I consider this is the best of the best Jacky's songs. This song particularly shows the beautiful voice of Jacky - a wide range of keys (from low A to high A), a clear sound at the lowest pitch and the power at the high pitches.
@freethinkermike Actually this song is from low G to high G, and yes it is a wide range. And of course this is definitely one of the very best Jacky's songs. I can't say which one is the best coz all of them are just too good.
@tmtstudio1983 Thanks for your correction. Anyway, it is an exceptionally wide-range song. I feel puzzled why someone says "歌神的聲綫......比以住低了很多" or other negative comments which are not the facts. Jacky always sing in the same key for this song.
@freethinkermike I think it is a human habit to say that, because Jacky's voice actually is DEEPER/RICHER than in the past, not LOWER, I have a friend who is a non-singer use "lower" to describe deeper voices like Jacky and Elvis Presley. And normally people would say a song has wide range when they hear some really high notes, e.g. the song 死了都要愛 that goes from D3 to D5 actually has the SAME RANGE as this song G2 - G4, 2 octaves. And not many singers can sing the word 癌 in such a rich tone.
@tmtstudio1983 Perhaps your interpretation of their words may be correct. But their words still contradict among themselves: one says "歌神的聲綫......比以住低了很多" while another says "他現在的聲音比較尖銳 比較薄".
And even if one's voice becomes deeper, it does not mean it becomes worse or better.
I love Jacky, he has an awesome voice. It´s a pity that i do not speak mandarin neither cantonese, so i can´t understand what his songs are about. But even so, i can still the emotion on his songs, because he´s again, such a good singer !!
那8個dislike的人腦袋有問題!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
KD3HO 1 week ago
唱著唱著...我哭了..
Rubit116 3 weeks ago
This 2003 version is always the best.
kelvinngui 2 months ago 2
你永远是我的偶像
Wei6693 3 months ago
K歌必点
kangqin 5 months ago
Live version is more awesome than pre-recorded. only can be done by Jacky Cheung
calvinfoo 8 months ago 3
另一屈機之作
VIPVICT 8 months ago 7
KTV 都點不到這首歌
s0915279175 9 months ago in playlist 音樂
@s0915279175 中壢星光大道唱得到
junstye1 2 months ago
沒錯,學友是最好的﹗
hungsiufung 10 months ago 3
i like it
cindy638329 11 months ago
唱功一流~
这个造型还真帅~
deliachong88 1 year ago 9
第一句已經唱進心坎裡了~~
好想哭
果然是"歌神"
fans87662000 1 year ago 7
2003 Live version is the best!!
fx3650 1 year ago
想出歌
wakoginza 1 year ago
死啦....已經聽到喊...
gn01777712 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
cy1995om 1 year ago
Very powerful at the ending!!
pshidden 1 year ago 15
我覺得我找不到比這更好聽的歌了.......太棒了.....!!
ichiro013 1 year ago 13
唔好話我好煩, 當年學友既歌真係可以tum我瞓架
pammok 1 year ago 2
歌神唱得太好了.....
funnybunny9396 1 year ago 12
This has been flagged as spam show
學友唱得超好聽
funnybunny9396 1 year ago
可能係全亞州最top 最重量級ge 歌手......King of cantopop!!!!!!!!
CarlChongKC 1 year ago 28
@CarlChongKC 佢大碟銷量只係比mj少,係全球第2
sunnyvip2001 1 year ago 8
Amazing voice. He is my favorite male singer.
alvin3535 1 year ago 8
I consider this is the best of the best Jacky's songs. This song particularly shows the beautiful voice of Jacky - a wide range of keys (from low A to high A), a clear sound at the lowest pitch and the power at the high pitches.
freethinkermike 2 years ago
@freethinkermike Actually this song is from low G to high G, and yes it is a wide range. And of course this is definitely one of the very best Jacky's songs. I can't say which one is the best coz all of them are just too good.
tmtstudio1983 1 year ago
@tmtstudio1983 Thanks for your correction. Anyway, it is an exceptionally wide-range song. I feel puzzled why someone says "歌神的聲綫......比以住低了很多" or other negative comments which are not the facts. Jacky always sing in the same key for this song.
freethinkermike 1 year ago
@freethinkermike I think it is a human habit to say that, because Jacky's voice actually is DEEPER/RICHER than in the past, not LOWER, I have a friend who is a non-singer use "lower" to describe deeper voices like Jacky and Elvis Presley. And normally people would say a song has wide range when they hear some really high notes, e.g. the song 死了都要愛 that goes from D3 to D5 actually has the SAME RANGE as this song G2 - G4, 2 octaves. And not many singers can sing the word 癌 in such a rich tone.
tmtstudio1983 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@tmtstudio1983 Perhaps your interpretation of their words may be correct. But their words still contradict among themselves: one says "歌神的聲綫......比以住低了很多" while another says "他現在的聲音比較尖銳 比較薄".
And even if one's voice becomes deeper, it does not mean it becomes worse or better.
freethinkermike 1 year ago
很感動,感動得哭了
wanchaksum 2 years ago 8
i simply love it!!!!!
VIPVICT 2 years ago
I love Jacky, he has an awesome voice. It´s a pity that i do not speak mandarin neither cantonese, so i can´t understand what his songs are about. But even so, i can still the emotion on his songs, because he´s again, such a good singer !!
thanks for uploading.
flyingvigil 2 years ago 5
Absolutely sad and absolutely lovely song, well written, like a story! Like a drama!
So well sung.
So sad.
I'd go nuts if my other half passed away.
MingGuoLi 2 years ago 4
lol awesome
MrJohnny1214 2 years ago
Comment removed
LuckyVLikeyU 2 years ago
jacky is the BEST !!!!
funnybunny9396 2 years ago 39
thanks for your support !
TKC0109 2 years ago
@TKC0109 are you Jacky?!?!?!:P
galpinj00 1 year ago
whatsoever, he is my best idol, he is the best
liandsakurarox915 2 years ago 3
jacky is the best !!!
funnybunny9396 2 years ago 3
I like this song
ABC57774 2 years ago 2
歌神的聲綫已開始不復當年勇, 比以住低了很多, 請好好保護美好的聲綫.
talktosummer 2 years ago
應該說 他現在的聲音比較尖銳 比較薄
沒有當年的渾厚宏亮
tea550 2 years ago
I actually like his voice like that more, so sexy. lol
d0ubled0uble 2 years ago 2
人家已經就黎五十也
Bryanluk2007 2 years ago
FYI, he was sick when he held this concert.
greeklander 2 years ago
我則認會低音致感性 , 比較溫柔。
現在這個版本不像年輕時那麼高昂、那麼激烈的愛 , 而是在這情人死了許多年後 , 午夜起來 , 回想起那個她時 , 那種長久而溫柔的愛。
qoopc777 2 years ago 13
可能也关年龄和经历的原因~
lovetvxqsj9330 2 years ago
thisis is the best version of this song as i reckon
VIPVICT 2 years ago 2
only jacky!!!:'(
so touching.his boice touches my heart deeply.
i really like him.
kaidiot 2 years ago 4
hmm..full of meaning..
asegorgon 2 years ago
Thanks For Uploading...
Wong 2 years ago
不愧是歌神,这么难唱的歌竟然游刃有余!佩服!
ImStupidEric 2 years ago 4
This is one of his song that's easier to sing... Many more I personally don't even want to attempt...
defencerulez 2 years ago 2
actually i dont think this song is hard. He has a lot other song that are killer if you try to sing it.
kggoh 2 years ago
i cant stop crying
lht002004 2 years ago
It is a sad but beautiful song!
edy043 2 years ago
Comment removed
vivaschan123 2 years ago
Jacky songs is very nice
curiank 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
king of asia!!!!!
至于陳奕迅...哈哈.....连HK都出吾到,点可以同king of asia 比较....
bnssapp 2 years ago
出到囉唔該
YAKI888 2 years ago
这歌听一次伤感一次!!也只有学友能唱出这种感觉了~!!!
qqyinsu9you 3 years ago 124
sad...
just sad
doonnneeee 3 years ago 4
遙遠的她(忘詞版)
xarm0844052 3 years ago
does any1 know wich concert this is ? i mean what year??
MikeC024 3 years ago
02-03 (in info)
jchou181 3 years ago
2003
0525mandy 3 years ago
very very nice!!
kwokbbb 3 years ago
Good song but sad story.
kenshin5883 3 years ago
I luv dis song already n it's my first listening 2 it
jy12000 3 years ago
陳奕迅更系唔得拉.
v3ijian 3 years ago 9
The combination of Jacky's voice + the awesome lyrics makes this song a classic.
pkl2k 3 years ago 3
這首歌有多難唱 問陳奕迅就知道 要唱的那麼好 簡直是神的技藝阿
guccihao 3 years ago 10
這首歌只有學友唱得最好 想模仿都模仿不來
guccihao 3 years ago 11
the lyric is a masterpiece
yanchunfu 3 years ago 6
jacky is a great singer!!
bdoll168 3 years ago 7
Brilliant
zedstranded 3 years ago 7
LOVE IT!
linglauan 3 years ago 6
勁到爆啊
GARRYFUNGHK 4 years ago 141
very gd!!!!
holyrainz 4 years ago 8