heh my dad told me a funny story about how he left his record player playing this record on accedint and he accidently stumbled over this song :) I love secret tracks
Is this the actual, official version as heard on "Broken (EP)" because I notice two odd but of course very subtle things:
4:11 - When the "Suck (Suck)" lyrics/echoes verse is done, you can faintly here Trent start to make an "S" sound like he was going to say "Suck" one more time but realized, "Shit that verse is done." If this was the official version he would of edited that out.
4:20 - From this point until the drums start again, the "Nurr-NURR" is slightly off timing for two measures.
@STVYT Let me just add that I was just pointing those out because I noticed it and I have very sensitive ears. I'm not trying to troll or anything lol...I love Nine Inch Nails! Also, it's confusing because there are several different releases of this song.
@STVYT I'm not saying you're wrong or anything, I totally see what you mean. But I think it was him breathing in. He breathes in after that as well. That's just what I think though :3
@AustinLuck78 everything Trent releases on his own sounds to upbeat and "poppy" it doesnt really fit the song in my opinion. But it has to be for his "style" it cant be too outrageous or "Much Music" wouldnt play it. This version is more "user friendly" and i like the madness of the original.
@ohgr919 I like instruments used in this version better. The other seems way too minimalist imo. On a personal level, I'm sorry I said those things to you.
Actually,you're half right.Trent was involved in the co-writing of the original Pigface version and yes this is his NIN remix.Pigface version released in 1990 on the album "Gub".
@swordofisis for all you know, it could be a reference to the omnipresence of God. Meaning that God does not physically exist as an entity in the sky.. but rather, God exists omnipresently.
@swordofisis if you can just say who "he" is, the question would make a LITTLE more sense. I am not a mindreader... so dont expect me to read your mind on what you meant by your: "but if he felt that way then why did he use that logic to decide it was alright to have sex with a guy?"
Second of all "why did he use that logic to decide it was alright" WHAT LOGIC?!?
You arent explaining the context of your question.
The whole question is based off of thoughts you are having and not explaining.
@swordofisis music doesnt have definite meaning, its about what sounds good. good lyrics are written in such a way where a person can grasp many meanings out of the same song, It doesnt really matter what I think the song means. It could mean something different to me one day than it means to me on a different day. It depends on the context in which you are listening to it. and I cant put myself into your context cause I am not you. with that said...
When Trent was In pigface and he Did vocals with Ogre That shit was epic .. I wonder how many drugs were Consumed when Pigface toured .. Check it out .. pigface-suck. soo awesome ..
@powerline8888 Hey, this was exactly what I thought after listening to their music the first time. I gave it a chance (cuz I kinda liked Trent's voice) and now I barely listen to something else:)
I remember I had the cassette tape of Broken (yes, I'm old) for about a year before I discovered the two hidden tracks. The tape put them all the way on the end of the 2nd side, so you had to fast forward through 10 minutes of silence before they started. One day I was lazy and let the tape run out only to discover one of the best songs Trent ever recorded. (and a decent cover as well).
this version is so much better produced, you can here the vocals so much better, and I personally like the added synth, and its so much heavier in the chorus, brings the song to life compared to the original.
@spawn22222 I'm confused though... Pigface was founded in 1990 and Trent played this in 1989 on the Pretty Hate Machine tour. I guess Trent must have composed it.
@TomMackio That would make sense. That also makes it Trent's song I guess, giving him every right to rerecord it and rerelease it under the NIN name. I suppose you could say that before Trent was definite with NIN, he worked around with other Industrial projects to get a feel for a distinctive sound. Some of those ideas carried over, and hence, Broken came out of it. That's very interesting though, I never before knew that this was performed on the PHMWT, thank you for sharing that.
i had the mini disc to this tune, soooo fucking cool
TheCogre 3 weeks ago
I´m in love wit da bass and 1:13 wow wake-up call .-)
fortheloveoftunes 1 month ago
heh my dad told me a funny story about how he left his record player playing this record on accedint and he accidently stumbled over this song :) I love secret tracks
MrPrimussucks123 1 month ago
This song is Sucky
MartyrLoserKing 1 month ago
@MartyrLoserKing It would have been funny if you said Nine Inch Nails suck.
KedViper 1 month ago
@KedViper -cause that's the title
KedViper 1 month ago
This song Sucks
MartyrLoserKing 1 month ago
I like fucking myself to this.
CaptainPommby 1 month ago
What is this song about?;-)
IzabellaRitaSzendi 2 months ago
very catchy drumbeat and chorus
TyphoonHubert 2 months ago
Such a sexy song
hotziiiaaa 2 months ago
The Pigface version is better.
ivanmarsh 2 months ago
@ivanmarsh Surely you jest.
lovesthebass 1 month ago
The good old self-loathing drug abusing god king called Reznor. Such a shame he stopped abusing drugs.
facepalm486 3 months ago 3
@facepalm486 a shame he stopped abusing drugs? he's gotta be responsible now, what with a fucking son and everything. twat.
yasminleveauparis 2 months ago 3
@yasminleveauparis it's not our fault he made a mistake and spread his semen now is it?
facepalm486 2 months ago
That song makes me thing terrible and dirty thingss!!!
yummm!!!! SUCK!!!
denniatthedisco 3 months ago 2
That akward moment when the second to top comment copied the top comment...
sidneykylebowman1 3 months ago 6
@sidneykylebowman1
*awkward
sidneykylebowman1 3 months ago
@sidneykylebowman1 The awkward moment when you spell 'awkward' wrong.
TheNetworkAces 2 months ago
@TheNetworkAces
I didn't spell 'Awkward' wrong.
sidneykylebowman1 2 months ago
@sidneykylebowman1 You did, you spelled it as 'akward' XD
TheNetworkAces 3 weeks ago
Very Lutheran, this song. Also... the last lines-- for Claude Rains.
BarnabasFrid 3 months ago
i am so dirty on the inside.
yasminleveauparis 3 months ago
@mymusicvidsandrants2 "metal wannabe"? man.. in this case - you suck!!!..D
schmidt969 3 months ago
The Fucks with all the Hate against Treznor? You Probably all Bum Beiber You Teeny Twat Bags
jizzvolcano 3 months ago 6
@mymusicvidsandrants2 dude, if you hate it then why are you listening to it?
LovePeaceAndMusic22 3 months ago
ohhhh shit.
I had forgotten the power of the riff at 2:50.
so simple yet so fkn badass
RobCardIV 4 months ago 2
Fucking Gay people are so anoying X_x.
I dont hate gay people but damn I sure hate the faggot comments X_x.
I dont want to hear about you wanting to suck cawk kid.
RobCardIV 4 months ago 2
@RobCardIV What? I couldn't hear you with that big dick in your mouth. Remove it and repeat that again, please.
dag101101 3 months ago
@dag101101 uncalled for..
AndyTVProductions 3 months ago
@AndyTVProductions You didn't read his comment, did you?
dag101101 3 months ago
*eating popsickle, then this song comes on* O.O ... *slowly puts popsickle down*
demonbuttercupp 4 months ago 9
Comment removed
MegaChase03 4 months ago
@demonbuttercupp LOL XD
MegaChase03 4 months ago
I don't want to do terrible things to him, I just want to sit down and have a beer with him.
Vai789 4 months ago 7
i wanna do good things to nobody
douchpooch111 4 months ago 2
@lovemeordie83 I think we ALL want to do terrible things to him.
torigob00m 4 months ago
heh... How about some funkycore my dear?
HELLYEAH!!!! >8D
schmidt969 5 months ago
This is number 99 on the cd. What a great song!
capone101284 5 months ago
you know trent reznor.... i wanna do terrible things to you too
LovePeaceAndMusic22 5 months ago 10
This has been flagged as spam show
Damn kick ass music!
kmlvr9 5 months ago
Production=badass
YasuKikyo 6 months ago
1 person likes Justin Bieber
MsRadar23 7 months ago
@MsRadar23 nah, somebody was offended by the greatness of this music
Wesley683 6 months ago
Comment removed
wrscalestore 7 months ago
A thousand lips, a thousand toungs, a thousand throats, a thousand lungs, a thousand ways to make it true, i want to do terrible things to you.
zach13NIN 7 months ago 8
can someone tell me what this songs about like the actual meaning of it like Only was about existentialism whats this about??
Zarathustra1919 7 months ago in playlist 9IN
@Zarathustra1919 its about deep throat
hedarfoota 7 months ago
@hedarfoota its literally about deepthroating
Zarathustra1919 7 months ago
@Zarathustra1919 shooting coke and heroin. "runs up my arms till i'm on track, itches the skin right off my back" = heroin use
StickyInADarkBlueCut 6 months ago
@StickyInADarkBlueCut im gonna go with that thanks man
Zarathustra1919 6 months ago
Did trent just hit on me? right at the end, where he whispers in to my left ear. haha
bluckagungo 8 months ago 29
@bluckagungo Hehe :DD
holymelodrama 8 months ago
broken was my first NIN album
25Quarters 9 months ago
Makes me wanna do terrible things to Trent Reznor. ;)
lovemeordie83 9 months ago 36
it's funny this album and t.d.s. are my 2 favs of nin and no one i talk to has even heard of broken....
jakeinthedark420 9 months ago
5:08 - really suck
TheRussia10 11 months ago
This song is missing the killer guitar riff that made the whole song
StickyInADarkBlueCut 11 months ago
Is this the actual, official version as heard on "Broken (EP)" because I notice two odd but of course very subtle things:
4:11 - When the "Suck (Suck)" lyrics/echoes verse is done, you can faintly here Trent start to make an "S" sound like he was going to say "Suck" one more time but realized, "Shit that verse is done." If this was the official version he would of edited that out.
4:20 - From this point until the drums start again, the "Nurr-NURR" is slightly off timing for two measures.
STVYT 11 months ago
@STVYT Let me just add that I was just pointing those out because I noticed it and I have very sensitive ears. I'm not trying to troll or anything lol...I love Nine Inch Nails! Also, it's confusing because there are several different releases of this song.
STVYT 11 months ago
@STVYT what you're saying about the "suck" part, he does that in lots of his songs. I think it adds something a little extra. ^_^
princesssookeh 11 months ago
@STVYT I'm not saying you're wrong or anything, I totally see what you mean. But I think it was him breathing in. He breathes in after that as well. That's just what I think though :3
TheSeventhChaos1 10 months ago
sorry ninies Ogre sings it way better
ReisterJP 1 year ago
He doesn't, and he couldn't have written it.
touchandgod 10 months ago
This song still turns me on. XDD
MirandaWinn 1 year ago
A thousand lips a thousand tongues
A thousand throats a thousand lungs
A thousand ways to make it true
I want to do terrible things to you
SizzleMuffinCeci 1 year ago 4
this song used to turn me on, in fact when he whispers used to tickle my ears lmao! sounds awesome,clear n heavy :) *kudos*
MsSandrix 1 year ago 3
ill heal youre wounds, ill set you free, im Jesus Christ, on ECSTASY
GuruBabadesh 1 year ago
got this song on hammer hard live. gota love the bass man
Apache2420 1 year ago
the original Pigface version is sooooooo much better
ohgr919 1 year ago
@ohgr919 Why do you think it's so much better? I'm not arguing, just asking. I'm done arguing. I just want your opinion.
AustinLuck78 1 year ago
@AustinLuck78 everything Trent releases on his own sounds to upbeat and "poppy" it doesnt really fit the song in my opinion. But it has to be for his "style" it cant be too outrageous or "Much Music" wouldnt play it. This version is more "user friendly" and i like the madness of the original.
ohgr919 1 year ago
@ohgr919 I like instruments used in this version better. The other seems way too minimalist imo. On a personal level, I'm sorry I said those things to you.
AustinLuck78 1 year ago
@waptek And, "I am so dirty, on the inside." Thank you.
ViewWatchGori19 1 year ago
Comment removed
ViewWatchGori19 1 year ago
now over the ex, think i need a neeew gurrl :)
evildnalor 1 year ago 2
Could someone post the lyrics?
ViewWatchGori19 1 year ago
Just thought I'd clear up some of the confusion.
Jam on.
KControlz 1 year ago
Trent Reznor can make even the straightest of men grow a few inches ;)
moosechoppy 1 year ago 8
pigface version is Trent too> you can't fix stupid.
syn4god 1 year ago
Trent's version blew the shit out of Pigface's
86RockandJock 1 year ago
@86RockandJock
The original Pigface version was Trent's.He co-wrote it.
KControlz 1 year ago
I think the version he did for Pigface sucks.
AustinLuck78 1 year ago
@AustinLuck78 actually, this is Trent's remix of the Pigface original. I think.
ViewWatchGori19 1 year ago
@ViewWatchGori19 Remake.
xxxstitchxxx 1 year ago
@ViewWatchGori19
Actually,you're half right.Trent was involved in the co-writing of the original Pigface version and yes this is his NIN remix.Pigface version released in 1990 on the album "Gub".
KControlz 1 year ago
@AustinLuck78
Maybe,but it is the original.Trent co-wrote it & that was some of his earliest work,,,
KControlz 1 year ago
@KControlz That may be his earlier work but I still stand by my opinion.
AustinLuck78 1 year ago
hawkings agrees! "there is no god up in the sky!"
swordofisis 1 year ago
@swordofisis you got it wrong... there is no God up in the sky, TONIGHT. meaning... there is a God, but he isnt up in the sky tonight.
havabighed 1 year ago
@swordofisis for all you know, it could be a reference to the omnipresence of God. Meaning that God does not physically exist as an entity in the sky.. but rather, God exists omnipresently.
havabighed 1 year ago
@havabighed but if he felt that way then why did he use that logic to decide it was alright to have sex with a guy?
swordofisis 1 year ago
@swordofisis you need to rephrase that question cause it doesnt make any logical sense. I dont understand what you are asking.
havabighed 1 year ago
@havabighed no, the question is logical... i think the problem is on your end!
swordofisis 1 year ago
@swordofisis first of all, who is "he"? are you talking about trent? cause... I didnt know trent was bisexual. or... are you talking about God?
havabighed 1 year ago
@havabighed i have a feeling that i am talking to a teenager... just... nevermind! go back to bed kid.
swordofisis 1 year ago
@swordofisis lol, you got angry before I even finished my response. Just goes to show who the real child is.
havabighed 1 year ago
@swordofisis if you can just say who "he" is, the question would make a LITTLE more sense. I am not a mindreader... so dont expect me to read your mind on what you meant by your: "but if he felt that way then why did he use that logic to decide it was alright to have sex with a guy?"
Second of all "why did he use that logic to decide it was alright" WHAT LOGIC?!?
You arent explaining the context of your question.
The whole question is based off of thoughts you are having and not explaining.
havabighed 1 year ago
@havabighed what exactly do you think this song is about anyway?
swordofisis 1 year ago
@swordofisis music doesnt have definite meaning, its about what sounds good. good lyrics are written in such a way where a person can grasp many meanings out of the same song, It doesnt really matter what I think the song means. It could mean something different to me one day than it means to me on a different day. It depends on the context in which you are listening to it. and I cant put myself into your context cause I am not you. with that said...
Its probably about love and fornication.
havabighed 1 year ago 3
Hard to pick a best song from that particular album. It was just tremendously well put together!
AntiSCO 1 year ago
how does it feel? suck suck suck!
damn, trent reznor is god ...
xFrankIero14 1 year ago 2
i wish he added in the suck suck suck from the demo , that would make this song perfect
yagsisiht99 1 year ago
When Trent was In pigface and he Did vocals with Ogre That shit was epic .. I wonder how many drugs were Consumed when Pigface toured .. Check it out .. pigface-suck. soo awesome ..
0xModzx0 1 year ago
idk this band bores me and i have not been able to finsh a song
powerline8888 1 year ago
@powerline8888 What other songs have you tried to listen to?
TheAtomic1234321 1 year ago
@powerline8888 Hey, this was exactly what I thought after listening to their music the first time. I gave it a chance (cuz I kinda liked Trent's voice) and now I barely listen to something else:)
Mertule93 1 year ago 2
"I am Jesus Christ on XTC" such an awesome line.
ViewWatchGori19 1 year ago 3
I remember I had the cassette tape of Broken (yes, I'm old) for about a year before I discovered the two hidden tracks. The tape put them all the way on the end of the 2nd side, so you had to fast forward through 10 minutes of silence before they started. One day I was lazy and let the tape run out only to discover one of the best songs Trent ever recorded. (and a decent cover as well).
Sarc37 1 year ago
second best song on broken-next to wish
streetlight482 1 year ago
I remember the annoyance of skipping on to tracks 98 and 99 on the Broken cd but they were always worth the wait.
korgull73 1 year ago 4
This song is so damn good!
JessicaAntoinetteUK 1 year ago
A thousand lips a thousand tongues
A thousand throats a thousand lungs
A thousand ways to make it true
I wanna do terrible things to you
<3 <3
stfubetchface 1 year ago 5
this version is so much better produced, you can here the vocals so much better, and I personally like the added synth, and its so much heavier in the chorus, brings the song to life compared to the original.
ihateu1979 1 year ago 64
@ihateu1979 What's the other version?
stakleni00 1 year ago
@stakleni00 The other version is the live version which was much later and is rubbish in comparison!
TomMackio 1 year ago
@TomMackio I see. I haven't heard it.
stakleni00 1 year ago
@ihateu1979 huh? I thought this was the original. It was on Halo 5!
TomMackio 1 year ago
@TomMackio Well, this song is a cover of a song by the band Pigface, which featured Trent on vocals actually.
spawn22222 1 year ago
@spawn22222 I'm confused though... Pigface was founded in 1990 and Trent played this in 1989 on the Pretty Hate Machine tour. I guess Trent must have composed it.
TomMackio 1 year ago
@TomMackio That would make sense. That also makes it Trent's song I guess, giving him every right to rerecord it and rerelease it under the NIN name. I suppose you could say that before Trent was definite with NIN, he worked around with other Industrial projects to get a feel for a distinctive sound. Some of those ideas carried over, and hence, Broken came out of it. That's very interesting though, I never before knew that this was performed on the PHMWT, thank you for sharing that.
spawn22222 1 year ago
i wish they put this on the pretty hate machine album
MrEspaillat 2 years ago 4
I like the original better
nonserviamreviews 2 years ago
I agree.
blitzkreig48 2 years ago 2
best song on Broken.
252477514 2 years ago 52
@252477514 "Gave Up" is the best song on the album.
ladylovelipgloss 1 year ago
@ladylovelipgloss i agree, and wish is number 2 to me
SekMekBek 1 year ago
@ladylovelipgloss the video is fuckn awesome
yagsisiht99 1 year ago
Comment removed
AustinLuck78 1 year ago
@252477514 It's good song but Wish is what got me in to nin.
AustinLuck78 1 year ago
@252477514 I concur
nancyjulian606 8 months ago
@252477514 Way too easily... But Trent stepped it up after so it's gravy and beans...
TonyRomoAKARayFinkle 8 months ago
@252477514 worst song by NIN
bukk3t 5 months ago
@bukk3t hey man.. its a sexy tune.. stop being such an opponent of sexy tunes..
schmidt969 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@252477514 worst song by NIN
bukk3t 5 months ago