Mrs Coulter wasn't supposed to tell Lyra she & Lord Asriel were her parents, John Faa did. This movie is SO off. I hope that someone remakes it even if it's a 2 and half hour film. They should do what they're doing with Harry Potter 7, making it into two parts.
tatar.............good sauce yeah and how did Rogers parents reach the spot without any bridge,forget it .....what about Iuric,how did he reached there.
Why do they make all the tartars have wolves? Wolves aren't evil for gods sakes! They're really beautiful creatures! Oh well, I love Northern Lights anyway - but this film... killed it slightly :/ Where is the bit when she goes and get's the Severed Kid's daemon spirits?
@WolvesLink1395 So are the bears, but they're also mercenaries in the book. Wolves do what's good for the pack, and the Magisterium offered them the best deal.
I like how Mrs. Coulter says "You are mine" instead of the easier choice of "I am your mother!". If she'd clenched her fist whilst saying it I would've LOLLED!
@gametyp900... whatever those Russian speaking Tartan's would have gather up all those pagan whiches, giptians and would of burned them. they would of also have eaten that bear
The book series was and epic masterpiece beyond words!!! His Dark Materials is sort of like my version of Star Wars or Lord of the Rings and has that status in my mythology. I know its a bummer we don't get more films of this epic story but they'll make another adaption in the future. Keep reading His Dark Materials and be like Lyra and Will and fight the evils of Finatical Religion, keeping in mind of course that people have the right to be religious but not dangerously religious.
@JasonQuahWL there's a lot of things making this a pretty weird movie for kids... like the hidden politic and the brutal fighting. I've never seen any other children's movie where polarbears rips eachother to pieces :P
ok thanks i get it now, and i just finished reading the 1st book but to me it seems that her dad is worse then her mother with the things he's also doing even though it doesn't involve separating children from their demons
so ein scheiß, be mir ist youtube so lahm...kann den film nicht gescheit schauen, da ich ständig auf diesen blöden roten streifen warten muss... ahrrrr
i wish Mrs.Coulter was my mother god its not fair i wish she wasn't her mom, but what i don't get is did lyra know she was her mother and if so then why did she not just give her the alietheometer?????
i wish Mrs.Coulter was my mother god its not fair i wish she wasn't her mom, but what i don't get is did lyra know she was her mother and if so then why did she not just give her the alietheometer?????
I don't mind changes in the movie, but it still saddens me that they didn't add the part with Serefina's Deamon and Lyra freeing all the kids deamons. That was a powerful scene, I thought.
In the book, John Faa was the one telling Lyra about Lord Asriel and Mrs Coulter being her parents, not Mrs Coulter. This film is totally different and not as interesting compared to the book.
Billy Costa doesn't lose his daemon in the novel. It was a kid named Tony Markarios who Lyra found in the village. I don't know why they made Billy lose his daemon when he lived and was reunited with his family, daemon intact. Also, Billy'd daemon isn't Ratter.
No, he didn't lose his daemon, but after he was reunited with his family, they were attacked. But not like the scene in the movie. It's when Lyra just freed the kids.
really? wow ill have to re read it. the thing that annoys me most about this film is the fact that roger is still alive at the end. because doesnt roger's ghost play a really big part in the amber spyglass?
The ending to The Golden Compass was going to be the beginning for The Subtle Knife, but because the movie was a flop in America, I guess we'll never know. I'm just about to start The Amber Spyglass but I think you're right about Roger's ghost.
Even though she's evil, it's so tense in sensing what's about to happen. And, the truth of it just sucks. I mean... for Lyra to finally meet her mother, but her mother turns out to be... not what she would have hoped for.
............... I can't believe you just compared The Lord of the Rings to fucking Narnia. Try to murder my soul with your nonsense, why don't you? Ugh.
Of course people should compare it. They were written by two authors who were best friends and had the same beliefs. They sometimes even nicked small ideas from each other and moulded it into their own. Look at Gandalf and Aslan - that's the most obvious one. Another very subtle one is the land of Etinsmoor in Narnia and the land of Etinmoors in Middle Earth.
I think that in the book at least, he gave them all wolf daemons because wolves are loyal creatures who are good and brave fighters, just like soldiers should be
No they aren't. They differ in many ways. For one, Aslan in Narnia is very good, but Iorek is much more savage. And Narnia does not have bear fights or daemons or anything of the sort.
three words ..... this is awesome!
lunaycorrecamino 1 year ago
Mrs Coulter wasn't supposed to tell Lyra she & Lord Asriel were her parents, John Faa did. This movie is SO off. I hope that someone remakes it even if it's a 2 and half hour film. They should do what they're doing with Harry Potter 7, making it into two parts.
larzkao 1 year ago
tatar.............good sauce yeah and how did Rogers parents reach the spot without any bridge,forget it .....what about Iuric,how did he reached there.
qetuo2ADGJL 1 year ago
tatar.............good sauce yeah
qetuo2ADGJL 1 year ago
I FORGOT THAT BIG TWIST IN THE BOOK!
g3g3ify 1 year ago
Why do they make all the tartars have wolves? Wolves aren't evil for gods sakes! They're really beautiful creatures! Oh well, I love Northern Lights anyway - but this film... killed it slightly :/ Where is the bit when she goes and get's the Severed Kid's daemon spirits?
WolvesLink1395 1 year ago 3
@WolvesLink1395 the bet where she goes to get the kids daemon's is a deleted scene on the DVD
TuggerBombaMunkus 1 year ago
@WolvesLink1395 So are the bears, but they're also mercenaries in the book. Wolves do what's good for the pack, and the Magisterium offered them the best deal.
Eldritchfan 1 year ago
@Eldritchfan very true heh - I guess you're right :P Plus I guess the wolves have to protect their humans
WolvesLink1395 1 year ago
@WolvesLink1395 I'll agree with you there, wolves arnt evil, there misunderstood.
TheGigaGliscor 1 year ago
Mrs. Coulter didn't tell Lyra who her parents were Lord Faa did
94gymnast 1 year ago
whitch? more like elves
OneOfTheAliens 1 year ago
NO ROGER, GO HOMMMEEE!!
mikky107 1 year ago
I don't get it. Why are the Russians always the bad guys? It hurts to see so many Hollywood movies with us as the villans.
DashaPx3 1 year ago
@DashaPx3
Me too, in american films the english are the bad guys.
-.-'
mikky107 1 year ago
@DashaPx3 Yeah! What's up with that! I'm not Russian, but I totally agree!
kvsyaoran727 1 year ago
I like how Mrs. Coulter says "You are mine" instead of the easier choice of "I am your mother!". If she'd clenched her fist whilst saying it I would've LOLLED!
intheTea04 1 year ago
A Dragon soul...that woulda been something!
Afamify 1 year ago
Comment removed
newworldboss 1 year ago
Comment removed
newworldboss 1 year ago
I,ll give you a answer to 3:26.
1.They are not Russian
2.There are Tatarian and they spoke Russian in Middleage.
Well,who is thinking,that they are Russian,he should piss off.
gametyp900 1 year ago
@gametyp900... whatever those Russian speaking Tartan's would have gather up all those pagan whiches, giptians and would of burned them. they would of also have eaten that bear
newworldboss 1 year ago
The book series was and epic masterpiece beyond words!!! His Dark Materials is sort of like my version of Star Wars or Lord of the Rings and has that status in my mythology. I know its a bummer we don't get more films of this epic story but they'll make another adaption in the future. Keep reading His Dark Materials and be like Lyra and Will and fight the evils of Finatical Religion, keeping in mind of course that people have the right to be religious but not dangerously religious.
Rainfish14 1 year ago
sweet explosion of the machine...haha feisty lil girl eh? SMALL CHILD STAMPEEEEDDDD i also luv the fire explosion when the daemon dies
joriemarymaas 1 year ago
sweet explosion of the machine...haha feisty lil girl eh? SMALL CHILD STAMPEEEEDDDD
joriemarymaas 1 year ago
sweet explosion of the machine...haha feisty lil girl eh?
joriemarymaas 1 year ago
Epic final battle,I loved it.
windrunnerkronicles 1 year ago
it pains me to see so many differences in the movie compared to the book.
callmeTAZZ 1 year ago
i love this scene with the battle, i think the ending was disappointing, and i really wanted a sequel to this,
edmundandlucy 1 year ago
Epic final battle
EpicDuck17 1 year ago
Why are wolves always the bad guys? :(
awesomefriends010 1 year ago
haha, seeing Ms. Coulter get all excited over the 'compass' made me laugh
andrielisilien 1 year ago
i love it when she throughs that thing into the machine and blows it up :D
LeeSmith9595 1 year ago
For a family movie, the main character is a real brat.
JasonQuahWL 1 year ago 2
@JasonQuahWL there's a lot of things making this a pretty weird movie for kids... like the hidden politic and the brutal fighting. I've never seen any other children's movie where polarbears rips eachother to pieces :P
BabyScarecrow 1 year ago
Lyra's mom is a cutter :)
NaoteToneeta 1 year ago
Lyra, I am your mother.... NOOOOOOOOO!!
DerPoltergeist13 1 year ago 3
1:25 her fingers! :AA
Tsubasa7859 1 year ago
"Ma Costa never told you about your mother." "She told me enough she told me you killed her."
"No Lyra, I am your mother."
Gerbilkit 1 year ago 5
dunno if anyone else thinks this, but i would happily make that monkey into a handbag, and not lose a wink of sleep over it......creepy lil fcuk!
joet66 1 year ago 4
great movie
love Nicole she is one of my favorite actresses
franknbarbie 1 year ago
ok thanks i get it now, and i just finished reading the 1st book but to me it seems that her dad is worse then her mother with the things he's also doing even though it doesn't involve separating children from their demons
merylfan1 1 year ago
The witches remind me of cupid, with their little bows and arrows and all. :)
alicerosemalfoy 1 year ago
the witches were supposed to have broomsticks... dam director...
deaglePwnz 1 year ago
thats their style!!!!!
bugo jud!!!!
jamessilver1 1 year ago
@deaglePwnz thats not true... witches are appeared with many things... i think its better like this because it is another point of view
musicandkisses 1 year ago
I was like "Lyra you idiot, you're so gullible!" and then I laughed my head off at how cunning she was with the spy-fly.
PrincesTomboy 1 year ago
so ein scheiß, be mir ist youtube so lahm...kann den film nicht gescheit schauen, da ich ständig auf diesen blöden roten streifen warten muss... ahrrrr
Malvina1987 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i wish Mrs.Coulter was my mother god its not fair i wish she wasn't her mom, but what i don't get is did lyra know she was her mother and if so then why did she not just give her the alietheometer?????
merylfan1 1 year ago
i wish Mrs.Coulter was my mother god its not fair i wish she wasn't her mom, but what i don't get is did lyra know she was her mother and if so then why did she not just give her the alietheometer?????
merylfan1 1 year ago
@merylfan1 No, Lyra had no Idea Mrs. Coulter was her mother and she didn't give her the alietheometer because her mother was doing terrible things!
Rita3500 1 year ago
um im tatar and we can speak russian wtf lol
Sany21 1 year ago
LO AT 7:15 xD *CRASH* DAAAAH!!!
photonreno 1 year ago
Luke... ;-)
GuillermoTemblalanza 1 year ago
7:55
this what happens when u mess with ma costa
BLUEYOSHl 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
*WATCH FULL MOVIES RIGHT NOW!* Visit TheFreeMovieCinema ( . ) ( com ) today!
fabinhogabor09 2 years ago
i cant believe i'm getting this movie for free
wert42381 2 years ago
how did she know what buttons to push ???
motherwelll 2 years ago
she didn't know. that's why she pushed all of them.
datrooth007 2 years ago
wow, somehow, i saw this coming. they do kidna resemble each other. but still, i dont like that lady....
sweetcakes200 2 years ago
Lol
at 4:19, I was like "Oh snap. Iorek Byrnison's about to fuck shit up."
bgibson36 2 years ago 2
y does the bad ppl have to be Russians?
MujahidsFoldedWings 2 years ago 4
@MujahidsFoldedWings
Well, they can't always be Germans ;-)
Stachelschwein1975 2 years ago 5
@Stachelschwein1975
or Israelis ;)
MujahidsFoldedWings 2 years ago 3
Hmmm, at 1:55, looks like she's a chip off the old block.
zisguy 2 years ago
You are not my mother! i will not rule the universe with you!
Come to the dark side, eh!
zisguy 2 years ago 43
@zisguy hahaha your funny... :)
sweetcakes200 2 years ago
yor really funny
wert42381 2 years ago
@zisguy i dunno, ms Coulter doesn't seem like a cookie person...
1andonlySaraEliza 1 year ago
@zisguy sure ill join you
blasd1000 1 year ago
Hahahaha
Tidustrix 2 years ago
it's clear: russians, inuit, doctors and clergymen are EVIL!
Lapsanglover 2 years ago
wasnt jahn fa meant to have a hammer or war axe.
changes for the movie Ok but thats just sloppy
911650 2 years ago
where r the demons in the lunch room
moshavmom 2 years ago
I don't mind changes in the movie, but it still saddens me that they didn't add the part with Serefina's Deamon and Lyra freeing all the kids deamons. That was a powerful scene, I thought.
JustAPrayer 2 years ago 4
yup. orange particles=dust
MadameSpazz 2 years ago
The orange particles are dust, right?
MadelenaVelvetcrush 2 years ago
In the book, John Faa was the one telling Lyra about Lord Asriel and Mrs Coulter being her parents, not Mrs Coulter. This film is totally different and not as interesting compared to the book.
MadelenaVelvetcrush 2 years ago 5
Comment removed
pinklisoff 2 years ago
Dude, YES!
Cullengirl449 2 years ago
dude this movie is so crappy compaired to the book its annoys me...
stine0225 2 years ago
it's a good movie for us dyslexias...
bravecat100 2 years ago
5:07 is AWESOME!!!
zombieporn99 2 years ago
DAAAAAAAAAAAAMN, i want one of those witches for me! *.*
ramonesaudibert 2 years ago
ignore error "Billy's"
shaneoisin 2 years ago
in the book the gyptians told her that lord a and ms.c was her father and mother
SailorAmu 2 years ago 3
ha that battle was epic!
mikeistheshiz 2 years ago
i LOVE this part of the movie!
bluekittykat77 2 years ago 4
i actually really like the witches XD
meathead689 2 years ago 4
this is like star wars when luke found out that darth vadar was his dad
MrDndspoon 2 years ago 4
Billy dies actually. Right after he reunites with his family.
rioschica 2 years ago
does billy ever get his ratter back i haven't read the books yet
14watssama 2 years ago
You're gonna be in for a big shock at how much different the book is. Whoever the screenwriter for this was fucked up big time.
I'll let you in on something. Billy isn't the one who they found in the shed. It was Tony Makarios.
WalkerKansasRanger 2 years ago
Billy Costa doesn't lose his daemon in the novel. It was a kid named Tony Markarios who Lyra found in the village. I don't know why they made Billy lose his daemon when he lived and was reunited with his family, daemon intact. Also, Billy'd daemon isn't Ratter.
shaneoisin 2 years ago
i think billy did lose his daemon but ur rght, his isnt called ratter
OOjuniperberry 2 years ago
No, he didn't lose his daemon, but after he was reunited with his family, they were attacked. But not like the scene in the movie. It's when Lyra just freed the kids.
shaneoisin 2 years ago
really? wow ill have to re read it. the thing that annoys me most about this film is the fact that roger is still alive at the end. because doesnt roger's ghost play a really big part in the amber spyglass?
OOjuniperberry 2 years ago
The ending to The Golden Compass was going to be the beginning for The Subtle Knife, but because the movie was a flop in America, I guess we'll never know. I'm just about to start The Amber Spyglass but I think you're right about Roger's ghost.
shaneoisin 2 years ago
holy shit this movie's too awesome!
jackkedrabbit 2 years ago
that's true daveyowhat!!! u are so right!!
Mskitty19911 2 years ago
i love it
Mskitty19911 2 years ago
thanx for uploading the actress who plays lyra is is a really good actress.
happyhorror13 2 years ago 4
Even though she's evil, it's so tense in sensing what's about to happen. And, the truth of it just sucks. I mean... for Lyra to finally meet her mother, but her mother turns out to be... not what she would have hoped for.
Daveyohwhat 2 years ago 8
This comment has received too many negative votes show
watta crap movie is shit man pointless fairytale..........narnia,lord of the rings and harry porter shit on this man
riveranna1999 2 years ago
............... I can't believe you just compared The Lord of the Rings to fucking Narnia. Try to murder my soul with your nonsense, why don't you? Ugh.
veerasix 2 years ago
Of course people should compare it. They were written by two authors who were best friends and had the same beliefs. They sometimes even nicked small ideas from each other and moulded it into their own. Look at Gandalf and Aslan - that's the most obvious one. Another very subtle one is the land of Etinsmoor in Narnia and the land of Etinmoors in Middle Earth.
jennythemusicmaker 2 years ago
I agree!
hvuseenmemonster 2 years ago
so why are u posting this when the movies early over?
moyakh 2 years ago
JEAH the Final battle is Great i love it...
I love the flashy entrance of the witches ^^
HolyShadowOMG 2 years ago 20
This comment has received too many negative votes show
She really is Lyra's mother, Asreal really is Lyra's father. The movie sucks but the score is awesome.
turnipz2 2 years ago
love the war
vladislavs2 2 years ago 6
Comment removed
HolyShadowOMG 2 years ago
nice One mOre tO gO
myboobhabes 2 years ago 4
its a nice movie hehehe
myboobhabes 2 years ago 3
was she supposed to give her the golden compass at the beginning or something?? and is she really her mother?
shadowgirl90210 2 years ago
u nutter course she's the mother but she's evil u r soo thick how do u manage through school?............. oh thats right u can't
jpgogo 2 years ago
wow, i guess dust isn't just dust ... phew!
musicandstrawberries 2 years ago
lol
shadowgirl90210 2 years ago
did anyone notice that after mrs coulter is attacked by the spyfly we can't see her face ? (i bet she's got a pretty nasty scar there)
bioniclefreak01 2 years ago 6
Why do all the bad guys have wolf daemons?
ReconditeDusk 2 years ago 5
couse they represent the character of theire owner, like guardians have dogs and liars have snakes as deamons (sry for bad english)
MetalXMind 2 years ago 4
not all of them, just the tartar regiment.
kristanova 2 years ago 4
beacuse of pop cultures protrayal of wolves being evil creatures, but I know better than that, how about you????!!!
elguerreromuisca 2 years ago 7
I think that in the book at least, he gave them all wolf daemons because wolves are loyal creatures who are good and brave fighters, just like soldiers should be
BriannaNLC 2 years ago
Wolves are loyal to whom?
stedav 2 years ago
To the other wolves in their pack
BriannaNLC 2 years ago
their loyal to their humans, their deamon's
raichy9525 2 years ago
no dogs are the most loyal creatures and lions too but if you keep them from litle
icemage123456 2 years ago
4:18 PAW!! :()
chocolytesprynkles 2 years ago
LUKE, I AM YOUR FATHER!
shizlnit 2 years ago 6
they can talk , remember on 2/11 u can see the snowleopard talking to Lord Asriel and that was his deamon
ThePKscene 2 years ago
5:05 so damn cool!
zombieporn99 2 years ago
ajah... and the bear was hidding were? in her buttock?
makloon 2 years ago
IS SHE REALLY HER MOM???????
Booklvr777 2 years ago
Nope. Not in real life.
But in the movie, yeah. :)
sweetheartartist 2 years ago
yes she is her mum
joeywoeybeeniebaby 2 years ago
In the movie only, though.
sweetheartartist 2 years ago
oh right sorry i miss read i thought you said that she was only her mum in the film i didnt realise you ment real life.
my bad
joeywoeybeeniebaby 2 years ago
It's okki. :)
sweetheartartist 2 years ago
roger should have went with the gyptians the next movie roger won't be in the movie real long its sad :'(
munsterhunter92 2 years ago
no, its not! In the 3rd book, he makes Lyra dream with him so that she can almost kill herself to TRY to help him just becuse she was feeling guilty!
Belacquagirl 2 years ago 4
witches kick your ASS!!! XDhahahah
Dancingintherain15 2 years ago
lol she throws the "toaster" into the seperation chamber and it blows up
CCSirius 2 years ago
I'm sure Nicole Kidman had some surgery on her upper lip. It wasn't that thick when she was a no-name star many years before.
mefeline 2 years ago
did you see the polar bears jaw come off
hocko11 2 years ago
GO POLAR BEAR!!!!!! gotta love this film
missbex123 2 years ago
1 shot frm an arrow n they DIE?? dang!!!
saezuri89 2 years ago
They're aiming at their daemons, which in this story's universe are people's souls. Hence the small explosions.
ThreeLeafIvy 2 years ago
LOL some of the arrow actually hit the person then their daemons went POOF!! haha
saezuri89 2 years ago
is this from a children's novel? isn't there too much violence for that? hahaha.. I LOVE IT ANYWAYS!!!!
princess0fdeath 2 years ago
Emmm...nooo, I wouldn't say the His Dark Materials trilogy are CHILDRENS novels at all really.
kluggaklug 2 years ago 4
I read them. Not at all. I was twelve and I hardly got it but I was fascinated!
GangstaBPRad 2 years ago
DUDE! When I watch the children escape and the gaurds tell them not to let them escape...just kinda reminds me of consitration camps... :/
misledmsd 2 years ago
Its kinda the same in alot of ways
kougalover555 2 years ago
serafina and lord asril both play in casino royal...both great actors...and their both in two great movies
tomleerik 2 years ago
Why doesn't Ms. Coulters daemon talk?
Agaettis 2 years ago
It does but only to mrs coulter I would imagine, secretive and devious just like her.
matykoran 2 years ago 6
Adults deamons can't talk, they've settled, meaning no speaking and unlike child deamons they can't shape shift either.
pixy2k2 2 years ago
adult daemons can talk...
Mintyflip 2 years ago 3
They talk. Lord Asriel's daemon, Stellamaria talked around the beginning of this movie.
sweetheartartist 2 years ago
Yeah, I realized it after I posted, haha my bad.
pixy2k2 2 years ago
they even changed the name...... and its like so many things changed from the books...
Fantasyger 2 years ago 2
the movie is good...but the kid's acting is soo exagerated
blacklight019 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
5:57 touched her boobies
shizi 2 years ago
CHARGE!
the other guys are like holy shit wth do they keep coming from"
kittencuddle771 2 years ago
At least it was an epic battle ... ah, I still liked to movies, though I liked the books better.
Isn't it nice to see how most people that saw the movie, have also read the books. It's quite the opposite when it comes to harry potter :p
melvinhendrikse 2 years ago
Hahah yeahh!
i saw that too. she said, she never wanted to be an actress. shw just wanted to play Lyra.
i thin k it would be awesome to have a daemon. wonder what mine would be?? haha
ZacEfronLurver 2 years ago
why they do the second and third books?? i hope they would!! otherwise the story wont finish!
MissNoOne555 2 years ago
they're going to.
ZacEfronLurver 2 years ago
sooooooooo. . . how do the mothers give birth to Daemons?
crazydancinggyal3 2 years ago
i think the daemons appear like they disappear when people die.
imacds 2 years ago
ooooohhhhhh thx!
crazydancinggyal3 2 years ago
i really like narnia.narnia and golden compass are very similar.
Gretusnikovas 2 years ago
No they aren't. They differ in many ways. For one, Aslan in Narnia is very good, but Iorek is much more savage. And Narnia does not have bear fights or daemons or anything of the sort.
dragonair907 2 years ago 2