since the VMAS Japan it had been a long time since not seeing a live performance! Im loving Bills body *.* his legs, his arms, his chest, and his face! *bites lip* that man keeps me going!! I fukin love seeing Tom play the guitar in front of Gustav! It looks so cute! and Georg`s bass playing skills are sooooooooo sexy!! ^.^
ma con che coraggio gli chiedono xk si chiamano Tokio Hotel? e sopratutto come fa Bill a formulare la risposta sempre in modo diverso? E' un genio. xD
Can I just say that it's incredibly sad that we get a fairly good quality video of a "secret show" after months of nothing and the first things fans do is try to determine whether it's live or not? I mean really??
@tokiotayo you said yourself it's not recent, which means they did this back when they were promoting in Japan. the fact that we just now get to see it doesn't mean they did something wrong or that they "owe us". whatever Japanese tv company that has the rights to this just now made it public outside of the country. what does that have to do with the band itself?
@tokiotayo IF it's playback, it's not used to "fool fans" (I mean really?), it's used to give a better performance FOR the fans (and potential fans). But once again, 1. I don't think it is, and 2. I'm done discussing it as I don't find it important.
@tokiotayo Eso no es engañar a las fans, varios artistas usan playback en presentaciones no importantes como esta. Obviamente en un concierto no usan playback, pero sí en presentaciones sin importancia.
@MaferDulanto Exacto! Es como si salieran en el programa de chismes de las 7. Obvio van a usar PB por que para algo tan corto no lo vale tanta preparacion.
No playback...are you deaf or what? Bill sings live...if you don't know yet..Bill can sing and he is great singer :) I love you Tokio Hotel <3 I'm proud to be alien...and Bill you are so cute here <3
@tokiotayo Honestly, the fact that Bill's voice doesn't sound as perfect as on the CD (a few wavering notes, imperfect acoustics, etc) makes me think this ISN'T playback.
@tokiotayo it's a possibility, but this version sounds different than the one from Humanoid City. That is, the notes Bill sings and the acoustics are not similar to the ones on tour. Then again, that's just me and what I hear.
@FairyCelt yeah but the break does exactly the same time that the humanoid city if you hear i mean when he say "we follow me in to the light" he make a pause exactly in the same momen at the cd
@tokiotayo as I said, I don't hear it as being the same as the Humanoid City tour (mainly because the sound it completely off from the tour performance). And I'm done debating this as it is unimportant. Instead of trying to play detective to see if it's live, I would rather enjoy the performance after months of not seeing anything brand new from the band.
since the VMAS Japan it had been a long time since not seeing a live performance! Im loving Bills body *.* his legs, his arms, his chest, and his face! *bites lip* that man keeps me going!! I fukin love seeing Tom play the guitar in front of Gustav! It looks so cute! and Georg`s bass playing skills are sooooooooo sexy!! ^.^
moonstarcrest27 1 month ago
This is soooo live
cindyta1993 2 months ago 2
I LOVE BILL HE SOOOO NICE
tokitaforever1000 2 months ago
I love the uhu of Bill in the beginning
awwwwww <3
nonniej483 2 months ago
finally a cameraman that shows Georgs playing for a decent amount of time. =D
gothmamafreedom 2 months ago
Damn....Bill has legs for fucking DAYS! *drools*
GuitarGoddess01 2 months ago
@FairyCelt what's your problem with my comment you little baby face?
LadyChrupek 2 months ago
TOKIO HOTEL AAAAWWWWWWWWWW !!!!!!!! :3
estrellatokita 2 months ago
I don't care if it's playback or not, They're perfect the same <3
fantwilight4ever1 2 months ago
Comment removed
fantwilight4ever1 2 months ago
LOL LOL of course it's live I know right? he sings so perfect that ppl think it's play back! They're perfect :DD
MrsSluty 2 months ago 2
Awwww 2:42 :D
thdiana92 2 months ago
Yay, something new! Or, new to us! (I'll stay out of the playback debate. :X)
THfanlucy 2 months ago
como pueden ser tan tontas y no conocer cuando bill canta en vivo, obvio que NO ES playback
kaltair06 2 months ago
it's not playback just look at his mouth . . .or.....whatever.
iama1directioner 2 months ago
Love it <3<3
Letthelightsexplode 2 months ago
Fuck it if it's playback or not! It's just a TV show, what really matter is that they don't do it in a live concert!
MyStrifyKaulitz 2 months ago
they looked fjkdsjflksdgfljdgl fine *__*
and of course they used their live cd material there ;) like for every performance/show after the tour (maybe not all songs)... IMO!
TOMsLiebhaber 2 months ago
He sings live with back up vocals. It's normal for a TV performance. stfu already.
ClaudiaTabak 2 months ago 4
aaaah no sound, I no can hear nothing!
why? :'(
The86vivi 2 months ago
if it is playback is for the show, but in concerts they play live! thats what matters!
vaniitha101 2 months ago
lol @ all the fans that dont care if a band uses playback or not. If you're okay with it it'll keep being done.
HarleyHatesYou 2 months ago
They're great I love them :-)
lionessgirl2007 2 months ago
<3<3
msjaklina 2 months ago
Playback or not, we know they are great live.
Stuttsis 2 months ago
It's not playback lol
EmooGirlxP 2 months ago
Ppl really needa GTFO or STFU! No one gives a fuck if its playback or not! Enjoy the music or GTFO
ArizBillTH 2 months ago
IF it's playback ( i don't think so) it's probably so that Bill can save his voice
daisy13111 2 months ago
Q Pena Pero Se Nota Q Es Un Concierto Obiamente Con Sus Efectos Pero Se Nota Q Es Un Concierto Y Ps Si No Te Gusta Ni Comente 7-7
I love Tokio Hotel The Best Of The World
natalia9707 2 months ago
i dont care if its playback...just they're amazing. :)
Pahyat 2 months ago 3
*_*
GOD!
I FUCKING LOVE THEM! <3
Daniielaa89th 2 months ago
aha.... aha.... :D
sveKKau 2 months ago 2
our guys is rocking!)
dreamfreakjenny 2 months ago
TOKIO HOTEL ♥ BEST BAND IN THE WORLD !
CaRlA7fanTH 2 months ago
I can't hear anything :/
MaferDulanto 2 months ago
I love it I love it ;D ;D ;D
HenriettaKaulitz 2 months ago
LOVE YOU TH!!!
shyrsol06 2 months ago
Comment removed
BrenHerzAlien 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
No, they just use the DVD version of the part where Bill says Hello! , after that, everything is in live.
In most of the interview they did the live show (in Japan), they did that.
tifani91 2 months ago
Is it only me enjoying that Bill is with black hair & make-up again? ;D
Yes, he's beautiful all the ways, but still - I like him more when is with make-up, black hair, thiny body & weird hair! ;D <3
billXhearts 2 months ago
@billXhearts This is an old performance. Bill has no snakebites (;
EmokidloveTH 2 months ago
I agree with @Fairycelt.
Here we get a never before seen performace - and an amazing one - and all people do is discussing if it´s playback or not!!!!
Just enjoy it people for Gods sake!!!!!
tetric1 2 months ago 14
@tetric1 damn agree too!
BritneyIsFemmeFatale 2 months ago
Comment removed
tifani91 2 months ago
The best band ever.
BKxAddict 2 months ago
Comment removed
FairyCelt 2 months ago
ma con che coraggio gli chiedono xk si chiamano Tokio Hotel? e sopratutto come fa Bill a formulare la risposta sempre in modo diverso? E' un genio. xD
Cmq: fantastici <3
483marty 2 months ago
WOW!!! SE LUCIERON...
shyrsol06 2 months ago
i miss the g's even more now:(
MsTinkerbelle87 2 months ago
Hermoso!!!!!!!
u_u los extraño tanto
la APP es genial, pero quiero verlos
a los 4 juntos (G,G,T,B)
que saquen ya su nuevo disco!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
NaLlElYZwilling2 2 months ago
Can I just say that it's incredibly sad that we get a fairly good quality video of a "secret show" after months of nothing and the first things fans do is try to determine whether it's live or not? I mean really??
FairyCelt 2 months ago
@FairyCelt
1.- that show is not recent
2.-and precisely because we do not deserve to make us a performance to playback after so
tokiotayo 2 months ago
@tokiotayo you said yourself it's not recent, which means they did this back when they were promoting in Japan. the fact that we just now get to see it doesn't mean they did something wrong or that they "owe us". whatever Japanese tv company that has the rights to this just now made it public outside of the country. what does that have to do with the band itself?
FairyCelt 2 months ago
@FairyCelt no quiero decir que los involucre a ellos si no que no se vale que usen un fondo musical para engañar a los fans
tokiotayo 2 months ago
@tokiotayo IF it's playback, it's not used to "fool fans" (I mean really?), it's used to give a better performance FOR the fans (and potential fans). But once again, 1. I don't think it is, and 2. I'm done discussing it as I don't find it important.
FairyCelt 2 months ago 14
@tokiotayo Eso no es engañar a las fans, varios artistas usan playback en presentaciones no importantes como esta. Obviamente en un concierto no usan playback, pero sí en presentaciones sin importancia.
MaferDulanto 2 months ago
@MaferDulanto Exacto! Es como si salieran en el programa de chismes de las 7. Obvio van a usar PB por que para algo tan corto no lo vale tanta preparacion.
trikigomez 2 months ago
guys, this is playback.
LadyChrupek 2 months ago
Comment removed
FairyCelt 2 months ago
I love them <3
VeroFreiheit 2 months ago
No playback...are you deaf or what? Bill sings live...if you don't know yet..Bill can sing and he is great singer :) I love you Tokio Hotel <3 I'm proud to be alien...and Bill you are so cute here <3
KarolineLeslie 2 months ago
hicieron playback?
tokiotayo 2 months ago
@tokiotayo Honestly, the fact that Bill's voice doesn't sound as perfect as on the CD (a few wavering notes, imperfect acoustics, etc) makes me think this ISN'T playback.
FairyCelt 2 months ago
@FairyCelt well maybe they used the cd of humanoid city or not? i think is a possibility
tokiotayo 2 months ago
@tokiotayo it's a possibility, but this version sounds different than the one from Humanoid City. That is, the notes Bill sings and the acoustics are not similar to the ones on tour. Then again, that's just me and what I hear.
FairyCelt 2 months ago
@FairyCelt yeah but the break does exactly the same time that the humanoid city if you hear i mean when he say "we follow me in to the light" he make a pause exactly in the same momen at the cd
tokiotayo 2 months ago
@tokiotayo as I said, I don't hear it as being the same as the Humanoid City tour (mainly because the sound it completely off from the tour performance). And I'm done debating this as it is unimportant. Instead of trying to play detective to see if it's live, I would rather enjoy the performance after months of not seeing anything brand new from the band.
FairyCelt 2 months ago
@tokiotayo no es playback es en vivo *--*!!
giuTomKaulitz 2 months ago
@giuTomKaulitz igual y pudieron usar el cd de humanoid city para hacer un plaback mas "real" no crees? osea un truco bastante bueno
tokiotayo 2 months ago
Excellent! Secret Shows Haha
MrHumanoidTv 2 months ago
@MrHumanoidTv Yeah, even I was wondering the same. Secret shows! Well said.
NedraLilith 2 months ago