Added: 5 years ago
From: azchicky99
Views: 47,596
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (130)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Different from the original, this is the way a cover version should sound! written by Martin L Gore 1984...

  • Just to let you know, the original song was actually done in the 80's by Depeche Mode.

  • @CrazyKittyCat0 I'd say original lyrics, the song is ENTIRELY different, lol. Kind of awful IMO, and I LOVE A Perfect Circle. Nanananana.....

  • i'm so glad you made this video, i was going to do one with some of the same photos, their must be a psychic wavelength people communicate on, but i was goona do the depech version. keep it up

  • For those who say this isn't A Perfect Circle song I will to say listen to both songs carefully. The lyrics are not the same, this is not a cover either, it's an adaption of the Depeche Mode song. Though it's clearly not a song originally conceived by Maynard this version has been twisted to his perspective.

  • I don´t like trolling, and i respect this band, but IS THIS A FUCKING JOKE/PARODY?! it doesn´t sound like a cover at all, it sounds like they intentionally tried to fuck this up this song.

  • Thoroughly enjoyed! Great job putting this together all the way around!!

  • Thank you for sharing this... Too bad so many people commenting seem to miss the point entirely, and they seem to be the ones who need to get it the most! (PS - I loved the Depeche Mode version of the song growing up, and while this version is different, but it seems to capture the angst of the lyrics much more.)

  • azchicky99 thanks for the video. I like the APC version of the song, just my preference and your video captures the somber atmosphere of the song.

  • @artislife07 How is being black being special? You can't compare a race with a sexual orientation. Being homosexual is special because humans weren't originally designed to be homosexual but to reproduce so I can understand why you classify them as special. Being black is different though, they are race that outnumbers your people in numbers...doesn't special mean rare? How are they special if they are more common? Please answer the question.

  • FUCKING TERRIBLE! AND THIS IS NOT 'A PERFECT CIRCLE' YOU BLASPHEMOUS CUNT!!! CHANGE THAT FUCKING TITLE YOU IGNORANT PIECE OF SHIT.

  • @MartyMoves Yes, it is A Perfect Circle. It's from the album eMotive. Calm down some, will you?

  • @artislife07 It hasn't been proven, and you are full of shit. Being gay is an insult to the gift of life that God has given. If the whole world went gay, mankind as we know it would end. Hence, Gay = EVIL. you do not, and can not love evil, you hypocritical cunt.

    They aren't born gay, nobody is. Its a fucking disease that needs to be cured. Death is a great way of doing this. Since they're all condemned to hell anyway, why not just kill them and get it over with. And you can die too, faggot!

  • @MartyMoves You obviously need some theropy.

  • @MartyMoves

    I'm not here to argue the issue, just the poor argument.

    I hate to see one.

    Using the presented "logic":

    If the whole world were male, the world as we know it, would end as well. Men=evil???

    but,

    Why not kill gay people? Because you are not in charge. You can take a life, but can you bring it back after? Does life belong to you? Bibically speaking: Romans 12:18-19 Romans 13:9 Matthew 7:1-2 John 13:34-35, but hopefully one can find decent morals & reasons within themselves as well.

  • lol bad depeche mode cover,very bad

  • The original is better than this cover.

    Originally by Depeche Mode.

  • Depeche Mode covers are great. 

  • This is my favorite version of the song, its much better than the original. Great Job putting it together!

  • lol gotta love the photo of the australia day riots in sydney

  • soccer riots thats why

  • great video

  • Death

  • okay we can say that we as humans are horrible creatures, but what are we doing to change it. some are horrible because they have no choise, or the choise is being horrible or death...wich is the lesser of the two evils?

  • There's always a choice. Now, I'm not gonna condemn those people that choose to be horrible because they're scared of death, but if they're truly forced into the things they do, they'll suffer by other means (not talking about diving retribution, I mean they'll probably be tormented by the things they've done). And it's nearly impossible for an individual to do anything to change the world. But it doesn't mean you can't try to stop hate in your everyday life.

  • @sandman1008

    You change the world one piece at a time. You don't solve a puzzle or build something in one step.

    You can not change everything alone, but each puzzle piece is important to make the whole.

  • @ferretsnax Yes, that's what I said, though not as colorful. One person may not be able to change the world,but it doesn't mean you can't try to stop the hate in your everyday life. As a result, if everyone tries to stop the hate in their everyday life, it'll become much larger, and can make the world a better place.

  • it's spelled "choice" dumbass

  • @guillermo6545

    Everyone has a choice, Sometimes the choices are limited, & that is when it is best to be creative, instead of going for what is easy or apparent.

  • Original song from Depeche Mode, you forgot to mentiont it, no biggie, i also earded this version before.

    One of the best cover, probably the best.

    You can also check the covers from "A string tribute to"; "Dope"; "Atrocity"; "Stone the crow"

  • haha you dislike gays because they caused aids but lesbians are okay in your mind cause well, be honest you think its hot, and that AIDS thing yeah pretty sure you can get it another way to0, oh yeah open cuts or sores, oh but it was the gays who did it not the people who have little healthcare in 3rd world countries and really it would have spread even if there were no gays, so your argument sucks, but thats just my opinion do with it what you may

  • asshole ,get a brain transplant,you might sound interesting to some idiot!

  • If it were proved that being gay is controlled by genes then would you like them? Afterall, to hate them would be like making yourself a god.

  • AMAZING , this song is pure gold and thats kinda sad =/ ...

  • Amazing compilation with an amazing song. I love it.

  • i'm not saying that any one said that im saying that the original version is better

  • ok....ok......ok.....this song is no way written or thought of by perfect circle unless you have proof that they wrote it i will stop spamming................foreve­r

  • No one said it was. v read v

  • It sounds like a perfect circle, it sounds like maynards voice. Who cares if he did it or not, it's a good song. Could you please stop spamming everyone? This is youtube! We can write our own opinions. You just don't have to go around thinking that you're right and assume that it's something it may not even be. I'm not saying you're right or wrong. But could you please be considerate and just STOP with the spamming!

  • @rapisgoodforu12

    \cduniverse(dot)com/search/xx/­music/pid/6790359/a/Emotive.ht­m

    Maynard is something else... Put forward an expectation for what he can do and you will be sorely disappointed

  • @Kajillin NO ONE CARES

  • @rapisgoodforu12 Agreed it is a cover of Depeche Mode song look it up people

  • @rapisgoodforu12 Sheesh, it's Depeche Mode.

  • i hate people that hate gays because you cant control your emotions or who you love so the people who hate gays well i hate you did god come down and tell you he hats gays , no! dont always listen to the book if god is nice then he will except you for who you r

  • Thanks for all the good comments, I really took some time to put this together and to get the message across. As for all the people just ragging on my video for the version of the song, open your eyes and use your minds to look past it and see the real meaning of this video. Besides this is the only version I was aware of , it was randomly on my computer and it spoke to me when I heard it.

  • @azchicky99 Love the song and good use of images for the vid thumbs up from me i used it in sociology class the other day.

  • @azchicky99 This is a wonderful collage of images for this song. I think you do fantastic work.

  • Every cover on this album is better than the original except for Imagine

  • good vid it really helps the point of the song.

  • god hates fags- true

  • god hates everything; even pee is a sin for god

  • God doesn't hate anybody we hate each other

  • that's kind of true. We interpret things the wrong way all the time. It's sick and somewhat uncontrollable. Humans are like that. All humans are unfortunately like that..

  • Right

    We use religions as an Excuse for hatred

    While Actually even if there was no religions we would have been killing each other and nothing would have been changed.....

  • thats the menatlity of thomas hobbes, that everyone is born evil and greedy.

    i dont think 'gays' really care if u hate him/her they dont care as long as u dont physicaly try to hurt anyone i mean its like people in general u can hate someone and they probably wount care as long as u dont really try to do anything against them.

  • yes, humans are the worst creatures. i honestly dont like people, make that what people are capable of doing, and the ignorance! but i guess a percentage are ok. people have done and will do horrible things... sucks...but im sure yur a nice person

  • if he hates everything thing then why did he create it?

  • I'm sorry, are you retarded?

    No, even retards grasp the simple concept of...well, sense. Something that is apparently above you.

    You have my pity.

  • i like this version the best dope and stone the crows versions aernt erally that good lol

  • i cant stand this version

  • dopes is alot better

  • no offense but this version of the song sucks...

  • This cover is definately really interesting. I like the fact that they changed it from a 4/4 dance beat to a 7/8 beat..which makes it totally undanceable..unless you're a freak lol. But overall..I'd still say that the Original song packs a more powerful punch than this one...just my opinion.

  • DM's version is really bad. It doesn't flow right (I agree with fanboyshaka). Everyone seems to think this is so brilliant and breath taking, when it's really not if you know the DM version.

  • maynard james is a genius! i cant wait for puscifer to come out!

  • genius because he used the words from depeche mode? there's no shame in that but that doesn't make him a genius.

  • It's everything he does that makes him a genius, not just this cover.

  • I'm a tool, APC and DM fan but gotta say this is rather not genius imo.

  • people are people and people entered into production relations with one another... production relations that have become stagnant and old to their relation with the productive forces... these antagonisms between different classes, that emeged from this fundamental irony, is what drives one man to hate another man... "people are people so why should it be..." because of the old ways... capitalism

    I gotta bring up the fact though depeche mode made this song, not perfect circle (no I'm not hatin')

  • I love this song. The message is simple, yet so beautiful. I've heard both versions, and I think they both have their own merits, but personally I prefer APC's take on the song. It's so emotive (no pun intended :P) and sounds more human to me...Great job on the images, it fits the song perfectly.

  • Hey, i usually hate this slideshows but this one caught me totally and had to watch it to the end. I really liked this one, it wasn't just pictures of rioting people what wouldn't be a surpise. You showed many pictures of regular people and that gave this slideshow a bit "art" kinda look. 5 stars for this. im sorry for bad english, I hope you undestand what i was supposed to say :) and sorry for way too long comment :DD

  • wow...just wow...lol

  • Bleagh... The original version by Depeche Mode is way better.

  • you SHOULD hate me!!!!!!!!

  • The song is great! Maynard is a genious, TOOL is best rockband ever!

  • apc nt tool

  • i prefer Dope's version of this song if i'm honest, but i like the video. it does make you think.

  • hey,you there that loves the 80s,have you listened to this song at all?you totally just became what this song is talking about.whatta loser.apc kicks so much ass guys!!

  • ew I hate this. this sounds like fucking morrissee. First APC song that makes me wanna throw up.

  • The 80's called, they said they are missing some Depeche Mode records and the dufus that owns them. This is a great cover. Way to go APC!!

  • this is disgusting. the depeche mode version blows this out of the water. you guys are fagots for even liking a perfect circle. bring back boingo.

  • LOL o.o

  • this is one my most held dear songs. And I am an Afghanistan vet. Why should it be you and I shouldn't get along?

    I love you too.

    W2

  • *hugs*

    Well said...well said. =¨)

  • im not gay...but i dont support hating someone because of what they choose to do...now dont get me wrong...i still think its gross....see think about this...your best friend eventually turns out to be gay...would you still hate him?

  • What twoddle

  • Oh its SOOO good disturbing and creepy and sad but good.

  • Great use of visualization. Disturbing...but real.

  • i love the song also

    i think that that is ridiculous that people hate gays so much

    it is of their free will to choose

    what they want to do with their life

    im not gay but i dont think we should shun

    them just because they are

  • I love this version of the song. Depeche Mode brought it to the surface but Perfect Circle Delivered it to the top!

  • Definitely not. They destroyed it.

  • why post negative comments about it if yo dont like it? seems like someone wants attention

  • i love dopes cover alot better, this is a totally different style though

  • ha ha thanks

  • its speaks in a more definite tone than dm does, its stronger, a strong voice for a strong song

  • For me DM version is worst anyway. This is much more touching. The style of playing and the vocal harmonizes with the message of the song.

  • DM version is alot better IMO. this one just...doesn't flow well to me.

  • I can see why people would like the Depeche Mode version better, but I like this version a lot. It is in the style of the band. I think this and Imagine are some of the most original covers I've heard. Redoing a song the exact way it was originally performed is lame.

  • i have to say that this is a terrible version of depeche modes people are people

  • Pretty cool. Some of the images, I don't see how they fit...but overall, not bad.

  • I like both versions of People are People, but the sound of this sounds more heartfelt than the opposing upbeat version by depeche mode. But anyway, prejudice is an awful thing, and we are ALL guilty.

  • depeche mode suck! perfect circle 4 eva suckers

  • I know the reply is totally late, but I agree 100 percent!!!!!!!

  • awful song... raped depeche mode!

  • Song is terrible.. The original version by Depeche Mode is so much better.

  • Im not intersted in the movie (but its still realy good). Im more interested in the music. Listen to the bass, its Jeordie White (Twiggy Ramirez). And his is like the best bassist ever!!!!! Listen to it!!!!!!!!!!

  • The world could really learn a lesson from most of the songs on eMotive...mainly this song, (What's so funny 'bout) Peace, Love, and Understanding, and Imagine...those 3 songs have a very powerful message

  • I think the video was outstanding. The APC version of People Are People leaves alot to be desired, for me. Since its missing the classic PAP melody and energy, it was driving me crazy not being able to hear it in the song. Like when someone is talking to you so slowly and you know what they are going to say and its makes you frustrated because you want to just finish their sentences..if that makes sense. But kudos to APC for totally changing up the song and making it sound like themselves.

  • kool! i like it.

  • The pictures were a little blunt at times, but superb job overall.

  • The pictures aren't "blunt" they are all real and if you think the pictures are a little rough then do something to stop them thats why i made this video to maybe show people how wrong it is so they will do something about it.

  • or a basic level of inteligence

  • ive always liked this remake better than the original version. great job on your video!!! a perfect circle is a great band i've seen them sevaral times . you need to be at a higher level of life to get it@|!?

  • Awesome video. Very powerful! Heard this version for the first time yesterday. I actually like both.

  • The definition of horrible.

  • nice job on the video. i was listening to the DM version and I thought about doing something like this but you beat me to it. i like the original version better, but this one grew on me by the end

  • even depeche mode hates the song people are people...stop whining.this is a good cover.

  • It sounds like they just took the words. Not a good cover. But there's something interesting in the melody. Good image choices.

  • dude you people suck this song is a great cover and nice vid

  • Christians that hate Gay People make me embaressed of my faith.

  • hey these people dont know music ,great cover. you did a good job on this!!!

  • worst cover ever. period.

  • They absolutely killed a classic song.

  • damn they fucked this song up.

  • You do know this song was originally by Depeche mode, right?  frankly, the depeche mode version is a lot better...but good job!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more