Added: 5 years ago
From: Xevanescencechick1X
Views: 240,415
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (358)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Where can I download the song since I can't find it in their discography...?

  • @thevicksta88 try a diferent discography,wiki says it is on b-side of lithium...if you can get a japanese version of the album evanescence there it should be as well.

  • master piece...

  • how come she doesnt sing this live?

  • @snoweatsbabies Because it wasn't on an album and people usually perform songs on albums live, though she does sing unreleased songs sometimes, like Understanding, I also think the meaning of the song is personal to her so I doubt she'd enjoy being asked who it's about or why :D

  • I used to love Amy Lee but she's really a studio only singer.

  • Amy lee is the most amazin female singer ever her voice is beautiful

  • this is why wars are fought and WON

  • im almost done with all of this day this day

  • It sounds like it's about a ex boyfriend and Amy and Ben never dated, she was dating the lead singer of Seether at the time.

  • is their a live version of this song, i don't think there is but i don't know for sure

  • @Thehighschool8888 I don't believe so. I don't even think this song was legally released. But I could be wrong.

  • @TheOpenDoor1990 I Know it was an outtake on Fallen, so maybe not. Never seen a live version, only covers. :))

  • @Thehighschool8888 Its the greatest song on earth, thers no live version I search all the time! I heard this is a secret track on the open door. Its a song about Ben........

  • @laydeeJ1 i love this song too and I wish they would have a live version :(( And you can tell its about Ben. Amy was too good for him I Guess.

  • @laydeeJ1 It was released at a bonus song if you bought the CD online when it first came out.

  • im in love :P

  • i love you !!!! 

  • really really beautiful. amy lee is amazing! i love her! <3

  • i thought Id heard literally every unreleased track every ep album before they were big, and i am sad to say i never heard this song, its amazing.

  • i love you

  • que viva la alcapurria

  • jusst .. tragic and beautiful

  • she has such a beautiful voice

  • Give up my way, and I could be anything

    I'll make my own way

    Without your senseless hate...

  • i LOVE this song :)

  • master of the slow-moody ballad

    no one does it better

  • I love her so much, I want to cry when I see her.

  • amy lee , i loove you........ <3

  • reminds me of my ex-boyfriend, I did alot of things wrong in the relationship, but he did many many worst things, he is so pretty in his pain!

  • wow.........im blown away......the lyrics are just.....wow...

    this is my first time hearing this song. What Cd is this from???

  • it's from The Open Door, but it's a bonus track.

  • oh i see.

    thx for the info ;]]

  • WTF! all i wanted to do was listen to this song (my FAVORITE!) and it won't load!

    uuugghhhh! this sux =(

  • woah, such a sad powerfull song its simply amazing - i love amy

  • poor ben!

    i luv ben!!!

    but i luv amy too!!!

    ^^

  • LOVE AMY FOREVER!!!!!!!!!!!! <33

  • i love you Amy lee

  • this song has so much meaning to me an always puts atear in mine eyes,

    its truely an amazin song..

  • if There were enough words 2 say what I FELT ABOUT this song..... THANK U AMY my ex took my son... no say that I didnt mess up but it has been 6 years and he sends all my letters back return 2 sender, he is a jerk, 2 think he was my 1st true love, thank u 4 writing this song!!!!

  • hey

    check out my cover for evanescence' last song im wasting on you

    feel free to comment

    thanks

  • great videeoo !!-...... weellll i also almost cry when i heard it for first time....but noww i hear it at night and makes me think about many thingsss....she's awesomee....can't wait for her next album !

  • Wow..this is sad...

    I almost cryed when i first

    listened to the Lyric..!!!!

    Amy Lee is a Legend..

    Just the Best <3

  • @Luffhoney You're right, Amy Lee is a legend.

  • this is one of my favorite songs by evanescence..

  • The new band 'We Are The Fallen' has almost every member of Evanescence in it except Amy Lee. The new lead singer is Carly Smithson. It appears that they are trying to move on without Amy. In my opinion, nobody can replace her. She has new stuff coming out next year. Can't wait!!!

  • I mite get thumbs down for this but with song and these clips it seems that she died... This song is pretty strong for a soft song...

  • i love her at 1:22-26 (think lol) its beautiful

  • ♥ this song.

  • that song is strong...

  • awhh this videoo is wickedd good with the songg good job :]

  • I love this song <3 It's so powerful and strong..

  • so amazing

  • I found my way out , you'll never hurt me again...

  • Am I the only one who's obseced with her hair since I saw her?! xD

  • No, no you're not. :]

  • no way! looool

  • @VampiricSnowWhite no youre no, i love her hair too!

  • this album demo origin first cd the  band

  • Who did Amy get married to?

  • His name is Josh Hartzler, apparently he's a long-time friend, he's a therapist. She said in some interview that the songs "Good Enough" and "Bring Me To Life" were inspired by him :)

  • Amy ... Cool Girl i' love her Voice !! Great Song !!

  • Awesome video! Please check mine out too --- it features the same song!

  • bei dem Lied...kann man die tränen nicht zurück halten....wunderschöne stimme....tragischer Text...erinnert mich an das was mal gewesen ist...

  • This song should have been a single instead of Good Enough.

  • there songs are so good and she is really pretty:]

  • album fallen, the open door???

    What album is this from?

  • well it was made while the open door was being made, but it wasnt on the open door, just like missing wasnt on the fallen album

  • It's on the Lithium single

  • Ooh! They have a single! XD

  • very good video!

    which concert is the first live video from?

  • good video, but sebnem ferah forever

  • esta canción es simplemente muy triste ptm me hara cortarme las venas pero esta ves si en serio

  • If you Like Fallen you Would Love ORIGIN it in my Opinion Was Their Best Ever

  • wow thats amzing wish i could sing like that lol

  • love Evan, is my fav

  • Amy's voice is amazing, and Evanescence is amazing!!

    ♥

  • wow, amy is just .... the best ....the band rocks too, broken is my fav

  • I now officially have a new favorite song from her.

  • the video looks a little bit like , if there were no evanescence any more

  • i luv this song.!!

  • This song is amazing, so good

  • love her voice and all her songs!!!

  • I love this whole song I cry every time I hear it.

  • hmm...you never told me who you were, except that I had to guess my way through, all I know is that I had nothing to do with that, if SHE is the one I'm thinking about, when we were kids.

    I'm not saying this to be mean or anything...

  • no, you are saying that to be mean so don't even try that ok.

  • I hope that's not directed to me, cause I honestly meant what I said O.o

  • yes i am so.....................

  • this song is very beautiful. i actually listened to the words this time. on all her other songs i never listened to the words

  • Honestly, when I first heard this song I started to cry unknowingly. Amy is my favorite female singer, both herself and her voice is so beautiful.

    Even though I'm in love with the whole song, my favorite parts are 1:28 - 1:47 & 2:30 - 3:00. Amazing how she can sing so high and clearly.

  • where are they @ 2:03 and 1:10??.....but....good job with the video=]

  • She is the best!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • love this song, pure art!

  • The best "good bye" song I've ever heard.

    It's perfect!!!

  • i REALLY love this song cuz its so unique...it doesnt have a chorus n stuff...just straight words...kinda like a poem type of song...its beautiful!

  • yeah its like letter or her thoughts :)

  • awesome

  • elle é sur un album cette chanson ou pa ?

  • Cette chanson est sur The Open Door,mais elle n'est pas sur tous les albums ou CDs. C'est une chanson secret.

  • C'est une "Bonus Track"

  • Oui

  • ***.***

  • hey hey hey worriesovernothing didnt do anything. shes sort of right. I didnt mean for it to sound like i know him, i was just saying.

  • yeah um worriesovernothing, how about you shut up because obviously YOU dont know what your talking about

  • you call him a jerk as if you know him. dont speak just cause you've probably heard a few negative things. you have no idea.

  • ben moody is a jerk. I mean dont get me wrong he and amy lee were a great pair music writing wise but friendship wise he was a jerk.

  • where can i get this song??

    i cant fnd it on itunes at all.

    why not??

  • it's unreleased so it's not on iTunes, it's on the demo album Origin, you can fid that on ebay. I was soooo disapointed when I couldn't find all there stuff.

  • thanks a bunch XD

    and yea, that kinda sucks

  • It isn't on Origin. It was a bonus track on a selected bunch on the open door cds.

  • Its not on the Origin...

    This is a new song, and It came as a bonus of the open door if you buy it on the web...

  • nice fading etc, think i personally would have cut a few of the clips maybe the lower quality ones, the moshy bits are just too energetic for the song- a little slow mo effect tho could be sweeet. beautiful song hope you don't mind a little constructive criticism :)

  • 2:27-2:30

    *-*

  • is this song about sean morgan? im not a amy lee expert, but i think "call me when your sober" was too. anyways, beautiful song and voice.

  • i believe so - of course there are so many rumors out there and only Amy Lee knows the truth but if the rumors are correct then this song is about Sean, as is 'Call me when you're sober' and its about her still loving him even though he was abusive and didn't really love her :(

    if you ask me anyone who has the chance of being with Amy Lee should not take it for granted - she is a very special, unique person and deserves the best!

  • *Sniffle* I wish I could be with Amy Lee. She's amazing and I luff her with all meh heart! <3

  • i dont remember..i never read nothing talking about some "Sean" .. who is it??

  • This song is about ben moody

  • i think that is about shaun morgan

  • It was confirmed by someone closed Amy it is about Ben, but whatever...

    (this song was written in 2004 when Amy was with Shaun, it wouldn't make sense if it was about him)

  • omg her voice is like an angel she is the best

  • Is this song about a woman being physically abused? that's the perception i get from the lyrics...am i right? beautiful song...love her voice.

  • yup its about her being her abused but she still loves him

  • yes, it is. it is well known that ben moody, old leader of Evanescence, phisically abused Amy Lee. this song is about him.

  • nice voice shes got

  • Uhm. First off, learn how to type English.

    Second off, the song isn't about you.

    That aside, I love this song.

  • lmao i agree

  • huh? tht dosent make sense

  • No...they're not over

    Don't worry

    Awesome video =]

  • What?! No more Amy Lee?! D:

  • i love this song sooo much it is so beautiful i cried xx

  • wow, it really seems like she dies or something,

    and this is a memorial video..

    but i still love this song, and the vid is put together very well

    very good job =)

  • it does!! it makes me sad just watching it :(

    btw evanescence isn't over - they're just taking a 2 year break cus Amy Lee got married and 2 members got fired :(

  • Loved her at Family V. Tour 08

    =]

  • does this band still exist? i hope so... )= love em!

  • Clearly they do. :)

  • I love this song, but every time i cry :'(

  • its sad, there's no more Evanescence:::

    the best songs.

    the best voice.

    °_o

  • evanescence still exist!! =)

  • wha...what???

    there's.....there's no more evanescence????

    *cries endlessly*

  • where´d u hear that?

    its totally false

  • And they're still not? No matter what singer they get, NW compositions still surpasses Evanescence, Within Poptation and Epica music all together BY MILES :S

  • She is the dark queen... beauty.

  • she is a queen

  • this song is beautiful

    i almost cried

  • this is beautiful

  • really a beautiful video.. and the song.. is amazing.. <3

    amy lee is great

  • i know this song is kinda like "what you wnt this to play at your funeral" but...its so beautiful ^^ and i really want this song to play at my funeral

  • i love the video!!

    and i LOVE amy lee lol

    and this song is perfect

    good job!

    this is amazing

  • "So run, run, run

    And hate me if it feels good,

    I can't hear your screams anymore"

    Wow, they're fucking AMAZING!!!

    EVANESCENCE RULLZ <3

  • it was a pre-order/download bonus track on the open door. it's easier to download it (i'm not just talking limewire, people, don't flame me.) it's a beautiful song though.. one of my favorites...

  • just record straight off sound card as u watch it here, works for me ;) fk limewire full of nasty trojans

  • HERMOSAA

  • Hey Guys you can get it at Limewire or Utorrent;D just go at homesite and download its Free and remember Utorren has no Virus Stuff ;D Evanescence For Ever<33

  • its not on the album.

    its on the single "Lithium"

  • If this is on the Open Door CD how come i dont have the song? the CD i bought didn't have the bonus track on it.

  • What CD is this on? Its a bonus track right?

  • It's in the "Lithium" cd single.

  • Yay! Thank you!

  • on what cd can i find this?

  • its impossible to listen to this song adn not just gain more respect for amy. its beautiful, she shows how much she has grown as a woman/artist. the way she has put aside all the abuse and pain and is finding her own light...its really beautiful.

  • i really wish i could get this song on iTunes

  • you can get it if you buy the cd...i think ._.

  • yeah, cause it`s the bonus track..

  • well yeah but some stores and itunes might not have it....i just dont wanna be wrong is all...

  • iTunes doesn`t have it.. lol

  • amy lee is the best!you only can say bad thigs for her becouse you are so jaleous on her!so FUCK THE HATERS!!!;)

  • besides the piano what else does amy lee play? she is a great singer with a beautiful voice.

  • She plays the guitar as well.

  • really that's so cool.

  • She plays the guitar and is learning the harp :)

  • that's cool.

  • the harp!?! thats badass dude lol

  • Will you all just shut up?!?!?!?!

    Pointless arguement does not solve anything!!!

    Is up to the "fans" to search what the hell ever they want!!!its their lives not yours!!!

    I suggest you guys just shut up and agree with each other that Amy is a great singer.....one of the best in the world

  • &hearts;

    i love this song...

    i love amy