Is the Quran Miraculous - Abdallah vs. Qureshi - 03 - Conclusions

[MrRomel00]

good job, i actually looked up these "Scientific Maricle" and yes they are taken out of context im an arab btw

[xxjaycxx1]

the miracles of the Koran scary stuff,

What muslims see in this stuff I dont know.

Thank GOD that many muslims are now seeking truth of the spirit and not of the flesh.

I have nothing against muslims but I do have issues with someone not taking the time to dig deep and put what they believe to the test.

GOD is reaching out to you muslims take his peaceful invite please before it is too late.

[xxjaycxx1]

GOD did not want for us to follow men, so he sent his son so that we may continue to follow the true GOD.

To us Jesus who is the word of GOD his son is GOD.

per Isaiah 9:6

Muslim's are stuck following one man and his own word.

Going against Yahwey , with man made religious traditions.

Why would GOD who gave us free will, would take it from us,when he does not change for nothing he stays the same.

Man's religion is holy perversion a religious cage enslaving your mind.

Jesus sets u free

[xxjaycxx1]

How do you talk about science and not know it?

Wow what Abdallah is saying is I don't care if this is a lie i'm a still believe in it cause my pride demand my ignorance.

[hamzah938]

Blah, blah, blah, da'wah, da'wah,...

[blitz2b]

" Blah blah blah OK " , " Blah blah blah OK " , " Blah blah blah OK " , " Blah blah blah OK "

Osama debating is NOT your forte. Don't quit your dayjob please.

[captaindisguise]

osama is such a loser

[ADAJ3]

If you break your back, you can't have sex. This is a scientific miracle? WOW!!!

[MayIPleaseAsk]

Does osama realise that he is HIGHLIGHTING that his cult of islam is for those who dont ENGAGE THEIR BRAIN?

I believe he is DENYING his historical islamic writings out of SHAME - :0(

Does he not ask himself "If" islam is true then WHY must I LIE about it?

Kat >^.^<

[penkallli]

These argms have already been answered already, the goat eating a verse, abrogation etc etc, just like the satanic verses issue, always bring it up like parrots and then close ur ears, thers no point anymore in debating if we have to bring the same lame debunked argms !

[penkallli]

Haha, no1 agrees with Nabil that quran has been corrupted but himself, we have abrogation sanctioned by God, and we know exactly what verses r abroggated, we have them in hadith, read the same Buhari that u refer;

To compare bible is apple and oranges because, quran is memorised and transmited in chain of narraation, and the bible has anonymous authors, thers hadith text dating to 1 cent hijra for the student of Abu Hurayra, and majority of hadith ther r in Buhari !! So ur wrong Nabil !

[prince4king7]

im sick and tired of abdullah saying this book has the spirit, show me a single verse from the quran which says that this book has a SPIRIT!!!! muslims dont even say that quran is inspired by God or by Spirit! cut the crap man! this is too much now!

[penkallli]

@prince4king7

"muslims dont even say that quran is inspired by God or by Spirit"

False, muslims believe the quran is the wordof god verbatim, see quran passages and hadith on this, this is unanimous belief of the muslims;

the bible actually is a word of man later to be believed as word of God, the letters of Paul to a congregation arent for sure word of God, a the biographies of Jesus the gospels, or acts of apostles, these r all words of men later to be taken as word of God-- so its the revers

[prince4king7]

how come this ignorant person present facts from neurology when he doesn't even know how to pronounce them???? did u actually read it ????? i seriously doubt it!

[prince4king7]

abdullah! if ubai was wrong, wot guarantee do u have that those compiling the quran under othman were not wrong??? i mean, its one person's word against their! and another thing, ubai must have had some following as well as he was appointed by muhammed as one of the top teachers! so can u give us a single reason to reject him and accept those under othman???

well it was othman and his followers who burnt all the previous manuscripts to destroy all the evidence, it makes that group more suspicios

[prince4king7]

just see abdullah shouting when its Dr. Nabil's time to respond!!!! he just cant see himself destroyed hahahahaha!

[prince4king7]

hahahahahaha, just see abdullah shouting when its Dr. Nabil's time to respond!!!! he just cant see himself destroyed hahahahaha!

[prince4king7]

hahahahahaha, now ubai is wrong and committed a mistake, again, this goes against u my friend! this shows that muhammed was ignorant in choosing the top 4 teachers and again shows he had no divine inspiration at all!

[penkallli]

@prince4king7

Many times Nabil brings a so called mistake by the companions and the arabic text belies him, check the debate with Bassam,

Ur statement of Ubay would be correct if ther was only Ubay who memorised the quran ! The last haj of the prophet ther was around 100 thousands companions, so we have great assurance of the text

[prince4king7]

Bukhari and muslim r garbage???? muslims!!!!! r u listening to this???? maybe abdullah is a wahabi!!! hey sunnis! this is a kafir as per ur sect!!! where is the fatwa to kill him???? lolzzzzz

[prince4king7]

if ur not a doctor, and then u say there is something there and then accuse an MD of being ignorant!!!! how pathetic and cheap can u get????

this is a major tactic of muslim debaters, when they loose, they start throwing insults!

[prince4king7]

i love the comment abdullah gave in relation to spermatogenesis and spinal cord! wot an ignorant prick! yes it makes sense to u cuz ur taught to follow blindly! its nice to see Dr. Nabil laughing at this comment cuz he knows wot kinda stupid this argument is! makes me laugh too, lolzzzzzzzz

[prince4king7]

@ThePrimordialAtom osama is just a fool!

[friendofsina]

What an embarrassement for Muslims this guy Abdallah is, this is the third debate I watch for him and he is a total fool!

[prince4king7]

@friendofsina yet muslims all the while refer to his web site to refute the Christians, i will like u to see my comments on part 2 of this debate, u might like some of them!

[sirjambo]

Osama Abdallah is a fool.

He makes a great muslim.

ISlamic logic at it's finest.

[sirjambo]

Osama Abdallah is a typical muslim.

What an idiot!

[prince4king7]

@sirjambo couldn't even defend his own claims!

[sirjambo]

@prince4king7 No muslim can defend their ridiculous false exaggerated claims!

[prince4king7]

@sirjambo agreed, and u can see clearly how abdullah proved himself to b stupid!

[Zdrazy]

Abdullah was talking nonsense with what he said about iron. It's atomic number is 26, but the verse number is 25, and the surah is 57, not 56.

The sperm from which man is created comes from the testes during ejaculation, not from the back bone, or from between the loins. I don't think the creator of the universe would struggle so much to get basic biology right.

[redman4853]

The Muslims are going to KILL ABDALLAH for this crazy talk! He just insulted 95% of islamic tradition!Why does Abduallah REJECT his TRUE SCHOLARS? I don't even think He notice what he is doing! This is truly a BRAINWASHED MAN! Abdullah is VERY STUPID! I am not saying this to be funny but this guy really has a problem!

[prince4king7]

@redman4853 he rejects his own sources to somehow reach the conclusion that wotever he says is right, by the way, he is also quoting wrong translations of the quran and that too, ripping the words out of context and IGNORING the words coming after it!

[gokilex]

Even in adulthood after the descent of the reproductive organs, these organs receive their nerve supply and blood supply from the Abdominal Aorta, which is in the area between the backbone (spinal column) and the ribs. The lymphatic drainage and the venous return also go to the same area.

[gokilex]

In embryonic stages, the reproductive organs of the male and female, i.e. the testicles and the ovaries,begin their development near the kidney between the spinal column and the eleventh and twelfth ribs. Later they descend; the female gonads (ovaries) stop in the pelvis while the male gonads (testicles) continue their descent before birth to reach the scrotum through the inguinal canal.

[frencyv]

Osama is floored!!!!

I think its better to debate with someone who can think logically.

Bro Nabeel, U Won Straight. He is jus blabbering.

Ur next target should be Shabir Ali from Canada, or Dr Zakir Naik from india. Pls take on Dr Zakir Naik. He is a thorn.

[prince4king7]

@frencyv joker naik has been challenged over and over again by Acts 17 and Br. Sam Shamoun and joker naik always has 2 replies,

1. i donot have time

2. plz gather an audience of 100,000 to debate me

the second point is the most silly, reason being, in today's world, u dont need an audience, just make a video, upload it on youtube and u have millions of viewers,\

that joker will never come out of his hole!

[Texas75023]

Wow. The generous willingness to excuse the scientific errors in the Quran defies description.

[Glorthac]

What's that green book that Mr. Abdullah is holding up?

[Chinomareno]

9:58 "I'm not a doctor, I can't explain it but there is... there is something there ok. Maybe you're ignorant about it, it doesn't make it wrong. Ok maybe that's an area for you sir, as a doctor to research"

All while pointing rudely and speaking condecendingly. This is so arrogant its funny, he even admits he doesn't know anything about the subject but is telling this doctor to do his biology homework.

[prince4king7]

@Chinomareno clearly shows the desperation and obvious defeat!

[OsamaAbdallahRefuted]

Osama Abdallah, Psychogenic erections result when messages are passed down the SPINAL CORD from the brain to the sacral area. Depending on the level and completeness of the injury to the spinal cord, men with SCI may or may not experience psychogenic erections.

In other words Osama, if you damage your spine & become paralysed you're less likely to get an erection, & less likely to perform sex.

do yourself a favour & pickup a medical book.

[OsamaAbdallahRefuted]

furthermore, sperm DOES NOT come from the ribcage area.

[OsamaAbdallahRefuted]

Ejaculation is a motor function which cannot take place if the particular nerves and parts of the spinal cord that control ejaculation are injured. The ability to ejaculate is controlled by nerves, which originate in the LOWEST (NOT UPPER) part of the spinal cord; that is, segments T-12 to L-2, and sacral levels, 2, 3, and 4.

[OsamaAbdallahRefuted]

However, some spinal cord injured men can ejaculate. In men with lower level injuries, most researchers report that ejaculation occurs in up to 70% of men with incomplete lower injuries, and in up to 17% of men with complete lower level injuries. In men with upper level injuries, most researchers report that ejaculation occurs in up to 29% of men with incomplete upper level injuries, and rarely, if ever, in men with complete upper level injuries.

[OsamaAbdallahRefuted]

which again proves Nabeel's point and refutes your point about sperm and semen coming from the ribcage area. the keypoints are:

1) Ejaculation requires particular nerves & parts of the spinal chord, that originate in the LOWEST (NOT UPPER) part of the spinal cord.

2) sperm is produced by the testicles & the testicles is connected to the Epididymis, then connected to the Vas deferens which semen is carried from the prostate gland.

[OsamaAbdallahRefuted]

3) erections (NOT SPERM OR SEMEN) result when messages are passed down the SPINAL CORD from the brain to the sacral area.

NO WHERE IN THE RIB CAGE AREA PRODUCES SPERM OR SEMEN.

Osama, I seriously doubt you're studying computer science. if you did would have researched the web, the reason you didn't is that biology refutes you and your religion.

[penkallli]

Also about semen in chapter Tariq - semen is sperm and other fluids wich come forth from prostate:... integral to the making of the sperm comes from between the ribs and the back. So its not just the spermatozoids wich make semen

[prince4king7]

@penkallli u really need to study the embryology my friend! and don't forget, Dr. Nabil is an MD, he has much more knowledge on this subject that this lame osama!

[penkallli]

Ubay and Abdullah ibn Masood had thier own codices where they wrote quran and their somwtmes their own comments, stop taking narrations out of context Nabeel; they didnt write Fatiha and last 2 small chapters..it doesnt mean they didnt accept the quran, they just didnt record them, all the muslims know them

[prince4king7]

@penkallli u need to listen wot Dr. Nabil is saying CAREFULLY< stop taking a superficial approach like abdullah who got HUMILIATED and BURIED in this debate!

[penkallli]

@prince4king7

Did he respond the the arguments abput the quran ?! No, he goes around and round with the same lame arguments debunked already, Abdullah has mentioned new arguments fro the quran that Ive not heard as a muslim in a debate, although his debating skills have to be improved

[penkallli]

Nabeel takes narrations out of context; when Ubay said let not any say that we have the entire quran..Hes was expressing sorrow for the 70 or so martyred Hufadh-quran memorizers in the battle of Yamama, that didnt mean they didnt have the quran, Nabeel takes it out of its real meaning;

Also the narration that prophet Muhamed was frightened and considered suicide...He doesnt show that after exiting from Hira cave, Gabriel appeared again and said:Im Gabriel and ur a prophet..again half quotes