ARE you kidding? your condutor might be the greatest ever!! he gave you and the rest of the orchestra two different tempo!!!! i dont care if your 11 you suck ass! go listen to yo yo ma cause rig!ht know your going to sound just like him
the notes are out of tune and for excellent style of baroque music, tune down a semitone. Also the speed is very slow, it must be faster and livelier. It sounds as though everyones asleep...
We are playing the International Music Co edition. They use the natural minor scale instead of the melodic minor so there is e-flat and f natural not e and f sharp in the 2nd measure.
Great job regardless of the age. The piece was near flawless. Perfect the theory first then add the passion. It is like trying to drive the fastest you can around a race course without first learning how to handle the car in the curves. Ignore the detractors, since they are most likely less skilled than you and are just simply envious.
Or in most cases (and indeed this one) I know what I'm talking about and want to maybe pass on some advice and my feedback to the performance. You are very cynical.
blindsolution, why do you feel such a strong need to belittle children? Jealosy perhaps? What are your credentials to state "I know what I'm talking about" . Are you a musician?
I'm not "belittling" and yes I am a musician. I'm a 16 yr old specialist cellist at one of 4 government music schools in England. I'm playing this concerto in a festival in London in Autumn, i was simply giving my opinion to this performance, it wasn't down to the fact that he was a "child".
not only are the soloists completely lifeless, unmusical, heavy and dull, the orchestra is out of tune and sounds as if everyone would rather be somewhere else...
yah the orchestra is very bad but i happen to be the soloist for the cello 1 part + you dont need to be full of life and movement to sound good its just a waste of energy
Well maybe if it did indeed sound good then it wouldn't be a problem. A waste of energy?!? You look bored! It shows no emotion at all which then makes the audience feel no emotion at all.
How the hell do they know where to put there fingers???? There all going everywhere without even looking once???
Guybobful 5 months ago
@Guybobful It becomes second nature after awhile
asinzum 1 month ago
@FiddlerAdam yes yes im sorry i got a little mad there, i was younger i completely agree with you now
pallopunters 8 months ago
The violinists suck! The cellos are AMAZING! :) Cello power! :)
ClydeHorse48 1 year ago
@ClydeHorse48 fuck yeah!!!
dragzz1 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
THEY ARE ALL ASIAN
Grundalizer 1 year ago
For this age group, this was well done!
JMOON0923 1 year ago
for 11 and 13. you guys are pretty good. although the accompany orchestra went out of tempo for a while. or vice versa? too lazy to go back.
jutjut417 2 years ago
@jutjut417 it was the orchestra
pallopunters 1 year ago
ARE you kidding? your condutor might be the greatest ever!! he gave you and the rest of the orchestra two different tempo!!!! i dont care if your 11 you suck ass! go listen to yo yo ma cause rig!ht know your going to sound just like him
bag12 2 years ago
Tsk... Sadly enough, your conductor was a failure for choosing you for the soloist, Ryan. Joyce is better than you.
StrikeFreedomKira33 2 years ago
Be more constructive in you comments. Give musical suggestions, not personal attacks on the players.
areyoumymother44 2 years ago
But see, I know Ryan. Personally.
StrikeFreedomKira33 2 years ago
@StrikeFreedomKira33 yah cause i beet u in this concerto competition
pallopunters 1 year ago
@pallopunters
Beating and being better are completely different.
StrikeFreedomKira33 1 year ago
@StrikeFreedomKira33 than why do you care?
pallopunters 1 year ago
Comment removed
rachem1243 2 years ago
harsh
orphan567 2 years ago
the notes are out of tune and for excellent style of baroque music, tune down a semitone. Also the speed is very slow, it must be faster and livelier. It sounds as though everyones asleep...
Montyleeny14 2 years ago 2
Where to get the Sheet Notes for this? I would really appriticiate it
redunder656 2 years ago
bad notes at the beggining. 1st cello have fis1, not f1...
kurczakfb 2 years ago
We are playing the International Music Co edition. They use the natural minor scale instead of the melodic minor so there is e-flat and f natural not e and f sharp in the 2nd measure.
pallopunters 2 years ago
but it sounds wrong xD
kurczakfb is right i think^^
StanEvalio 1 year ago
Great job regardless of the age. The piece was near flawless. Perfect the theory first then add the passion. It is like trying to drive the fastest you can around a race course without first learning how to handle the car in the curves. Ignore the detractors, since they are most likely less skilled than you and are just simply envious.
oszy13 2 years ago
Or in most cases (and indeed this one) I know what I'm talking about and want to maybe pass on some advice and my feedback to the performance. You are very cynical.
BlindSolution 2 years ago
ok, sorry who r u anyway
pallopunters 2 years ago
blindsolution, why do you feel such a strong need to belittle children? Jealosy perhaps? What are your credentials to state "I know what I'm talking about" . Are you a musician?
areyoumymother44 2 years ago
I'm not "belittling" and yes I am a musician. I'm a 16 yr old specialist cellist at one of 4 government music schools in England. I'm playing this concerto in a festival in London in Autumn, i was simply giving my opinion to this performance, it wasn't down to the fact that he was a "child".
BlindSolution 2 years ago
what r u playing?
pallopunters 2 years ago
i thought he put he was a cellist
bluemoon6656 2 years ago
Better then other videos! And they are just kids! Great!
silentstorm32 2 years ago
Great for being 11.
flyocat 2 years ago
Extraordinary youth orchestra! Bravo!
dnumst 2 years ago
....or not
BlindSolution 2 years ago
what do you mean??
pallopunters 2 years ago
not only are the soloists completely lifeless, unmusical, heavy and dull, the orchestra is out of tune and sounds as if everyone would rather be somewhere else...
BlindSolution 2 years ago
yah the orchestra is very bad but i happen to be the soloist for the cello 1 part + you dont need to be full of life and movement to sound good its just a waste of energy
pallopunters 2 years ago
Well maybe if it did indeed sound good then it wouldn't be a problem. A waste of energy?!? You look bored! It shows no emotion at all which then makes the audience feel no emotion at all.
BlindSolution 2 years ago
i was only 11 in that video, one of the youngest in the entirre orchestra
pallopunters 2 years ago