What do they want her to do? Belt songs all of the time? Then that would get boring, and she definitely get good comments. I think that the judges have lost thier touch
Season 6 was the best... 5 was close but this one sucks... Jordin, Melinda, Lakisha... powerful voices and consistently giving smashing performances... this year sucks
This performance gave me goosebumps. When you take on a great classic song like this - already brilliantly performed by a legend like Shirley Bassey - you had better bring it all the way.
And I thought Lakisha did. Wow. What a voice she has for these kinds of songs!
I agree with the fella who called this performance underrated. I absolutely adore this rendition, and it still gives me chills. I was surprised at the judges reactions though, they didn't really enjoy it for some reason :-S
LaKisha is not a trained singer. Jordin is boring but extremely commercial. Idol really sucked this year. Hopefully the show is taking a down turn. It's about time.
she is not meant to sing soft like that, but i loved that performance lol, if she woulda just sang loud and powerful tho (without yelling) she woulda had a g00t chance at winning
This is getting on my nerves because you're saying that America would rather choose an unoriginal great singer(Melinda or KiKi), rather than a original potentailly phenominal singer (Jordin). Melinda might be in the top 3, but like KiKi, she's getting kind of boring while Chris is singing really good and being current and modern, same with Blake. Jordin is fresh, original, beautiful smile, amazing personality, and phenominal voice. Why should two unoriginal trained singers beat her out?
Lakisha is the American idol, before i thought her and melinda were even, but Lakisha can hold notes way longer and she doesn't over-riff her songs!!!
She really blew me away with her singing this song. I thought she was the best singer that night. I was speechless when she was done singing. I was like, keep singing....lol
this performance is absolutely beautiful and I`m taking NOTHING away from Lekisha, but come on . . . better than Shirley? Shirley's voice has this smooth melodic calm to it that just embodied this song when she sung it. Nobody's gonna top that.
I don't think Mau's voice is nearly as good as Lakisha's. It's restricted and small. Lakisha is powerful and free. Melinda blew the socks off Shirley Bassie. I listened to Shirley's version, it just didn't quite do it for me. Lakisha does sing a verse differently too. (FROM A JORDIN FAN)
I agree that Melinda's version of ALAHNM is better than Shirley's. I've always found that song boring, and Melinda made it semi-interesting. Still love Shirley though.
IMO, she tried to be too much like Shirley Bassey. When she does that, it invites the comparision. It's a decent imitation of Shirley but it's not Shirley. You'd rather have the real Shirley. Jordin and Melinda both did songs Shirley Bassey has also performed; but they performed it like themselves. That's why they were better.
I agree with you, Daybreaq, I felt she was copying Bassey's phrasing a little too much. She really didn't -- to use Randy's favorite line -- "make the song her own". Bassey's voice is so one of a kind if you're going to tackle one of her songs you at least have to do it completely different to stand apart from that legend.
Mau Marcelo's performance for Philippine Idol is excellent. She interprets the song very well and she has great style and stage presence. But with all due respect, she can't touch Lakisha vocally. Mau hits a number of sour notes, and she just doesn't have Lakisha's vocal command. I'll give a slight performance edge to Mau (although I wasn't crazy about her arrangement) but Lakisha takes the vocal honors, hands down.
I don't know where my comment went. Anyway, I was asking if you can also post the other Shirley song done last night, as well as this one. I'm very glad Shirley got so much exposure last night.
OMG Goosebumps 0.0 especially in the ending
irockvery 2 years ago
she spoilt the song :(. i love shirley, she did not do justice to the song.
h2h3h 2 years ago
I like the ending other than that it was average....
justschr 2 years ago
i love this song ^_^ and she sang it amazingly. loves it! <3
LBreezySnappin2 2 years ago
this is the type of music she should sing
fireandicecube 2 years ago
I love the way she sings this...amazing.
italianluvah83 2 years ago 2
A different version of the original - I LIKE IT! A very hard song to sing except for the great Shirley Bassey, but this is nice too.
Liberate006A 2 years ago 2
1.15 Great! Great ending...
AdianeLee 2 years ago 2
Wow, I thought this song would be a hard one to get right, but her version was AWESOME!
Sparx1 2 years ago 3
I don't care what nobody say! She song this song and was no damn joke!!!
AdonisNinja 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
come on. Lakisha and Bond?? just dont mix....
Dannoo007 2 years ago
i like her ending better than shirley's. she hits a higher note and fully resolves it...
osahju914 2 years ago 6
linda voz!!
paulobenedetti 2 years ago 3
Shirley would be proud! NICE job on the Classic Bond Theme. You got my vote!!
polkadotbox2 3 years ago 5
Her voice is PERFECT for this song...
AbyssalTitan 3 years ago 6
it was OK.
bw100 3 years ago
try awesome!
osahju914 2 years ago 3
I loved it!!!
songbird2875 3 years ago 4
What do they want her to do? Belt songs all of the time? Then that would get boring, and she definitely get good comments. I think that the judges have lost thier touch
ilovemusic4529 3 years ago
ay i really like this...
its different..
but really good...
datboywitdemvocals06 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this song is awkward
dreabatyah 3 years ago
the your at 139 was a bit rough. besides that, no problems, perfect pitch, perfect enunciating
osahju914 3 years ago
I prefer Mau Marcelo's version on Philippine Idol. Check out her video. It'll give you goose bumps as well.
luntianbughaw 3 years ago
Season 6 was the best... 5 was close but this one sucks... Jordin, Melinda, Lakisha... powerful voices and consistently giving smashing performances... this year sucks
mktoatlondon 3 years ago
american idol sucks, all the drama really detracts from the brilliant vocalists!
osahju914 3 years ago
There's drama? I know that there were only 3 or 4 good singers.
AkeemJamalRollins 3 years ago 2
This performance gave me goosebumps. When you take on a great classic song like this - already brilliantly performed by a legend like Shirley Bassey - you had better bring it all the way.
And I thought Lakisha did. Wow. What a voice she has for these kinds of songs!
windigo44 3 years ago 2
I agree with the fella who called this performance underrated. I absolutely adore this rendition, and it still gives me chills. I was surprised at the judges reactions though, they didn't really enjoy it for some reason :-S
chammeroo 4 years ago 4
i love the ending gives me chills
pianoking149 4 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
not her best pormances, i didnt like it
masterchad5 4 years ago
underrated performance, my favorite of hers, after maybe "this aint a love song" and "Stormy weather"
osahju914 4 years ago 2
great job!!! i think idol this year waz a lot better than last year!!!!!
dakrunkest1 4 years ago
as a whole, the top 12 of season 5 were SCORES better than the top 12 for season 6.
jordin kicks taylor's ass though
osahju914 4 years ago
LaKisha is not a trained singer. Jordin is boring but extremely commercial. Idol really sucked this year. Hopefully the show is taking a down turn. It's about time.
jocool5578 4 years ago
Exactley what do you mean by this?
idoltyler06 4 years ago
she is not meant to sing soft like that, but i loved that performance lol, if she woulda just sang loud and powerful tho (without yelling) she woulda had a g00t chance at winning
yojustine 4 years ago
Mau Marcelo of Philippine Idol version is better than lakisha's jones because mau has the voice quality and good interpretaions!
fergsneb 4 years ago
i watched that performance... it was pretty flat... more so than this one
simianantithesis 4 years ago
I don't know why Simon did not like this performance. I thought it was very good.
ABALLAM3 4 years ago
well it just too dated..that was kinda the nature of the theme, though. that's what he was trying to convey. he thought it was good, just old
theforeman118 4 years ago
nah i dont think shes that good
col06 4 years ago
sugarrush has a point she was really good that night but not the best...i would give jordin best of the night with I WHO HAVE NOTHING.
aeboy10 4 years ago
If neither Melinda or Lakisha win then that shows
America can't judge talent and American Idol deserves
to get bashed by its critics. But if these two finish
in top 3 like they should, than i will have even more respect for American Idol's
ability at discovering and showcasing our brightest new singing talent.
Nathan411466 4 years ago
This is getting on my nerves because you're saying that America would rather choose an unoriginal great singer(Melinda or KiKi), rather than a original potentailly phenominal singer (Jordin). Melinda might be in the top 3, but like KiKi, she's getting kind of boring while Chris is singing really good and being current and modern, same with Blake. Jordin is fresh, original, beautiful smile, amazing personality, and phenominal voice. Why should two unoriginal trained singers beat her out?
abangel18 4 years ago
She brought new life to a classic. Not bad for a week's preparation. I think she could be one of the next great singers.
whcoy 4 years ago
Lakisha is the American idol, before i thought her and melinda were even, but Lakisha can hold notes way longer and she doesn't over-riff her songs!!!
eathenallen 4 years ago
She really blew me away with her singing this song. I thought she was the best singer that night. I was speechless when she was done singing. I was like, keep singing....lol
SugarRush1000x 4 years ago
this performance is absolutely beautiful and I`m taking NOTHING away from Lekisha, but come on . . . better than Shirley? Shirley's voice has this smooth melodic calm to it that just embodied this song when she sung it. Nobody's gonna top that.
ho0dfemme 4 years ago
I think Ginas better.
PureConfusion335 4 years ago
i love lakisha and i think this version of (diamonds are forever) sounds better than original.
bussimama 4 years ago
Lmao, has she ever been bad? Every week her and Melinda are just sensational
julialovey 4 years ago
this is what we call "professional"
LocaDiff 4 years ago
She is my favorite girl this season
karly8191 4 years ago
she better win!!!
dmoney6967 4 years ago
KIKI fuckin' rocks big time. She is the BEST, get a grip you deaf haters.
SASSSYBRATT 4 years ago
I wish YT had censored your stupid comments because I find YOU really offensive. Now SHUT UP!!!!!!!
ABALLAM3 4 years ago
Whoo! She brought the CAMPY! So theatrical. Loves it! (boo for going against Lulu's time-tested intuition, though)
TykoEaston 4 years ago
loved it. loved it lakisha. absolutley loved it.
satellitedish 4 years ago
I don't think Mau's voice is nearly as good as Lakisha's. It's restricted and small. Lakisha is powerful and free. Melinda blew the socks off Shirley Bassie. I listened to Shirley's version, it just didn't quite do it for me. Lakisha does sing a verse differently too. (FROM A JORDIN FAN)
Caco185 4 years ago
I agree that Melinda's version of ALAHNM is better than Shirley's. I've always found that song boring, and Melinda made it semi-interesting. Still love Shirley though.
Rosannasfriend 4 years ago
IMO, she tried to be too much like Shirley Bassey. When she does that, it invites the comparision. It's a decent imitation of Shirley but it's not Shirley. You'd rather have the real Shirley. Jordin and Melinda both did songs Shirley Bassey has also performed; but they performed it like themselves. That's why they were better.
Daybreaq 4 years ago
agreed!! I did feel she was copying Shirley, and that's why it didn't quite work.
Rosannasfriend 4 years ago
I agree with you, Daybreaq, I felt she was copying Bassey's phrasing a little too much. She really didn't -- to use Randy's favorite line -- "make the song her own". Bassey's voice is so one of a kind if you're going to tackle one of her songs you at least have to do it completely different to stand apart from that legend.
PrestonPowell 4 years ago
the performance of the first philippine idol which is MAU marcelo is far better than what lakisha shows in this song...
atlantisnhoj22 4 years ago
loved this performance, very ertha kitt sounding!
ksw111102 4 years ago
go kiki go kiki go
adriene00 4 years ago
As much as I don't like Lakisha, I actually like this performance.
abangel18 4 years ago
I LUV THE WAY LAKISHA SINGS omg she sang this song SOOOO good i hope she wins ... either her, melinda or blake ....
SinginSweety432 4 years ago
she should have sang the other song. this was weird.
newdeep87 4 years ago
Awesome, best performance of the night in my opinion.
Yivia 4 years ago
lovin lakisha in the UK! xoxo
MATERIALGIRL1988 4 years ago
isn't she the fav to win this year??
greetz from the Netherlands
goldenToothpick 4 years ago
Mau Marcelo's performance for Philippine Idol is excellent. She interprets the song very well and she has great style and stage presence. But with all due respect, she can't touch Lakisha vocally. Mau hits a number of sour notes, and she just doesn't have Lakisha's vocal command. I'll give a slight performance edge to Mau (although I wasn't crazy about her arrangement) but Lakisha takes the vocal honors, hands down.
melomanny 4 years ago
I have to agree 100%. Well said. Thank you, I don't think I could have said it any better.
Shizdizzy 4 years ago
She's amazing! I'd trade my right arm for a voice like that. She looks gorgeous too!
galadriel6969 4 years ago
check this out from philippine idol version of diamonds are forever.. so much better than Lakisha
search:mau marcelo - diamonds are forever
wildstar07 4 years ago
I love how you can clearly hear every word she sings, unlike someone like, say, Janet Jackson.
yobivan 4 years ago
DAMN! that was some vocal. another voice immitated w/ surprising clarity.
wallykget 4 years ago
I don't know where my comment went. Anyway, I was asking if you can also post the other Shirley song done last night, as well as this one. I'm very glad Shirley got so much exposure last night.
Rosannasfriend 4 years ago
Actually, Jordin sang a song from Tom Jones: "I Have Nothing." Melinda is the one who sang a Shirley Bassey song: "As Long As He Needs Me."
ABALLAM3 4 years ago
Shirley sang I Who Have Nothing as well. Its on Youtube. Ryan mentioned she sang it as well as Tom.
Rosannasfriend 4 years ago
You're right. She did record this song and it made it to #6 on the British charts. I discovered off of Wikipedia. Thanks for correcting me.
ABALLAM3 4 years ago
the song Jordin sang was also by Shirley. Do you think you can post that up. I'm so glad Shirley's music got so much exposure last night.
Rosannasfriend 4 years ago
I LOVE HER!!! GO LAKISHA!!!
ElphieGirl1026 4 years ago