 letters
Thumbgump 3 years ago 2
no ,thats 2 words,,,BULL SHIT
hamzeeco 3 years ago
that so cute.. :')
bunny608 4 years ago
Beautiful, very beautiful work, congrats!
Bolduc619 4 years ago
no me gusto
mustarasta 4 years ago
its great,yet to long and at a time quait boring
rikaclaudiu 4 years ago
Great , great , great ! I was almost crying ... this was really cool
Proacro 4 years ago
that waz so good and sad!
DarkWolf3453 4 years ago
miguel was already dead but its a great story in an eerie sort of way
evintari 4 years ago
I think that andy was the one of whom they thought had died. So he can see dead people or something. Anhowy, great animation. Must have taken a long time.
4uky 4 years ago
the only thing I don't get is who is in the grave called Miguel.. I thought Miguel was the friend he met ?
But anyway, GREAT models and anmiations , the narratar was very good , and the story was great !
YouToad 4 years ago
Very well done... great animation... great story...
Frezzer12 4 years ago
Gret story line and point
RLG07 4 years ago
The narrator sounds like he should be doing commercials XD
RainVine 4 years ago
that was so beautiful....the ending made me all teary ^^;
sageofwinds 4 years ago
OMG!! he met a ghost!!
monkeys19 4 years ago
Please check out my latest 3D short film titled "Red Roses" ,which are using Snow Patrol_Chasing Cars as the theme song and give ur comments & responses.
Thanks!
manhunterproductions 4 years ago
Fantastic! excellent animation, great story!
GreatFrosty 4 years ago
What was that about?
Crazyanna94 4 years ago
Great story and animation
athabascamedia 4 years ago
awesome!^^,
KjamizLoL 4 years ago
Please! Make a real movie like this ;) This was asoum!
KjamizLoL 4 years ago
It's such a nice story, i love it, but also it's sad!
Very good work!
Bilbo
TheOnkelBilbo 4 years ago
It's so beautiful.
cyberrsj 4 years ago
The Red Fairy says nice animation. She was once 3D herself says she.
tarazod 4 years ago
amazing if i was a mutant i would give this 10 thumbs up
sonic911 4 years ago
It was so beautiful.
fmagravifan 4 years ago
i give it like...90 million stars...brilliant! so touching.
fathercwabby 4 years ago
exelente video con contenido y calidad de imagen. impresionante de verdad!!
toledosx6 4 years ago
Whoa! Luvvin' Claude, wot a nasty geeza!
Seriously tho', superb short animation beautifully done...
PompeySomerstown 4 years ago
Probably one of the best animated shorts I've seen on Youtube...it was sad, touching, and carried a great story with a twist.
hammy116 4 years ago
Wow. I cried. So sad. Miguel was a ghost and Andy was always getting hurt.
Bunnysitter4 4 years ago
I love the animation and the story..but I don't understand the ending with Miguel. I know that Miguel is a ghost, but I became a little lost...I would love to understand the deal with that kid.
yukkayo 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
100,000L$+ Prize Fund and Trophies
We are inviting entries for the Tube2SL Youtube Film Producer 2007 contest. See your film on the big screen in the virtual world of Second Life (TM) for the run up to and during the event. One lucky winner will receive 25,000L$, the title of Tube2SL Film Producer 2007 and their winning film broadcast four times daily in our Tube2SL virtual cinema complex for the remainder of 2007.
For more details visit the Tube2SL Youtube channel
elektrik11 4 years ago
I think that this clip was very well done, and I am very interested in the program that you used to create this wonderful short.
aceviajr 4 years ago
this is very impressive good work.
Mycomputer6 4 years ago
very well done...sound design is great
szlotescu 4 years ago
great story! good work!
yfeChris 4 years ago
Story, lighting, compositon, character detail (artistically and emotionally) are all exceptional. This is truly an extraordinary piece.
kinkaids 4 years ago
The characters are ugly. The "moral" is okay, I guess. I agree with DrCarter2001: the miraculous birth isn't neccesary. And the parents weren't around. The screenwriter could've explained like the parents were busy and their abandonship added to Claude's attitude. Overall, ***1/2. (stars)
ADevilsReject6 4 years ago
get A clue..
masterod1 4 years ago
Did you like it?
ADevilsReject6 4 years ago
claude almost looks like chucky.
thesoracle 4 years ago
what program did you use these is amazing
muthatruckaa 4 years ago
I agree with one of the earlier comments, that Claude's change of heart seemed a little too abrupt. However, I loved the style, the animation was beautiful. I'm extremely impressed, well done!
EsheArt 4 years ago
amazing work and story line also, wow
patelnarhari 4 years ago
beautifull xD
leonardo006 4 years ago
Its really amazing!!! iim in love with it... the message, the animation and the music its totally professional, Excelent Work!!!
OonaBelmont 4 years ago
The story/message is good and the animation is great, but the execution is a bit rough. I don't really buy Claude's corruption (where were the parents in all this?) and his redemption is much too quick. Plus it drags at points -- it feels like it should either be much shorter with more summary, or much longer to build the suspense and demonstrate the changes in Claude's personality. Plus I don't see how Andy's fetal death and "miraculous" birth ties in.
DrCarter2001 4 years ago
awesome!, profesional stuff!!!
Eshguemundol 4 years ago
I guess it's for kids...but they we'll love it.
mrsuser13 4 years ago
Wow. I'm completely impressed! AMAZING!
coolmancool1234567 4 years ago
Sad, but amazing animation and good storyline. Could do with less narraration. Still, 5/5
Haha5473 4 years ago
GOOD GOOD GOOD
watch my videos pls.
freekoh 4 years ago
FABULOUS!
debmik22 4 years ago
Indeed fabulous! And very well orchestrated!
n2cora 4 years ago
aww that was sooo sooo sad :(
aznzensation 4 years ago
good story, but i was quite scared during the middle part and thought it would turn out to be a horror film :(
xuantra 4 years ago
So did I. I thought Andy's brother was going to kill him. -shivers-
RensGirl 4 years ago
so sad
wertydm 4 years ago
im luky i dont have a bro
wertydm 4 years ago
Very good indeed! Loved it!
Bobas1 4 years ago
really good
thekingsalive 4 years ago
No the narrative voice seems ok,I have heard even the worst.
Well Done.:)
techgeodude 4 years ago
I hate the narrarator's voice
iluvbeatle 4 years ago
that's the power of sharing
carfield13 4 years ago
i'm glad i'm not like that, i love my brother
1000calories 4 years ago
thought it simplistic : you are sad. you get given a book. everything is alright. yeah, that works! art work very good though, just needs a better story line to do it justice.
catyule 4 years ago
COOL short film!!
Forzamad 4 years ago
OMG! i'm speechless that was awesome.
pepsigal86 4 years ago
Awesome video, love it. But I begin to miss my cousin. T.T
19491001 4 years ago
how do u make these
tomatoe39 4 years ago
Well done.
GranitW 4 years ago
timeless- like a halmark! i loved it. 5 stars all the way!
bigblue123 4 years ago
Awesome story!!! I love it!
faithconnell 4 years ago
very good !!!!
cozanostraa 4 years ago
Killer >>>>
Exar46 4 years ago
wOw love it <3 <3
embracethedead 4 years ago
such beauty...love it<3
iiipink 4 years ago
Nice animation, tiresomely moralistic story, hokey narration.
markproxy 4 years ago
So true. It is quite beautiful to look at, though.
deadmoki 4 years ago
couldnt have put it better myself! sentimental drivel.
catyule 4 years ago
whatttttttttttttttt.
that was so creepy
but great job man
NateDogg7 4 years ago
is it like two diffrent ways one the brother dies and the other lives sort of thing? and who thats deep
devilpie999 4 years ago
lovely sentiment ,really emotive
stigmacam 4 years ago
I once had a cat called Claude, I didn't like him because he was always leaving a stinky mess behind the couch, I don't like this Cluade either, he's mean!
What's a meanie! But great animation and interesting story.
NightmareHippy 4 years ago
very beautiful video keep up the good work
rmjjrenfro 4 years ago
Great story! Great Animation! Great!
LiquidSociety0092 4 years ago
Wait wtf? how and when did miguel die, and how did andy see him if he was dead, but not the dog?
snurkman123 4 years ago
Beautifully rendered animation. Story appeared to be a summarised, truncated version of a classic. To the dunderheads: Miguel is a ghost (as is the dog in the final act) and he is finally at peace. His brother - presumably a bully as a child - feels the weight of guilt lift from his shoulders as his dead brother finally forgives him.
brianmit 4 years ago
I thought it was really good, and kinda sad, but I enjoyed it.
shamshea 4 years ago
Great animation, but it was hard to understand and the narrarator was completely boring.
KrasivaSoul 4 years ago
stupid plot
0nster 4 years ago
It was GREAT! I loved it : )
Anacry 4 years ago
im confused... was the guy with gray around the eyes at the end with the dog dead...or is the guy in the tux a vampire...like when the mean brother got scared in the graveyard... vampire scared him right?
irishboy45455 4 years ago
The animation was done from great talent, the writing however, glorified old Navajo trickster stories into epic movements.
Veritas0808 4 years ago
I think the animation from this film was excellent, but the story line was very poorly done. it had too many twists. for example, the exact same dog comes to the new pair of brothers which means the dog would die and the two brothers would be mad at eachother again. just very confusing
einfgg 4 years ago
It was sad but good i liked it a lot
beachbum4lifeioc 4 years ago
hard to understand this movie in some parts...kinda act gay once awhile too. :P
Good movie though
JamesWorldStudios 4 years ago
very moving....a beautiful story,,,well done
k42252 4 years ago
So sweet..it's sad that the other brother is dead...but it's nice...
s26marie 4 years ago
I swear to god that's like me and my twin!!!!!!
he's so stupid.
yet he doesn't realize how wrong he is.
GreyFox001 4 years ago
so creepy!
grapessss 4 years ago
I don't get it. What was the deal at the end?
racevws 4 years ago
Beautiful! <3 I nearly cried at the end.
Rayzser 4 years ago
That was cute and amazing animation!
Cocacola1052 4 years ago
God dammit Youtube needs to feature this!!!
acematthew 4 years ago
This was excellent, I loved it.
jlad90 4 years ago
Good done .And it's worthwhile to do that .
shirleyhot 4 years ago