Added: 3 years ago
From: llunatiq
Views: 42,933
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (28)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • BRAVI!!!saluti

  • drama drama

  • in effeti questa esecuzione è eccellente, anche se le donne in giacca e cravatta nera mi danno l'idea di lesbiche

  • Who is this buffone of a tenor ??? Those 'so call' stage directors are destroying opera, with this shits of productions, extremelly untalented garbage

  • @delosreyesgavikanes

    The staging looks really great in a live performance. Very different from the visual you see here.

  • Quite good singing and wonderful acting from her, but he is not believable, too much violence.

    However this is my 3rd favourite traviata, after Callas (in the past) and Gheorghiu (I have the DVD and it's the first I saw so I am used to it).

  • I find the staging odd...not sure I get it. But it's a great interpretation either way.

  • Carlo Rizzi one of the best conductors in nowadays' opera circuit.

    Chiaramente in Italia non si sente. E a Roma ci tocca Gelmetti.

  • He wouldn't be that violent with everyone watching, it's not believable. Possibly if they were alone but still I don't see Violetta just lying there having money shoved in her mouth without putting up some kind of resistance.

  • Me encanta la pareja que hacen Villazón y Netrebko, transmiten los sentimientos por medio de sus privilegiadas voces. Hacen de esta ópera una delicia. Son la máximo!!!!!

  • C'est la première mise en scène ou je vois Alfredo faire bouffer ses biffetons à Violetta, rien que ça ! Mais bon ils ont quand même une sacré présence, sans parler de l'interprétation.

  • E' irritante. Per quanto mi sforzi di appuntare una critica ai limiti tecnici di entrambi, non posso fare a meno di pensare che questa sia la migliore Traviata di sempre. E Villazon non è Di Stefano, e la Netrebko non è la Callas.

  • @Vendimi3 Per me è praticamente lo stesso!!!!! Questa è la mia terza Traviata preferita in generale. (Mamma mia quanta violenza però Villazòn!).

  • Me gusta los interpretes, su interpretación, pero la puesta en escena... no me gusta nada.

  • Dios cuanto dramatismo me encanto es mejor que la Traviata de Gheorghiu, me encanta la Netrebko.

  • Comment removed

  • Excelente, Excelente, Excelente

  • Alfredo's treatment of Violetta is unnecessarily brutal.

    It was humiliating enough just to throw money on her.

  • Yeah, it wasn't very subtle. But these days, I guess audiences aren't as sharp.

  • Subtlety isn't the goal. Alfredo is taking out all his anger and sadness out on Violetta....I don't think he would make it very slight.

  • Muy buena actuación pero no encontré las encenas 9,10 e 11 del segundo acto.

  • i saw so many traviata on the stage, on movies, and i was looking for a staging tht would express all the potential of this scene...simply wonderful, and true at once, the performance is really great thank you so so much ...is there a Dvd of this traviata in salzbourg ? anyway thanks to lunatic for uploading all these scenes

  • oh my god, that was haunting (o_O)

  • I actually really like the staging in this scene. Weird...

  • oh thank you sooooo much! I was looking for this scene, and it's excellent! can you please, pleeeeeeaaaase upload the death scene? la escena de la muerte? thank you!

  • de lo mejor que he visto; las voces, la actuación GRACIAS!!!

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more