Roger Waters - Perfect Sense (Parts I & II) - live

[ksifounwn]

Can't you see

It all makes perfect sense

Expressed in dollars and cents,

Pounds, shillings and pence

Can't you see

It all makes perfect sense

..........best words ever told in a song....σιγουρα

[druug]

@EckC27.

He said Mama Mama, the President's a fool

Why do I have to keep reading these technical manuals

And the joint chiefs of staff

And the brokers on Wall Street said

Don't make us laugh, you're a smart kid

[HeyDreamer25]

IM GOING TO HIS CONCERT TOMORROW YAAY! :D

[Andronichuk]

11 people misread the button as "dis I like"

[EckC27]

Presidents a fool why do i have to keep reading these technical manuals and judges are scared from the brokers on wall street!! roger waters = LEGEND!!

[Lightning1369]

Waters bustin a move@ 4:03 lol

[craigyjac2]

Piece of genius, in the true sense of the word.

[Stratosticks]

As far as my solo Roger favorites are concerned, this is one of the two. I just cant choose between this and Amused To Death. Both are soooooo good.

[Bertrand16]

This is an unbelievable song!!!!!!

[ricoaperitivo]

GENIO

[ricoaperitivo]

y no me canso de verlo!!!!



[mrdavidpeter01]

fantasti!!!!!!!



[someonecalledlaura]

actually breathtaking. I get shivers when ever I listen to this song. Why it does not have more views I will never know, but I am so glad you people appreciate it. x

[TheLostinadream]

One of my all time favorite tracks to drum allong with, Graham Broad really does a swell job with Roger.

[MrSTEPHANE2272]

amen to that



[MrSTEPHANE2272]

amen to that

[UncleAndy13]

That is one incredible song/album!!!!

[johnartmaster]

@UncleAndy13 WITHOUT A DOUBT MY FAV OF ALL TIME!1

[cloudchaser07]

Obama won today



[Grafschnitzel]

Obama vs. Osama... I guess it all makes perfect sense

[paulypoo66]

...how anyone can dislike this tune is beyond me... one of the most prolific titles and verses ever penned...make that 10 crazy people cpato^^ they don't know what good music is...

[celsizinho]

Amiga sem quaquer dúvida ...esse é o cara....embora tenha uma preferencia pessoal por Gilmour...é inegavel que o performance de Walters...e sua sincronia com a melodia e tudo que acerca.....seu desempenho se destaca..!!! Obrigado pelo lindo envio e por ter lembrado de sua amigo de longe.....espero que tudo fique bem com voce e sua linda familia ...desejo a voce um final de semana repleto de bóns acontecimentos ..........."Celsizinho amigo do vento e seu amigo tambem "......" menos

[electricheel]

@celsizinho i wish i knew what you said.But i caught enough to know that you like this!

[celsizinho]

Amiga sem quaquer dúvida ...esse é o cara....embora tenha uma preferencia pessoal por Gilmour...é inegavel que o performance de Walters...e sua sincronia com a melodia e tudo que acerca.....seu desempenho se destaca..!!! Obrigado pelo lindo envio e por ter lembrado de sua amigo de longe.....espero que tudo fique bem com voce e sua linda familia ...desejo a voce um final de semana repleto de bóns acontecimentos ..........."Celsizinho amigo do vento e seu amigo tambem "......

[Autofilkis]

this is the fourth time in row i listen to this song without changing!!!!

[jesse5852]

Holy crap they have the dialogue of HAL- 9000 from 2001 A Space Odyssey I was watching not so long ago. One of the best musicians taking dialogue from one of the best movies ever.

[elaletitas]

Pfff.... amazing.... no more saying. Roger is master of the masters!!!

[11ellsbells]

Nobody else does what this guy does.

Arise Sir Roger!

[jesse5852]

I can't wait for the Wall DVD's release. Let's all have our fingers crossed that Dave Gilmour is on that DVD

[hobilek]

@jesse5852 That would be absolutely amazing! Can't even imagine how the crowd explodes when David appears up there on the wall..

[uh0oo]

@jesse5852 OMG... OMG Are you serious where did you hear this!!!

[jesse5852]

@uh0oo Why do you think he has 6 days booked in london. The possibility is very high. He also siad it in his blog

[marciaplant]

Não me canso de ouviii. Linda demais a canção, toca.

[albino6021]

amazing! just amazing!!!!

[wonputt777]

Intellectual, Musical, Auditory, Story telling, captivating....BLISS!

You all have NO idea how Blessed You are to be able to witness

this Mans creations!

Thank You Roger!

[Sk1nUpUk]

Amazing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[willow456789]

briiillluuuunnnnnttt

[TheTwelly]

A1.

[andrefelix96]

best music ever made

[himtnman]

Seen this done in Omaha NE,

Tears in my eyes, AMAZING, when Roger turns around and acts like he's in a submarine.

[mariorossi890]

only one word: FANTASTIC!

[barnacora]

PERFECT SHOW!!

[DreaminMyLifeAway]

you all know the beginning "stop, dave..." is from 2001 a space odyssey,

[Isurus67]

@DreaminMyLifeAway Yes HAL 9000 - Speaking to Dave

[labyonnette]

weow wow and double wow !!!!!!!!!!¬!!!!¬! tghank you roger for putting this all together

[FRANCISCOJOSEALMEIDA]

Simplesmente brilhante!!!!!1

[potele2]

Thrilling!

[dwarrel137]

9th of april i am going to the concert of Roger waters in Arnhem Holland

[GIG042]

INCREDIBLE!!!!! it must have been almost chilling to be there.

[grangonian]

this is my best roger song! reminds me of many things!

[WTLYNX]

... ROGER WATERS - HOJE É UM GRANDE DIA PARA QUEM GOSTA DE MÚSICA DE CONTESTAÇÃO CONTRA TODOS OS TIPOS DE VIOLÊNCIA CONTRA A HUMANIDADE E TODAS AS GUERRAS INÚTEIS QUE DEIXAM MILHARES DE FAMÍLIAS DESTROÇADAS NÃO SÓ NA GERAÇÃO PASSADA, NA ACTUAL, ASSIM COMO NAS GERAÇÕES VINDORAS...

E PORQUE NINGUÉM ESQUECE UM ENTE QUERIDO OU AMIGO PERDIDO NUM QUALQUER CONFLITO QUE CONTINUA A SER UM FLAGELO NO NOSSO SÈCULO XXI.

[chrabine1]

And they don't understand music too.

[cardo1111]

Perfection.

[chrabine1]

Perfect sense = Perfect song

Just WON-DER-FUL!!

It should be an Anthem.

[borisrainesh]

Just ingeniously GREAT!!!

[pedro18881]

this song is class

[ionia23]

"If you give a monkey a bone, sooner or later said-monkey is going to bash in another monkey's brains with it."

[BartsMyName]

cant decide if it's better than the album version, cause they're both so damn gooood :)

[uhoitsjono]

@BartsMyName I'll be honest. I like the singing on this version a lot better. Also the part when the crowd sings the "global anthem" sounds more awesome because the actual crowd is singing it. Haha.

[BartsMyName]

@uhoitsjono I think I don'r remember pros of the album version and this one will be remembered, so probably you rite.

[hamrunspartans80]

just perfecttt!!!

[mardares1]

@hamrunspartans80  Perfectual manual!!!! The best message. From Romania

[Jacarevoxxx]

great performance!

[cheaprickchris]

This is our world ...captured... sumarized...in less than ten minutes.

[johnartmaster]

@cheaprickchris YOU SAID IT !! THIS GUY IS AMAZING

[SaraSuicide666]

my god.......... the most ahmazing i have ever seen

[redwhitch17]

Carnt you see,It all makes PERFECT sense.......

[cpato1]

9 dis likes? WTF????????? get a life! this is a master class!

[SaraSuicide666]

@cpato1 i agree!

[Finc89]

@cpato1 :::: 9 dislike, guess they don't understand English looll :P

[mardares1]

@cpato1 p p arnold is the voice  God bless her voice

[johnartmaster]

@cpato1  I KNOW VERY SHALLOW RATARDS

[LeCourvoisier]

IF YOU DON'T LIKE, GO TO HELL !!!

[Silencedscope]

This song touched me in my 20s and still makes perfect sense in my 40s.. Roger is an ageless musician and his messages in his music are timeless! How I appreciate every song he has ever contributed too!! Bravo!! xxx

[facepalmization]

9 people don't have any sense

[kentishplato]

In all of my musical life i have never known a more moving performance

[MrGuitarXX]

im new to youtube. please check my shit out.

[jjGettingBetter]

amazing <3<3

[snowzonetelevision]

Surely one of the most underrated songs of all time!

[sefaroth]

amazing song

[DonSudia]

Roger Waters is a freakin genius.. It all makes perfect sense, expressed in dollars and cents. He sees the human race in a very realistic way.

[johnartmaster]

Roger is the master!! my frickin hero!

[MauerEllsbury]

And the Germans kill the Jews

And the Jews kill the Arabs

And the Arabs kill the hostages

And that is the news

An amazing lyric that shows how one war leads to another.

[timeandtimeagain777]

i pity the 9 mentally ill psychopaths who disliked this

[03thinkfloyd]

great song roger waters the best

[mortensnedker]

Am I looking forward to his performance in DK this summer...think so!

[Polterguist]

You can tell Rgoer is singing from his heart at part 2. Great song.

[recfc]

thay, my friends, is called perfection!

[gaffeltroll]

Wish you were my brother, Roger!

[weirhere]

@gaffeltroll He is, my friend. He is.

[joeball1000]

Por incrivel que pareça, a guerra esta na natureza dos homens

[Sencimilla]

PP Arnold, you rock my world xoxo

[trumancapote69]

Where and when was this performance?

[rushtopn]

These words woke me up i didn t know how asleep i was living.....but it all makes perfect sense....these words are my bible i am now awake

[anamgify]

11 out of 10 for Roger Waters GENIUS !!! even to select the female singers..

[SuperMarcello18]

Fantastica!!!

[Gerardinho59769]

O MY FREAKING GOD! ;bghbgkvuhgvi;fvghvg sorry, i was wiping the jizz off of my keyboards because that female singer is an amazing singer.

[touarec]

amazing.

[grmpfie]

If I could.. I would

[grmpfie]

And.. the Germans killed the Jews, and he Jews killed the Arabs, and the Arabs killed the hostages.. Is it any wonder..?? That the monkey is confused..?? Love all the Roger fans.... HE LIVES IN MY EARS FOR THE LAST 30 YEARS

[grmpfie]

And here come the players..

[grmpfie]

And the Germans killed the Jews, and the Jews killed the Arabs, and the Arabs killed the hostages and that is the news.. Is it any wonder that the monkey is confused,,? Kiss for all the Roger fans

[Akira1422]

Video doesn't capture how amazing it is to see this in person.

[silvano148]

È simplismente P E R F E C T .

[silvano148]

È simplismente P E R F E C T.

[snowzonetelevision]

Roger rules the roost

[carlosdn62]

PP Arnold, Genius!!!

[AwesomeCoasters]

I'm afraid

I'm afraid

[cosmicrider287]

very smart to add the 2001 a space odyssey hal voice.

[TheArturhash]

Masterpiece

[DrTHENgr1mReap]

how can u dis-like this???? its crazy

[guitaresb]

my god the part for the female singer is incredibly hard to sing. thumbs up for this diva!!!

[JosephDillon57]

Assange/Waters 2012

[Tom14hh]

9 people miss the button

[kamiokta]

Ja comprei meu ingresso pro show dele em Barcelona!

Te vejo em março,Roger! Casa comigo! hahaha

[rockerchick613]

I saw him live a week ago.

Words cannot describe how amazing it was.

R.I.P Wright <3

[Quilbo]

i can't believe i found this song after 25years. omg

i NEED to see him live in milan!

[mollysangelique]

this,is,the,music,of,music,top­,of,all,damned,bullshit,like,g­aga,etc.the,background,singers­,are,ladies,treated,as,ladies

[lemekid]

Brilliant, just brilliant. Epic song.

[dassler42]

i'm afraid to

[mirnixdirnix78]

So nice!

[MariaGanip]

the best!

[ngu4u]

Thanks, she's really great. They are really great.

[boxtie]

Katie Kissoon, Susanah Melvoen and PP Arnold......wow.......what a backing vox line up........

[wonputt777]

@boxtie You are Totally Right On,

these Chick really FEEL it and We Love it

when they Do!

[powerbooms]

Yes Sublime!!! It made me cry !!! Hight Emotion .

[andrew406]

since his floyd days roger seems 2 have warmed 2 the crowd lol ledgend i prefer him spitting on em

[tigla111]

it's incredible

[bartje21]

goin to see him in April 2011..can't wait

[fehercsongor]

The voice at the beginning is from HAL 9000.

[alitamda]

Powerful song!

[krocodyllo]

SUBLIME!!!!!!!!!

[babyjo21166]

WHAT A TOTALLY AWESOME SONG, ROGER MUST'VE WROTE THIS AFTER HE DEPARTED FROM PINK FLOYD, I REALLY LIKE IT, ANYONE OUT THERE HAVE ANY INFO ABOUT IT, PLS EMAIL ME, THANKS! GOSH , I JUST LOVE THIS, AND I ALSO LOVE THE WAY ROGER TRY'S TO ENGAGE THE AUDIENCE, TOO COOL.

[babyjo21166]

WHAT A TOTALLY AWESOME SONG, ROGER MUST'VE WROTE THIS AFTER HE DEPARTED FROM PINK FLOYD, I REALLY LIKE IT, ANYONE OUT THERE HAVE ANY INFO ABOUT IT, PLS EMAIL ME, THANKS!

[1888jayne]

@babyjo21166 ye it was long after he left floyd... its from his best album ever... my favourite.... Amused To Death and i own all his albums, which are also great in their own right but this ones a masterpiece....... the sales of it were crap tho, something like 65000 wtf

[daveveerman]

@1888jayne I have one copy as well :-)

[Indomi2008]

Thanks Ana

[elpinchegrabador]

simplemente extraordinario,

[elpinchegrabador]

simplemente extraordinario

[acid612]

I am willing to pay 10k to go Roger concert !

[Polterguist]

The lyrics kick my ass, but I still love the song. 

[SFCISME]

I personally feel like this is the pinnacle of Rogers solo work. Beautiful,and amazing song..

[Smashinz2002]

Listen to this carefully. . This is incredibly brilliant and insightful to a very high degree. Lyrics like these require many listens, and careful interpretation, and too intelligent for many people, which is sad. . And the music itself, is so simple, yet powerful and so moving. My favorite Water's song probably.

[TheWall2000]

@Smashinz2002

Man you hit the nail on its bloody head - well done.

[frecklesdk]

@Smashinz2002 your right had to listen many times still the monkey is confused

[haro82]

One of his best songs ever. I got to see this at MSG in 2000 and it brought the house down.

[beyond0darkness]

absolutely great.always been...

[otherworldjourneys]

There's something about Floyd and Waters' songs; they reach parts that others just can't. They're incredible, anthemic and powerful. The musicians and singers, are like, well, awesomely integrated.

And it's fun to recall Andy Fairweather-Lowe, so different from his days as 60s teeny-bopper heartthrob of Amen Corner, and P.P. Arnold being blown away by one of the best soul singers that Britain ever produded, Steve Marriott, in one of his classic performances. SMALL FACES - Tin Soldier (Colour)

[redifreddy14]

some days .. feels like the monkey sitting on a pile of stone... staring at the broken bone in my hand...

thinking to myself memory is a stranger ..and history is for fools....

hold on soldier. hold on soldier...

wishing it all made perfect sense........cant you see.?

[randy6382]

awesome song awesome singers and it does make perfect sense,wow wow wow one of these days i hope i can see pink floyd's concerts.who's the back up vocals done by?anyone know?thank goodness for sirius radio.

[Smashinz2002]

the piano music sounds just like something Rick Wright would compose, so beautiful and moving. . I think this entire piece proves how much Roger was moved and influenced by his former band members, most notably Rick. The lyrics are of course pure Roger; brilliant, open to interpretation, and complex to the point of being over the heads of many listeners, which requires repeated listening to develop a personal interpretation. . Oh yes, this is wonderful art, pure, honest, and heartfelt.

[yanishmakaro]

Roger is to music what the Pope is to catholicism.

[jrrr72]

WOW

[RENAUDF38]

Nothing to say just listen

[RENAUDF38]

Nothing to say just listen

[groaakre1]

wow

[ludocrat]

That was amazing.

[ciferrara]

grazie

[toketlenfecske]

I think this is the best version of this song on Youtube... It sounds so good (especially the female singer :))

[2006geralt]

So fucking beautifull, i can here this everyday !

[fremmed1]

The backup singers is one of many essential things that spices up the reason why music can be an expression of art witch cannot be defined completely through traditional science. You either "get it" or you don`t. And just like "In held t`was in I" by Procol Harum, the lyrics stands out as philisofical poetry and surrealism combined in a unike way. I can`t listen to this song without feeling a connection with somethig witch exist beyond matter...

[ciferrara]

Grazie lo compro subito

[TheDSOTM1973]

@ciferrara

Ho risposto 3 volte.... Problemi col tubo!

[ciferrara]

Qualcuno mi sa dire quale è questo dvd? quale è il concerto. Mille grazie

[bokorro]

the strangest of all ,the guy is dressed in an office outfit and the shirt is still well tucked behind...bravo roger .

[Matyldonka]

I love that song!