Added: 4 years ago
From: Chenzo55
Views: 344,639
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (515)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Who had the brilliant idea of filming this with a potatoe?

  • 1:44 "Well, that was coo... HOLY FREAKIN SANTA CLAUS POOP!!!!!

  • DT made a huge mistake choosing Mangini over Minneman. ADTOE could have sounded better with him behind the kit ;)

  • @irwin3036able Check out the Aristocrats band (Marco, Guthrie and Beller). The best instrumental rock trio of all time.

  • marco's a drum god, shame the youtube quality video

  • yeah different but what song (s)do you play this stuff in that people want to hear or dance too ?

  • animal

  • There must be some trigger he pulled in his head to be that free and concentrated playing like he does.

  • The drummer twin of Paul Gilbert!

  • Oh fucking hell.. he is.. THE JACKHAMMER!

  • You have to be deaf and blind if you wanna compare this guy to Joey Jordison. Just because they're both playing fast notes it is not the same.

  • I cannot understand how Portnoy would beat him.............Really?...That­s stupid

  • the drumset must be MINE!

  • Any bad comments play this yourself or go f## off with negative comments this guy plays drums no comparing he is talented

  • Marco minnemann's tribute to buddy rich

  • Joy Jordison???? Wtf is this mtrfckr?. Come on, we talking about another level of drumming here. Jordison is a good drummer but, that compares of this, his a baby playing rockband.

  • awful sound quality

    

  • Why don't everybody understand that all the Joey Jordison and Lars Ulrich comments are just trolls?

  • @tohsmir

    because they want to make themselves feel better by talking about something that they know some 11 year old on youtube will agree with them about. it's unfortunate.

  • @tohsmir They aint the worse...This guy Cobus is getting a stupid push because of his shit covers (A DW contract?) Marco had to struggle more for it, as a lot of legend (Vinny Appice was dumped by DW cause Dio died :/ )..And everything because of his idiotic fans trolling on pro drummers videos...Trolls are powerful trying to mismatch the world :/

  • Marco drummer monster

  • so am I supposed to be impressed?

  • 35 ppl were looking for polo

  • ugh 240p

  • lol sound like you guys are fucking 5 years old jesus

    

  • @DTROXX Joey is better in his way, (not justin bieber) Same as Donati, chambers, mike adler or who ever. so if ur into heavy metal, u will like Joey. If ur into jazz, funk or something else, u will like these kinda ppl. So dont abuse any Drummer!

  • who ever voted this down has some serious things to work out with there phsychiatrist

  • Geez...why everybody hating on Joey Jordisson...Its totally different styles , you cant compare drummers like Marco , Virgil , Mike mangini , steve smith and other best drummers of the world to Joey....Joey has a band and his own thing going...these guys just...they fuck their drums at night

  • looks like he's trying so hard and usually when you try so hard you're not playing it right, well... perfect, wich is what drummers should aim to; perfection even if its the simplest rudiment or whatever

  • Virgil donati still the best.

  • @cocoazedodoinferno virgil looked like he was going to rape someone - he even had the pedo lisp going on

  • @oldcrappymcweaksauce but, still the best =P

  • @oldcrappymcweaksauce

    Dude I fucking love his crazy look.

  • still doesnt even touch virgil donati

  • Does he remind anybody of an astronaut at the end ?

  • Wow it really gets old when people diss Joey Jordison. He's a great drummer and he's good at the style he's known for. Again, he's a great drummer but nowhere's near as good as Marco.

  • what's disappointing about Marco Minnemann is that he's so technically advanced, his groove skils will always be questioned. The best way to anwser if a drummer is grooving or not is the reaction of the crowd and if those who go and see him are dancing or grooving well then, I guess he can groove.

  • All I hear are paradiddle diddles over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over. I teach middle school drummers who can sit and go RLRRLL all day long across the drum set. This guy is incredibly boring to watch and listen to. Also, speed doesn't necessarily make a drummer good...technique and soul play a much larger role than speed.

  • @ProgDrummerQ

    Man, just STFU. Who the fuck gives a flying shit about your opinion?

  • @nyedale Obviously you do. You took the time to reply. Also, maybe you should take the time to come up with intelligent sentences. You make yourself look like an ass when you just plaster obscenities.

  • @ProgDrummerQ Hey guess what he plays music which makes him happy. So I suggest you do the same and play the music that makes you happy.

  • @ProgDrummerQ Wait a minute,this Marco MInnemann,I think you are confusing him with Joey Jordison or someone else

  • @ProgDrummerQ You should check the vid "Marco Minnemann - Drums Addict Festival 2006" and then your opinion, I can almost promise you, will be completely changed. Remember that if you play drums with joy - and Marco clearly does (just look at the guy, or watch his DT audition lol) - you definitely have soul and passion, and not to mention his INSANE groove/technical feel. Also, check his tribute to Buddy Rich (yes I am a jazz drummer, I would mention that haha) Give him another chance. (:

  • I didn't say he was without talent, I said he was sloppy. How do I know that? Well.... I've been a musician/ drummer for 45 years and I've seen and done it all. You want to learn something listen to Chick Webb circa 1920's - 30's, Look him up, listen to him read about him....

  • Sloppy drumming really sloppy....

  • very good, but sounds like Terry Bozzio...

  • Joey Jordison clicked the Dislike Button 33 times...

  • DT announced it's not Minneman, but they still haven't announce who it is...

  • @mjohnson801 I hope so it is Simon Phillips!

  • @123TheBaron456 Phillips is a great drummer...I don't think he's a good fit musically though.

  • THERES NO FUCKIN WAY HE CAN REPLACE MIKE..TRY WITH JARZOMBEK..

    HES FUCKIN KEWL !

  • Marco would be an incredible addition to DT. MP has left the band stale and uninspired.

  • @above90decibels Stale an uninspired? What freakin' planet have you been on? Clearly not Earth.

  • @ejsanch That last pathetic piece of crap they called an album was pure MP drivel, with him whining on background vocals, and a poor attempt to finish what started as a wonderful idea with The Mirror, and ended with crap,. I live on earth, and I love the work MP has done up through Octavarium, but this last album, I honestly can't even remember the name, was stale, uninspired and WAY TOO MUCH MP. I'm glad he's gone and look forward to whomever replaces him; it's been a long time coming.

  • @above90decibels

    Wow. I wish there were more people with your opinion. Most DT fans seem to be ignorant and unconditional... anyway, I agree with everything you said.

  • Marco Minnemann for Dream Theater

  • @jodrum95 HELL YEAH!!!

  • i guarantee that half of the views on this come from people who heard marco was being considered a replacement for portnoy and have never heard of him before... and are beaking marco just cause he isnt portnoy, ive been a marco for years and he is def one of the worlds greatest thats not just my opinion its a fact

  • @WigglyFilly

    I first checked him out when he played with Necrophagist and when I looked at his solo stuff I was blown away.

  • Seeing Portnoy fans whining was annoying... but its kinda funny now that I get used to it, they bitch, moan, and complain even if they never heard the new DT material. I'm a MP fan myself, but I admit that there are better drummers out there, and I'm really looking forward to the next album, DT needed a change, they sounded a bit to straight in the recent albums.

  • Man. If he HAS joined DT, he will have a massive amount of material to learn :O

  • i have see him to all of that without doulbe bass!

  • WOW I think he could actually give Mike a run for his money. Cant wait for the new album <3

  • youtube.com/watch?v=WxuYIiGqXW­k

  • This guy is dream theaters new drummer.

  • VERY IMPRESSIVE! beast! independence, speed, creative. And now maybe in the best band in the world, DREAM THEATER.

  • amazing drumkit. what's on the left pedal? is it a second snare? and what's that huge tom on the left?

  • Uhm portnoy is amazing but he was not a master of odd time signatures like marco. I totally agree with DT. Even though MP will be missed, i am looking forward to the future of the new dream theatre. 5/5

  • hes replacing portnoy, definitely doesnt deserve to

  • I hateee him!!!

  • This bro is hunked out 5/5

  • sounds like he IS the replacement for MP

  • I see why they wouldn't let mike back, but alas, its dream theater, that's MIKES band.

  • Mike who?

  • He's really a machine. Anyway, I personally don't like his style neither his sound. It's too much "chaos theory", sounds like a drum fill in loop to me. I'm missing a nice groove in his playing. Hope he has not joined Dream Theater, a rumors say...

  • He played a show with Rudess tonight at 8pm, so I think he very well might replace Mike, only time will tell. I wouldn't be upset with this choice though, guy's skilled as fuck.

  • who does this guy think he is buddy rich???!!!?!?! Marco rocks, hoping he will replace Portnoy...

  • This guy is far from a minnemann ha ha (sorry just found that funny)

  • OH MY GOD

  • Minnemann > Portnoy

  • whoa i have that shirt marco's wearing XD

  • did he play with necrophagist?

  • @jonathanbenaroche he filled in until romain goulon stood up to the plate (i forgot the former drummers name sry).

  • I can play this with 1 hand and one foot.

  • @NisseEricsson don't lie, only with the nose

  • impressive but not my kind of soloing. I prefer to hear more of a groove style like harrison or greb.

  • he's quick and cordinated no doubt! but no groove! nothing really singing there!

  • He's as good as Portnoy, probably better. But you can't REPLACE Portnoy. Especially Marco... Marco has a way different attitude, and being a member in a band isn't just about playing ability.

  • JESUS FU KING CHRIST!

    That's right, if you film jesus actually fucking Christ and then view the video, all a sudden there's Marco Minnemann playing drums on your screen.

  • This is so irregular. most of the drum show outs sound all the same.

  • isnt that just a PDP kit with a DW head on it??

  • @DrumCoalitionWithWar

    Nope. Real DW.

  • MARCO FOR DREAM THEATER!!!!!!

  • he could replace Mike Portnoy...

  • @hellskitchen123 EXACTLY

  • why should he replaced? im glad that there are so many talented musicians out there in the world. and we can enjoy them! @hellskitchen123

  • @TheLausi Mike left DT that's why he needs to be replaced

  • @hellskitchen123 Technically he could replace anyone. this guy can do anything.

  • He could replace most drummers. lol

  • @hellskitchen123 he could replace god

  • @hellskitchen123  REPLACE PORTNOY?!?!?

  • @skater8999 didn't you hear the news then? ...

  • @skater8999 hes better than portnoy hands down

  • @Krank0514 he is a more skilled drummer than MP... i wont argue that..

    but nobody... nobody can replace Mike...

  • @hellskitchen123 and he surpass him lol

  • @hellskitchen123. I think that he would make a good choice to replace Portnoy in DT, because he seems to play a smilar way to MP. But if I were being honest no one can take MP's place @ DT's drum stool. To me Portnoy is DT and forever shall be no matter what he dose in the mean time.

  • @hellskitchen123 not could, shoud!

  • @hellskitchen123 if i can believe the latest rumors, I might be right actually...

  • Looks like he will!

  • @hellskitchen123 actually he replaced Portnoy :-)

  • @RobZamboni I know :-D it's not official yet, but most likely it will!

  • @hellskitchen123 and he did!yeahhhhh

  • @hellskitchen123 supposedly HE IS replacing portnoy

  • @hellskitchen123 Hahaha.. He did..

  • @hellskitchen123 He did.

  • @hellskitchen123 he should portnoy sucks

  • @VegaWgn no you suck. MP is godly, so stfu asshole

  • @VegaWgn haha yea ok man hes awesome for playin the same shit all the time

  • @hellskitchen123 no one can reeplace portnoy, he was the best :/

  • @Dragonforce6709 WAS <-

  • @sxestrid and still is! just cos you leave a band dont make your drummin skills deterierate

  • @hellskitchen123

    he could replace Mike Portnoy,Terry Bozzio,Joey Loldison and Jesus Christ.

  • @hellskitchen123

    He replaced Mike Portnoy

    He is new DT drummer :D

  • @LarsMetallica79 No its just a rumor.

  • @DTxOctavariumx

    It's a rumor, but we're all pretty sure that it's true. I read an article in a magazine which I don't remember the name, and the drummer will most likely be him.

  • @DTOSX666 I hope not.

  • @DTxOctavariumx

    Check the DT website

    they are making a new album with Marco Minneman in the drums (:

  • @LarsMetallica79 It says nothing.

  • @LarsMetallica79 Check the .net versoin the .com isnt the actual site.

  • @hellskitchen123 yes, he could, but his drum ki is too small for dream theater .......

  • @hellskitchen123 I hope not. Clearly he's fast, technically skilled, and well-respected in the elite music world. But his acts have always been supporting roles, providing just enough virtuosity to backup Paul Gilbert and Necrophagist. He hasn't demonstrated the inextinguishable creative Heart that Portnoy had. His drumming doesn't sing in the ways Portnoy's did.

  • @hellskitchen123 he will....

  • @hellskitchen123 yoooooooooo  they should battle. that would be epic.

  • @hellskitchen123

    he does

  • @hellskitchen123 NO! I WANT PORTNOY BACK

  • @hellskitchen123 He could easily replace him. Mike Portnoy isnt that much good, i mean he's good at what he's doing but i dont really like him cause he's too square; no groove

  • @BlindedByTheLight17 Portnoy had an immense amount of groove that's why he was great for dream theater's uneven time signatures which is also a strong point for Marco. Marco has a lot of groove, too, but the thing that really sets them apart from Mike is his hand speed. I agree that Marco is better, but not because of his groove.

  • @BlindedByTheLight17 Hes incredibly overrated..Im actually tired of overrated drummers...I dont even like Portnoy right now...I see him as the guy I used to like, but no longer have as an influence...overrating drummers makes it boring...

  • seeing this truckload of abilities live some years ago made me seriously question my aspirations in drumming...

  • WTF....amazing...

  • 25 justin bieber fans missed the like button

  • that was just his warm-up...lol jk

  • in your face joey joerdison

  • @quadcannon95 your fucking retarded

  • @quadcannon95 yeah buy joey sux

  • @quadcannon95 haha

  • @quadcannon95 Yea screw Joey Joerdison

  • @quadcannon95 Joey Jordison...That' Justin Bieber's drummer, right?

  • @DTROXX why insult joey jordison like that¿? cmon¿? i mean yea i understand that the stuff this guy does is a whole lot more complicated but cmon even if u hated him don't use something like that as an insult thats just too harsh :/

  • Love this comment!! Joey Jordison isn't fit to lace this man's boots, can't believe he was voted worlds number 1 drummer! There's just so many better than him!!

  • 1:22 to 1:27 LOVE IT!!

  • Hmpf dont like it :E

  • he is the drummer of the technical metal band, NECROPHAGIST

  • @ianpo22 No hes not. He played live with them before tho.

  • @ianpo22 no he isn't Romain Goulon is. He was only in the band for 2 years

  • Sapporo?

  • amazing fills

  • @mikaronos in his teeth?

  • WTF at that sound from 6 to 11 seceonds in

  • @MegaYoshitsune Maybe he was getting his Schlong ready to drum?

  • really awesome rhythmfeeling!

  • This guy makes Blake Richardson seem average

  • does this video just look 20 or 30 years old to anyone else?

  • amazing chops but this solo looked too improvish - like he didn't plan anything at all and it was kinda random in the middle - great beginning and end though...

    I get the feeling he wasn't really trying his best.

  • haha his gesture at the end suggested inebriation.

  • This same DVD has an amazing solo, called Extreme Soloing, where creates passages with very hard polyrhythms, using the kick snare on his right, the hi-hat pedal and soloing over that, among other things. This one you've uploaded is great, but nothing compared to that one.

    That's the greatness of Marco Minnemann, complex polyrhythms and odd time signatures, among other things, like his versatility.

    Could you upload it?

  • I've just realized that these are the last 2 minutes of the solo that I mentioned...

  • Just the fact that marco plays WITH the Buddy Rich band, DOES NOT MEAN HE IS A JAZZ MUSICIAN.

    Ofcourse! each drummer can learn jazz!

    Marco plays very often just Pop/rock/metal THAT'S HIS STYLE. nothing more nothing less.

  • boy oooh Boy

    you have a strange definition of JAZZ.

  • Oke,

    Can you show me "1" video in which marco plays Techno then or can you show me '1' video in which he plays with Buddy Rich?

    I mean; saying is one, but to prove is second.

  • wooooww sooo! And?

    Did i offend some marco fanatic here?

  • He plays in Kreator?

  • No, he plays with Necrophagist^^

  • @Petruccinho

    No, he played with Necrophagist during their tour in 2007, and he appears in the dvd of that tour, published on 2008.

  • @Aensgard he also plays with paul gilbert in racer x

  • he used to... 2 or 3 years ago.

  • I cant belive how these people go like WHOA!!! this guys is just spreading sinle stroke rolls and double pedaling just like if world is gonna end in five minutes.