Red Dead Redemption: Video Game Review - Rob Talbert (9.5/10) S02E36

[KillStealer426]

I know am posting this a year later but He does know you can turn the aim assist off right?

[chrisistrippi]

i seriously neglected any sort of social life these last 6 days just to finish the game which i bought this week. so worth it

[Seamighty]

I'm getting it next week so if anyone wants to play freeroam add me on xbox live jannmodifyer

[DoYouFingerPaint]

Ive put over 5days just in the singleplayer, i dont even want to look at multi

[bakuoh]

Thumbs up if you agree! Rockstar has made a game in present time, 1940 Los Angeles and the old west. I want to see a rockstar game in medieval times! That would be one of the best games ever!

[loudmusicman4]

@bakuoh meh, there are already so many games that take place in medieval times (skyrim, for instance) that it would just be white noise. one way that rockstar distinguishes itself is by offering new environments and game settings that havn't been tried before. i don't deny that a medieval rockstar would rule, i just think that genre is full enough as it is

[HipolitoDiaz]

sorry machinima but you gave Black Ops a 10, so 9.5 is TOO LOW: dislike button.

[Sc2mapper117]

This game was THE BEST I've played in a long time. Great job rockstar, this has earned you one more fan!

[MetalSmartie]

your fame never goes down..

[WhiteNinja33445]

This guy is worse than reviewing games than ign

[Maggot4life9slipknot]

I don't get how this game has so much mire bugs than fallout nv but this never gets marked down for it when fallout nv had a lot of crapy reviews for it?

[ThatDude14100]

UNDEAD NIGHTMARE

[brandooooon5]

i spent the first 5-6 hours of the game killing and skinning animals

[Totorosauce11]

You know, you can turn off the target assist. :)

[LoveSarcoptesFilms]

how the hell can black ops score higher than this??

[haters123]

@LoveSarcoptesFilms Because COD is a shit franchise. A Kid console shit franchise.

[TheJklay]

@LoveSarcoptesFilms mad



[TheIcYAssassin]

see im glad i looked at the game reviews i chould get a new game tomorrow

so i was looking at halo reach , skate 3 and now red dead redemption [:

im very pleased at the reviews for this game im gonna get this tomorrow [:

and maybe if i can i whould get un dead nightmare [:

lolz

[SantiiTrucoteca]

10/10



[edhardy369]

0.5 out from correct

[denisiscena]

c'mon guys the game dosen't dezerve 10 out of 10 i think 9.5 it's ok...

[guywithstiches]

i fucking love this game but the multiplayer was bull after a few hours

[TurkeysGoGobble]

this game is a revolutionary game, it got 9.5, black ops is pretty much the same as the other 7 in the series, it got 10. why I may ask?????

[mastermclovin0]

red dead is a good game its just not 9.5 good... and definately not game of the year good, i have it beat it and havent touched it in a looooong time... great story just no re playability

[idontlikeyoubarry96]

@mastermclovin0 Have you not played free roam?

[mastermclovin0]

@idontlikeyoubarry96 ya i have... gta4 free roam is better

[idontlikeyoubarry96]

@mastermclovin0 what would have to be added to make red dead redemption have replayablity?

[mastermclovin0]

@idontlikeyoubarry96 i dont know, in gta4 there was a bunch of shit you could do with friends, gamplay wise (like mechanics, contols, graphics) red dead is better but just the game, because it takes place during that time period, it makes everything you can do so limited... you cant even jack the train, i thought that was bullshit

[idontlikeyoubarry96]

@mastermclovin0 Fair enough, you want something like GTA4. Well at least theres Saints Row 3 cming out soon for that,

[mastermclovin0]

@idontlikeyoubarry96 not exactly, gta4 has already been done, it would be nice to have something new (like red dead) but it not be so limited in what you can do (like red dead)

[FlopsyDiggins]

What's a pop-in?

[expensivetax]

@FlopsyDiggins its when suddenly something you should have seen from the distance pops up

[lukabery]

lol you guys seriusly need to shut up. 9.5 is a great score. black ops got 10 whatever move one children

[hachano24]

I think that Rockstar should make their next game a pirate free roamer. You could get awesome pirate guns, swords, get a ship, get a crew, and travel island to island on a huge map. It would be so awesome to hijack ships and protect your ship from hijacking. Then this idea could lead to better missions like killing a kracken or something more legendary than just walking around L.A with and AK47. I really hope Rockstar gets this comment, the only way they'll see it is if you give me thumbs up

[qwqwq2000]

@hachano24 i like tha way you think

[TheOnePistol]

But cant you turn target assist off?

[walrus141mauler]

this game got a 9.5 but black ops got a 10, bullshit!!!!!!!!!

[topografer]

Machinima and gamespot reviews are the best. About the game i am really happy that rockstar did something else than GTA. First this now LA noire, rockstar is gaining my respect once more, for not letting GTA become the next COD (the most maistream average and for somehow loved by ignorant kids game).

[agentfire102]

if this was gta he would give it a perfect score because well he can't take the fact that gta sucks now and that rdr is really good

[electroplaja]

can someone ewplain how it got 9.5 and not a 10

[agentfire102]

@electroplaja because its not gta he is a fanboy

[NightStreet50]

What the fuck do you care?

It's all a scam anyway.

If you think that even ONE of these guys are legit, you're a fucking idiot.

[NightStreet50]

Fuck me?

I have nothing to do with this.

I'm just saying that there are hundreds of people out there scamming everyday using that exact tactic.

[StephenMcManus2K10]

this guy is an absolute joke.nobody and i mean nobody knows what great games are anymore.this game is a MASTERPIECE and yet it only get 9.5 while that piece of fucking shiiiiiiite black ops gets a perfect 10.are you kidding me?are you fucking kidding me?

[DippersandSmiles]

@StephenMcManus2K10 They gave Black Ops a 10 because these guys are addicted to Call of Duty. They play it 24/7. They would give all the Call of Duty games a great score. Even thought there are so many mistakes in the game that they just completely ignore. I swear while you are reading this comment they are playing a Call of Duty right now.

[StephenMcManus2K10]

@DippersandSmiles yeah i know what they are mate every fucking machinima video apart from about 3 in the past 4-5 days has been cod>:(i fucking hate fanboys of anything

[agentfire102]

@DippersandSmiles if cod was a guy (which its not its a pussy) they would marry him

[DippersandSmiles]

@StephenMcManus2K10 But this doesn't really diverse a perfect 10. 9.5 is really good but we all need to agree that this game is kind of glitchy. But at least this got so many Game of the Year nominees.

[StephenMcManus2K10]

@DippersandSmiles well first i have never had any crashes or experienced any glitches in this game and i really have played it nearly everyday since may 22 last year.other people may have but i definitely haven't.and the graphics are fucking amazing in this game not so much in b-ops.all im saying is machinima directors and reviewers and staff are total fucking cod fanboys and that is just saaaaaad if you ask me they're pathetic and if cod was a balanced and fun,good game at least but its not

[DippersandSmiles]

@StephenMcManus2K10 lol true.

[MrTypicalBadass]

@agentfire101 a pc version would be better. A console can never top a top-notch computer.

[clokedbigman]

@MrTypicalBadass especialy when your computer crashes and cant play anymore right?

or your graphics card cant handle the awesome beauty of this game

Ya Pc's RULE!!!

[reredrumuoy]

you can adjust the target assist asshole i hate ignorant reviewers if there is a negative it better be a true negative

[clokedbigman]

@reredrumuoy ya if they would have noticed it the game would probably made a 9.9 out of 10

[ollobrains1]

stop recommending this crap to me youtube

[alexbeathaloreach]

@ollobrains1 wats the pros and cons of this game

[Hazlett5551]

RDR is kickass no question asked... NO QUESTION ASKED.......

[Arkains10]

...this game is great but overrated.

[KiLLaKiWi002]

@Arkains10 you can't overrate a masterpiece

[Arkains10]

@KiLLaKiWi002 i see it as a pretty great game, but i dont see how it is a masterpiece... sure its stuff is good but there aint too much '' holy fuck , that awesome'' stuff in the game.

[agentfire101]

@Arkains10 your rdr is best game of year

[Arkains10]

@agentfire101 there is nothing mindblowing in the game...

[StephenMcManus2K10]

@Arkains10 are you cracked mate

[ImYourWingMan]

I hate this game...

[Babyjuice333]

How much used??

[brawlboy3285]

Has anyone been to machinima now? Well, if you haven't, let me tell you why I ask. They actually turned Machinima into an ADVERTISMENT for Machinima! I mean, how do I get there?

[Gelenvader3]

a face for once

[xkaizin]

this guy don't know what he's talking about, he gave 9.5 out 10?

[Paddimac01]

@xkaizin yea, but he gave black ops 10/10. watch his review of it, you want an honest review, have a look at ign

[buddyrofro]

I have NEVER been able to play the multiplayer. I hate how you have to connect to everyone and not just one host. Victim of strict NAT

[LLOYD19851012]

the game would be a lot better if it was on PC

[agentfire101]

@LLOYD19851012 nope pc is not the best

[JoschlBoschl]

@tmg331 GET IT!!! It's worth!! You have to play it!! Undead nightmare is so damn cool :D

[tmg331]

should i get this game, or just wait for another gta to come out

[Thelightblade1]

Should i get this or AC brotherhood

[dropdead360]

@Thelightblade1 this, lasts longer, better graphics, cheaper, better multiplayer, better everything :P

[Thelightblade1]

@dropdead360

ok thanks man

[willjon100]

@Thelightblade1 AC brotherhood

[brunobb1]

@Thelightblade1 RDR

[ektor66]

Check out 'Your Review: Red Dead' for your opinion.

[sunsine8675]

Thanks

[sunsine8675]

For xbox 360 how do you use dead eye targeting?!?!

[shadofighter33]

@sunsine8675 ONCE you have gone to mexico click RS and then RB before mexico click RS and then you have to drag your aimer over the person or thing you want to kill. hope that i helped

[TheDiscountFilmmaker]

The target assist is too helpful? You don't have to use Dead Eye, it's not like it's completely necessary, and it's always enjoyable to watch people die in slow motion.

Pop-in issues? I can agree with that, but if you say that you would expect that from this massive game, then why mark that as a negative? Every sandbox game has that problem, and it's barely noticeable, unless you're riding a fast horse in a straight line.

This guy complains about every game except for Black Ops. Load of crap.

[chargerfighter1]

@TheDiscountFilmmaker

But of course, he can't bring down the love of his life (CoD). And if he doesn't like the target assist, he should just set it to Expert.

[clokedbigman]

@TheDiscountFilmmaker to give a game a 10 it has to be perfect...target assist? ya thats not a problem

but the pop-in's are a flaw and even though a game like this is known for those types of issues...it's still there....i imagine thats why they took off the .5 percent of a perfect 10 game

[purplerage96]

@TheDiscountFilmmaker hes not talking about dead eye hes talking about the basic aim assist and hes not complaining hes criticizing but i do agree with you on the black ops thing

[NickTorrance237]

@TheDiscountFilmmaker Yeah, Black Ops is a shit game. Red Dead is what gaming should be. Not dumb ass war games. So sick of that shit.

[MrTehproworld]

@TheDiscountFilmmaker True, if you go on gamefly you'll see the skill rating for every game! the skill rating for Red Dead Redemption is 8.7 and the skill rating for Black Ops was only 2.4 and I agree with that cause you really dont need skills to play Black Ops since there is only automatic weapons.

[someguywithgames]

@TheDiscountFilmmaker and he can change it to expert

[nub924]

Undead DLC is fucking awsome

[matt10897]

@rockerage UC2 its absofuckinlutely amazing.

[matt10897]

2:40 hahahahaha you shot the bird too.

[Kelsor815]

@Commonsafetypolitics Starcraft 2 is

[AdamAus85]

Trivial, but like in GTA4 is there a functioning train service in this game?

[xmikerinehartx]

the game sucks ass. riding a horse sure is fuckin fuuuun. not?

[Commonsafetypolitics]

@xmikerinehartx omg really? Damn, now I won't gonna download the game because you said it sucks *sad face

[CodeNameButcher]

I'm not into Western games, but this game kicks ass!

[AceRadster]

just so you all know the games targeting system can be switched off for more of a challenge or just to make the game that much more EPIC

[ZeppelinFloydRoses]

I tried to find a video where someone says ''red dead redemption sucks''...... i got fucking rick rolled. That's how good this game it.

[xmikerinehartx]

@ZeppelinFloydRoses actually, this is game was the biggest disappointment in my video game history. the chance of it winning game of the year is 0%.

[ZeppelinFloydRoses]

that's too bad :(

[RyanKingGervin]

@xmikerinehartx LOL ur a true dum ass to say that its either u dont have internet or u just dont plain have this game to say that lol funniest thing i heard all year seriously

[xmikerinehartx]

@RyanKingGervin nope, im serious alright.. this game was a huge disappointment to me. everything they showed on the trailers, you couldn't do. i figured taking over towns online and holding trains out, and all this other awesome stuff but u couldn't do any of that shit. the game truely sucked ass. gta 4 was much better. they should stick to gta

[agentfire101]

@xmikerinehartx dont misslead ppl gta 4's free roam was awful there was nothing to do that was in the story rdr > gta4 and technicly they showed everything in the trailers from live game footage they never said you could rob a train or take over towns

[Defekto21]

@xmikerinehartx lolz this game won "game of the year" award...you just dont have taste in good games

[agentfire101]

@xmikerinehartx um no this game is goty

[imangekyo]

i bought this game when i had no internet so i was playing the single player only, that means no side wuest or mini games, just the story. then i got internet back and i jumped online. i lost interest in about 3 weeks and returned game tol get killzone 2. i personally am a linear game person who for some unknown reason hates such blarge expansive options

thats why they said i would suck with an infinite amount of money in school i guess

[rockerage]

Should I get Uncharted 2 or this?

[SullyCentarl]

@rockerage depends on what your into, they are both great games, but if you like open world games or gta 4 pick up red dead redemption, but if u like amazing story and core gameplay pick up Uncharted 2, either way u can't go wrong. I personally would choose red dead redemption because it has more replay value and addictive multiplayer. Also, it's just amazingly fun and entertaining.

[rockerage]

@SullyCentarl thank you for your suggestion, I picked up red dead redemption, great game.

[xXEpicallyInsaneXx]

fuck you talbert you gave this and reach 9.5 they are both 10

[Commonsafetypolitics]

@xXEpicallyInsaneXx no game is perfect

[chargerfighter1]

@Commonsafetypolitics

Red Dead is.

[Commonsafetypolitics]

@chargerfighter1 I meant that as a figure of speech. You simply can't make something that everybody in the world will love/hate. However, I've got SC2 and played with this game at a friends house, and needless to say they are 10/10...for me atleast:)

[chargerfighter1]

@Commonsafetypolitics

To each their own. I just love open-world games, and Red Dead, to me, is perfect.

[mickymousesbesty]

u can turn the targeting system off

[ILoveStupidCows]

9.5 ?! WTF ?! 

[aidanlaw95]

Well turn off the aim assist if its too easy. Christ

[TheMattMX]

@xLASTxSTANDx 14.5 out of 10

[tbilg]

just turn the targeting system to advance to make the game harder

[KottonmouthFace]

eh its alright but its over rated

[SloeElvis]

There is absolutely nothing bad with this game, no reason not to give it 10.

[guitarheromast123]

i hope you know that u can turn off the targeting assist -.-

[SaLVAgEKillZ]

ukno that theres an expert targeting mode that doesn't help u aim.

[THEFALLEN093]

9.9 - 1 becouse my horse is stupid xD

[weeka74]

hey skaternaz that's my opinion if that piss you off so be it you act as if you are the one who created the game mind your damn bs you ignorant piece of shit and if graphics is not everything go play packman you loser !!

[ChadtheWhad]

@weeka74 i think you are the one being ignorant

[hellraiser2345]

I dont like how you gave it a minus for the target assist because you can just turn it off......

[weeka74]

u bought that game last night its not that great the graphics is nothing comparing to other games like Mafia 2 or Heavy Rain people looks unreal hands looks crazy and u cant even swim its boring nothing to do but riding your horse somewhere stupid and dont stand up to all this hype

[skaternaz]

@weeka74

You are obviously An idiot if you believe the graphics is everything in a game, besides I dont know what your talking about. The graphics in Red dead redemption are probably the best I've seen so far.

You just go tthe game Why dont you give it a chance before writting a paragraph about it as if you've played it your whole life.

[MrOnlineSurvival]

Pop in is a downside?? Does anyone really care about pop in?

[MaNgAnlmE]

target assist too helpful? Then use expert mode Problem solved

[superdupersprocker]

why would he fault the game for the target assist??? U CAN TURN IT OFF

[occidotuum]

LOVE THIS GAME!!

[9nxt]

most rockstar sandbox games have pop ins ea: GTA!

[spencerjj2]

I'm gonna get this game once I get the money. Looks awesome, looking really forward to getting it.

[LOLdijust]

OMG why does everyone rate this awesome game 9.5?

every single game has a downside

[YaroKior]

picking this game up today, so exited to finaly play this

[gamemaster123abc]

2 - wtf 10/10 evrything is realistic it is awsome multiplayer singleplayer DlC BEst GAme EVer !0.5 :)

[davo1277]

does he know that he can turn off auto aim?

[TheGanonpork]

XD fame cannot go down

[actionjackr]

10/10 i beat it a few days ago and the storyline is awsome

[alvin1075]

worth watching

[gummystar45]

it took me 4 weeks to finish the story but i was always trying to get the most out of it......i did all the strangers tasks.......and im now almost done with all the outfits

[actionjackr]

@gummystar45 wow dude thats pretty good i beat the story finished half the strangers and got like 4 outfits in about 4 weeks

[linkthehero5]

I would give this game a 10/10 but there are so many glitches in the game I would probably give it a 9.5/10 too

[Spitfireunleashed]

thumbs up if you like the change in direction of the rockstar protagonist being a FAMILY MAN ON THE GOOD SIDE

[electrictiger101]

I WANT THIS SO BADLY!

[theexpelled027]

9\10 the game is wonderful, cept its FILLED with bugs and glitches, both in multiplayer and singleplayer

[chris117mex]

@theexpelled027 all this sandbox games will always have this kind of things like glitches

[xxXST0N3DXxx]

@theexpelled027 except the fact that i saw a flying wolf once i never yhad any glitch.. this game is almost perfect

[zorabr]

fame doesnt go down and i completed the whole story and a couple of gang hideouts in 14 hrs, not 20

[b00mYou]

This is easily the best game I have played, ever. I've been playing for about 4 hours, and I've BARELY scratched the surface and only gotten about 10% through the game. There are so many different activities to do that it's RIDICULOUS.

[gasterboy123]

@b00mYou why you watching the review then

[SuperFunnier]

10 out of 10 the game is awsome,the dlc is awsome,the multiplayer is awsome

[winterbo5]

@SuperFunnier srry i thought you said DICK

[KidnappedbyNinjas]

Cool review here: youtube.com/watch?v=lVqNCfwtKc­4



[cerj4eva]

personally i like GTA: TBOGT better. i didn't think it was worth the money :/

[kookybuger]

can't wait for halo reach he is going to give it a perfect 10

[MrMackan12]

GETTING THIS GAME ON FRIDAY OMFG CANT WAIT O.o ITS LOOK SO EPIC !!

[Dylan6648]

Which is has more stuff to do? Fallout 3 or Red Dead Redemption?