When I hear people starting to sing this song, I'm always afraid they won't make through some of the parts. And I'm always happy to find out that some people actually manage, like Bryan. ♥
@msalbego93 are you talking about pete townshend or roger daltery ? dunno abt their future.. but my god they have a colorful past.. in their hay day they made other rockstars look like school kids !!!
Zac Starkey (Ringo's son) was 12 years old when Keith Moon died. He didn't join The Who until 1996. Kenny Jones and others played drums for the band. Zac has been with the Who off and on since 96.
No cover has the depth of feeling of the original. What an honour for Bryan Adams to share the stage with rock royalty and be allowed to add his twist to one of their hits.
I think we all do! But you've got to admit Zak Starkey comes a close 2nd! ;-)
And he was taught how to play by KM....! There are some really good benefits when your Dad is part of the biggest pop band of them all! :-D The Beatles might have been the biggest, but even they knew that The Who was the best! ;-)
Pete Townshend, man of many mistakes: He let Limb Biscuit do the horrible cover; he let Simon Phillips play with The Who; he let Elton John, Phil Collins and Billy Idol sing for The Who. The last mistake he even committed several times.
Sorry... comment was written badly and was incorrect - I meant to say that the drummer is Zac. The song was about Keith. I have since found the song was written for Lifehouse.
Zac Starkey didn't replace Keith Moon. Kenny Jones replaced Keith Moon. Zac Starkey is Ringo Stars son and this is him but well after Kenny Jones bit with the Who.
@mikeb33 It's not. It's not about Keith Moon, either. The song was originally written for The Who's rock opera Lifehouse (abandoned project). Moon died a good 7 years after this song was written.
My favorite performance of the song. The show is wonderful. Such places as the Royall Albert Hall, Madison Square Garden or Hammersmith Odeon have its own unique atmosphere, and played in their concerts are special. At least in my opinion.
And Limp Bisquit should not even touch this track. They are unworthy.
Holy! 3rd fret capo?! That's bloody high for Behind Blue Eyes... though hearing Mr Townshend and Mr Daltry sing that high on the harmonies is kinda funny.
this guy has one of the most beautifull voiceis ever and he is so down to earth!!omg bryan is the best love singer all time!he can rock the stage so easy!
i'm a mega who fan and as much as i like bryan's vocals on this performance, i can't believe he screwed up the lyrics. he sang, "... my dreams ARE as empty... ". the correct lyrics go, "... my dreams AREN'T as empty... ". a minor quibble, yeah, but still... sheesh.
Ok.. so I saw Bryan Adams a few hours ago in the BJCC concert hall in Alabama. A few months ago I saw clapton and Roger opened for him. THIS IS PUTTING THEM TOGETHER!!!! Magic. :3
waaaaaa...amaaazing! much better then the original!
it is his voice...it is the special sound of his voice...just amazing and great to listening him. i love to hear him...the way how he´s singing. fantastic!
@rwwagsneb While I love Bryan Adams, I agree with you that he just doesn't quite pull this song off. Having heard both Roger and Pete sing this song over the years, it is really difficult to think that anyone else could ever come close to interpreting it adequately. Roger's version always has that tinge of anger to it, and his voice has a growl to it that I've not ever heard anyone else duplicate. Pete's version has the depth of feeling that only the author of the song could ever truly know.
Excellent, Bryan! I'm sure diehard Who fans may have been disapponted that Daultry didn't sing this, but Bryan did kick ass on this song!! YOU ROCK, BRYAN!!!
This is seriously incredible. Bryan is amazing. There is no other Bryan.
I just wish I was born 20 years earlier so I would have remembered when he was HUGE. Selling out arena shows all over the world, because all the videos i have seen of it are incredible.
why? he is stil on tour... I've seen him once in 2008 and it was simply awesome. I'm looking so much foward for June, when he is coming again to Berlin... (btw. I'm 28 ;)) So it doesn't matter how old you are, the concerts are still incredible. Visit one if you have a chance and you won't regret it...
Pretty Good! I love the Who, B.A is great too but I rather hear them seperately, this didn't sound like it came from a real place. But he gets away with it :)
people say bryan fell off. bryan has certainly not fallen off. he may not command the arena shows like he once did,but he still rocks. his collaboration here with the who is proof that bryan is a rocker at heart and not a balladeer. his gigs are amazing. they rock just as much as this performance.
The "And if I swallow anything evil, put your finger down my throat, and if I shiver give me a blanket, keep me warm let me wear your coat." line gives me chills everytime I hear it, Keith's drumming on it is so dramatic that it evokes so many emotions and fits the lyrics perfectly, and the vocal harmony that comes in there accentuates the importance of that whole line as well. I think the original is a masterpiece. This performance is excellent, the singing has pure emotion in it.
limp bizkit stole the song....and i thaught it was going to be a disaster when i heard but it was very good....i still like THE WHO'S version better though....
Such a great Song and bryan sings really well
jnkss18 1 week ago
2:35 + Oh God !
HollowMXstudio 1 week ago
ya dont often see roger daltrey playing guitar.
bav854 2 weeks ago
When I hear people starting to sing this song, I'm always afraid they won't make through some of the parts. And I'm always happy to find out that some people actually manage, like Bryan. ♥
flowerpod 1 month ago 3
Still for sale sew on badges of Glitter and Townshend.
joedog281 2 months ago
I dont know. This guy playing guitar, I think he has a brilliant future ahead.
msalbego93 2 months ago
@msalbego93 are you talking about pete townshend or roger daltery ? dunno abt their future.. but my god they have a colorful past.. in their hay day they made other rockstars look like school kids !!!
madhavan84 1 month ago
also Cause life is a game
loveilybabi91x 2 months ago
Zac Starkey (Ringo's son) was 12 years old when Keith Moon died. He didn't join The Who until 1996. Kenny Jones and others played drums for the band. Zac has been with the Who off and on since 96.
LesMac1000 2 months ago
lool i got moneys
meganwhitewhtie 2 months ago
Should have let Pete just take the harmony. Still great.
alvin01 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
hm sharing fantasies and if possible put them into practice
priyama1999 3 months ago
I would like more please !
stuartsum69 3 months ago
To my privat blue eyes irish man who i LOVE!!!!
Merava1 3 months ago
awesome BA
bryanadamsholic 3 months ago
шедевр!!!!!!!!!!!!!
SSETE15 3 months ago 19
they r gethered for a good cause...nice performance..
MrVaibhav2905 3 months ago
i will perform this...love u bryan adams..
MrVaibhav2905 3 months ago
when my fist clenches crack it open!.."...Woow!
coratris 3 months ago
love love love Bryan
bryanadamsholic 3 months ago
woooow, the drummer look like he got 4 HANDS and 4 LEGS!!!!
subhiad 3 months ago in playlist Bryan Adams
@subhiad That drummer is Zak Starkey, son of Ringo Starr so apparantly it's in the family haha
Darkpietje 3 months ago
@Darkpietje yes sure he is :)
subhiad 2 months ago
check my vocals out
neilengland1977 3 months ago in playlist More videos from bryanadams
erm Be ready to jump to the world full of pleasure
119tomcambero542 4 months ago
Pretty good one !
FraggyFred 4 months ago
oh no!!..stick to your own songs Bryan..not believable...no feeling in that, sorry;(
SuperLuckao 4 months ago
Brian Adams can do some great work.
This is proof.
JonChappell77 4 months ago
No cover has the depth of feeling of the original. What an honour for Bryan Adams to share the stage with rock royalty and be allowed to add his twist to one of their hits.
paultgreen 4 months ago
Everybody slating Limp Bizkit, oi! This is Bryan Adams!
jasonpatchett1 5 months ago
@adisily12, this song is actually about an innocent blonde haired blue eyed German in the second world war
13Musicmachine 5 months ago
@13Musicmachine actually this song was written as an olive branch from Pete to Roger the song itself is about Roger and his anger issues.
pty4488 5 months ago
@pty4488 Pete loves to change his mind on songs.
Says something about about the quality when either meaning still works.
erock195 3 months ago
god i miss Keith Moon
viggy123 5 months ago
@viggy123
I think we all do! But you've got to admit Zak Starkey comes a close 2nd! ;-)
And he was taught how to play by KM....! There are some really good benefits when your Dad is part of the biggest pop band of them all! :-D The Beatles might have been the biggest, but even they knew that The Who was the best! ;-)
Sardonicus81 5 months ago
Great song, he sings it better than the original. I usually hate live music, but I love Bryans live music, its as good as his studio stuff.
LS1350Camaroz28 6 months ago
I dig the higher tone he sings at for this. "...but my dreeeeEEEeeams they aren't as empty...as my coooonscieeeence seeeeems to be..."
ReeseMac 6 months ago
The best version of this song is Limp Bizkit's and Richie's cover <3 they roooock so hard :)
Iasa18 6 months ago
I think Bryan didn`t sing this to bad. Roger hadn`t the powerful voice of old days in the time this were recorded.
My personal favorites:
1.: Original by The Who
2.: Cover by Richie Kotzen (very well job done)
3.: The Who feat. Bryan Adams
4. and worst: Limp Biskit Cover
wepo59 6 months ago
Pete Townshend, man of many mistakes: He let Limb Biscuit do the horrible cover; he let Simon Phillips play with The Who; he let Elton John, Phil Collins and Billy Idol sing for The Who. The last mistake he even committed several times.
pptthik 6 months ago
i don't care about their comments.....the most important is...i love his songs..
MyElena37 7 months ago
pos bang if you think the drummer is better than his dad!
nemesis1365 8 months ago
this song is about pete, it cant be about keith he had brown eyes
alisidey12 8 months ago
I like Bryan Adams but this vocal rendition is a total failure.
Levethian 8 months ago
@Levethian Really ? No, Really . . you are tone deaf then
superzapper 6 months ago
Sorry... comment was written badly and was incorrect - I meant to say that the drummer is Zac. The song was about Keith. I have since found the song was written for Lifehouse.
rjblue42 8 months ago
how the hell does anyone think this song is about zac ??????????
100movieman 8 months ago
Limp Bizkit version is much much much..... better !
xxxlethalxxxb 8 months ago
@xxxlethalxxxb
I dont think so!... But The Limp Bizkit Version is diferent and its a good version Too!!
darthfexx 8 months ago
@xxxlethalxxxb no way in fucking hell....
TheRollingStoner75 7 months ago
Zac Starkey didn't replace Keith Moon. Kenny Jones replaced Keith Moon. Zac Starkey is Ringo Stars son and this is him but well after Kenny Jones bit with the Who.
Josiahoox 8 months ago
That is TOTAL GARBAGE!!!
Fritzcatseven 8 months ago
AFFFFFFFFFF HORRIBLE!!!!!!!!!!
Louquixots 8 months ago
@mikeb33 It's not. It's not about Keith Moon, either. The song was originally written for The Who's rock opera Lifehouse (abandoned project). Moon died a good 7 years after this song was written.
jessannie9 8 months ago
GeneralDissarray - The drummer is Zac Starkey, who replaced Keith Moon after his death... and about whom this song was written
rjblue42 8 months ago
@rjblue42
I've never heard this was about Zac before. Where did you hear that?
mikeb33 8 months ago
GeneralDissarray - The drummer is Zac Starkey, who replaced Keith Moon after his death... and about whom this song was written
rjblue42 8 months ago
i liked this before i see :)
ChilliSmashBros 8 months ago
shivers down me spine... amazing
Audunum 8 months ago
excelente video GRANDE BRYAN!!!!!!!!!!
buenjovi4000 8 months ago
excelente video GRANDE BRYAN!!!!!!!!!!
buenjovi4000 8 months ago
i tottaly love bryan he is brilliant
helenbry 9 months ago
The Who <3
MrScreenn19 9 months ago
Not as emotive as Roger
randomdave30 9 months ago
My favorite performance of the song. The show is wonderful. Such places as the Royall Albert Hall, Madison Square Garden or Hammersmith Odeon have its own unique atmosphere, and played in their concerts are special. At least in my opinion.
And Limp Bisquit should not even touch this track. They are unworthy.
JTAqualung 10 months ago
My favorite performance of the song. The show is wonderful. A version of Limb Bisquit is a parody.
JTAqualung 10 months ago
i have no blue eyes but i like it! 'cuz nobody knows what is behind our eyes
joshuaslogand 10 months ago
@umida0803: no, the Original is from the who and limp bizkit covered this song!
ribery1000 10 months ago
@ribery1000 ohhh okay... hhaha
umida0803 10 months ago
I thought this song was originally by Limp Bizkit??
umida0803 10 months ago
@umida0803 no... hahaha
taricco 10 months ago
@umida0803 the who did this song over 30 years ago....
damn generation of kids these days!
TheRollingStoner75 7 months ago
this is a fantastic collabaration, bryan adams sounds most unlike himself he has an angst ridden sound
unopalomablanco 11 months ago
like all who have said in the other comments this is just pure fucking greatness
hashboyuk 11 months ago
This blows me away - my favorite version of this EPIC song. Profound lyrics and timeless moving passionate musical instrumental expression.
charadeyouareha 11 months ago
LONG LIVE PETE!! LONG LIVE THE WHO!!!
dersh65 11 months ago
mandou bem! não me canso de ver e ouvir
rick245100 11 months ago
worst crowd ever
ytuser121 11 months ago
oh ,,my blue eyes lady,,,, i love you...
beeburg100 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Not even close...
PA28140 1 year ago
My new favorite video! Wish there were more Who/BA videos.. Is it me.. or does BA make the song sound better than the original??
phanttomracer 1 year ago
love his voice
Theisisify 1 year ago
Bryan Adams and The Who? I can officially die happy now.
day500champ08 1 year ago
Holy! 3rd fret capo?! That's bloody high for Behind Blue Eyes... though hearing Mr Townshend and Mr Daltry sing that high on the harmonies is kinda funny.
AngelofMusic2288 1 year ago
bryan adams has the most beautifull voice in the world and he is so down to earth!!he is a reall artist and he can rock the stage so easily!
michael43205 1 year ago
this guy has one of the most beautifull voiceis ever and he is so down to earth!!omg bryan is the best love singer all time!he can rock the stage so easy!
michael43205 1 year ago
Ladies and Gentlemen MISTER BRYAN ADAMS !
Rifederica 1 year ago
Great job by Mr Adams, RIP Ox bass legend!!!
cormackjames 1 year ago
Comment removed
mollysangelique 1 year ago
bryan adams è bravissimo
aurora5584 1 year ago
Comment removed
mollysangelique 1 year ago
Comment removed
mollysangelique 1 year ago
@mollysangelique huh? wat bedoel jij?
chris93TV 1 year ago
Comment removed
mollysangelique 1 year ago
Brian makes the big time. He hasn't recorded anything but ballads in years unfortunately. Must be that Bruce Allen management.
whotwo 1 year ago
Had no idea Daltrey played guitar...Great song and performance!
Mashfan6507 1 year ago
what a voice!and what a performance..!!
bonniedas 1 year ago
aaaawesome
chris93TV 1 year ago
me emocionei ao ver meu cantor preferido cantando minha musica preferida!!! coisa liiiiiiiiiinda de se ver!!! o Bryan arrasa toooooooodas!!!!
alinelanna 1 year ago
Comment removed
mollysangelique 1 year ago
i'm a mega who fan and as much as i like bryan's vocals on this performance, i can't believe he screwed up the lyrics. he sang, "... my dreams ARE as empty... ". the correct lyrics go, "... my dreams AREN'T as empty... ". a minor quibble, yeah, but still... sheesh.
brian37671 1 year ago 9
Too bad Limp Bizkit ruined this song! Noone can do it better Than BA!
RaneMike 1 year ago 2
Amazing, Bryan!! Excellent!! But then I am never disappointed in anything he sings.
what a gifted, talented musician...a genius!
janieusa 1 year ago 2
Delicious !!!!!
Mojowillyray 1 year ago
Look at Moose!!
RIP brother.
THB79 1 year ago
@THB79
You ean Ox
mcd428 1 year ago
absolutely amazing
grindlestheelder 1 year ago
this is freaking awesome. well done bryan.
JennaaaXxo 1 year ago
I want an mp3 to thisd versiooon!
any idea where I can get it?
simpleplanloverrr 1 year ago
@simpleplanloverrr any p2p program (limewire, etc)
mondoguitar 1 year ago
Zach Starkey is the bollox - can hold his own with any drummer
garryness1969 1 year ago
@garryness1969 --agreed ...without a morsel of dissent!
He is VERY talented. The concert(s) for George Harrison--he shines there, too.
The Who-New York shows--he's superb.
rwwagsneb 1 year ago
Feel sorry for the drummer...Living up to Keith moon!!!!!!!!!!!!!! FUCK THAT!!!
vempire2000 1 year ago
great great ! ! ! !
freddywar84 1 year ago
The drummer is Ringo's son Zach Starkey!
widestrides 1 year ago
Wow, amazing. Bryan rocks the Who.. <3
flowerpod 1 year ago
This was in 2001. When he was i think 40 here.
DanielAvilaAGT 1 year ago
I love this man he rocks :D
zjoker0 1 year ago
Bryan Adams rocks! best singer ever!
mauadams 1 year ago
@mauadams Best singer ever? Yah, he is damn good but that is one hell of an over statement!
chucke1963 1 year ago 2
I love this song! It's awesome to hear Bryan Adams sing & of course, The Who is classic. I'll always be a Bryan Adams fan!! Rock on :)
margpisces 1 year ago
10 out of 10 for the drummer, looks rather young to be playing the Who
GeneralDissarray 1 year ago 53
@GeneralDissarray
GD, that is Ringo Starr's son - Zak Starkey. Who was taught how to play by the master himself... Keith moon... :-)
Sardonicus81 1 year ago 2
@GeneralDissarray
it's zak starkey (ringo's son)
grindlestheelder 1 year ago
@GeneralDissarray he's Ringo's son.
Moleyindaclub 1 year ago
@GeneralDissarray The drummer is Zach Starkey. Ringo Starr's son.
702996 1 year ago
@GeneralDissarray thats zak starkie (ringo's son) he was give a drum kit by keith and a drumming leason too
Steelbackuk 1 year ago
@GeneralDissarray I believe that is Ringo Starr's son, Zach Starkey. He actually got his first drum lesson from Keith Moon
brennanh31 1 year ago
@GeneralDissarray Zak Starkey my friend! Keith Moon's godson
Izzibow 1 year ago
@GeneralDissarray
Thats the incredible Zak Starkey taught by The Great Moon The Loom himself
H1GhVoL7aGe 11 months ago
@H1GhVoL7aGe He is also Ringo's son.
aeroman4life 11 months ago
@GeneralDissarray That's Zak Starkey Ringo's son.. He also played with Oasis for a while as well
jimiaxe 9 months ago
@GeneralDissarray The drummer is Zak Starkey... Ringos son!
mattylover 8 months ago
@GeneralDissarray its probably ringo star's son
defleppardgirl2009 8 months ago
Ok.. so I saw Bryan Adams a few hours ago in the BJCC concert hall in Alabama. A few months ago I saw clapton and Roger opened for him. THIS IS PUTTING THEM TOGETHER!!!! Magic. :3
yuhs3 1 year ago
waaaaaa...amaaazing! much better then the original!
it is his voice...it is the special sound of his voice...just amazing and great to listening him. i love to hear him...the way how he´s singing. fantastic!
Mave242 1 year ago
this is cool. only if he does more music with the who how cool would that be
MrSimonmayer 1 year ago
that was awesome!
ekimfloom 1 year ago
this song is fair to say my everyday life. I love it
0000mot 1 year ago
The wrong lyrics are irritating, but its good otherwise :)
gurlpookiegurl 1 year ago
@gurlpookiegurl --ya caught those too ?
Dreams are(n't) as empty, etc ....
I do like Bryan's rough hewn canadian voice---but it lacks the lifetime of survived weariness to pull this song off. Daltry and Townsend can do it.
Still one of the best "Covers" I've heard any one do.
I'd still like Sir Anthony Hopkins to read/sing these lyrics---with his blue eyes.
A James Galway pennywhistle thrown in for good measure...??
rwwagsneb 1 year ago
@rwwagsneb While I love Bryan Adams, I agree with you that he just doesn't quite pull this song off. Having heard both Roger and Pete sing this song over the years, it is really difficult to think that anyone else could ever come close to interpreting it adequately. Roger's version always has that tinge of anger to it, and his voice has a growl to it that I've not ever heard anyone else duplicate. Pete's version has the depth of feeling that only the author of the song could ever truly know.
alcest35 1 year ago
Excellent, Bryan! I'm sure diehard Who fans may have been disapponted that Daultry didn't sing this, but Bryan did kick ass on this song!! YOU ROCK, BRYAN!!!
ceterababe 1 year ago 3
magadia
devadze1 1 year ago
lol he is looking at the lyrics :D good one tho..
TheJuliusJT 1 year ago
Behind Blue Eyes
anurags9810 1 year ago
Love Bryan
furmanka 1 year ago
He kicks ass.
Ilovetriops 1 year ago 5
This is seriously incredible. Bryan is amazing. There is no other Bryan.
I just wish I was born 20 years earlier so I would have remembered when he was HUGE. Selling out arena shows all over the world, because all the videos i have seen of it are incredible.
itsmydestinytolive 1 year ago 59
@itsmydestinytolive
why? he is stil on tour... I've seen him once in 2008 and it was simply awesome. I'm looking so much foward for June, when he is coming again to Berlin... (btw. I'm 28 ;)) So it doesn't matter how old you are, the concerts are still incredible. Visit one if you have a chance and you won't regret it...
JamieKayara 1 year ago
@itsmydestinytolive LONG LIVE PETE!!! LONG LIVE THE WHO!!!
dersh65 11 months ago
2:40
giftysohal 1 year ago 7
This has been flagged as spam show
Bryan, you always dazzle an audience. (because, You are loved by the world.!)
SpaLaLand 1 year ago 2
Comment removed
SpaLaLand 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
He is pushing the phrasing - like he is rushing it.
camcoop25 1 year ago
Wow! Beautiful!!
santamara 2 years ago
OMG... goosebumps :D
laauuurrrr 2 years ago 3
i tell ya. i celebrate his entire catologue. seriously!
igloowompa 2 years ago 2
love the who and bryan, seen bryan in concert near on 200 times and he always knocks it out of the park!
IMHAVINHOOPS 2 years ago 2
Pretty Good! I love the Who, B.A is great too but I rather hear them seperately, this didn't sound like it came from a real place. But he gets away with it :)
jmverhoef80 2 years ago
Oh this is too cool.
MrROTD 2 years ago 3
Great Performance and great music..
stranger571 2 years ago
Ah man, it doesn'y get much better than this; Bryan Adams singing Behind Blue Eyes. I saw him in concert...he is absolutely amazing!
wca85 2 years ago
bryan has a powerfull voice!
madneess 2 years ago 3
Bryan is almost more Daltry than Daltry Im blown away.
MrROTD 2 years ago 2
people say bryan fell off. bryan has certainly not fallen off. he may not command the arena shows like he once did,but he still rocks. his collaboration here with the who is proof that bryan is a rocker at heart and not a balladeer. his gigs are amazing. they rock just as much as this performance.
padawanangelo 2 years ago 2
I think its Zack Starkey on drums (Ringo's son)
coulp01 2 years ago
@coulp01
yeah it's ringo's son
when was this recorded?
poke398 2 years ago
shit, entiwistle on bass, fuck yeah! who is on drums?
elitet0kr 2 years ago
Amazing... best version ever!
AnaBordas 2 years ago
Very very very good stuff
seannymac33 2 years ago
Best version ever!
Gorenatic 2 years ago 3
WoW,
Just so fucking nice,
What a great voice that men have,,
Bolduque 2 years ago
The "And if I swallow anything evil, put your finger down my throat, and if I shiver give me a blanket, keep me warm let me wear your coat." line gives me chills everytime I hear it, Keith's drumming on it is so dramatic that it evokes so many emotions and fits the lyrics perfectly, and the vocal harmony that comes in there accentuates the importance of that whole line as well. I think the original is a masterpiece. This performance is excellent, the singing has pure emotion in it.
NaserMestarihi 2 years ago 10
supurb comment !!!!
kevj247 2 years ago
Thanks!!
NaserMestarihi 2 years ago
this is how it's supposed to be.....best song ever, and cracking performance by all, especially Bryan....
volvot5turbo 2 years ago
he sings this real good in my opinion, has feel and tone
gambit5150 2 years ago
this is not bad at all.......but limp bizkit style is more like it should be :) sad and sarow.....not as live and happy like this......
DiVlJaKzzzz 2 years ago
limp bizkit stole the song....and i thaught it was going to be a disaster when i heard but it was very good....i still like THE WHO'S version better though....
beagler45 2 years ago
whell xD it's not stolen it's just......remade :P
DiVlJaKzzzz 2 years ago
yea stolen wasnt very good word choice was it ...lol
beagler45 2 years ago