Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,016)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Sti is better build overall!!!

  • The slowest cars bet the STI!?....lmfao.....these guys shouldn't be allowed to review anything but interior decorating.

  • its not all about the cars its also about the driver and the style the driver has i saw vw and audi all the wayy :)

  • besides the all wheel drive there is nothing u can compare the vw to witht the evo and sti

  • a LOT of sti lovers crying!!!!!! so sad.... I love my cars (VWs)..... you should do the same and dont wait for someone else to tell your car is good

  • STI ALL THE WAYYY

  • 3:27 :D

  • Ok this wrong. my 04 STI is better than my friends 09 lancer evo. he even wishes he got the sti for less and way more fun. and i get boost at 3000 when i gun it

  • The guy that did this is a FAG!

  • @dmcmahan121 he is a F.A.G......a Fucking Awesome Guy!

  • stupid guy how you going to say the sti is bad when it comes to turning when the sti is basically made for being able to turn and take corners and etc? And i say STI any day !!

  • @lostkid111 stupid guy? hahah i cant believe how stupid you are!

    You have nothing to back up your statement, and you call him stupid?

    Atleast the people in this experiment actually have data and actual personal experience.

  • I love them all but the evo and the sti is too cliche. Every little white kid wants it even if he can't handle the damn car. Ill take the Volkswagen!

    ....well the 2004 volkswagen r32 is much more attractive

  • I don't know about anyone else but I hated this review...

  • I want one of each, please. But, since I can't afford them right now, I'll stick with my MK5 GTI.

  • i'll take the evo anyday

  • camaro ftw!

  • But, since most people are idiots, the subaru wins... Both great cars, but , I'd take the subaru over the lancer any day.

  • @bencinurts It's easier to mod, and it's more respected in the class...

    

  • @cloudstrife1188 Thats true theres so much nice cars in europe and japane, garmany that US dont have!

    All the limits and their stuff!

    Love that evo fq 400 :)

  • how come STI same engine for the passed like 8 year??? No big changes... like 04 model has 300hp and its almost 2012 and its still only 305hp.. ??? =/

  • @ludah22 There is a huge reason for that. Back when the cars were made. Mitsu and subaru made a pact not to make their cars super amazing. Im serious. only in europe they can make evo fq 400s

  • Don't ever buy a used WRX or evo, as they're run hard by the same twats who are arguing on here about aspiration and turbos and what not.

  • @ponyboy6666 so buy the new ssc

  • oh and btw it's .:R for life...

  • you guys are fucking stupid.... the r32 doesn't even have a turbo and does 0-60 5.4 seconds. add a turbo and its 3.5 seconds to 60mph. @skyline750 btw the r32 would destroy them in a lap race... doesn't have to be a straight line drag race idiot.

  • @Joegtibmp08 the R32 has 6 cylinders while the jap cars have 4. and i doubt adding a turbo will make its 0-60 1.9 secs faster... and what makes you say that a r32 would "destroy" them in a lap race? just curious

  • @Joegtibmp08 no

  • IMO the R32/Golf R is a total waste. I own a GTI and I love it...but I was going to spend 10k more, I'd get an actual sports car, not a VW that is trying to be too many things at once.

  • @HariVIyer Because for 10k more you still arent going to get a more refined, luxurious, and rare yet classless car.

  • why would you put the R32? its not even competition compared to those Rally Mosters!

  • Put a turbo in the R32 and there u have the best car.. The R32 in better looking inside and outside, its just slower but like i said, just put a turbo and it'll go to 400 hp and leave the evo full of dust...

  • they all are good cars. I always had subaru's and I love them. I had 02 wrx 04 sti 08 impreza non turbo and my pride and joy 2011 sti. Handles like a dream man i'll tell you that much. I would go with an sti bro. Thats just me. Also it depends what you like and what you can afford. STI's have really good engines and bullet proof tranies. Also keep in mind that evo's are still dominating STI's in handling wise.

  • I just got my 2011 sti pearl white

  • @Mel007ize should i get an s2000 2002 an evo 2005 or an sti 2006????? wich would be more reliable and good all around?

  • Wait. The GTI beat a STI? Expect Suby to come back angry next match-up.

  • "at first glance the vw r32 looks like an over glorified gti or a bargain audi tt."

    "and its no surprise its the slowers car of the trio."

    Just admit is biscuit lovers... your VW;'s just keep getting shittier and shittier. bwahahaha

  • Subaru is sick but leave in the rally section, the evo is for cheap queers who have to beat someone in a race(you turn a bolt and you gain 50 horsepower), r32 sounds the sickest, awd is a plus, looks the sickest even though mark 4 looks the best.

  • this is total bullshit they got both times wrong for the wrx and evo.... wrx is way faster than the evo which is proven in all other comparison tests

  • well this video is no good now since the GSR is 7 grand more expensive than the STi in Canada. as well as not even as nice to drive. I like how he didn't mention that the STi can split traction side to side like the evo.

  • JAPAN POWA FUCKING REDNECKS

  • id take the evo over all of them

  • Scoobies can hang on my nut sack. I beat new and old sti's all day in my evo 8!

  • Those numbers are way messed, i own a r32 and love it, but 5.4 to 60...not a chance. Even with the dsg and launch control, you could maybe get 5.8 if youre lucky. Also their prices are wrong, back in 2008 i couldnt find a decently spec'd evo for less than 39000$, similarly spec'd sti's were around 37000$ and the golf was around 33000$, so this comparison=eff'd in the a

  • fucking bullshit. its been know to man that a stock sti would fuck a stock evo in the ass

  • love all 3 of these cars but i personally think the R32 is the sexiest =) still would do bad bad things for any of them..

  • EVO all day.

  • Track=Evo

    Fun=STi

    Vdublove=2004 R32 because the new models look like shit

  • @squirlybmx so true man

    

  • VW R32 all the way!!!

  • STi > everything

  • STI power

  • I like STI's a lot, but it seems to me that EVERYONE has one... Kinda played in my opinion (I know as if anyone asked for my opinion...) After a year of debating and saving $, I think I've finally decided to go with the Evo... More unique and from what I hear better overall... Im not writing this to get anyone riled up for any reason... and YES I know they each have their perks... just Evos seem to have more.

  • all the dislikes are for putting the r32 in second. What a POS. For the money I would just get a honda.

  • R32 should be 3rd!

  • COOL. That's why I bought an EVO.....yeeeaaaahhhh

  • y not put in a decent interior into the Evo, if ur already paying 30k+.

  • Jeremy Clarkson compared the STI Hatch to a crushed buttock .. :P ... He liked the look of the EVO X ...

  • i like the vw but i knew the best car here was mitsu

  • wait a min

    my buddy said an evo beat him in his amg 600 benz now i see why

    AWD

    0-60 in 4.6 seconds for under $30k...amazing

    im still waiting for the new gen 300+hp GTI though

  • @DoomCity202 not gonna happen the newest and most powerful will be a 265hp 2.0t fsi .:R20 coming this winter

  • they should wait till the new gen awd Gti with 300+ hp comes out in 2012

  • This just shows how completely stupid this website is. R32 is ugly, handles horrible, slower than the normal WRX. automatic 3rd. Evo, also handles bad, put that car on a windy hill with the STi and it'd roll right off. Although the Evo is fast, that car is a total piece of shit. It's 4k cheaper bc that's how all the cash your going to have to spend to fix while you own it. The STi handles the best and is the fastest of the three cars so go run your obviously bias tests again. Horrible vid.

  • Id take the VW any day.

  • if you want a shitty interior ugly piece of mitsubishi trash buy the evo! STi 3rd place my ass.

  • I'll still take the Subaru. =)

  • I dont know why but i hate the new subi...

  • @AlexSZ241 it would be so much better if it wasnt hatchback it kind of ruins the look , but thats just me

  • thats good cause the evo is my favorite and even jeremy clarkson from top gear liked it better that the subaru

  • @dude12345274 jermey clarkson like the edm jdm only version that has more hp in it its almost more expensive.

  • @GarrettKeetley

    that's nice. Oh hey, u have a little german on the side of ur lip. Might wanna wipe that off.

  • the R32 is betterin all ways to the Sti Quality makes the sti look american made where VW shows their heritage for making a superior car all around

  • @123tokey dude, the R32 is worse in every way, from 0-60 to quartermile, to handling, to everything, not too mention it is ugly. and its way overpriced.

  • @FadedRX8 if u actually have owned one which i do u knw the difference between german quality and Japanese plastics ive driven the evo its great for track use but for everyday driving the r32 is superb and besides i own a c63 im not lacking power

  • @FadedRX8 you have no clue what you're talking about.

  • @AndreasFalk8 Thankyou for commenting that!

  • @FadedRX8 Alright your an idiot.. Firstly the R32 is the BESY sounding car out of all of them.. People with a R32 have a good taste in cars and don't need to look like wogs to show that..

  • @FadedRX8 and quality and reliability are crap

  • @FadedRX8 Better than your Prius

  • Comment removed

  • @FadedRX8 You have no taste in cars.

  • Both Top Gear and CARandDriver agree, the GSR is the better car. Mitsubishi really went all out with this one, considering it's also a 4 door family car.

  • EVO X ....anyday!!

  • they say the subaru is bad in the coners and the lancer tries to go around the pilon and skided out of control when the subaru went through with ease.

  • @YamahaKodiak915 you're blind lol.. he did that spin on purpose to show how precisely the car turns to the steering response from the driver

  • The best one is the R32. those ricers look like shit. Fuckin ugly plastic jap pieces of shit. Oh and listen to that sweet exoust sound.

  • german cars are for ladies.......jap cars are for DRIVERS....usa cars are for rubish..thats the truth i am sorry

  • @Defectordrunkzone why are japanese cars limited to 180 kph? like the gt-r..

  • @TheNothar From what i understand is IN japan, they are actually all limited to like 112 MPH or sumthin along those lines, which is where you get your 180 kph (111.8 mph). This is due i believe to the fact that the police cars there are not capable of keeping up with anything faster than that, and rather spend money to get faster cars for the police, they just limit everyone else.

  • STi dissapointing in the corners? What planet are you on? Maybe you need a little more practice chucking it into the corners??!!

  • evo ftw

  • Ya but honda f1 win races and I don't feel like using periods learn how to read it's not hard to know when a sentence starts and one ends and it's not like I'm writing a novel

  • im sorry but wut the fuck is a vw doing in this video??

  • @fudogchomp idk...but def looking and sounding better than the other two thats for sure.

  • how in hell did they rule the R32 over the Sti? thats bogus

  • @mikethebeast1012 have you ever seen Honda race f1 they know how to make fast cars and don't forget an evo and sti are 4 bangers just like a Honda I've seen hondas eat corvettes ya u gotta put money into the engine all they need to do is make a good awd car and slap a turbo on a civic si motor and what do u get a car that can run with an evo and sti cuz they evo motor is nothing but a beefed up version on the eclipse motor well the evo 9 was I'm not sure about the evo x Honda could make a car

  • @doubble80 please use periods.

  • @doubble80 renault also makes F1 cars. that doesn't mean they're fast

  • I've had 6 bikes and 11 cars, so what the fuck do u know?

  • mike...sure, right, i it was 96 when i had the corrado

  • evo is alot better butt they chose the shit one , the 9 would have raped

  • i have a question i know alot about my cars...

    but which is the best EVO X to buy... i mean theres a fair few.. i just want something that would put other cars to shame on wet roads.... the MR seems like a fine choice... its got the new dual clutch gearbox and can have launch control... please help me out here...

  • @Istoderescu1 Where do you live? Come and steal an EVO X here they're just too many of them its ridiculous

  • I like all three cars.

  • I love all these cars but the sti is my choice and I wish Honda would start beefing up their cars cuz they would shit all over the competition

  • @doubble80 honda would get destroyed if they tried to enter this segment lol. hondas are reliable and that is all

  • @doubble80 should i get an s2000 2002 an evo 2005 or an sti 2006????? wich would be more reliable and good all around?

  • Evo all the way

  • HAHA this video is a joke. maybe they use a driver who knows how to drive a car cuz obviously the subaru is better at every angle

  • Just gotta say between the subaru and mitsubishi, I looked very thoroughly over the internet and found a bunch of people replacing the transmission on,the evo's after about 25,000miles or for even giving the engine more power, the wrx can handle having 500hp and the STI 600hp, both with the stock engines and transmissions. The subaru's are really reliable and long lasting as well

  • evo fuckkkkkkkkkkkkkkk!!!!! i gara bay this cafr

  • Golf R32 can go 280 more........ Km/h :)

  • EVO RULEZZZZZ..

  • EVO IS THE BEST

  • Japan rules as always.

  • Co za idiota wymyślił porównanie VW do rajdówek

  • @BmathFromGab automatic is boring

  • he said "Sweet engine" vw ftw

  • VW R32 is just superb

  • i hate vw

  • good video, you should all visit Germany and enjoy the Autobahn with no speed limits

  • VW has never been my kind of car that i would like. To me, it looks ugly. Lancer to me is the best :)

  • @BmathFromGab i test drove the sti and the r32, and the r32 wasn't as fast, but there was just something more elegant and refined about it. plus everyone has an sti.... so i bought a mk4 r32 and i love it. most pencil pushers who buy STIs cant even drive anyway. so they usually lost when it comes to racing.

  • @eric62backstrom Im from Northern Ontario. Your R32 would be useless here. The Subaru's dominate up here in real weather conditions. And I mean everything from 3 feet of snow, loose gravel, mudd, black ice, and tarmac all in 2 km of road.

    The R32 to me is something a secretary would get. Sorry it just isn't functional enough for us up here.

  • @MastodonDR Yeah, well i'm from New Hampshire, and we get a lot of fucking snow, and have a lot of dirt roads. Drive down here to Plymouth Stave University and ill have you towing your car home on a flat bed, boy. U think just because you have a little bit more power and acceleration that I have a bitch car? haha I'm a mechanic and a stereo installer. And I run world class snow tires. Suck it. Save your opinion for someone who has a real bitch car.

  • @eric62backstrom I never said it was a bitch car. Its a secretaries car. I said this because two of my secretaries have one. lol...

    you need to calm down. I run a $600 dollar used pair of snow tires...but more horsepower and better acceleration would make your car somewhat bitchy if we were in a race wouldnt it?

  • VW's are nice cars to drive when they actually work. My mate has had 2 golfs and both of them have had something stuff up. First one snapped the clutch cable, second one had an electronic problem where it had some light flash on the dash and limited the power or something like that. Im not saying they are bad cars, i like VW's, and are very nice to drive...... But i have a Subaru Legacy with 310,0000km's on the clock, and it still runs like new and never had a problem.. Need i say anymore.

  • subaru all the way

  • Comment removed

  • @burtonium1 Yeah, because i'm sure a Legacy has NEVER needed rear axles, lol. You cant make a remark like that based on a comparison of 2 single vehicles. I have beat the SHIT out of my r32 for three years on a daily basis and have never done anything besides replace 2 coils. AND it has over 120k miles on it. lets see your legacy keep up.

  • @eric62backstrom MKIV .:R FTW!

  • compare it to an rs, o that's right, americans don't have the good focus :P

  • @BmathFromGab couldn't say better!

  • r32 is a joke compared to STi and EVO. Road & track is a great magazine

  • @wrxsti2k4 - Go drive an R32 and go figure.

  • caranddriver?

    more like carandretard

  • caranddriver?

    more like carnadretard

  • The Subaru only has a lot of turbo lag for this video testing because in the first 1000 miles of its life from off the lot the computer chip inside is trying make the turbo fit your driving style. trust me i own a subaru and thats what the guy at the dealership told me. plus i felt the turbo lag everytime id try to get up and go for the first 1000 miles but after that, the turbo is very punchy. the subaru is 0-60 in 4.6 sec! look on any website. screw you car and driver..

  • i dont understand why the vw is in it the subaru and the evo are rally cars that fight to each other for years and they put a rich kid vw in it??

  • @camiel221 Yeah. You never see ANY rich kids driving STis and Evos!

  • @mister929rr if that was sercasim then ur wrong.

    evo and stis are mostly droven by older people vw is a typical car that rich kid people get for there 16 or 18 birthday not an evo or sti

  • this vid just makes me 100% sure that car and driver just blow shit out their asses

    that list backwards... nothing against the cars. their all great but the subaru is by far the best

  • @R31oH new subarus blow up quick, a buddy of mine blew up his on 22 pounds getting it tuned, am still thinking how much did mitsubishi payd this guy to make this adverstsiment lol

  • @illestk24civic New ones only blow up if dumb ass drivers flog them before running them in properly, like my mate who just got a new Mitsi, he's already running it over 5000rpm half the time and it's done under 300km's!

  • @Matty231 you could be right, ppl dont wait to break inn the motor and are already reving it t odeath lol

  • @illestk24civic Yea lol too excited and forget to not over rev. When they take it in to get serviced first the guy says, well the motors pretty much f**ked now!! :P

  • @Matty231 ahahahaha thats funny my mate blew up his subaru from the botton end craked the sleeves it fucked everything up hardcore

  • @Matty231 I believe mitsu breaks in the motor on the evos ( and I think sub. on the STIs) on a machine, so that when you get them, you are able to do this if you choose to. Though i wouldn't suggest it haha.

  • @lollerskates115 Oh serious? Thats alright but i'd probably rather get the car with the engine still like new new not with 1000km or 10 hours of time on it....

  • @R31oH says a scuby fanboy xD Subarus have gone from ugly to uglier n the next year scuby is gonna be tagged ugliest

    then they have the understeering issue which hasnt been solved yet.... like Jeremy said... the evo can literally run circles around it

  • @R31oH Really... so like they are the only ones who have reviewed the STI and Evo and say the evo is the better of the two... O wait.... Just because you have an STI doesn't make it the best car.

  • impreza el mejor sin dudas!!!!

  • @elnegromoreno89 el evo siempre le ha ganado al impreza y siempre le ganará

  • I want an EVO! @_@

  • @BmathFromGab yep . its lil bit slower than sti and evo but its much better in everything else

  • if i was american i think i'd kill myself

  • Comment removed

  • @ear12861 The fug are you talking about?

  • @ear12861 your exaggeration of VW problems is very comical, however if a VW (any car for that matter) is properly maintained it will last forever, ive had 2 VWs with no major problems nothing more than some minor electrical stuff. compared to the EVO and STI the R32 is nowhere close performance wise but in terms of quality it blows both away

  • R32 all the way :)

  • @BmathFromGab my friend has a stg 1 mk5 4 door 6 speed black..... i wouldnt mind driving it over my stg2 legacy

  • @BmathFromGab very well said. how could anyone hate the inventors of the Bugatti.

  • SUBARU IS #1....

  • I still want a EVO

  • Just to prove a point about VW's, fun to drive if u have the money to fix them... Shit the 1st 4 cars were VWs (69 Bug, 90 G60 Corrado, 87 GLI, and 88 Cabrio). I also had 6 bikes. I just got sold my SRT-4 and that was a lot of fun. I never had a problem with it. That car was one of the best rides i've ever owned. I would buy another in a sec! I've had 2 Mec's (c230 coupe and 4door), which the 4dr start have TCU and Tranny bushing problems. I have a 2011 WRX limited and I Love it!

  • @espyerudition You definitely will need money to fix those 20+ year old VW cars you mentioned.

  • @espyerudition if you had a modern VW your opinion might be worth something but since you owned old ones it not worth shit, any old car will have problems. also srt4s are garbage, fast? sure but they are still a shitty neon

  • My neibour bought an R34 sold it the next month for an evo sold it the next two weeks and got the STI he said he would never buy another car.

  • I'll buy a WRX and get 90% of the performance for 70% of the price.... and if I want to get back the 10% performance... I can use the $8500 I saved and smoke all 3 cars listed above, seven ways on sunday.

  • Comment removed

  • I'm confused about the Evo's drag speed. I've come across different 0-60 & 1/4 mile runs. Which is the best: the MR or GSR, Evo VIII, IX, or X? Whats the difference between all the models? Help me understand!!!

  • I'd go R32 Golf any day over the other 2

  • Have to agree with their conclusion, but i still like the R32 the most. Can't believe they said the subaru is good looking though, it's fucking hideous...

  • notice the r32 isnt turboed and a turboed on beats all of them