踢爆容祖兒百老匯 X Sheena Easton Telephone 老翻電視廣告2007

[mmaann778899]

祖兒只係唱歌姐....你要鬧就鬧陳奐仁...

[CARLHILTER]

唉!係度講即係明柴容祖兒粉絲場，POST落討論區仲好=.=

[chinchin1984]

艾辛@@

[JoeyFans616]

1句都叫抄,死87

[iamduckhong]

得一句似咋喎 .. 一句似就叫抄 ? 笑左

[hyt1234567]

joey只係負責唱,唔係作架,要鬧就鬧陳奐仁啦!

[tcyeung1874]

係wo,,好似wo..

咁點解唔去嘈作曲果個既,,

竟然係嘈打工唱歌果個?

[gooegg]

無錯

個廣告既concept係抄外國既,又係嘈個廣告既主角

講真,佢點會有權力去干涉個廣告點拍呀?

[WatchOutYourBack]

the modern arrangement is better. i dont think kids now will like to listen to the old song. should keep the good music i believe there was a classical musician also do that in the past.

[darkniel105]

一首樂曲要有 4 節一模一樣先叫做抄襲 ~

而且如果一句相似就叫抄，咁呢個世界好多歌

都其實互相抄襲喎 ~

你都可以話HoCC 首《明目張膽》抄陳百強首《等》~

[joshiko]

there are 8 bars identical already...

('coz one bar does not equal one sentence)

4 bars for the first sentence and 3 bars for the one follows

so there's 7 bars in a row

[streetkingzz]

hanjin sux! leave HK u copycat!

[choiling003]

u using english now ? are u the one invent english ?

[streetkingzz]

hanjin sux! leave hk u copycat!

[Desireelei]

抄一句就唔係抄呀!?抄就係抄!==

[kenkenchihaha]

係辯論學黎講你 le d 係以偏蓋全.

[ellakou]

甘抄都五系渠竟错者。。可能渠自己都五知呢。。再+埋作曲个个同­作词个个又五系渠。。你系骂就骂创作个个啦。。抄呢d也真系预计­五到嘎吗。。五通渠要只只歌都要check过晒先准出啦喔。。

[louiskit0601]

講真個句真係激似,,

但係其他都唔似..

又好難講係米真係抄...

[cocofucking]

老你係豆a~你a 媽都係老翻lo~

用下腦la ~老翻

leo 個首仲似la~

[shyguyisshy]

They sound similar SOMEWHAT, but I hardly think it's a direct imitation at all.

Of all the songs that are composed already in the world, some are bound to sound similar to people's ears.

[kenkenchihaha]

le個帖都幾呃人 得一句似就話抄 咁陳奕迅既"k歌之王"咪抄王菲ge"約定".

[lilchinky]

of course Joey is better man..... even though this song was originally by Sheena in that boring version.....

[blah8001]

also, i don't get why ppl always blame Joey wen it comes to stuff like this wen she doesn't write the song. wen Leo's 錢錢錢錢 came out everyone knew that he wasn't the one to blame and that Mark Lui was the one to blame, but wen Joey has a song that is similar they blame her...

[blah8001]

i think its just a coincidence, i don't Joey has ever heard this song before. i mean, its an english song from the 80's, and its not even a big classic. also, Joey didn't even write the song herself.

[ITEA0919]

咁又咁講la 如果佢有首歌好成功既話

咁仲會唔會有人話 邊關容祖兒事吖 係首歌作得好姐

而首歌既獎 亦只落於佢手上

大部份既功勞係佢既

某程度上E d可以叫"輸打蠃要"

[blah8001]

yes there is a big difference. wen someone likes a song its not only the melody that makes the song good, its also the performance by the singers. dats why awards are given out to the singers and also the composers. but wen it comes to copying a song's melody, its the composer that should take the blame.

[Hanabi0413]

只是一句似(幾個音), 唔覺係抄

[lomohi]

正係無用腦的盲目Fans才會上頭,

踢爆抄歌好明顯唔係針對Joey小姐,

反而我也很認同她的唱功!

但我們也應正視抄襲的是實.

[lovetwinsjoey]

@lomohi 你都打上她的名字了 還說不是針對誰

[ilovemondy]

跟本就係陳奐仁的事 關joey 咩事呀  joey作架首歌????

用下腦la

[sophielam]

As she said "Mix & Match" got it?

[manyuenwong2006]

N years ago

[fiona886]

天之抄女~華麗A后

[andrew88330]

我唔信你讀書個陣無抄功課 唔該唔好咁多野講

同埋炒歌唔關容小姐事囉

[c1186]

its telefone

[japjapjapjapjap]

ai....too bad!

[CreamMilkSugar]

老抄天后....失禮哂香港人

[alleeckw]

抄人的

[sze0401]

其實次次話佢抄人 都唔係好關佢事ga喎 抄歌 係作曲人問題 抄衫抄mv都係設計師既問題 同佢...好似關係唔大(but i'm not her fans)

[lomohi]

很同意你的說法, 但如果她和她的班底知情的話,

又互相包容的話, 抄襲風氣便遭合理化了。

[sze0401]

我覺得應該話俾人知 佢地好似太似lo喎 但係就唔應該鬧得佢地太西利

[RubyAries0415]

@lomohi 但..如果佢知道的話...

有冇可能佢都無得揀?

[lovetwinsjoey]

@lomohi 一個歌手的責任是唱好一首歌 為甚麼都批評歌手? 他們知不知情你又知道了?? 請你將心比心一下 一兩句旋律相似你是叫人怎麼找出來? 更何況作曲者根本不是容祖兒 如果妳真的覺得踢爆抄歌唔係針對Joey 那為甚麼還在這裡說這種話呢?

[ilovemondy]

冇陳奐仁 咪冇e首歌lo

[ilovemondy]

白痴仔...唔好低b

[lomohi]

你係咪講緊陳奐仁？

[canwong719]

copycats need to be exposed! good work!

[jadegalore]

This is called a cover!

 是翻唱﹐不是老翻﹗

[lomohi]

容祖兒呢隻歌係寫陳奐仁作曲喎！

Sheena Easton 個隻就係1984年推出o架！

擺明中文呢隻係老翻啦！小朋友！