@JudgeD007 i think people misunderstand mawlid, what it represents. If you suggest Sahaba remembered Prophet(pbuh) in his life and after he departed from this world. I agree Prophet(pbuh) should be remembered every day and not just one day. his life should be celebrated everyday. To remember the day he was born is recommend and forbidden, there is no evidence in the Quran nor hadith to suggest it is forbidden.
@mainmosque Show me thw evidwnce where Prophet(pbuh) has forbidden remembering, celebrating his life, showing gratitude to Allah for sending him(pbuh).
Celebrating the Prophet(SAW) birthday is NOT a Sunnah , its not something the Sahaba did or the generations after them- a king introduced it about 600 year after SAW. Allah (SWT) and his Rasool (SAW) only gave us 2 annual Eids- are you saying they forgot to tell us about one of them?
The Sahaba loved Muhammad (SAW) more than anyone - they did not celebrate it- Are you saying YOU love the Prophet more than the Sahaba ?
YE MURDAAR DOCTOR ISRAAR JAHANUM MAI JAAL RAHA HAI,ISNAI JITNI MARTABA BHE NABI E KAREEM S.A.W KA NAME PAK LEYA HAI NOTE KARAIN K KAHEN BHE IS HARAMI NE DUROOD PAK NAHE PARHA.BUS YEHE IS K HARAMI JAHANAMI HONAY KA SUBOOT HAI.WASALAM
JO JO DR.SAHAB SE IKHTILAAF KERTA HAI WO JAAN LAIN K HUZOOR S.A.W.W KI NA TAREEF MANA HAI NA DUROOD MANA HAI....DUROOD PADHNEY K LIYE JHANDEY LEYKEY MEHFIL SAJA KER CHILLA CHILLA KER LOUD SPEAKER PER DUROOD NAHIN PADH SAKTEY....IMPORTANT DEEN MAIN WO KAAM HAI JISKA ''HUKUM''''' HAI.DEEN SARE KA SAARA HUMKUM PER CHALNA HAI..MAGHRIB KI NAMAZ 4 RAKAT PADHNEY MAIN KIA BURAI HAI..THODI AYAT HI ZIADA PADHO GEY..KUCH SAJDEY HI ZIADA HONGEY..BURA KIA HAI IS MAIN????BURA YE HAI K YE HUKUM K KHILAAF HAI.
Inke imaan ka undaza is baat se hi lagalo bhai, ke wo din jis din Allah ne tamaam Alamo ke lie Rehmat-allil-Alaameen bheja, us din ki khushi mananay ko ye log kitna na pasand kartay hein ... In se poocha jaye konsa esa kaam hai jo Mehfil-e-Milaad-un-Nabi(SAWW) mein hota ho aur wo Allah ya Rasool (SAWW) ko napand ho...
Milad-un-Nabi (SAWW) mein konsi esi cheeze hai jo ke bidaat ho? Kia Tilawat bidaat hai Nauzubillah ? Kia Uske baad Hamd Perhna bidaat hai? Kia Naat perhna bidaat hai ? kia Salaam bhejna bidaat hai ? Kia mehfil ke ikhtitaam per Allah se dua maangna bidaat hai ? ager inmein se koi bhi cheeze bidaat nahi, to mehfil bidaat kese hosakti hai, jahaan log Allah aur uske Habib (SAWW) ki tareef bayan kartay hon ? Jo log Mehfil-e-Milaad-Un-Nabi (SAWW) ko bidaat kehtay hein actually unko takleef hai.
@odaaroo yaar good comment , keya masla hai in logo ko, ke Nabi paak ki hushi nahi mana saktey, kahan ka ishq hai yeh? koi nahi, doorr nahi hai woh din jab in ke paas pachtaway ke siwa kuch nahi hoga. Allah in ko hidayat dey . Ameen
@missmisyar You are right, meri nazer mein in logon ke dil mein ek bugz hein, ye log sub bardasht karsaktay hein bus ye nahi bardasht kersaktay ke Huzoor (SAWW) ki tareef bayan ki jae, inke pass koi esa proof nahi jis se ye Milaad-Un-Nabi (SAWW) ko ghalat sabit karsakein, aur bhai kia Allah aur Huzoor (SAWW) ki tareef bayan kerne ke lie bhi koi certificate layna hoga, Allah ka to hukum hai Huzoor (SAWW) per durood aur salaam bhejo, Nabi(SAWW) hein hi taareef ke laiq to kyun na karein ham tareef
@missmisyar You are right, meri nazer mein in logon ke dil mein ek bugz hein, ye log sub bardasht karsaktay hein bus ye nahi bardasht kersaktay ke Huzoor (SAWW) ki tareef bayan ki jae, inke pass koi esa proof nahi jis se ye Milaad-Un-Nabi (SAWW) ko ghalat sabit karsakein, aur bhai kia Allah aur Huzoor (SAWW) ki tareef bayan kerne ke lie bhi koi certificate layna hoga, Allah ka to hukum hai Huzoor (SAWW) per durood aur salaam bhejo, Nabi(SAWW) hein hi taareef ke laiq to kyun na karein ham tareef
@MrSarfaraz85 Aik sawal hai app se jis din roza ho uss din eid hoti hai kia or jiss din eid ho us din roza hota hai kia agar nahee to mera AAQA MUHAMMAD (SAW) ni uss din roza rakh ker ummat ko bataya kay bahi meri piadaish walay din ko eid na mana kiou kay ma roza rakhta hoon or jis din roza ho us din eid nahee hoti.. Roza walay din roza hota hai or eid walay din eid .
lo molana sahib jo meelaad waghaira k baray main dalil le kar aay hain or inhon ne jo hadees bayaan ki ha es k matan (words) main kahan likha ha k mmeelaad manana haraam ha???
aise he apni taraf se meaning nikaal lena koi achi baat nahi ha Hazoor ne khud irshaad farmaia k main har monday ka roza es liay rakhta hon kiun k main es din paida howa. ab Hazoor khud aoni aamad ka kisse wajah se ahtamaam kar rahain hain or es molana ne aik hadees he ka ghalat mean le lia ha
@atiqsajid01 yaani aap 2 ghantey ki shadi guzar ker, orat ko bachey ki maa bana ker talaq de saktey ho?
nah meri jaan, kin ulama ki baat kertey ho, keya yeh upni betiyan qurban kerein gey kuch din ke liey? keya main keya aap? hosh kero. jago is sey pehley ke abadi neend so jaao.
@atiqsajid01 jee jee dekhi hai video, yakeenan aap ko ghor kerney ki zaroorat hai per shaed fursat nahi,or aap ke arabs ahl e hadees bhai is ko kesey istemaal ker rahay hain ? keya ye misyaar hai, yeh to aap ki porani aadat hai, ke aayat e Qurani ka ghalat terjuma, ahadees ka ghalat matlab. tumeh hosh us wakt aaey gi jab muh per matti perey gi. yaar anaa ka masla nahi hai tumsey, muslim bhai ho tum upney is liey time waste nahi kertey ke tum sey reyal chahiey, is liey k tum sey piyar hai.
@atiqsajid01 bhai matlab saaf hai, key laraai jagda nahi or nah he dushmani hai aap logo sey or nah kisi cheez ki lalach hai, thats because i love you. or yaar aap apney ulamaa ki kutab perh ker yaa takareer sunn ker follow kertey ho, or Alhamdulillah hum ney to dekha hai ankho sey toh yakeen kesey nah ho. ummeed hai ab aap ko samajh aa gai ho gi. baki tabeeb ka kaam hai dawai dena, shifa to Allah ney deni hai na.
Hafiz Ibn Kathir writes:" On the day of the birth of the Prophet (May Allah bless him and grant him peace) Shaytan cried a lot." [Ibn Kathir, Sirat an-Nabi, 'Birth of the Prophet']
From Ibn Kathir's narration we can see that to feel unhappy on the birthday of the Prophet (May Allah bless him and grant him peace) is the way of Shaytan, not the way of a Muslim!
Hafiz Ibn Kathir writes:" On the day of the birth of the Prophet (May Allah bless him and grant him peace) Shaytan cried a lot." [Ibn Kathir, Sirat an-Nabi, 'Birth of the Prophet']
From Ibn Kathir's narration we can see that to feel unhappy on the birthday of the Prophet (May Allah bless him and grant him peace) is the way of Shaytan, not the way of a Muslim!
Hafiz Ibn Kathir writes:" On the day of the birth of the Prophet (May Allah bless him and grant him peace) Shaytan cried a lot." [Ibn Kathir, Sirat an-Nabi, 'Birth of the Prophet']
From Ibn Kathir's narration we can see that to feel unhappy on the birthday of the Prophet (May Allah bless him and grant him peace) is the way of Shaytan, not the way of a Muslim!
Hafiz Ibn Kathir writes:" On the day of the birth of the Prophet (May Allah bless him and grant him peace) Shaytan cried a lot." [Ibn Kathir, Sirat an-Nabi, 'Birth of the Prophet']
From Ibn Kathir's narration we can see that to feel unhappy on the birthday of the Prophet (May Allah bless him and grant him peace) is the way of Shaytan, not the way of a Muslim!
MiddleEast ALWAYS at war! Mohammad violent SINFUL cult Murderer!Jesus/Healed/Blessed/Peace/Salvation/GOD! All MUSLIMS who converted to Christianity ARE HAPPY & FREE OF ABUSE & MISERY! Islam leaders are killing you! Christians LOVE YOU! PLEASE accept JESUS CHRIST as your SAVIOR! John 3:16 He that believeth on the Son hath everlasting life: and he that believeth not the Son shall not see life; but the wrath of God abideth on him! REBEL & ACCEPT JESUS! Be FREE of ISLAM LIES! Visit wlix radio.com
The Sahaba, earlier imams did not see this as an issue because they were engrossed in the Prophet(pbuh) devotion and remembering him everyday. Today Muslims need to be reminded of that blessing of Allah which earlier Muslims never forgot. Every believer must be happy and grateful for the blessing of the Final Messenger of Allah (pbuh). Its a sign of Iman to be happy for this blessingand should be everyday, but if not at least once in a year.
Mirza, Why once a year why not the entire year. Muhammd never celebrated his birthday and he also disallowed such things inspired by Satan. Do you know what goes on in these meelaads and how these meeladi call for even more innovations.
Mirza, Why once a year why not the entire year. Muhammad never celebrated his birthday and he also disallowed such things inspired by Satan. Do you know what goes on in these meelaads and how these meeladi call for even more innovations.
atleast open your ears, eyes and hearts. what did he said in his talks is from quran and hadeesh so plz do not take offences if you do so then Salam to you and goodby
HE IS TEACHING YOU VERY CLEARLY DON'T DO THIS, DON'T DO THAT OTERWISE WHATEVER HE SAYS NOT TO DO, IT HAS BEEN DONE AND IT WILL HAPEN UNTIL THE OF JUDGEMENT.
LETS BELIEVE IN THE PROFIT WITH A TRUE FEEELINGS , TRUE LOVE TRUE EMOTIONS.
AND
IF YOU THINK THERE IS NO EMOTIONS, NO LOVE, NO FEELINGS IN ISLAM, YOU CAN OBJECT MY SAYING AND I WILL PROOF IT.
BROTHERS I M NOT A SCHOLER, I M JUST A SIMPLE MISLIM, I LISTEN TO PREACHERS ASWEL BUT I LISTEN TO THE ONE WHO REMINDS US THE STORIES AND RESPECT OF PROFIT, STORIES AND RESPECT OF SAHABA AND DAYS OF ALLAH. N SO MUCH MORE BUT NOT NAGITIVE TALK.
HE KNOWS HE IS TELLING YOU WRONG BECAUSE HE HAS RED THE FULL HOLY BOOK WITH TRANSLATION AND ITS VERY CLEARLY IN THE BOOK THAT WE SHOULD CELEBERATE THE MILAD.
ALLAH CELEBRATE HIS PROFIT'S MILAD. can proof from Al Quran.
PROFIT CELEBRATED HIS BIRTHDAY. I can Proof from Hadith
Satin was very big scholer and head of Angels can you please tell me who is he now.
please do not look at someone's qualification ok look the feelings, respect, love of the person for Profit and His companians and all the Aoliya ALLAH.
you see person is on TV 24/7 and he is right, brothers for coming on tv is not Impossible ok they bought the chennel for that they get money from somewhere, you don't know how much money they must be getting for that.
FOR A REFERENCE YOU CAN CHECK CHRISTIAN, HOW DID THERE BIBLE GET CHANGED THE PREACHER IN CHRISTIAN THEY CHANGED IT SAME WITH JEWS AND AS ALLAH HAS PROMISED TO PROTACT THE HOLY BOOK, NOW SOMER MUSLIM SCHOLER ARE CHANGING THE TRANSLATION OF AYAATS HIDING THE TRUTH BUT THEY CAN'T. HAVE YOU SEEN WHAT HAPEN TO AHMED DEEDAT? HIS WHOLE BODY WAS PERALIZED COULD NOT DO ANY THING ACCEPT BREATHING AND DIED AFTER NINE YEARS, BROVE NINE YEARS ARE TWO MUCH THEN HE DIED.
You are right Bajaur88 that Dr. Israr is right about the so called "Eid meladun nabi". It is a bida and should be abolished. These Disco Maulanas who celeberate Miadun Nabi that chant and chant are a black scar on our society. Also if one care to notice, you would find that most of them are after the power, money and or the women so watch out and stop celeberating milad as there is no such thing in Islam.
YAZEED KI JO OLAD HON UN KO KYA PTA SHAN E NABI KA
KOI BHAI KAH RHY THY ISLAM MN 2 EID HN 3RD NHI TO UN K LIYE ARZ HAI K JUMMA MUBARAK K DIN KO EID KAHA GYA,POCHA GYA Q TO FERMAYA IS DIN HAZRAT AADAM KI PAIDAISH HUI THI
I WANNA EXPLAIN U SMTHNG about it ....eid meelad un nabi ki ibtada ....imam ul ambya a.s ki hijrat k 604 sal bad eesaion ki dekha dekhi iraq me arbl k badshah mlk muzafr abu saed jo ek bad deen fazul kharch or eyash shaks tha us ne apne dunya parast kazab molvi umer bin hasan k 7 mil ker meelad un nabi s.a.w.w ki is rasam ko ijad kia tha...( bahawala tarikh ibn e khalqan)
eesai bhi apne nabi a.s k padaish k din ko eid ka din kehty hain musalman bhi, woh bhi apne ghar bazar temples ko sajaty hain aj musalman bhi yeh sab kar raha hay ...so where is the diffrence??? kia diffrence reh gaya phr??? plz think about it..ALLAH HUM SABKO NAIK HIDAYT DAY SUMMA AMEEN
he was very great personality..he doesn't say a word about islam without refrence.. ALLAH unhe jannat ul firdous may jaga ata fermaye...ap s.a.w.w nay kabhi meelad nahi karwai ...and jo kehty hain k karwai hay to plz explain this with refrence from qura'an and hadith ...if anyone succeed to explain with refrence from quran and hadith i will celebrate meelad next year ok
@Bajaur888 sahi bat hay ...kia sahaba karam sy ziada hum hen ashiq unke??? so mene kahi nahi parha jaha ye likha ho k ap s.a.w.w ne apni salgira manai ho
Thid man is calling on his followers to hate and fight against those who celebrate Milad. RasoolAllah (saw) said anyone who prays towards the Kabba cannot be called kafir and yet he wantd to kill them. He is Just an ignorant hate preacher like all his minority kind are.
what about the Jammat of Taraweeh Namaz started by Hazrat Omer [RA] which never happen [as Jammat] during the time of Prophet [PBUH[ is that Biddat as well!!!!
what about adding totally new line in Azaan-e-Fajr by Hazrat Omer [RA] will that also classify as Biddat!!!
will i be momin if i do Jehad against Hazrat Omer [RA] for adding these new Biddats in Islam?
Dr Israr is right! Try to listen to diverse views with patience. If someones want to celebrate tu kerta rahay but anyways this Eid milad un nabi has no significance in Islam. This would be an individuals act.
@Atif000001 yes dr. israr ahmed marhoom ALLAH unhe jannat ul firdous may jaga ata fermaye ..he's absolutely right with refrence.. he doesn't say anything without refrence i also like him..
i diss agree about the BIDDAT Dr sb yeh batain k Dr Zakir jo cap pehanta hay kia yeh us ki apni ejad nahi jo aap jinah cap pehantay ho is ka hukm kahan hay ya yeh kab sunnat hay ???????? to yeh aap nay khud hi bana li na in ki ijazat ka masala nahi uthaya
@MrMajorsign1 bhai please thoda to reham karen aap musalmaan bhaiyo par. Yahood o nasaara maar rahe hain hame aur aap aapas mein hi lad rahe hain? Ek ho jaaye aur nikal jaayen baahar in maslo se.
1.tere jaise drawni khofnak shakal , chahra kisi aur ka main nen nhen daikha hai. mujhe daleel la kar daina keh
# yeh jo tum kitab print karwate ho
# ye jo chanda mangtay ho
# yeh jo tum bayan k lea speaker use kartay ho. etc yeh kahan likha hai. harami dale kutay . bas tumharay dilun par muhar laga di gae hai. tum jahanami ho. shaitani qafla. dr.pur asara & his followers
@MrMajorsign1 dekhiye, kya hamaare nabi ne gaali dene ki ijaazat di hai?? kya kisi ko jahannami kehne ko ijaazat di hai ? hame aqal se sochna chaahiye aur zyaada jazbaati nahi hona chaahiye
@hasancoool U R RIGHT ..I WANNA EXPLAIN U SMTHNG about it ....eid meelad un nabi ki ibtada ....imam ul ambya a.s ki hijrat k 604 sal bad eesaion ki dekha dekhi iraq me arbl k badshah mlk muzafr abu saed jo ek bad deen or eyash shaks tha us ne apne dunya parast kazab molvi umer bin hasan k 7 mil ker meelad un nabi s.a.w.w ki rasam ko ijad kia tha...( bahawala tarikh ibn e khalqan)
TO bhe aur tera yeh molvi dr.pur asrar bhe bakwas kar rha hai. ap ye jo internet use kar rahen to ye bhe Sarkar say sabit nhen hai. bas ap muje in kutun say aik dalil jo milad e pak ke nafi main ho la kar daina . apny in chamchun say
Our Prophet Muhammad saws taught us how to send Darood on him. We masha'allah do that in every salah and when someone takes the name of Rasullullah, we send darood by saying sallallahhu alayhi wasallam.That's how he taught us.Anything we add in Islam is Bidaah and anything we emit in Islam is bidaat. Those who celebrate Milad un Nabi, go back to Allah swt and make Taubah. Swearing at this lecturer will not benefit u anything but u just paving your way towards hell. Don't become a blind follower
Agree with Dr. Israr (ALLAH inhey Jannat-ul-Firdous main jaga ata farmai, Ameen). Jo cheez Nabi (S.A.W.) ne nahi ki aur na unke sahabiyoun (R.A.) ne ki hai to humney kaisey apnaliya isey?
Eid Milad Nabi mananey ka koi bhi hukam na to Quran main hai aur na Hadith main or na Sahabiyoun ne manai or na Charoun Imamoun ney manai!!!
So kyoun bidaat main par rahe ho,,,lot aao apney RUB ki taraf, beshak wo muaaf karney wala hai. ALLAH hum subko shirk, bidaat aur her buri cheez se bachaey. Ameen.
@DonOfTheWorldMall keun to agree ho gaya. aur kitnay fatway laga lea hai in par 1.todays madern transport 2.tv, internet , 3.yeh jo tumharay fathers deobandi chanda mangtay hain. chalte jaen . kahen say koe jawab nhen milay ga. so what dr.pur asrar saying is bullshit and nothing else. just take a fatwa from this deobandi for those who celebrate his birthday himat hai to bool k dikha harami kutay!
chor do sari bat or batado muijhay itna. jo shikaya Muhammad ne us par kisnay amal kia ho agar tum barelvi ,dewbandi,ahledhadis, chor kar ye fik ye bata do tum me se koi aisa hai jisnay sharab na pi ho, zana na kia ho, jhoot na bola ho, ghaibat na ki ho, chori na ki ho, or har wo bat jis say islam nay or hamaray Nabi ne mana kia ha. agar nai kia to plz safai bhi mat dein, ham sab aik he thali ke hain,sab apne gareban me jhank kar dekhein or phir apni islah karien
may Allah do DR israr ahmeds maghfira i have never seen dr israr ahmed saying any thing against quran and hadeeth. Brother hadeeth is sunnat most of the brothers take hadeeth as some thing against sunnah. Well javed ghamidi saheb is the one who denies hadeeth and praises qadiani fitnah to my surprise he also has his followers.Any one who follows quran and hadeeth(sunnat) will inshallah never go on the wrong path. All muslims except qadianis have the same basic faith.
The prophet saws told us that the ulema are the inheritors of the prophets. The ulema presented the same message to us in ways we can understand it. Things outside acts of worship are permissible except those prohibited by islam, things inside acts of worship are prohibited except those that are made permissible by islamic law. That is the aalims explaining it to us. It is so obvious that i dont know how you can question it. ask your imam he will agree to it totally, worship is sacred.
@immyovuk you are right but, what is the credibility of this aalim? is he perfect? I saw him saying syedna ALI as was drinking alcohol and then on protest of people he apologized... what kind of aalim is he? couldn't withstand what he says. Anyway, he has knowledge, but its the use of knowledge whcih makes someone true person in front od Allah swt. You can see other aalims too by the way, I mean Tahirul Qadri etc... They'll never agree with Dr. Israr. So, my question here, which aalim to follow?
@akhir786 aslamualaikum, firstly brother if one has an unbiased open mind and sees both sides, one will find that israr ahmeds comments were taken out of context, abit was taken out and pasted, and he was sorry that people were upset by what they heard, but he went on to explain what he actually said but that bit was cut by the haters. Sheikh Israr Ahmed was a great man in my opinion. One needs to be aware of satan and the blind haters and dividers. Peace tv is the most on the truth, watch that.
@akhir786 also my brother the prophet saws left us two things the quran and his sunnah, simple. Imam ghazzali ra went on a journey of seeking knowledge and it is said he passed away with sahih bukhari on his chest. The hadith says it is compulsory on us to go seek knowledge, understand the creed. We should be open minded and seek the truth and not be biased to one clan or go on hearsay, i feel the salafis to be most on haq they are the most hated too, but sit with them for a while.
@akhir786 Atleast dont follow Tahirul Qadri. he is fake. us ko loog khud sajda kertay hain aur wooh bajaye un ko mana keray un ko galay laga laita hai :S
Issi k bayanat ka nateeja he k melad un nabi k jaloos per dhamake hote hein aur yeh log dil se nafrat rakh ker apni taraf se jihad kerte hein aur dehshat gardi machane k baad munafiq bajai k is baat ka iqraar karen yeh log tv per a ker un dhamakon ki muzammat kerte hein are tum jesa munafiq to shetan bhi na hoga
Dr.Pur Israar Gustakh-e-Rasool,Gustakh-e-Ali aur Gustakh-e-Sahaba to qabr me apni kher mana
Dear brothers, I am not a Brailvi but i think these kinds of videos only serve the purpose of our enemies to divide us.A huge no of people believe in this ritual,let them do it.We should refrain ourselves from writing offensive comments also.Let not the world laugh at us and use it as ammunition against us.Let PAKISTANIS be united.
well brother i suggest you read the books by scholar of jalauddin suyuti he was an egytptian scholar and i know alot of scholars who celebrate the prophets birthday who are arab sunnis but hey i dont really celebrate it myself lol
brother i dont wanna argue but all i can say is that none of the scholars in islam have refuted celebrating the prophets birthday so your saying there narrow minded aswell and we dont worship graves never have done we do tawassul which is allowed and because the holy people in th graves or the prophets are alive we can make tawassul its perfectly allowed.
@machine9191 brother..plenty of scholars disagree, but yes, most of pakistani, indian molvees celebrate milad..lets not label people wahhabee etc.. the hadith is clear that anybody who introduces anything new to this affair of ours will have it rejected. 600 years later the sunnis started celebrating milad..subhanallah. What is a bad bidah? now tell me the difference between the bad bidah and good bidah please..simple question.
@immyovuk: If this hadith was so stright forward then why did Muhaditheen have to classify bidah in to diff. categories ? let me give you a defensive answer ...so if Milad un Nabi is new practice and falls under the criteria of the above mentioned hadith then what about gaining islamic knowledge from the video clips of Dr. Israr on youtube ... is this new practice or not ?
@TruthFerreter walaikumsalaam, islam is simple..bidah by definition is worshipping allah in ways allah has not prescribed, in ways that are not those of the prophet saws or his rightly guided successors. When it comes to sattellite etc.. if people disagree with it then we should respect that opinion, however it is not worship, it is a tool to amplify the voice of the speaker to many people, like the car we use. Its use does not come outside shariah, compared to having a third eid.
@immyovuk: brother you don’t really know the definition of bidah … you are confining it to worship which is totally wrong … bidat is "that belief or action which was not in practice during the blessed age of Rasulullah (sallal laahu alaihi wasallam) but was introduced after him." as said by Imam Nawawi, Mulla Ali Qari, Shah Abdul Haq Muhhadith Dehlwi
@immyovuk: Many new practices were introduced after the age of Nabi (sallal laahu alaihi wasallam) For instance, Construction of Madressas, Mehraabs of mosques, dividing the Quran into thirty parts, marking the expressions(a’rab) on the Holy Quran, the compilation of I'lm-e-Hadith and Fiqh etc… these are all bidah but are these practices a form of worship??
@TruthFerreter. that is not my definition, its from the biggest ulema in mecca, i quoted it from sheikh uthaymeen. The prophet saws told us to keep mosques simple so we focus on allah more, the looks of the mosque are not worship, madresah is a place of learning, it can be anywhere?? they had places of learning in the early times. The same principal goes for rest of your points non of them constitute worship or addition to worship, they are just means to make existing worship more comfortable.
@TruthFerreter...well yess in this context.. worship is sacred, we should not twist the aqeeda, allah says in the quran that the religion given to the prophet saws was complete, surah maida, also that he has created us for nothing but his worship, we should not make additions or developments to the worship, it leads to misguidance. If you love the prophet saws, follow his sunnah, be good people, seek knowledge, follow his message.
@immyovuk So u agreed that those practices are NOT bidah, but earlier you wrote in your post “the hadith is clear that anybody who introduces anything new to this affair of ours will have it rejected” and at other point you wrote “The hadith is clear every innovation is misguidance, which leads to hellfire.” Now on what basis are you exempting those practices from the words of the ahadith that you emphasized on and saying they are NOT bidah?
@TruthFerreter..brother..please i am trying to have a discussion with you, not a debate, i am no scholar. You are making a mistake of trying to be too smart without paying attention. It is a common pitfall. Bidah in this context is introducing something new into the WORSHIP. Having loudspeakers is not worship in itself, it just makes existing original worship easier. Please read my last 3-4 paragraphs and try to understand and please dont waste the space asking stupid questions.
@immyovuk : Things start sounding stupid when you don’t have answer to it. I was discussing on your presented definition of bidah instead of the four imams. I didn’t talk about loud speaker at all, but when students go to madrassas, study Quran, usul e deen and books of ahadith to get Islamic degree, this is indeed ibadah, and was not in practice at the time of prophet(sallal laahu alaihi wasallam) and sahabas, but you wont dare to call this as bidah.
@immyovuk : (Cont’d ) Can you prove your definition of bidah from Sunnah? Give me one hadith which says that any new practice which is not worship (but addition to worship or makes existing worship easier) is permissible.
@TruthFerreter..brother you are trying to argue with me, trying to outsmart me. Let me make it simpler, Circles of knowledge were in the time of the prophet saws, so were masjids, recognition of aalims was too as the prophet saws said the aalims are inheritors of the prophets-al bukhari. How is this bidah? Lets go to the main question, you do milad, now it is on you to go to quran and sunnah and prove the milad party. The fact is it wasnt done by sunnis for 600 years after the prophet saws.
@TruthFerreter..alot of what you do on milad, dhikr, worship, bayaans are not bidah, we should do this more often than to have one day a year for it- a third eid, a day which you believe is extra special with added virtue and benefit. This is bidah.
@immyovuk I’ll come to Milad's topic if you’d be able to do intellectual discussion, but do not change the topic for now. I am not trying to outsmart you, I am just showing you how troublesome your definition of bidah is. You claim to follow only Quran and Sunnah and reject taqleed. I asked you to support your definition of bidah from Sunnah but you just ignored my question. If you don’t have hadith for ibn uthaymeen’s definition of bidah then you are doing his taqleed, aren’t you?
@immyovuk Circles of knowledge were there, so were masjids and every sahabi was aalim. But they didn’t go to madrassas to hifz Quran, nor did they study usul e deen and compiled books of ahadith. When someone learns islamic sciences, i.e sarf, nahw, mantiq, usul e tafseer, usul e hadith etc does he get thawab or gunnah? Obviously he gets thawab, but these sciences were introduced after the time of sahaba. So this practice seems to be bidah(cuz its a form of worship) according to ur definition
@TruthFerreter..surah imran 3:31, allah says if you really love him, follow the prophet. The prophet saws never did milad, he fasted on mondays because he was born that day and got the revelation on a monday. The sahabah nor the 4 imams including abu haneefa ra did milad. He who innovates in this religion of ours that is not of it will have it rejected-bukhari and muslim. EVERY innovation is a misguidance-muslim. Allah says the religion was completed at the prophets time in surah maidah.
@TruthFerreter..Things outside acts of worship are permissible except those islamic law prohibits. All acts of worship are generally prohibited except those which islamic law has made permissible." You must follow my sunnah and that of the rightly guided khalifas. hold to it and stick fast to it. Avoid newly invented matters, as every newly invented matter is an innovation, every innovation is an error-ahmad, tirmidhi. Now please present your proof for the milad? Abu haneefa ra did not do it!
@immyovuk "Things outside acts of worship are permissible except those islamic law prohibits. All acts of worship are generally prohibited except those which islamic law has made permissible." i asked to back ur def. from hadith ... is that a hadith ??????
The other two ahadith you quoted are contradicting with your definition of bidah.One has word "every" and other has words "that is not of it" .... I need a hadith which says... every new form of worship is bidah ...
@TruthFerreter brother you are trying to be too smart, you dont want to learn and be open. Ask any imam, if you do an act it is up to you to justify the act you do. You cannot present 1 hadith to me yet you are beating about the bush acting like a spoilt person with the hadiths i presented you trying to find loopholes and twisting the words of the prophet saws so that you can justify an act added to the worship 600yrs later by sunnis. You do milad. Carry on. Im done with you, i know your type.
@immyovuk Alhemdulilah, so called Salafi claiming to follow only Quran & Sunnah was not able to present one hadith to support his def. of bidah. You claim milad to be bidah, yet you don’t have a single hadith to support your def. of bidah. According to you, what is bidat? every new form of worship is bidah, but new practices to facilitate worship are not bidah. Whats the proof from hadith? Every innovation is misguidance. SubhanAllah, what an argument to support your def.!
@immyovuk “He who innovates in this religion of ours that is not of it will have it rejected-bukhari” just ponder on the words of hadith you quoted “that is not if it” means? ..only that innovation is rejected which is against Quran & Sunnah. Now you claim milad is bidah by putting it in category of “that is not of it”. Now it is your responsibility to prove how it comes under “that is not of it”. No indication of impermissiblity for an act is enough to be it permissible.
@immyovuk I knew you would you run away from the argument, only that person uses words like too smart, outsmart, stupid, beat about the bush, spoilt person.. who runs short of proofs and have nothing else to say. This is what happens when you leave the path of true Salaf. I don’t blame you and I know your type too!
@TruthFerreter, sheikh uthaymeen ra said that bidah is worshipping allah in ways not prescribed by allah, in ways other than that done by the prophet saws or his rightly guided khalifa. What else could it be? In surah maida allah says the religion was completed. Having a third eid, a day of extra virtue and rewards and is a bidah that was not done for first 600 years by sunnis, first 300 years by shias. Think about all the greats who did not do it, who loved him saws the most.
@immyovuk ..he who innovates in this religion of ours that is not of it will have it rejected- bukhari and muslim. It means who ever adds to the religion that what is not from it, it is alien to it, eg a third eid, if something is added to the prescribed worship which is not from allah through the prophet saws i.e in quran and sound hadith. The other hadith that every innovation is a misguidance-muslim, is in this context that everything added to the religion i.e the worship, is a misguidance.
@TruthFerreter.. please brother to make it a balanced discussion you have to provide your evidence for it. The prophet saws said "Verily the best among you are my generation, those who follow them (tabiun), then those who follow them(tabi tabiun)."-muslim. Did the best of muslims do a third eid? Allah created us for nothing else but his worship, a third eid is unauthorised by the prophet saws. Now because you do it, the priority is with you to provide evidence for it.
@TruthFerreter..brother every act that induces thawaab has its foundation in quran and sunnah. Eg being kind is from sunnah, and in hadiths, if you want i can find you specific hadiths but i dont think you need me to. Eg, if you give a brother a free lift you are being kind and charitable, doing ikraam. If you remove obstacles from the path you are doing an act of charity etc, if you show good character and conduct-its from quran and sunnah. Milad is not.
ya Rabul Alalmeen ghamdi dr israr zakir naiyk tuseef ko kal kiamat k den abu jhal k sath otha mere malik tujhe tere piyare mehboob bando ka wasta Ameen
@swahid1000 mere bhai kuch toh sochen bolne se pehle. Kya faaida ho raha hai aapko baddua de ke? aman rakhe.n. Dr Israr ne sirf ek hadeeth sunaayi hai..
@MrMajorsign1 bhai hamaare Nabi SAW ne aur Sahaba RA ne kabhi Meelaad nahi manaaya. Eid Milaad 600 saal ke baad manaaya gaya tha pehli baar Islam ki taareekh mein. Kya iska matlab ye hai ke 600 saal tak musalmaano ko deen ka feham nahi tha ? Please thande dimaagh se sochen. Ghussa na karna.
Dr israr was a great man, very powerful mind. Now milad un nabee was not celebrated by muslims nor the prophet saws until 600 years later by sunni muslims. This is the belief that this day has extra special virtue and we should celebrate it. Now when they start saying its a good bid'ah and allowed, ask them what is a bad bid'ah?? then ask them whats the difference between the bad bid'ah and good bid'ah. The hadith is clear every innovation is misguidance, which leads to hellfire.
well you carry on celebrating wat u want - dont expect others to follow your lot.you dont call salafs kafir??? are you blind? do yoou not read what this page says?? lol.i can post you 100 clips just off you tube where salafs have been called kafir?? do you people even know the meaning of the word SALAF.salaf refers to the generations of sahabas who were promised jannah! by calling salafis KAFIR u lot r calling the sahabas KAFIR na'uzubillah!!! whats the difference between u & shia?
@xxSonuJeexx you are welcome to do your grave worshipping, celebrating birthdays, hanging verses round your neck in belief of protecetion, asking from so called holy peers and fakeers... go for it. do as much as you want- leave others to there beliefs. Allah swa has preserved the qur'an for over 1400 yrs knowing that certain people wil try n change islam..and us salafs thank allah 4this. it means we wont b fooled by sufi barailawi mentality!
when dr tahir qadri says a statement false or wrong which it isnt hes right , hes never appoligised people like this kafir and dr nalaaaaiq ha ha aha , start to cry the whole muslim world put a fatwa on these munafiqs who are you ??? to say this guy is right......
This has been flagged as spam show
if something is haram.forbidden it will be clearly stated in the Quran.
you think birthday celebration of Prophet (saw) is wrong. The Prophet (saw) fasted on Mondays.. :))
you such ignorant people read the Quran properly.. its Good inovation :))
''Allah has done a Major favour upon Muslims by Sending His Beloved Messenger 'peace be upon Them' To them'' (Quran; Surah Al-Imran:164)
''Publicize well the favours of your Lord'' (Quran; Surah Duhaa: 11)
01whussain 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Islam = Obedience = Respect = Love = Mercy = Islam = Peace... stop hating you people.
from the Quran.. not haddith = ).
01whussain 1 month ago
@JudgeD007 i think people misunderstand mawlid, what it represents. If you suggest Sahaba remembered Prophet(pbuh) in his life and after he departed from this world. I agree Prophet(pbuh) should be remembered every day and not just one day. his life should be celebrated everyday. To remember the day he was born is recommend and forbidden, there is no evidence in the Quran nor hadith to suggest it is forbidden.
MrRiz157 2 months ago
@mainmosque Show me thw evidwnce where Prophet(pbuh) has forbidden remembering, celebrating his life, showing gratitude to Allah for sending him(pbuh).
MrRiz157 2 months ago
Celebrating the Prophet(SAW) birthday is NOT a Sunnah , its not something the Sahaba did or the generations after them- a king introduced it about 600 year after SAW. Allah (SWT) and his Rasool (SAW) only gave us 2 annual Eids- are you saying they forgot to tell us about one of them?
The Sahaba loved Muhammad (SAW) more than anyone - they did not celebrate it- Are you saying YOU love the Prophet more than the Sahaba ?
Only way of worship which SAW taught is accepted!
DO NOT CHANGE ISLAM !
JudgeD007 2 months ago
YE MURDAAR DOCTOR ISRAAR JAHANUM MAI JAAL RAHA HAI,ISNAI JITNI MARTABA BHE NABI E KAREEM S.A.W KA NAME PAK LEYA HAI NOTE KARAIN K KAHEN BHE IS HARAMI NE DUROOD PAK NAHE PARHA.BUS YEHE IS K HARAMI JAHANAMI HONAY KA SUBOOT HAI.WASALAM
381najam 3 months ago
JO JO DR.SAHAB SE IKHTILAAF KERTA HAI WO JAAN LAIN K HUZOOR S.A.W.W KI NA TAREEF MANA HAI NA DUROOD MANA HAI....DUROOD PADHNEY K LIYE JHANDEY LEYKEY MEHFIL SAJA KER CHILLA CHILLA KER LOUD SPEAKER PER DUROOD NAHIN PADH SAKTEY....IMPORTANT DEEN MAIN WO KAAM HAI JISKA ''HUKUM''''' HAI.DEEN SARE KA SAARA HUMKUM PER CHALNA HAI..MAGHRIB KI NAMAZ 4 RAKAT PADHNEY MAIN KIA BURAI HAI..THODI AYAT HI ZIADA PADHO GEY..KUCH SAJDEY HI ZIADA HONGEY..BURA KIA HAI IS MAIN????BURA YE HAI K YE HUKUM K KHILAAF HAI.
hasssaan99 5 months ago
Inke imaan ka undaza is baat se hi lagalo bhai, ke wo din jis din Allah ne tamaam Alamo ke lie Rehmat-allil-Alaameen bheja, us din ki khushi mananay ko ye log kitna na pasand kartay hein ... In se poocha jaye konsa esa kaam hai jo Mehfil-e-Milaad-un-Nabi(SAWW) mein hota ho aur wo Allah ya Rasool (SAWW) ko napand ho...
kingadee111 5 months ago
Milad-un-Nabi (SAWW) mein konsi esi cheeze hai jo ke bidaat ho? Kia Tilawat bidaat hai Nauzubillah ? Kia Uske baad Hamd Perhna bidaat hai? Kia Naat perhna bidaat hai ? kia Salaam bhejna bidaat hai ? Kia mehfil ke ikhtitaam per Allah se dua maangna bidaat hai ? ager inmein se koi bhi cheeze bidaat nahi, to mehfil bidaat kese hosakti hai, jahaan log Allah aur uske Habib (SAWW) ki tareef bayan kartay hon ? Jo log Mehfil-e-Milaad-Un-Nabi (SAWW) ko bidaat kehtay hein actually unko takleef hai.
kingadee111 5 months ago
Hazrat k chehray per noor he itna ziyada hai k sub kuch ayaan ho jata hai k sahab kitnay paani mein hein!
odaaroo 5 months ago
@odaaroo yaar good comment , keya masla hai in logo ko, ke Nabi paak ki hushi nahi mana saktey, kahan ka ishq hai yeh? koi nahi, doorr nahi hai woh din jab in ke paas pachtaway ke siwa kuch nahi hoga. Allah in ko hidayat dey . Ameen
missmisyar 5 months ago
@missmisyar You are right, meri nazer mein in logon ke dil mein ek bugz hein, ye log sub bardasht karsaktay hein bus ye nahi bardasht kersaktay ke Huzoor (SAWW) ki tareef bayan ki jae, inke pass koi esa proof nahi jis se ye Milaad-Un-Nabi (SAWW) ko ghalat sabit karsakein, aur bhai kia Allah aur Huzoor (SAWW) ki tareef bayan kerne ke lie bhi koi certificate layna hoga, Allah ka to hukum hai Huzoor (SAWW) per durood aur salaam bhejo, Nabi(SAWW) hein hi taareef ke laiq to kyun na karein ham tareef
kingadee111 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@missmisyar You are right, meri nazer mein in logon ke dil mein ek bugz hein, ye log sub bardasht karsaktay hein bus ye nahi bardasht kersaktay ke Huzoor (SAWW) ki tareef bayan ki jae, inke pass koi esa proof nahi jis se ye Milaad-Un-Nabi (SAWW) ko ghalat sabit karsakein, aur bhai kia Allah aur Huzoor (SAWW) ki tareef bayan kerne ke lie bhi koi certificate layna hoga, Allah ka to hukum hai Huzoor (SAWW) per durood aur salaam bhejo, Nabi(SAWW) hein hi taareef ke laiq to kyun na karein ham tareef
kingadee111 5 months ago
venomx79 Dr israr tu Momin ki maut gaya, Tu to Suar ki maut maray ga inshaAllah.
egoboy99 6 months ago
ghatya aur bohat hee zaleel chootya aadmi, achah hoa sala kuttay ki maut margaya gandoo dalla sala
venomx79 6 months ago
@venomx79 bura huwa, acha to tub hota jo eeman per maot aaati.
missmisyar 5 months ago
ALLAH may bring you in PARADISE and give us all muslims the sence of understand QURAN and Sunnah. Ameen.
researchforiman 6 months ago
@researchforiman Ameen, and true love of Prophet (ASSALAM O ALAIKA YA RASOOL ALLAH).
missmisyar 5 months ago
@MrSarfaraz85 Aik sawal hai app se jis din roza ho uss din eid hoti hai kia or jiss din eid ho us din roza hota hai kia agar nahee to mera AAQA MUHAMMAD (SAW) ni uss din roza rakh ker ummat ko bataya kay bahi meri piadaish walay din ko eid na mana kiou kay ma roza rakhta hoon or jis din roza ho us din eid nahee hoti.. Roza walay din roza hota hai or eid walay din eid .
NoumanNaqshbandi 7 months ago
lo molana sahib jo meelaad waghaira k baray main dalil le kar aay hain or inhon ne jo hadees bayaan ki ha es k matan (words) main kahan likha ha k mmeelaad manana haraam ha???
aise he apni taraf se meaning nikaal lena koi achi baat nahi ha Hazoor ne khud irshaad farmaia k main har monday ka roza es liay rakhta hon kiun k main es din paida howa. ab Hazoor khud aoni aamad ka kisse wajah se ahtamaam kar rahain hain or es molana ne aik hadees he ka ghalat mean le lia ha
MrSarfraz85 7 months ago
is ko mein keya kahu bechara guzer geya hai? aap mein sey koi bata dey keya NABI paak ney kaha tha k misyaar kerna?
missmisyar 7 months ago
@missmisyar misyaar pe ulama ne ijtihaad kia hai......jo k jaiz hai....aur misyaar me kuch objection bhi ni hai islamically
atiqsajid01 7 months ago
@atiqsajid01 acha to milaad per objection kahan hai bhai?
missmisyar 7 months ago
@atiqsajid01 yaani aap 2 ghantey ki shadi guzar ker, orat ko bachey ki maa bana ker talaq de saktey ho?
nah meri jaan, kin ulama ki baat kertey ho, keya yeh upni betiyan qurban kerein gey kuch din ke liey? keya main keya aap? hosh kero. jago is sey pehley ke abadi neend so jaao.
missmisyar 6 months ago
Comment removed
atiqsajid01 5 months ago
@missmisyar is ka mtlb hai k ap ko pta hi ni hai k misyaar hota kia hai...aur awain apni ghatya soch ki akaaasi kye ja re hoo..
atiqsajid01 5 months ago
Comment removed
missmisyar 5 months ago
@atiqsajid01 acha jee, aap ko toh pata he ho ga? aap ker do zera taareef, taa ke baki log be jaan jaaein. waiting for your good reply mr.
missmisyar 5 months ago
@missmisyar "Mubashir Luqman:Islam and Misyar ( temporary )marriage? p1/4" is vedio ko ghor se dekh aur sun len...shayad apki aqal ka prda hat jae
atiqsajid01 5 months ago
@atiqsajid01 jee jee dekhi hai video, yakeenan aap ko ghor kerney ki zaroorat hai per shaed fursat nahi,or aap ke arabs ahl e hadees bhai is ko kesey istemaal ker rahay hain ? keya ye misyaar hai, yeh to aap ki porani aadat hai, ke aayat e Qurani ka ghalat terjuma, ahadees ka ghalat matlab. tumeh hosh us wakt aaey gi jab muh per matti perey gi. yaar anaa ka masla nahi hai tumsey, muslim bhai ho tum upney is liey time waste nahi kertey ke tum sey reyal chahiey, is liey k tum sey piyar hai.
missmisyar 5 months ago
@missmisyar "tum sey reyal chahiey, is liey k tum sey piyar hai."" is kya mtlb hai?????
atiqsajid01 5 months ago
@atiqsajid01 bhai matlab saaf hai, key laraai jagda nahi or nah he dushmani hai aap logo sey or nah kisi cheez ki lalach hai, thats because i love you. or yaar aap apney ulamaa ki kutab perh ker yaa takareer sunn ker follow kertey ho, or Alhamdulillah hum ney to dekha hai ankho sey toh yakeen kesey nah ho. ummeed hai ab aap ko samajh aa gai ho gi. baki tabeeb ka kaam hai dawai dena, shifa to Allah ney deni hai na.
missmisyar 5 months ago
he was a very educated and pious person
may Allah Almighty grant him jannatul firdous.....Ameen
mikeb0069fj 7 months ago
Allah aap per rehmat farmay
softbhatti 7 months ago
ALLAH IN KA JANAT MAIN DARJAT BULAND FARMY AUR JIS NAY YE VEDIO POST KI HAY UN KAY BHI DARJAT BULAND FARMAY
swabienterprises 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hafiz Ibn Kathir writes:" On the day of the birth of the Prophet (May Allah bless him and grant him peace) Shaytan cried a lot." [Ibn Kathir, Sirat an-Nabi, 'Birth of the Prophet']
From Ibn Kathir's narration we can see that to feel unhappy on the birthday of the Prophet (May Allah bless him and grant him peace) is the way of Shaytan, not the way of a Muslim!
MMRaza1 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hafiz Ibn Kathir writes:" On the day of the birth of the Prophet (May Allah bless him and grant him peace) Shaytan cried a lot." [Ibn Kathir, Sirat an-Nabi, 'Birth of the Prophet']
From Ibn Kathir's narration we can see that to feel unhappy on the birthday of the Prophet (May Allah bless him and grant him peace) is the way of Shaytan, not the way of a Muslim!
MMRaza1 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hafiz Ibn Kathir writes:" On the day of the birth of the Prophet (May Allah bless him and grant him peace) Shaytan cried a lot." [Ibn Kathir, Sirat an-Nabi, 'Birth of the Prophet']
From Ibn Kathir's narration we can see that to feel unhappy on the birthday of the Prophet (May Allah bless him and grant him peace) is the way of Shaytan, not the way of a Muslim!
MMRaza1 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hafiz Ibn Kathir writes:" On the day of the birth of the Prophet (May Allah bless him and grant him peace) Shaytan cried a lot." [Ibn Kathir, Sirat an-Nabi, 'Birth of the Prophet']
From Ibn Kathir's narration we can see that to feel unhappy on the birthday of the Prophet (May Allah bless him and grant him peace) is the way of Shaytan, not the way of a Muslim!
MMRaza1 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
MiddleEast ALWAYS at war! Mohammad violent SINFUL cult Murderer!Jesus/Healed/Blessed/Peace/Salvation/GOD! All MUSLIMS who converted to Christianity ARE HAPPY & FREE OF ABUSE & MISERY! Islam leaders are killing you! Christians LOVE YOU! PLEASE accept JESUS CHRIST as your SAVIOR! John 3:16 He that believeth on the Son hath everlasting life: and he that believeth not the Son shall not see life; but the wrath of God abideth on him! REBEL & ACCEPT JESUS! Be FREE of ISLAM LIES! Visit wlix radio.com
tigersforchrist 9 months ago
god this MULLAH is UGLY!!! looks like a MONKEY with a BEARD
QuranVsHadith 9 months ago
Subhan Allah! Your a great scholar! I love you Doctor Sahib!!
keepcrawling 10 months ago 2
The Sahaba, earlier imams did not see this as an issue because they were engrossed in the Prophet(pbuh) devotion and remembering him everyday. Today Muslims need to be reminded of that blessing of Allah which earlier Muslims never forgot. Every believer must be happy and grateful for the blessing of the Final Messenger of Allah (pbuh). Its a sign of Iman to be happy for this blessingand should be everyday, but if not at least once in a year.
MrRiz157 11 months ago
@MrRiz157
Mirza, Why once a year why not the entire year. Muhammd never celebrated his birthday and he also disallowed such things inspired by Satan. Do you know what goes on in these meelaads and how these meeladi call for even more innovations.
mainmosque 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@MrRiz157
Mirza, Why once a year why not the entire year. Muhammad never celebrated his birthday and he also disallowed such things inspired by Satan. Do you know what goes on in these meelaads and how these meeladi call for even more innovations.
mainmosque 9 months ago
what is friday?
islamservices 11 months ago
takbeer!
Zaheerhussain1984 11 months ago
atleast open your ears, eyes and hearts. what did he said in his talks is from quran and hadeesh so plz do not take offences if you do so then Salam to you and goodby
webleo786 11 months ago
tu karo Jahaad hamare khilaf
shoaibjee1 11 months ago
This guy is Burning in Hell.
bill66y 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@bill66y do you claim to have knowledge of the unseen?
rahilhabib 11 months ago
@bill66y Kya ap k pas ilm e ghaib hy?
powerboy372000 10 months ago
Dr. Israr ALLAH Aap ko Janat ul Firdos ma Alla Muqam De....Ameeeeeen
Peyda Hoye han Jis Din se Aadam ,,, HaQ-o-Batil ka hai Osi Din se Tasadum...
truthispainfull 1 year ago
Parrot k child tum log to apni hadith banane walo ek din aayga tumhari badmashi nikal jaygi galia mat dena insan wali harkat kar .
S.s.p
Kingshedow1 1 year ago
@tyuk.
Aye chutiya stop spreading ur trash
nasirlamma 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
IS MAADAR CHOD KO MERE LUN KA PATA HAI PHAINCHOD KUTTA HAI KAAAFIR SAAALA MAA CHOODO HUM KO KHUSHI HOTI HAI EID MILAADUL NABI MANAA K
AAKHIR TUM LOOGON KO TAKLEEF KYA HAI
tuyk56 1 year ago
IS MAADAR CHOD KO MERE LUN KA PATA HAI PHAINCHOD KUTTA HAI KAAAFIR SAAALA MAA CHOODO HUM KO KHUSHI HOTI HAI EID MILAADUL NABI MANAA K
AAKHIR TUM LOOGON KO TAKLEEF KYA HAI
tuyk56 1 year ago
HE IS TEACHING YOU VERY CLEARLY DON'T DO THIS, DON'T DO THAT OTERWISE WHATEVER HE SAYS NOT TO DO, IT HAS BEEN DONE AND IT WILL HAPEN UNTIL THE OF JUDGEMENT.
PLEASE REPLY I WILL PROVE IT
muj143 1 year ago
LETS BELIEVE IN THE PROFIT WITH A TRUE FEEELINGS , TRUE LOVE TRUE EMOTIONS.
AND
IF YOU THINK THERE IS NO EMOTIONS, NO LOVE, NO FEELINGS IN ISLAM, YOU CAN OBJECT MY SAYING AND I WILL PROOF IT.
BROTHERS I M NOT A SCHOLER, I M JUST A SIMPLE MISLIM, I LISTEN TO PREACHERS ASWEL BUT I LISTEN TO THE ONE WHO REMINDS US THE STORIES AND RESPECT OF PROFIT, STORIES AND RESPECT OF SAHABA AND DAYS OF ALLAH. N SO MUCH MORE BUT NOT NAGITIVE TALK.
muj143 1 year ago
WHAT EVER HE IS TALKING IS IN RUBISH WAY.
HE KNOWS HE IS TELLING YOU WRONG BECAUSE HE HAS RED THE FULL HOLY BOOK WITH TRANSLATION AND ITS VERY CLEARLY IN THE BOOK THAT WE SHOULD CELEBERATE THE MILAD.
ALLAH CELEBRATE HIS PROFIT'S MILAD. can proof from Al Quran.
PROFIT CELEBRATED HIS BIRTHDAY. I can Proof from Hadith
muj143 1 year ago
@muj143
Please can you prove as you say from quran and hadith that we should celebrate Milad ul nabi.
Allah has prescribed 2 days for a muslim to celebrate - Eid ulk fitr and eid ul adha so you are confusing me.
Please suggest the chapter and verse in quran where it says we have to celebrate the profits birthday.
Thanks
quranisthetruth 11 months ago
@muj143 please provide your daleel if you are truthful
rahilhabib 11 months ago
ISLAM is free of cast and full of EMOTIONS.
muj143 1 year ago
Satin was very big scholer and head of Angels can you please tell me who is he now.
please do not look at someone's qualification ok look the feelings, respect, love of the person for Profit and His companians and all the Aoliya ALLAH.
you see person is on TV 24/7 and he is right, brothers for coming on tv is not Impossible ok they bought the chennel for that they get money from somewhere, you don't know how much money they must be getting for that.
muj143 1 year ago
FOR A REFERENCE YOU CAN CHECK CHRISTIAN, HOW DID THERE BIBLE GET CHANGED THE PREACHER IN CHRISTIAN THEY CHANGED IT SAME WITH JEWS AND AS ALLAH HAS PROMISED TO PROTACT THE HOLY BOOK, NOW SOMER MUSLIM SCHOLER ARE CHANGING THE TRANSLATION OF AYAATS HIDING THE TRUTH BUT THEY CAN'T. HAVE YOU SEEN WHAT HAPEN TO AHMED DEEDAT? HIS WHOLE BODY WAS PERALIZED COULD NOT DO ANY THING ACCEPT BREATHING AND DIED AFTER NINE YEARS, BROVE NINE YEARS ARE TWO MUCH THEN HE DIED.
muj143 1 year ago
JO YAZEED PALEED KO R.A KAHAIN UN KA KYA IMAN?
JIS NABI KA KHATAY HO USI KO GHURATAY HO?
Azher0302 1 year ago
Juma k din Adam as ki birth huee yun hm saal mn 52 eids manate hn.
jis roz mere AQA peda hue us din ko kon kafir eid na manay ga.
Nisar teri chehal pehal pe hazaro eiden a rabeeulawal
siway iblees k jehaan mn sabhi to khooshia mana rahe hn
astana2007 1 year ago
chehray sy chalak jata hai noor jo momin hotay hn
c ur dr naik , israr :p
mujay ye btao jumma mubarik ko b eid kaha gya
ab is pay b aitraz hai?
jummah ko eid is liye kaha gya Hazrat aadam ki paidaish hui thi
munkiron samjho is bat ko
TheGhurki 1 year ago
n its MASJID not mosque
jo words Islam ny select kiye unhy hi bola kro mosque k buht mtlb hn
TheGhurki 1 year ago
@main mosque
ALHAMDULILLAH i know abt Islam more than u
u the followers of yazeed...u call him janati ? that laanti
go n listen What is eid milad un Nabi by dr tahir ul qadri
start listening ullama not the maloons n kharji
TheGhurki 1 year ago
@Bajaur888
You are right Bajaur88 that Dr. Israr is right about the so called "Eid meladun nabi". It is a bida and should be abolished. These Disco Maulanas who celeberate Miadun Nabi that chant and chant are a black scar on our society. Also if one care to notice, you would find that most of them are after the power, money and or the women so watch out and stop celeberating milad as there is no such thing in Islam.
mainmosque 1 year ago
JO YAZEED PALEED KO R.A KAHAIN UN KA KYA IMAN?
JIS NABI KA KHATAY HO USI KO GHURATAY HO?
1886 MAIN TO FIRQA WAHABI BNA HAI ISAY KYA PATA DEEN KA
TheGhurki 1 year ago
@TheGhurki
Go first learn about islam before posting useless comments.
mainmosque 1 year ago
PHIR AIK DAFA HAZOOR PAK S.A.W K GHAR KISI JUNG KI FATAH KA JASHAN MANAYA JA RHA THA TAB AAQA S.A.W NAY FERMAYA HAR UMMAT KI KOI EID HOTI HAI
I GUESS JAWAB IS MN MIL GYA HO GA K EID 2 SY ZAYADA B HN
TheGhurki 1 year ago
YAZEED KI JO OLAD HON UN KO KYA PTA SHAN E NABI KA
KOI BHAI KAH RHY THY ISLAM MN 2 EID HN 3RD NHI TO UN K LIYE ARZ HAI K JUMMA MUBARAK K DIN KO EID KAHA GYA,POCHA GYA Q TO FERMAYA IS DIN HAZRAT AADAM KI PAIDAISH HUI THI
AB AP KIS PAY FATWA LGAIN GAY?
TheGhurki 1 year ago
MASHA ALLAH
fajatoi 1 year ago
@nayab72 islam me just 2 eids hain koi 3rd eid nahi ...
TheSadia10 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I WANNA EXPLAIN U SMTHNG about it ....eid meelad un nabi ki ibtada ....imam ul ambya a.s ki hijrat k 604 sal bad eesaion ki dekha dekhi iraq me arbl k badshah mlk muzafr abu saed jo ek bad deen fazul kharch or eyash shaks tha us ne apne dunya parast kazab molvi umer bin hasan k 7 mil ker meelad un nabi s.a.w.w ki is rasam ko ijad kia tha...( bahawala tarikh ibn e khalqan)
TheSadia10 1 year ago
eesai bhi apne nabi a.s k padaish k din ko eid ka din kehty hain musalman bhi, woh bhi apne ghar bazar temples ko sajaty hain aj musalman bhi yeh sab kar raha hay ...so where is the diffrence??? kia diffrence reh gaya phr??? plz think about it..ALLAH HUM SABKO NAIK HIDAYT DAY SUMMA AMEEN
TheSadia10 1 year ago
he was very great personality..he doesn't say a word about islam without refrence.. ALLAH unhe jannat ul firdous may jaga ata fermaye...ap s.a.w.w nay kabhi meelad nahi karwai ...and jo kehty hain k karwai hay to plz explain this with refrence from qura'an and hadith ...if anyone succeed to explain with refrence from quran and hadith i will celebrate meelad next year ok
TheSadia10 1 year ago
@Bajaur888 sahi bat hay ...kia sahaba karam sy ziada hum hen ashiq unke??? so mene kahi nahi parha jaha ye likha ho k ap s.a.w.w ne apni salgira manai ho
TheSadia10 1 year ago
Thid man is calling on his followers to hate and fight against those who celebrate Milad. RasoolAllah (saw) said anyone who prays towards the Kabba cannot be called kafir and yet he wantd to kill them. He is Just an ignorant hate preacher like all his minority kind are.
javidf 1 year ago
what about the Jammat of Taraweeh Namaz started by Hazrat Omer [RA] which never happen [as Jammat] during the time of Prophet [PBUH[ is that Biddat as well!!!!
what about adding totally new line in Azaan-e-Fajr by Hazrat Omer [RA] will that also classify as Biddat!!!
will i be momin if i do Jehad against Hazrat Omer [RA] for adding these new Biddats in Islam?
drawaiskhalil 1 year ago
Dr Israr is right! Try to listen to diverse views with patience. If someones want to celebrate tu kerta rahay but anyways this Eid milad un nabi has no significance in Islam. This would be an individuals act.
Atif000001 1 year ago
@Atif000001 yes dr. israr ahmed marhoom ALLAH unhe jannat ul firdous may jaga ata fermaye ..he's absolutely right with refrence.. he doesn't say anything without refrence i also like him..
TheSadia10 1 year ago
i diss agree about the BIDDAT Dr sb yeh batain k Dr Zakir jo cap pehanta hay kia yeh us ki apni ejad nahi jo aap jinah cap pehantay ho is ka hukm kahan hay ya yeh kab sunnat hay ???????? to yeh aap nay khud hi bana li na in ki ijazat ka masala nahi uthaya
salmaan6071205 1 year ago
acha dr pur israr k pithu
celebrating birhday is common in our society
so why they have not given fatwa about this bidaat ? deobandi jahanami hain.
MrMajorsign1 1 year ago
@MrMajorsign1 bhai please thoda to reham karen aap musalmaan bhaiyo par. Yahood o nasaara maar rahe hain hame aur aap aapas mein hi lad rahe hain? Ek ho jaaye aur nikal jaayen baahar in maslo se.
hasancoool 1 year ago
aray baighairat kutay pur asrar
1.tere jaise drawni khofnak shakal , chahra kisi aur ka main nen nhen daikha hai. mujhe daleel la kar daina keh
# yeh jo tum kitab print karwate ho
# ye jo chanda mangtay ho
# yeh jo tum bayan k lea speaker use kartay ho. etc yeh kahan likha hai. harami dale kutay . bas tumharay dilun par muhar laga di gae hai. tum jahanami ho. shaitani qafla. dr.pur asara & his followers
MrMajorsign1 1 year ago
@MrMajorsign1 dekhiye, kya hamaare nabi ne gaali dene ki ijaazat di hai?? kya kisi ko jahannami kehne ko ijaazat di hai ? hame aqal se sochna chaahiye aur zyaada jazbaati nahi hona chaahiye
hasancoool 1 year ago
@hasancoool U R RIGHT ..I WANNA EXPLAIN U SMTHNG about it ....eid meelad un nabi ki ibtada ....imam ul ambya a.s ki hijrat k 604 sal bad eesaion ki dekha dekhi iraq me arbl k badshah mlk muzafr abu saed jo ek bad deen or eyash shaks tha us ne apne dunya parast kazab molvi umer bin hasan k 7 mil ker meelad un nabi s.a.w.w ki rasam ko ijad kia tha...( bahawala tarikh ibn e khalqan)
TheSadia10 1 year ago
TRUE..
shami4you 1 year ago
@shami4you
TO bhe aur tera yeh molvi dr.pur asrar bhe bakwas kar rha hai. ap ye jo internet use kar rahen to ye bhe Sarkar say sabit nhen hai. bas ap muje in kutun say aik dalil jo milad e pak ke nafi main ho la kar daina . apny in chamchun say
haram k tilay!
MrMajorsign1 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Our Prophet Muhammad saws taught us how to send Darood on him. We masha'allah do that in every salah and when someone takes the name of Rasullullah, we send darood by saying sallallahhu alayhi wasallam.That's how he taught us.Anything we add in Islam is Bidaah and anything we emit in Islam is bidaat. Those who celebrate Milad un Nabi, go back to Allah swt and make Taubah. Swearing at this lecturer will not benefit u anything but u just paving your way towards hell. Don't become a blind follower
befair4all 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
JASHAN-E-MILAD UN NABI (SAWW) ZINDABAD.
ISRAR JESAY LANTI MIL KAR APNA ZOR LAGA LEN MILAD UN NABI (SAWW) BAND NAI HO GA INSHALLAH.
QURRAN YA HADEES MAIN AGER MANA HAI WOH SABIT KAR DO??
margaya mardod na fatiya na dardood,,,u can c munafiqat on the face of this man,
Is ki shakal to dekho. agar zameen pe shetan dekhna ha to isko dekh lo,
EID MILAAD UN NABI ,,,,,,,,,zinda baad
powersunisaifi 1 year ago
Agree with Dr. Israr (ALLAH inhey Jannat-ul-Firdous main jaga ata farmai, Ameen). Jo cheez Nabi (S.A.W.) ne nahi ki aur na unke sahabiyoun (R.A.) ne ki hai to humney kaisey apnaliya isey?
Eid Milad Nabi mananey ka koi bhi hukam na to Quran main hai aur na Hadith main or na Sahabiyoun ne manai or na Charoun Imamoun ney manai!!!
So kyoun bidaat main par rahe ho,,,lot aao apney RUB ki taraf, beshak wo muaaf karney wala hai. ALLAH hum subko shirk, bidaat aur her buri cheez se bachaey. Ameen.
DonOfTheWorldMall 1 year ago 5
MrMajorsign1 1 year ago
@MrMajorsign1 Zuban sanmbhal k baat kar,,,dunya se utha doon ga tujhey !! tharki sala,,,
DonOfTheWorldMall 1 year ago
partnerlover 1 year ago
Is tarhan tou tu sooot bhi khata hoga
TheSmarty74 1 year ago
prophet ko yad karna kia ba'is'e sawab naheen? tau un ke milad walay din kia issue hai?
kalilanipk 1 year ago
@ VERY TRUE !!
raqib56 1 year ago
YEH FITNA YHA BOHAT BARA,IS PE BAISAHK AZAB HI NAZIL HO RAHA HOGA!
lodam21 1 year ago
He is absolutely right. May Allah grant him place in Jannatul ferdaus Aamin
hussen67 1 year ago
yeh video musalmanoo main tafarqa danlnay main No.1 rated hay. Great Job Mr Israr....
shaukat9823 1 year ago
may Allah do DR israr ahmeds maghfira i have never seen dr israr ahmed saying any thing against quran and hadeeth. Brother hadeeth is sunnat most of the brothers take hadeeth as some thing against sunnah. Well javed ghamidi saheb is the one who denies hadeeth and praises qadiani fitnah to my surprise he also has his followers.Any one who follows quran and hadeeth(sunnat) will inshallah never go on the wrong path. All muslims except qadianis have the same basic faith.
g1heart 1 year ago
Jo koe bi hai, us ne bat Hazor saw ki hia, or un ki mubarak hadees sunae hai.
sayfrndship 1 year ago
he is absolutely right.....may Allah bless him
midrees100 1 year ago
is khinzeer ko ab kaber min pata chala ho ga k milad manana shrik tha ya sawab mar gaya mardood shakal khizeer ki tarha hia
khan4672 1 year ago
@khan4672 You are not God to judge others! so please avoid it!
PersonOfBook 1 year ago
( every misguidance leads to the (Hell-) Fire)), [an-Nasaa.ee, Volume 3, Page 188; Saheeh Sunan an-Nasaa.ee 1487].
((He who innovates something in this matter of ours that is not of it will have it rejected)), [Saheeh al-Bukhaaree 2697 and Saheeh Muslim 1718].
babadada1000 1 year ago
The prophet saws told us that the ulema are the inheritors of the prophets. The ulema presented the same message to us in ways we can understand it. Things outside acts of worship are permissible except those prohibited by islam, things inside acts of worship are prohibited except those that are made permissible by islamic law. That is the aalims explaining it to us. It is so obvious that i dont know how you can question it. ask your imam he will agree to it totally, worship is sacred.
immyovuk 1 year ago
@immyovuk you are right but, what is the credibility of this aalim? is he perfect? I saw him saying syedna ALI as was drinking alcohol and then on protest of people he apologized... what kind of aalim is he? couldn't withstand what he says. Anyway, he has knowledge, but its the use of knowledge whcih makes someone true person in front od Allah swt. You can see other aalims too by the way, I mean Tahirul Qadri etc... They'll never agree with Dr. Israr. So, my question here, which aalim to follow?
akhir786 1 year ago
@akhir786 aslamualaikum, firstly brother if one has an unbiased open mind and sees both sides, one will find that israr ahmeds comments were taken out of context, abit was taken out and pasted, and he was sorry that people were upset by what they heard, but he went on to explain what he actually said but that bit was cut by the haters. Sheikh Israr Ahmed was a great man in my opinion. One needs to be aware of satan and the blind haters and dividers. Peace tv is the most on the truth, watch that.
immyovuk 1 year ago
@akhir786 also my brother the prophet saws left us two things the quran and his sunnah, simple. Imam ghazzali ra went on a journey of seeking knowledge and it is said he passed away with sahih bukhari on his chest. The hadith says it is compulsory on us to go seek knowledge, understand the creed. We should be open minded and seek the truth and not be biased to one clan or go on hearsay, i feel the salafis to be most on haq they are the most hated too, but sit with them for a while.
immyovuk 1 year ago
@akhir786 Atleast dont follow Tahirul Qadri. he is fake. us ko loog khud sajda kertay hain aur wooh bajaye un ko mana keray un ko galay laga laita hai :S
khawajanaina 1 year ago
mashallah subhanallah
haroones007 1 year ago
Issi k bayanat ka nateeja he k melad un nabi k jaloos per dhamake hote hein aur yeh log dil se nafrat rakh ker apni taraf se jihad kerte hein aur dehshat gardi machane k baad munafiq bajai k is baat ka iqraar karen yeh log tv per a ker un dhamakon ki muzammat kerte hein are tum jesa munafiq to shetan bhi na hoga
Dr.Pur Israar Gustakh-e-Rasool,Gustakh-e-Ali aur Gustakh-e-Sahaba to qabr me apni kher mana
MuhammadFahadAttari 1 year ago
Dear brothers, I am not a Brailvi but i think these kinds of videos only serve the purpose of our enemies to divide us.A huge no of people believe in this ritual,let them do it.We should refrain ourselves from writing offensive comments also.Let not the world laugh at us and use it as ammunition against us.Let PAKISTANIS be united.
aamirmp1 1 year ago
@alpinesx0 never you call anyone 'kafir', no one is the judge except Allah
peaceloverr 1 year ago
well brother i suggest you read the books by scholar of jalauddin suyuti he was an egytptian scholar and i know alot of scholars who celebrate the prophets birthday who are arab sunnis but hey i dont really celebrate it myself lol
machine9191 1 year ago
brother i dont wanna argue but all i can say is that none of the scholars in islam have refuted celebrating the prophets birthday so your saying there narrow minded aswell and we dont worship graves never have done we do tawassul which is allowed and because the holy people in th graves or the prophets are alive we can make tawassul its perfectly allowed.
machine9191 1 year ago
@machine9191 brother..plenty of scholars disagree, but yes, most of pakistani, indian molvees celebrate milad..lets not label people wahhabee etc.. the hadith is clear that anybody who introduces anything new to this affair of ours will have it rejected. 600 years later the sunnis started celebrating milad..subhanallah. What is a bad bidah? now tell me the difference between the bad bidah and good bidah please..simple question.
immyovuk 1 year ago
@immyovuk: If this hadith was so stright forward then why did Muhaditheen have to classify bidah in to diff. categories ? let me give you a defensive answer ...so if Milad un Nabi is new practice and falls under the criteria of the above mentioned hadith then what about gaining islamic knowledge from the video clips of Dr. Israr on youtube ... is this new practice or not ?
TruthFerreter 1 year ago
@TruthFerreter walaikumsalaam, islam is simple..bidah by definition is worshipping allah in ways allah has not prescribed, in ways that are not those of the prophet saws or his rightly guided successors. When it comes to sattellite etc.. if people disagree with it then we should respect that opinion, however it is not worship, it is a tool to amplify the voice of the speaker to many people, like the car we use. Its use does not come outside shariah, compared to having a third eid.
immyovuk 1 year ago
@immyovuk: brother you don’t really know the definition of bidah … you are confining it to worship which is totally wrong … bidat is "that belief or action which was not in practice during the blessed age of Rasulullah (sallal laahu alaihi wasallam) but was introduced after him." as said by Imam Nawawi, Mulla Ali Qari, Shah Abdul Haq Muhhadith Dehlwi
TruthFerreter 1 year ago
@immyovuk: Many new practices were introduced after the age of Nabi (sallal laahu alaihi wasallam) For instance, Construction of Madressas, Mehraabs of mosques, dividing the Quran into thirty parts, marking the expressions(a’rab) on the Holy Quran, the compilation of I'lm-e-Hadith and Fiqh etc… these are all bidah but are these practices a form of worship??
TruthFerreter 1 year ago
@TruthFerreter. that is not my definition, its from the biggest ulema in mecca, i quoted it from sheikh uthaymeen. The prophet saws told us to keep mosques simple so we focus on allah more, the looks of the mosque are not worship, madresah is a place of learning, it can be anywhere?? they had places of learning in the early times. The same principal goes for rest of your points non of them constitute worship or addition to worship, they are just means to make existing worship more comfortable.
immyovuk 1 year ago
@immyovuk : so those practices are not worship or addition to worship, that means they are not bidah ..right ?
TruthFerreter 1 year ago
@TruthFerreter...well yess in this context.. worship is sacred, we should not twist the aqeeda, allah says in the quran that the religion given to the prophet saws was complete, surah maida, also that he has created us for nothing but his worship, we should not make additions or developments to the worship, it leads to misguidance. If you love the prophet saws, follow his sunnah, be good people, seek knowledge, follow his message.
immyovuk 1 year ago
@immyovuk So u agreed that those practices are NOT bidah, but earlier you wrote in your post “the hadith is clear that anybody who introduces anything new to this affair of ours will have it rejected” and at other point you wrote “The hadith is clear every innovation is misguidance, which leads to hellfire.” Now on what basis are you exempting those practices from the words of the ahadith that you emphasized on and saying they are NOT bidah?
TruthFerreter 1 year ago
@TruthFerreter..brother..please i am trying to have a discussion with you, not a debate, i am no scholar. You are making a mistake of trying to be too smart without paying attention. It is a common pitfall. Bidah in this context is introducing something new into the WORSHIP. Having loudspeakers is not worship in itself, it just makes existing original worship easier. Please read my last 3-4 paragraphs and try to understand and please dont waste the space asking stupid questions.
immyovuk 1 year ago
@immyovuk : Things start sounding stupid when you don’t have answer to it. I was discussing on your presented definition of bidah instead of the four imams. I didn’t talk about loud speaker at all, but when students go to madrassas, study Quran, usul e deen and books of ahadith to get Islamic degree, this is indeed ibadah, and was not in practice at the time of prophet(sallal laahu alaihi wasallam) and sahabas, but you wont dare to call this as bidah.
TruthFerreter 1 year ago
@immyovuk : (Cont’d ) Can you prove your definition of bidah from Sunnah? Give me one hadith which says that any new practice which is not worship (but addition to worship or makes existing worship easier) is permissible.
TruthFerreter 1 year ago
@TruthFerreter..brother you are trying to argue with me, trying to outsmart me. Let me make it simpler, Circles of knowledge were in the time of the prophet saws, so were masjids, recognition of aalims was too as the prophet saws said the aalims are inheritors of the prophets-al bukhari. How is this bidah? Lets go to the main question, you do milad, now it is on you to go to quran and sunnah and prove the milad party. The fact is it wasnt done by sunnis for 600 years after the prophet saws.
immyovuk 1 year ago
@TruthFerreter..alot of what you do on milad, dhikr, worship, bayaans are not bidah, we should do this more often than to have one day a year for it- a third eid, a day which you believe is extra special with added virtue and benefit. This is bidah.
immyovuk 1 year ago
@immyovuk I’ll come to Milad's topic if you’d be able to do intellectual discussion, but do not change the topic for now. I am not trying to outsmart you, I am just showing you how troublesome your definition of bidah is. You claim to follow only Quran and Sunnah and reject taqleed. I asked you to support your definition of bidah from Sunnah but you just ignored my question. If you don’t have hadith for ibn uthaymeen’s definition of bidah then you are doing his taqleed, aren’t you?
TruthFerreter 1 year ago
@immyovuk Circles of knowledge were there, so were masjids and every sahabi was aalim. But they didn’t go to madrassas to hifz Quran, nor did they study usul e deen and compiled books of ahadith. When someone learns islamic sciences, i.e sarf, nahw, mantiq, usul e tafseer, usul e hadith etc does he get thawab or gunnah? Obviously he gets thawab, but these sciences were introduced after the time of sahaba. So this practice seems to be bidah(cuz its a form of worship) according to ur definition
TruthFerreter 1 year ago
@TruthFerreter..surah imran 3:31, allah says if you really love him, follow the prophet. The prophet saws never did milad, he fasted on mondays because he was born that day and got the revelation on a monday. The sahabah nor the 4 imams including abu haneefa ra did milad. He who innovates in this religion of ours that is not of it will have it rejected-bukhari and muslim. EVERY innovation is a misguidance-muslim. Allah says the religion was completed at the prophets time in surah maidah.
immyovuk 1 year ago
@TruthFerreter..Things outside acts of worship are permissible except those islamic law prohibits. All acts of worship are generally prohibited except those which islamic law has made permissible." You must follow my sunnah and that of the rightly guided khalifas. hold to it and stick fast to it. Avoid newly invented matters, as every newly invented matter is an innovation, every innovation is an error-ahmad, tirmidhi. Now please present your proof for the milad? Abu haneefa ra did not do it!
immyovuk 1 year ago
@immyovuk "Things outside acts of worship are permissible except those islamic law prohibits. All acts of worship are generally prohibited except those which islamic law has made permissible." i asked to back ur def. from hadith ... is that a hadith ??????
The other two ahadith you quoted are contradicting with your definition of bidah.One has word "every" and other has words "that is not of it" .... I need a hadith which says... every new form of worship is bidah ...
TruthFerreter 1 year ago
@TruthFerreter brother you are trying to be too smart, you dont want to learn and be open. Ask any imam, if you do an act it is up to you to justify the act you do. You cannot present 1 hadith to me yet you are beating about the bush acting like a spoilt person with the hadiths i presented you trying to find loopholes and twisting the words of the prophet saws so that you can justify an act added to the worship 600yrs later by sunnis. You do milad. Carry on. Im done with you, i know your type.
immyovuk 1 year ago
@immyovuk Alhemdulilah, so called Salafi claiming to follow only Quran & Sunnah was not able to present one hadith to support his def. of bidah. You claim milad to be bidah, yet you don’t have a single hadith to support your def. of bidah. According to you, what is bidat? every new form of worship is bidah, but new practices to facilitate worship are not bidah. Whats the proof from hadith? Every innovation is misguidance. SubhanAllah, what an argument to support your def.!
TruthFerreter 1 year ago
@immyovuk “He who innovates in this religion of ours that is not of it will have it rejected-bukhari” just ponder on the words of hadith you quoted “that is not if it” means? ..only that innovation is rejected which is against Quran & Sunnah. Now you claim milad is bidah by putting it in category of “that is not of it”. Now it is your responsibility to prove how it comes under “that is not of it”. No indication of impermissiblity for an act is enough to be it permissible.
TruthFerreter 1 year ago
@immyovuk I knew you would you run away from the argument, only that person uses words like too smart, outsmart, stupid, beat about the bush, spoilt person.. who runs short of proofs and have nothing else to say. This is what happens when you leave the path of true Salaf. I don’t blame you and I know your type too!
TruthFerreter 1 year ago
@TruthFerreter, sheikh uthaymeen ra said that bidah is worshipping allah in ways not prescribed by allah, in ways other than that done by the prophet saws or his rightly guided khalifa. What else could it be? In surah maida allah says the religion was completed. Having a third eid, a day of extra virtue and rewards and is a bidah that was not done for first 600 years by sunnis, first 300 years by shias. Think about all the greats who did not do it, who loved him saws the most.
immyovuk 1 year ago
@immyovuk ..he who innovates in this religion of ours that is not of it will have it rejected- bukhari and muslim. It means who ever adds to the religion that what is not from it, it is alien to it, eg a third eid, if something is added to the prescribed worship which is not from allah through the prophet saws i.e in quran and sound hadith. The other hadith that every innovation is a misguidance-muslim, is in this context that everything added to the religion i.e the worship, is a misguidance.
immyovuk 1 year ago
@TruthFerreter.. please brother to make it a balanced discussion you have to provide your evidence for it. The prophet saws said "Verily the best among you are my generation, those who follow them (tabiun), then those who follow them(tabi tabiun)."-muslim. Did the best of muslims do a third eid? Allah created us for nothing else but his worship, a third eid is unauthorised by the prophet saws. Now because you do it, the priority is with you to provide evidence for it.
immyovuk 1 year ago
@immyovuk 1st tell me, any act that induces thawab, would it be considered as worship ?
TruthFerreter 1 year ago
@TruthFerreter..brother every act that induces thawaab has its foundation in quran and sunnah. Eg being kind is from sunnah, and in hadiths, if you want i can find you specific hadiths but i dont think you need me to. Eg, if you give a brother a free lift you are being kind and charitable, doing ikraam. If you remove obstacles from the path you are doing an act of charity etc, if you show good character and conduct-its from quran and sunnah. Milad is not.
immyovuk 1 year ago
ya Rabul Alalmeen ghamdi dr israr zakir naiyk tuseef ko kal kiamat k den abu jhal k sath otha mere malik tujhe tere piyare mehboob bando ka wasta Ameen
swahid1000 1 year ago
@swahid1000 mere bhai kuch toh sochen bolne se pehle. Kya faaida ho raha hai aapko baddua de ke? aman rakhe.n. Dr Israr ne sirf ek hadeeth sunaayi hai..
hasancoool 1 year ago
acha agar woh kahta keh ap harami hain??
ya phir woh kahta ke ap ka baap bara bura insan hai ? to ! apna mun band kar k rakh. yeh hamari puri history ko ghalat keh rha .
han Sarkar nen farmaya meri umat main kuch aisay bhe hun ge jo yahudeon aur christians wali ayaten naik logon par chipsan karen gay.
Hadees byan ke hai!
MrMajorsign1 1 year ago
@MrMajorsign1 bhai hamaare Nabi SAW ne aur Sahaba RA ne kabhi Meelaad nahi manaaya. Eid Milaad 600 saal ke baad manaaya gaya tha pehli baar Islam ki taareekh mein. Kya iska matlab ye hai ke 600 saal tak musalmaano ko deen ka feham nahi tha ? Please thande dimaagh se sochen. Ghussa na karna.
hasancoool 1 year ago
@immyovuk...an example if for fajr instead of readng 2 sunnahs you read 3, will it be accepted, why not? ask yourselves.
immyovuk 1 year ago
iagreeee....
ikramniazi 1 year ago
Dr Israr Pr Allah Ke Rehmatain Nazil hon He is a Great and True Muslim.
MrEjaz402 1 year ago
Dr israr was a great man, very powerful mind. Now milad un nabee was not celebrated by muslims nor the prophet saws until 600 years later by sunni muslims. This is the belief that this day has extra special virtue and we should celebrate it. Now when they start saying its a good bid'ah and allowed, ask them what is a bad bid'ah?? then ask them whats the difference between the bad bid'ah and good bid'ah. The hadith is clear every innovation is misguidance, which leads to hellfire.
immyovuk 1 year ago
well you carry on celebrating wat u want - dont expect others to follow your lot.you dont call salafs kafir??? are you blind? do yoou not read what this page says?? lol.i can post you 100 clips just off you tube where salafs have been called kafir?? do you people even know the meaning of the word SALAF.salaf refers to the generations of sahabas who were promised jannah! by calling salafis KAFIR u lot r calling the sahabas KAFIR na'uzubillah!!! whats the difference between u & shia?
xxSonuJeexx 1 year ago
@xxSonuJeexx you are welcome to do your grave worshipping, celebrating birthdays, hanging verses round your neck in belief of protecetion, asking from so called holy peers and fakeers... go for it. do as much as you want- leave others to there beliefs. Allah swa has preserved the qur'an for over 1400 yrs knowing that certain people wil try n change islam..and us salafs thank allah 4this. it means we wont b fooled by sufi barailawi mentality!
xxSonuJeexx 1 year ago
MERER BHAI WOR US WAQT SAHABA SHARAAB PEETER TER UNTIL , AQA S.A.]W NER FARMAYA ALLAH KA HUKUM TOR PHIR QURAAN KI AYAT NAZA HOYEEE,
IM SAYING , ISLAM WASNT COMPLETE THEN ...... WHY IS THIS JAHIL TALKING ABOUT THE BAD POINTS OF ISLAM .....
nisbatmurshid 1 year ago
Ya Allah Madad.
Dr Israr infact a great person who show the way to Khalaft e Rashda.
Its our own duty to follow his mission.Other molvie like dr tahir ul qadri never try to impsoe or explore the Khalaft e rashda.
vickeyrandhawa 1 year ago
this guy is nothing but a ghustaaaaah!!!!!!
nisbatmurshid 1 year ago
when dr tahir qadri says a statement false or wrong which it isnt hes right , hes never appoligised people like this kafir and dr nalaaaaiq ha ha aha , start to cry the whole muslim world put a fatwa on these munafiqs who are you ??? to say this guy is right......
nisbatmurshid 1 year ago