Mariah Carey & Amy Lee

[MissCraZy4895]

I don't like this type of music that mariah carey sings but i have to admit that she has got perfect voice. Amy Lee is my idol so I love her anyway :)

[krist3n626]

im not a huge fan of mariah carey and so i ask why is it when she hit the high notes 1:58 - 2:48 she kept touching her ears? b/c the "high pitch-ness" (so 2 speak) of her own voice? O.o um, alrite then! Amy Lee is so much more talented then mariah carey anyhow

[karen55478]

conserteza eu sou mais emy lee claro a mariah carey canta pra caramba mas eu amo a amy lee

[wachm3]

Mariah Carey = Cunt

[sacharagoobar]

uuummm ok but both of them are really awesome singers...dont get me wrong i like Mariah alot bt i <3 AMY !!!!

[wadefire23]

let me say a part of me yeah i will admit that i love pop music but a big part of me is rock ,metal,i will say i love mariah but i more love amy :D

[ferenznadasdy]

esta mariah suena como un maldito pajaro de mierda qe asco ¡¡¡

[MissCrystalBawl]

Oh my God...Does she shatter glass?

[3BsAlaska]

Mariah is talented. but i dont like her as a person. Amy is suuuper talented, and i LOVE her as a person.and i think shes prettier. but thats just my opinon.

[BellaSwan406]

8:25 - 9:14 omg look at that awful hair!!

[BellaSwan406]

Mariah Carey sounds like a fucking chirping bird

[BellaSwan406]

@BellaSwan406 and a broken record

[LynneCorrea]

num tem nem comparação !! Amy Lee com certeza <3

[andrijana1991]

♥ AMY LEE!!! ♥

I don't hate Mariah Carey, I just like more gothic metal. :)) ♥

[monysaints]

I love Amy Lee!!!!

[vanessamjeff]

I like them both! It just depends on my mood.

[TheKaylaBernardo]

it mostly showd maria carey .__.

[chicababyphat]

amy is awsome and has a great voice aswell.

[chicababyphat]

i love mariah she gives me the chills when she sings

[iloveevanescence1795]

AMY! <3

[animalscrossing]

Hey are they enemies? why the hell is this for?

[rckrvt19]

I love them both.

[Ladysolittude]

amy is supreme

[LoveMusicForeverLMF]

@MariahCelineFan Not even a chance.

[angel0634]

Why si everyone trying to compare them? They're COMPLETELY different!

[Violetdoll16]

Amy ! (L)

[patogena]

cuando amy canta la cancion de mariah....estas igual!!!

[MorbidVampire1]

Mariah aos 3:38 parece um cd riscado XD LOL Amy Lee Forever

[Criiistinna]

@MorbidVampire1 nossa, eu acho essa parte maravilhosa! como ela consegue fazer isso? *-*

[Beaubeauyyy]

Amy Lee........ I love you soooooooooooooo

You are queen of rock.......

[xevanescencex4evax]

that without you song mariah covered it but anywho i love both the rock

[Badboy306mustang]

Everything you show is old Mariah she is past her prime seen her on the Today show.Nothing like she use to be at all!!

[RoniRoy3000]

amy lee rocks

[MKNJ1109]

I used to love Mariah but when she started singing that nigger crap I lost all respect for her  f u Mariah

[JessiMarie1010]

Mariah Carey is okay, but I got a little annoyed at her super-high pitched screech-like singing in this video... overall, I prefer Amy Lee.

[BigBlyeEyes1234]

Mariah Carey is a much better singer. I like Amy Lee but she's no MC.

[Koriinjrocklova]

Mariah Carey is the best! Amy lee is the best! <---comments I see. What I say: Both are the best! Mariah has like a lighter tone while Amy has a darker kind of tone. Like Mariah=light blue, Amy=Navy blue. That probably doesn't make sense....

[ThePepii19]

@Koriinjrocklova It make a lot of sense for me

[eugenvalentin89]

mariah carey is more known because she sings pop music witch is more commercial...amy lee sings rock witch is also known but not as commercial...anyway they're both natural talented :)

[Olivercord]

LOL ? mariah carey is the best singer in the world... omg Amy lee is also wonderful, but mariah is the best.....

[PinkSakuraMoon]

they r powerfull...but i love amy lee more..:)

[charmedones2009]

Mariah Carey Lead The Way..

[jessicapedhe]

like light vs dark

[OJLuscious]

Lee is better? Wow ppl are sooooo dumb! MC is my inspiration, she is the BEST! Amy Lee is GREAT! but she is no way NEAR BETTER than Mariah

[2JoeBLACK7]

Nice

[seguindoAmyLee]

Amy foreeeeever!!!!

[BigBlyeEyes1234]

I don't mind me some Evanescence, but Mariah is definetly the better singer. Amy's voice is a bit too much sometimes.

[GeorgeLoveful1]

Amy Lee Forever!!!

[smokey56265]

i hate all the female singers who over do it when they sing cause then it just sounds like crap and amy doesn't do that unlike mariah

[veromariahfan]

Lol my two favourites artist!!!!! BUT Mariah is THE GODDESS!!!!!!! She's the best vocalist in earth!!!♥♥♥ she have power, range, unique texture, very low notes, she has everything!!!!!!!!♥♥♥ But i love amy anyway!!! :D

[MoonAutumnify]

I don't like Mariah's voice. It's too high. She sounds like a mouse instead of a singer. Amy Lee best <3

[hasekrocks]

The difference isn't just the style, its that Amy is rock and Marish is not. Amy Lee is Rock Royalty and amazingly more talented..... and she doesnt have to be half naked to prove it *cough cough*. Mariah sucks

[amberlynnew1]

Mariah is annoying.... there are a coupl songs I listen to, that's it.

[paoidky]

amy lee is soo much better...!!!\

[iiAmitx3]

yea im sure Pepsi thought what can we do with mariah on our commercial? ohh we'll copy amy from her clip everybody's fool! and mariah's beautiful and she likes to show it off she's a diva. so im not gonna take this video as a hate video cause you weren't saying mean stuff about her. but to all the people saying negative stuff about mariah, amy will never be better than her...

[MsDemiLovatoo]

Amy Lee ! 

[AnnyCullen1995Kiryuu]

7:54 Muse!!

[AnnyCullen1995Kiryuu]

2:58 sounds much better than the original

[melilla32]

this could be a great duet!! MIMI and Amy will be number 1 sure!!

[venausar1]

Can someone please remind me what Mariah is singing from 8:29-9:16?

[iiAmitx3]

@venausar1 My all! :) @AnnyCullen1995Kiryuu how can 2:58 be better than the original when you can hear the "original" after and hear that it's way better! 3:05 >>> 2:58

[aaronbenvenuti14]

alot of mariah's modern belting and whistle register is mimed because she has some throat dieseas the same one that julie andrews had

[TheMickj23q]

@aaronbenvenuti14 NO! Mariah's had vocal nodules since she was a kid, she's worked with it vocally. Julie Andrews had an operation to help her nodules that in fact left her not being able to sing at all! Get ur facts straight!

[aaronbenvenuti14]

@TheMickj23q i know im late in replying but vocal nodules are from over singing so i highly doubt she's had them since she was a kid it takes time! just sayin

[TheMickj23q]

@aaronbenvenuti14 Mariah sings in the whistle register and she has said many times she developed them as a child as she'd sing in that register... you don't even know her vocals so you can't say what she does or does not have!

[aaronbenvenuti14]

@TheMickj23q cause ur totally her vocal chords right haha ok little stalker mariah stan even if she can sing in whistle register that doesnt mean she instantly got them as a kid maby like her early twenties when she was still young

[yina112329]

doesn't matter if Mariah uses her body, it won't take away the fact that she can really sing. They both are amazing singers, have no words 4 Mariah's voice live same with Amy so why do we even compare them when they clearly do different things & have different styles. like them both <3

[EvHateisForbidden]

By vocal abilities Mariah's better then amy, but Amy Has different vocal.. her voice sound like angels songs... it's abnormal.

[EvHateisForbidden]

Of Course Amy Lee,I'm dying for Amys voice... But I respect mariah too. she has amazing vocal... but Amy Rules!

[karina1678f]

but i still like mariahs squeaks

[karina1678f]

Amy Lee is better i Love Evanescence

[Blackrose6767]

I got goose bumps at everytime I hear Amy Lee's voice.

[Blackrose6767]

I got goose bumps at 6:54.. only Amy Lee can do that. I was listening to Mariah Carey, I only like few of her songs. But Amy *SCREAM* She moves your soul!!! AMY LEE ROCKS!!

[bcrary2488]

mariah could make a scream and a squeak sound like heaven

[BriaMaex]

Amy Lee.

She uses her voice no her body and I respect that.

[aldys92]

I love Amy and Evanescence is my favorite band... but Mariah is a legend :)

[DarkArtist]

What concert is the Fly Like a Bird performance from?

[WutangClan4LiF3]

different voice for different genres.... open your head that much and you ll get it

[tonytonz88]

Mariah has a better voice. Both good. I dont like who Mariah is now and what she has become. But she can sing like no one else

[caarankin69]

i'd love to see them two sing a song together

[Daanava]

Everyone is talanted who writes their songs. their songs is their face. I like Amy Lee songs more. Mariah Carey - will not remember any of them tomorrow. Anyway Tarja Turunen is better :-)

[AdamsMusic11]

i really respect you for making this comparison vid... it's genius!!!!!

[BenMoodyFan]

AMY LEE 4ever !!

[natelaaly21]

At 3:35 mariah looks like she is givin a Blowjob. Sorry made me laugh. I think mariah has a good voice. But why brag about havin a whistle register it sounds bloody awful.

[AmyLeeRules111]

Amy Lee is the most amazing person in the universe, and Evanescence is the best THING in the universe. I think Mariah Carey is overrated, and the only reason she gets attention is because she uses her body to get attention, where as Amy, is an amazing person inside and out so everyone loves everything about her anyway.

[AmyLeeRules111]

@AmyLeeRules111 But Mariah is talented!! Just in my opinion, Amy is more talented.

[RaciouS91]

@AmyLeeRules111 bla bla bla. So why do they say mariah had a 5 octave vocal range? My god, in fact, she wrote most of her songs.

[eltazz1]

1:28 what is that AAAAAAAAAMMMMMMMMMMYYYYYYYYY IS WAY BETTER GO AMY GO AMY GO AMY GO AMY

[TheSpecial9]

I think that Amy is more original.

[SuperEttezus]

^^

[TheDeadlyFurby]

What song is it at 1.59? please

[monsterlady6]

PERFECT AMY LEE IS BEST AND THANK`YOU FOR MUSIC ! I LOVE YOU AMY AND MARIAH!

[VivienneRoi]

love amy leeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee! <3 <3

[DarKiNeZiS]

Difference*

[dnangel109]

what song at 2:45??????

[alfonsdark]

Lee is Better.

[BananRadar]

You forgot to put in the description that they are also both beautiful!

[Dreamb4reality]

I have looked to both singers for inspiration myself. Although I have the soul of Mariah's more R&B style, I am more a rock singer-! My recent songs have been more bluesy lately.

[anastasiyia]

mariah ugly!!!she like a monkey, amy very beutiful and her voice too much better

[resigal04]

Also, I feel Amy can pull off a larger range, she can go straight from a high note to a very low note

[resigal04]

I personally like Amy Lee WAAAAAAY better. Mariah's high notes are too screechy, more like yelling. Her normal voice is amazing but her high notes are just too much screeching

[freshkidd4life21]

i thing amy lee is waaaaaaaaayyy better then mariah carey

[ale5677]

Both really talented artists in their own unique ways BUT Amy lee only in her dreams is better than Mariah Carey. Vocally this is not even a competition Mariah Carey murders her even know Amy Lee is a good vocalist BUT compared to Mariah Carey she is just another mediocre singer in the bunch. MARIAH IS JUST OUT OF THIS PLANET. Oh! And Amy Lee tends to scream to much sometimes is like she's trying so hard to sing in a register that doen'st go with her voice. She DOESN'T have a whistle register!

[cblachsa]

AMY LEE <3

[Scremo3mo]

You should of shown Amy Lee's Higher notes. Like her high E6 nd what not. But yes both verry talented.

[88evanescence]

Amy Lee rocks!!!!!!!!!!!!! ^,.,^

[hessounusual95]

i love them both,

i like mariah carey's voice overall as a whole.

But i love amy lee's tone, especially in her head voice notes, there just beautiful

and haunting

both talented women of there genre's :D

[pumkinchunkin123]

I dont really like Mariah, she sqeaks (to her its SINGING) but it sounds like she squealing and screaming into the mic. but Amy sounds like she yelling in the mic because she MOVES AROUND ON STAGE, and dances around, that could make you really tired and hard to sing. I <3 Amy Lee.

[pumkinchunkin123]

I used to like Mariah, then I saw he style and everything, then I didn't like her. But i've been a long fan of Amy Lee since i was in 4th grade the first time I heard one of her songs. AMY LEE 4 LIFE '<3

[raul7193]

mm, hard, both are very beautiful voices. But amy sounds a lil forced sometimes, like an overdone sound. Any way both are great.

[lanakatana]

You posted alot more Mariah Carey than Amy...

:P

Shows youre side. :<

But Amy is better, Mariah just does alot more with her voice.... which keeps people interested and more people listen to her as a mainstream thing.

[ekiiim]

Mariah the Best Forever <3

[NaldinhoAzumy]

Gostei muito do vídeo...

antes de tudo sou fã da Amy x)

respeito muito a Mariah ,mais a voz da Amy é angelical,como pode ser visto nas seguintes musica: Good Enough , My immortal ,Call Me When You're Sober (Acústico) e muintas outras...

[7891midnight]

my god mariah carey doesnt waste a breath

[unknownthinges]

Amy Lee \o

Im just a fan. Respect the other opnion, that is mine.

[dorker1992]

Amy doesnt need to be sexy to compete. Im sure Mariah doesnt have to but she does it to get attention while amy doesnt. But they are different in styles anyway.

But i think Amy is underrated when it comes to her voice.. people mention christina, mariah but amy isnt really ever mentioned much when it coems to voice.

[WhitneyElizabethH]

@dorker1992

Amy could kill Christina

[dorker1992]

@WhitneyElizabethH  Yeh Amy is soooooo Under-rated!! there should be more credit for her voice!! and i love mariah too..however more when she was fresh and didnt expose her brown unnatural cleavge to the world.

[WhitneyElizabethH]

@dorker1992

The most overrated vocalist in the world is Christina, her technique is Horrendous and she thins out and loses resonance after C5, Amy would devour her in a duet, i hope it happenes soon!

[dorker1992]

@WhitneyElizabethH i think christina over sings like u know if u sing too high or big for too long ur voice gets tired and strains and CRACK!! like u're having a poop! sometimes when xtina over sings i hear this!! do you notice?

[WhitneyElizabethH]

@dorker1992

yeh ur practicly telling me something i already know :D

[dorker1992]

@WhitneyElizabethH :D Hello my new best friend!! I love whitney!! fav female singer ever!! and the best

[WhitneyElizabethH]

@dorker1992

lol :P

[RaciouS91]

@dorker1992 sexy is just for commercial and style. Of course physical appearance, gave some sort of attention.

[javachipo]

why did amy lee stop singing ?:( she has great voice n personality ( love her :( )

[gloomyxcookie]

@javachipo She didn't stop singing. They're working on their new album... o.O But it might come out in 2011 instead of 2010

[spirkass]

dear god... what were you thinking with this video? amy lee has nothing to do with carey. omg it's an insult to compare them. i'm not saying that carey is bad but dude... it's like mr. bean vs einstein... they're both good but you will never see their names together :-)

[duntzwitch]

I kinda felt this was more like, "Miriah Carey and a little Amy Lee" ....

[760emo]

Most of mariah carey's pics are edited! amy is real. plus mariah carey got a boob job!

[trhoward8502]

Both are amazing singers, but you don't see Mariah singing like she use to!

[Blackcat0x66]

they both have amazing voices but i think amy is better <3 but they sound awesome live unlike other singers that sound like crap live, oh and amy doesnt need to strip down to look hot nor sexy.

[evilsteezle]

I think Amy has much better stage performance. She does more than just throw her arms around like an evangalist.

[neverendingchrissi]

omg does anyone know how i can make the youtube videos on my computer stop stopping or skipping whatever u wanna call it

[XnightroseX]

Mariah's vocals give me shivers, even when she is singing up-beat music, she shits on everyone. Amy Lee is way over-rated, i mean sure her voice is good, but there are many singers who are much better. I love Mariahs old stuff. We belong Together was her last good song.

[r92cab]

amy lee doesnt have surgery...or am I wrong.?

[SoNotEmonescence]

Amy and Mariah are both amazing vocalists!  I thought it was funny that you compared them though, because they're such diffrent styles. Personally, Amy is my favorite, but reasantly, I've been listening to some Mariah Carey because my vocal coach wants me to listen to other vocalists with whistle register. I loked the video. Very Good. =)

[Falenir]

I agree with this... but I've have to say that mariahs stuff from musicbox is a way better demonstration of her talent.

Anyone that disagrees that both mariah and amy lee have amazing talent is not looking at technical talent. They could both shatter glass. The only problem I had with mariah was her all over the place style. Other than that though she could outsing any female vocalist on the planet... including wittney houston and celine dion.

[0rianaWisdom]

Nice video. I love them both. I like alternative the best though.

[Amygirlevangirl]

AMY HAVE MORE POWER SHE IS SO FUCKING AWESOME

[ChristinaARihanna]

I think Amy Lee is so much better than Mariah Carey!

[2bastarborn1]

Who in the world has the temerity, the umittigated gall to compare MARIAH with Amy Lee? Mariah is a Lioness, Amy a mere sad sounding, depressing, downer, a kitten in omparison. Mariah is from another galaxy musically! Please...Mariah outsings, Whitney when she could sing, Glady's Knight, Aretha Franklin, Celine Dione, Patty Label, Shaunice, the former great Minnie Rippleton, Cristinia Aquilara, Pink - all the rest of present and past great performers. Mariah is still head and shoulders above

[2012oceanlover]

I love amy lee! i get people have their opinions, but anyone who says amy lee can't sing has serious hearing problems....she can big time. i don't listen to mariah, but i've heard a couple of her songs, and she has a good voice too :). both very talented singers!

[ServatisPericulum]

Am=) Evanescence 4 life!!

[InsaneGoonRules]

Mariah sucks. Amy rules.

[harryp7111]

lol the ending is funny .. i have respect for mariah but amy is my favorit i like her style and the fact that she unlike other female artist uses other atributes other than her sexuality. what can i say the music sells its self

[Tombothebomb]

r u kidding?

mariah carey has been compared to whitney Houston,Celine dion,Aretha Franklin

the fact ur comparing Amy is an insult

[RaciouS91]

@Tombothebomb hahahahaha

[ZAshleyAngieZ]

i love amy's smile at the end...so cute : )

[sweetsacrifice180]

i don't like mariah carey she looks like a ....lol XD but i love amy lee ^_^ i can't wait for the new eva album

[SeaKitten00]

Haha they're both terrible, mariah carey sounds like a rusty door and amy lee wails like a dying cat, sorry just my opinion

[Criiistinna]

guy, you have to open your mind!

[SeaKitten00]

I'm a girl actually =)

Sorry don't mean to sound bitchy but I've opened my mind to far more talented singers than these two and honestly both amy and mariah are way, WAY too overrated for talents neither of them have

[Criiistinna]

Yeah, you have your opinion of course! But you have to agree that musically this singers are very tallent... They have their own qualities.

[Criiistinna]

And sorry about ''guy'' =/

[TristanandIsolt]

@SeaKitten00 Just because they are famous does not mean they don't have talent. Maybe, just maybe they got famous because they do have talent. What an Idea. Sure there are many talented people who are not famous but you invalidate yourself by saying Mariah and Amy are not talented.

[LeTressino]

@SeaKitten00 You may not like them and their styles... but you can't say they're not talented.

[zellytega12]

@SeaKitten00 Sounds Like your a bit jealous, or maybe just real Stuckup

[ZAshleyAngieZ]

ur fav idol sucks, ok? : )... u like that uh?! dont insult none of them they both rocks

[animefan848]

@SeaKitten00 I am a huge Amy Lee fan but I understand, most people have different ears and prefer a different sound to their music.

[adr14ntr]

@SeaKitten00 I've seen your channel, and I see that you like same bands that I love, and the same singers: Tarja, Simone, Liv... but I dont know why a lot of fans of Symphonic Metal bitch on Amy, Amy Lee is very good and Evanescence is as good as many symphonic/gothic metal bands

[pannenkoekensmurf]

@SeaKitten00 WTF what's wrong with you

[loveisgreat41]

@SeaKitten00 I know that you are entitled to you're opinion however, you should get a life rather than hating on these two amazingly different women you coward...grow up and stop hating on them just because you don't even have half of the talent they posses.

[taffie411]

@SeaKitten00 WOW! WHAT A POOR JUDGMENT IN MUSIC!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! OBVIOUSLY U ARE JUST A JEALOUS PATHETIC PIECE OF CRAP! AMY LEE AND MARIAH CAREY ARE THE BEST SINGERS EVER!

[immahotpepper]

amy aint a slut, shes classy and talented.

[xSashaxinSanityx]

Amy all the way ^^

[pablorubiolugo]

Mariah has 5 octaves, Amy Lee, like 3 0r 3.5.

Mariah is the best vocalist in popular music history, Amy Lee is nothing without her

[1993evanescence]

I love them both..but amy is better.