this is my least favorite season just because michael johns was voted off. he surely should've won. his voice is by far the best, he has great taste, and one day he will change todays music
Wow, this was difficult to watch again. It still hurts after all this time! Michael should have been in the Top 3, at the very least! What a loss for TV viewers and the potential for more fans!!!
i waz sooooo happy when michael came back with the top 12 and they performed!!! and when michael and carly did that 1 song 2gether!!! omg, i almost melted!
its soooooooooo sad he got voted off! and he waz only in top 8!!!! i think the top 2 shudve been david cook and michael johns! and then i wudve wished david coo won! which he did, ut then michael johns 2nd!!!! i luuved michael johns!!! and amanda overmyer waz awsum 2!!!!
That is sooo meen! He even smiled a little bit when ryan said"last year we didnt vote anyone off" sooo meen! They said he only lossed by about 1000 votes ): Hell be successful though!
Also, I can't believe the writers are so pathetic that they would make Ryan say what he did. (about last year they didn't make them leave during Idol week but this time they will.) I can't even stand to watch that part.
He didn't trip, he was upset about being voted off and didn't get the high note and bent forward out of the view of the camera probably because he was embarrassed.
I can not believe he and Carly are gone and Sy and Jason are still there. Good job America.. I guess if you weren't born here you don't deserve to be called an American Idol, right? (and don't get it twisted.. I was born and raised in Ky)
now i am convinced that discrimination rule over AI...first it was ramiele who's a filipina...now michael...who's next carly?oh please michael's elimination is too much to bear to add another...
AI is rigged! well, really i don't know but omg. i was like so mad and upset when he was voted off i wanted to strangle someone! im aussie so you know, aussie in AI? oh, yeah! i think AI is rigged. i'm going to go eat some comfort food now.
seriously and the way ryan seacrest said he was eliminated just made it worse, he was such a jerk wen he was like michael had the lowest number of votes and tried 2 lift his spirits by saying last year we didnt vote anyone off now but you are eliminated. he was my all time fav. and america got it wrong, how can evryone b so shocked wen we did the voting
america makes the shittiest decisions, but by this, i wasn't surprised. think about it: we're letting an idiotic shit-for-brains guy run our country for god's sake.
WHY THE HELL IS THIS A SURPRISE? Chris Daughtry was voted off, and he's doing better that friggin Jordan Sparks.
How can a lame country girl, an Irish fashion disaster, a dude that seriously needs to lose the dreads, and a wannabe Christina Aguilara still be in the competition? America has done it again.
From the country who elected Clinton twice and can't come up with any better candidates that what we have now, NO SURPRISE. I am guessing that the next two contestants to go will be the two Davids and then Jason, Carley and Syesha will be the next two to go. Leaving us with Brook and Krysti for the worst American Idol finale ever. Way to go America, way to keep up your image. Unbelievable!
I missed this episode, I didn't know they had an elimination last week because of Idol gives back.
This is so sad, he was hot and talented. WHY IS KRISTY STILL THERE? I mean she is decent but the weakest of the bunch, she should have never even made the top 16 let alone the top 8.
you honestly think he didnt have a fan base? please look at ALL of his videos and notice all of the views and comments. please he had one of the largest fan bases this show is bullshit now
To make it in show biz you got to be able to build a fan base which he wasn't able to do, not enough to stay on the show. Too bad because I thought he was great but not enough people thought that he was.
that is so wrong...he should have won the entire season...why didn't they come up with the judges' save back then??
mkr88lm 1 month ago
this is my least favorite season just because michael johns was voted off. he surely should've won. his voice is by far the best, he has great taste, and one day he will change todays music
gibsonlespaul5709 11 months ago 2
carlys hilarious i like how she raises her hand when ryan says who got the lowest number of votes?? haha
liz20141 1 year ago
Mikey Johns getting voted off was so wrong. :(
sonyab1974 2 years ago
much more better version tan danny gokey's..haha
riejin 2 years ago 2
HAHAHAHAHAHA! Douche!
EdgeMusicOfficial 2 years ago
Wow, this was difficult to watch again. It still hurts after all this time! Michael should have been in the Top 3, at the very least! What a loss for TV viewers and the potential for more fans!!!
lulusaddiction 2 years ago
Looking back on this still makes me upset. Michael Johns was my favorite contestant last year. I think he should have or could have won.
saulaidolfreak 3 years ago 2
this elimination was a disgrace! i was so angry!
bananacraz06 3 years ago 2
Seacrest out
higgsyhiggs 3 years ago
dude, ryan is a prick.
jendeg313 3 years ago
Look at Paula's face... she is equilly shocked as the rest of us!
CuteLittleTomato 3 years ago
no, somebody just told her that "lowest amount of votes" means you're voted off.
drifter6276 3 years ago
he has a nice ass.
kenyaDI9it 3 years ago
It was rigged, that or Kristy was told what to sing to be safe
tallderektoronto 3 years ago
I wanted kristy lee cook to get voted off!! ...
theMeganRshow 3 years ago 2
you can really tell he was singing his heart out his last performance. when he sang that in concert I was like OOO: AMAZINGGG
lunerosse 3 years ago
I didn't get to vote that night.
Teeftaller 3 years ago
carly and paulas face say it all .
this still gives me chills and it happened months ago .
unbelievable .
and god ryan , could you be a bigger jerk ?
vannersx3 3 years ago
This was shocking but not as shocking when daughtry went home.
Teeftaller 3 years ago
wow this was one of the worst nights of my life!!! gosh i wasssss sooooooooo mad!!!!
i cried!!!
michael johns is sooo amazing!!!!!
love him!!!!!!
abbbla11 3 years ago
What's wrong with Ryan that night. He suddenly turned into an ass
RoadKill700 3 years ago
I HATE RYAN.
"last year during 'idol gives back', we didn't eliminate anybody. TONIGHT...we say goodbye to michael johns."
WHAT A JERK.
SYESHA SHOULD HAVE WENT HOME!!!
MrsDavidCook715 3 years ago 3
i might have to agree with that
blackpaintbrushes 3 years ago
those damn producers it was already enough of a dramatic moment without making Ryan do that
JediMasterFisher 2 years ago
michael johns , you are deserving to win. .
Philippines loved you and we're always support you..
love you MJ!
SonOfSparda0902 2 years ago
SonOfSparda0902....your English sucks!
PerpetualEricShawn 2 years ago
I nearly cried the night he got booted and I'm a straight guy!
AnswerManSam 3 years ago 2
i waz sooooo happy when michael came back with the top 12 and they performed!!! and when michael and carly did that 1 song 2gether!!! omg, i almost melted!
iluvzacefron123 3 years ago
its soooooooooo sad he got voted off! and he waz only in top 8!!!! i think the top 2 shudve been david cook and michael johns! and then i wudve wished david coo won! which he did, ut then michael johns 2nd!!!! i luuved michael johns!!! and amanda overmyer waz awsum 2!!!!
iluvzacefron123 3 years ago
MJ should be in the top 2 with Cook.
cookieglow 3 years ago 5
That is sooo meen! He even smiled a little bit when ryan said"last year we didnt vote anyone off" sooo meen! They said he only lossed by about 1000 votes ): Hell be successful though!
Daughtry311c 3 years ago
yeah ryan shouldn't have gotten michael's hopes up like that.
nickjoekevin4 3 years ago
I didn't get to vote that night.
Teeftaller 3 years ago
and david cook is still here?????? he's just an emo fuck wataever.. oh well.. michael johns is just so good
walrus80 3 years ago
lol
knightruelz 3 years ago
dAvId cOoK rocks!!!!!!
Daughtry311c 3 years ago
Also, I can't believe the writers are so pathetic that they would make Ryan say what he did. (about last year they didn't make them leave during Idol week but this time they will.) I can't even stand to watch that part.
sugarcoma82 3 years ago 2
Best part is 8:43 where he tried that wanna-be steven tyler shrieking and he trips on the stage.
He definatly wasn't the worst left but he most certainly wasn't the one who should have won.
shyngo 3 years ago
He didn't trip, he was upset about being voted off and didn't get the high note and bent forward out of the view of the camera probably because he was embarrassed.
I can not believe he and Carly are gone and Sy and Jason are still there. Good job America.. I guess if you weren't born here you don't deserve to be called an American Idol, right? (and don't get it twisted.. I was born and raised in Ky)
sugarcoma82 3 years ago 2
michael, i love you....
luckyeula 3 years ago
now i am convinced that discrimination rule over AI...first it was ramiele who's a filipina...now michael...who's next carly?oh please michael's elimination is too much to bear to add another...
idealistic03 3 years ago
another thing, the look on paula's face!
bechino1 3 years ago
AI is rigged! well, really i don't know but omg. i was like so mad and upset when he was voted off i wanted to strangle someone! im aussie so you know, aussie in AI? oh, yeah! i think AI is rigged. i'm going to go eat some comfort food now.
bechino1 3 years ago
he better get a record deal
bechino1 3 years ago 3
He will
Teeftaller 3 years ago
i loved him.... i was so upset when he left. i really want david cook to win (and he will.)
abcedefghijklm 3 years ago
i don't think that he should have been voted off. he was really good!!!
berryshine123 3 years ago
There must be a mistake here; maybe a miscount or something? Because honestly, how can America be this stupid.....
kittylover1046 3 years ago
seriously and the way ryan seacrest said he was eliminated just made it worse, he was such a jerk wen he was like michael had the lowest number of votes and tried 2 lift his spirits by saying last year we didnt vote anyone off now but you are eliminated. he was my all time fav. and america got it wrong, how can evryone b so shocked wen we did the voting
gymnasam101 3 years ago
america makes the shittiest decisions, but by this, i wasn't surprised. think about it: we're letting an idiotic shit-for-brains guy run our country for god's sake.
WHY THE HELL IS THIS A SURPRISE? Chris Daughtry was voted off, and he's doing better that friggin Jordan Sparks.
How can a lame country girl, an Irish fashion disaster, a dude that seriously needs to lose the dreads, and a wannabe Christina Aguilara still be in the competition? America has done it again.
kittylover1046 3 years ago
what's going on in this season ?! it should be brooke ! not him!
aldiajalah 3 years ago
This was a MAJOR shocker. It wasn't his time to go.
Jiggabel 3 years ago 2
why did they have an elimination on idol gives backkkk???!!
lalab4ll 3 years ago 2
FINALLY!
VonzellSolomon38 3 years ago
wut do u mean by that??? he was like the best
gymnasam101 3 years ago
No he wasn't, David Cook is. Johns was good though, shouldn't have been voted off YET.
Samprasisthebest 3 years ago
No he was not the best!
VonzellSolomon38 3 years ago
From the country who elected Clinton twice and can't come up with any better candidates that what we have now, NO SURPRISE. I am guessing that the next two contestants to go will be the two Davids and then Jason, Carley and Syesha will be the next two to go. Leaving us with Brook and Krysti for the worst American Idol finale ever. Way to go America, way to keep up your image. Unbelievable!
jazzybleyl 3 years ago
ow. he's my favorite among the boys.
quistis04 3 years ago
I missed this episode, I didn't know they had an elimination last week because of Idol gives back.
This is so sad, he was hot and talented. WHY IS KRISTY STILL THERE? I mean she is decent but the weakest of the bunch, she should have never even made the top 16 let alone the top 8.
nickfvideoaddict 3 years ago
what was the point of ryan doing that!!
username32826 3 years ago
that is so messed up he shouldnt have been voted off he is like one of the best
wesleythebleedingboy 3 years ago
makes me sick. i'm so sad
kelamram 3 years ago
i've lost all faith in america
dancinglesbians 3 years ago
Well then I guess you will have to dance your lesbian ass somewhere else.
jazzybleyl 3 years ago
it makes me cry
CLaiReThECuPcAke 3 years ago
me to
rhcpluver25SEJR 3 years ago
that's not nice how ryan did that!
nycLAgirl123 3 years ago 2
he shouldnt have been voted off
yudelkamusic 3 years ago
you honestly think he didnt have a fan base? please look at ALL of his videos and notice all of the views and comments. please he had one of the largest fan bases this show is bullshit now
redsox1625 3 years ago
this makes me cry every single time i watch it he was so good he does not deserve this he will get a record deal in no time
jadequeen222 3 years ago
omg !!!!=!=!!==!!=!!======!!!=!=!=!==!=!=!=!
DavidLuisNCarlosSHOW 3 years ago
What a set up.
ERINxGOESxLAWLZ 3 years ago
What a set up.
ERINxGOESxLAWLZ 3 years ago
To make it in show biz you got to be able to build a fan base which he wasn't able to do, not enough to stay on the show. Too bad because I thought he was great but not enough people thought that he was.
authorworld 3 years ago
this makes me cry everytime.
it is not fair & it's not right.
x3BRiTTx3 3 years ago