I just want to thank all of you for posting comments on this piece...Your words touch me very deeply, and reading all of them, i simply would like to say artists express and create themselves from different visions as people do. That' s what i did there. One night during which i felt no struggle making the beautiful music score, that it is, be mine for a second. Cause i really meant what came out, and was in harmony with what i was saying.
So many contemporary dance pieces seem to involve a lot of extraneous movement that expresses very little--except the dancer's technique. it's time for some meaningful minimalism in dance. In short, other music could have been playing during this choreography and nothing would have had to be changed in the choreography. Forsythe often changes his music before a premiere and none of the choreography gets changed. I don't get it.
So many contemporary dance pieces seem to involve a lot of extraneous movement that expresses very little--except the dancer's technique. it's time for some meaningful minimalism in dance.
It makes me think deep and reflect. For that I thank you for posting it. For those who knock it, I can only think that you watch too much daytime TV? Or read the Guardian.
I think that people who comment without contextual reference are only exposing their lack of education and limited intellect. Do some research! This piece of music is immensely complex. There is even a wikipedia explanation of the piece. You don't have to look very hard. It is only the ignorant who denigrate that which they do not understand.
To say its not good because it's simple is just awesomely DUMB. It's just so beautiful. If I could write something so beautiful and so simple......I'd be both hugely proud.....and very rich.
thanks for posting, very beautiful and professional, but for me some of the movements are a little too strong an energetic for this kind of minimalistic music ...
Bravo, well said 'warspite0... Just listen and enjoy this sublime piece of beautiful music. So clean and simple yet sparks a million thoughts and memories... Thanks for posting this fabulous tune 'desiderium1', it is awe inspiring... :0)x
I understand shnimmuc's point, however, this not a piece about complex musical thought: it is about piercing simlicity and directness and, as such, succeeds brilliantly. Though myself a professional musician, most untrained ears cannot process, much less appreciate, the complexity of Bach's Fugues, for example.
However, this music can (and does) effectively reach those people AND be appreciated for both it's simplicity and sheer purity of spirit by trained and untrained ears alike...
Beauty is about subtle balances. The music here brings some joy, some contentment, just in the right proportions. The ballet matches the secret elements.
Who ever put that horrible advert on this beautiful piece, which really desecrates the experience, just has no soul or feeling, youre a robot out for commerce.
While I respect Bach's genius and musicality as much as the next music lover, I must humbly disagree with you. I do not believe complexity is what makes it impressive or mediocre. Bach expressed emotion through complex, layered melodies. Minimalism expresses the same emotions, but through a different means: simple, elegance. To state that a composition is "written for dead people" simply because the notes of the song are few and far between, is a statement that I think would even make Bach sigh.
The dancing and music are both fabulous. I tend to agree with Katiesaik in the two not going together. While I agree with Spookysaurus in the tension created by what I might call discord it doesn't create the emotional impact that I might have received from a congruent interpretation of the piece.
As with all things artistic, beauty is in the eye - and ear - of the beholder.
I can't help thinking that katiesaik has missed the point here. This music has such an extraordinary fragility, and it is exactly the more earthbound style of the choreography that provides the necessary visual counterfoil to that. Together, the two create a tension that makes this a moving performance to watch.
The dancing is beautiful, but I don't really think the choreography matches the piece. It's missing a legato and fluidity that could really make it touching to the viewer. It seems to fiery and choppy for this music.
The piece (by Arvo Pärt) is called "Spiegel im Spiegel" or "Mirror in the Mirror".
This is beautiful Natacha, thank you. Both your choreography and dancing are just right for the piece. So many people swamp Pärt's music with excess. You have achieved an intricate simplicity if that's possible.
Wonderful.. It is as though you expressed the undercurrent of sorrow and angst of the music with your interpretation of dance. Brava!
karmakomodia 4 months ago
beautiul beautiful beautifull, in all aspects.. respect to you , thank you for this dance..
smoullinka 5 months ago
Some stuff could have grown but i leave it as it is.
This is Spiegel im Spiegel to me, that night, that place and that moves swinging on the melody.
Thank u so much for the support and sharing!
I appreciate...
Nat
npierart 8 months ago
I just want to thank all of you for posting comments on this piece...Your words touch me very deeply, and reading all of them, i simply would like to say artists express and create themselves from different visions as people do. That' s what i did there. One night during which i felt no struggle making the beautiful music score, that it is, be mine for a second. Cause i really meant what came out, and was in harmony with what i was saying.
npierart 8 months ago
So many contemporary dance pieces seem to involve a lot of extraneous movement that expresses very little--except the dancer's technique. it's time for some meaningful minimalism in dance. In short, other music could have been playing during this choreography and nothing would have had to be changed in the choreography. Forsythe often changes his music before a premiere and none of the choreography gets changed. I don't get it.
ploplisphilin 8 months ago
So many contemporary dance pieces seem to involve a lot of extraneous movement that expresses very little--except the dancer's technique. it's time for some meaningful minimalism in dance.
ploplisphilin 8 months ago
It makes me think deep and reflect. For that I thank you for posting it. For those who knock it, I can only think that you watch too much daytime TV? Or read the Guardian.
willietoyboy 10 months ago
I think that people who comment without contextual reference are only exposing their lack of education and limited intellect. Do some research! This piece of music is immensely complex. There is even a wikipedia explanation of the piece. You don't have to look very hard. It is only the ignorant who denigrate that which they do not understand.
MFAexpert 1 year ago
Great song and great dancing! Thanks for posting!
thewho30rb 1 year ago
To say its not good because it's simple is just awesomely DUMB. It's just so beautiful. If I could write something so beautiful and so simple......I'd be both hugely proud.....and very rich.
symphusion 1 year ago
Beautiful piece of choreography. The dancer has such fluidity in her movement. I loved every minute of it. Beautiful!!
ceshanks 1 year ago
Wonderfull in every melody that softly falls from his fingers x
SuperAlexander1001 1 year ago
thanks for posting, very beautiful and professional, but for me some of the movements are a little too strong an energetic for this kind of minimalistic music ...
metsesell 1 year ago 5
I enjoyed this very much. Thank you!!! Greetings from Rhodes,Greece!!!
anixneyths 2 years ago
a compelling performance
mrmike9959 2 years ago
lots of talk...lots of comments....put it all away...this is beautiful music...
warspite0 2 years ago
Bravo, well said 'warspite0... Just listen and enjoy this sublime piece of beautiful music. So clean and simple yet sparks a million thoughts and memories... Thanks for posting this fabulous tune 'desiderium1', it is awe inspiring... :0)x
wenglishsal 2 years ago
this is very surprising ... but that 's what is nice about it .
violetparme 2 years ago
I understand shnimmuc's point, however, this not a piece about complex musical thought: it is about piercing simlicity and directness and, as such, succeeds brilliantly. Though myself a professional musician, most untrained ears cannot process, much less appreciate, the complexity of Bach's Fugues, for example.
However, this music can (and does) effectively reach those people AND be appreciated for both it's simplicity and sheer purity of spirit by trained and untrained ears alike...
DaveD5929 2 years ago
Nailed it. I am a music lover, but have no musical education (whatsoever).
But I love Part. It really wakes something inside me.
conejoinmutablea 2 years ago
Beauty is about subtle balances. The music here brings some joy, some contentment, just in the right proportions. The ballet matches the secret elements.
Outstanding.
joseignaciolatorre 2 years ago
Who ever put that horrible advert on this beautiful piece, which really desecrates the experience, just has no soul or feeling, youre a robot out for commerce.
Phidian 2 years ago
That horrible advert is indeed killing the experience. I very much wonder about people who make that kind of choices.
That being said, YouTube has a function to the right, at the bottom of the vid, so you can switch it off.
I know that hardly prevents the ad from starting, but at least you can watch the rest of the vid without it.
moveste 2 years ago
amazing.....
rachelsouza 2 years ago
Its touching...you can feel a lot of sensations and emotions like sadness and love at same time with this piece
bapermo 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is not spectacularly written. Compare it , you simpletons to the Bach`s Art Of The Fugue-- this is music for dead people.
shnimmuc 2 years ago
While I respect Bach's genius and musicality as much as the next music lover, I must humbly disagree with you. I do not believe complexity is what makes it impressive or mediocre. Bach expressed emotion through complex, layered melodies. Minimalism expresses the same emotions, but through a different means: simple, elegance. To state that a composition is "written for dead people" simply because the notes of the song are few and far between, is a statement that I think would even make Bach sigh.
DancingPancake 2 years ago 12
I doubt anyone could have said this any better. thank you.
johnhreid2 2 years ago
@DancingPancake comment from England - - -Goodness !!
werenutz 1 year ago
@DancingPancake Totally agree :) whatever the style of music it can still be just as brilliant.
Except 'organised sound' and 'musique concrete'. They are pish... :P
dougaljn 1 year ago
thats the special thing on arvo pärts music
...the simplicity !!!
he could write more difficult pieces if he would want to, but difficulty is not what makes music great...
dadaanii 2 years ago
Hail shnimmuc! You surely must be the most musical person on the planet.
I'm convinced that as a result you like just one piece of music from a 1000 year old classical history.
Only the best for you!
I am sure you are an inspiration to many.
PS, you obviously fail to get the purified brittleness in Pärt's composing, its ENORMOUS reference frame and its deep humanity.
That's OK, really, but it should just mean that you're a trifle more modest, and less aggressive towards people who do get it.
moveste 2 years ago
Not only is the music haunting, and spectacularly written... but the dance is awesome too...
Darramondo 2 years ago
Beautiful and amazing.
Thank you.
atticaally 3 years ago
Very interesting work!
browndanceproject 3 years ago
does anybody know any other music like this?? i really like it =]
orangelemonsaresour 3 years ago
Philip Glass's violin concerto is beautiful as well.
miriamnz 3 years ago
Arvo Pärt Für Alina - and the CD by Arvo Pärt : Alina
AVATAR0103 3 years ago
That is such a moving song it touches the soul.
stretch4859 3 years ago
Spiegel im Spiegel as the title says :) Arvo Pärt
liesanc 3 years ago
Don´t know why the choreographer decided to set such a fast pace for the dancer... music is so peaceful...
jorgeazamora73 3 years ago
I think that it makes such a great contrast, and that's why they did it...
johnhreid2 3 years ago
Merci pour cette si belle année Mina : ) A tres bientot ^^
carluccia2b 3 years ago
Tout simplement Magnifique ..
( L `
emmawatson483 3 years ago
I think only one word can describe both the dance, and the piece of music.... "wow"
Darramondo 3 years ago
Timless, endless joy, uplifting the spirit enhancing the soul.
banjgoboy24 3 years ago
So priveliged to see such beauty and hear heavan, tasting my tears of joy, sadness, happiness. complete, thanks for the vison, thanks.
banjgoboy24 3 years ago
beautiful
AriellePetruzzella 3 years ago
Siegel im Mirror...
Mirror in Espejo ...
Espejo en Espelho ...
Espelho em Mirroir...
Mirroir en Ispilu ...
amigodaonca 3 years ago
The dancing and music are both fabulous. I tend to agree with Katiesaik in the two not going together. While I agree with Spookysaurus in the tension created by what I might call discord it doesn't create the emotional impact that I might have received from a congruent interpretation of the piece.
As with all things artistic, beauty is in the eye - and ear - of the beholder.
seniorjc 3 years ago
I can't help thinking that katiesaik has missed the point here. This music has such an extraordinary fragility, and it is exactly the more earthbound style of the choreography that provides the necessary visual counterfoil to that. Together, the two create a tension that makes this a moving performance to watch.
spookysaurus 3 years ago
the music was used in van Sant's Gerry, correct? mesmerizing :)
blissery 3 years ago
The dancing is beautiful, but I don't really think the choreography matches the piece. It's missing a legato and fluidity that could really make it touching to the viewer. It seems to fiery and choppy for this music.
katiesaik 4 years ago
Amazing
jujuzinhex 4 years ago
Beautiful music and dancing.
SOSTuk 4 years ago
Beautiful.
michaeljholme 4 years ago
Thank you for this beautiful piece. You are
such a good dancer. I'd love to see more of your work. Can I suggest you come to Greece for one of our many international dance platforms?
marillenna 4 years ago
The piece (by Arvo Pärt) is called "Spiegel im Spiegel" or "Mirror in the Mirror".
This is beautiful Natacha, thank you. Both your choreography and dancing are just right for the piece. So many people swamp Pärt's music with excess. You have achieved an intricate simplicity if that's possible.
Omnilingual 4 years ago
What is the name of that song?
CRincon8491 4 years ago
Susan.
I love you.
Tommy.x.
TOMMCFERRAN 4 years ago
Beautiful!
Tarka42 4 years ago
so melancholic...
is it a Mats Ek choregaphy?
mercator92 4 years ago
no it s not Mats Ek choreography
it s from me..
desiderium1 4 years ago