I agree - she has good technique and sings with passion. But a vastly different interpretation. Billy Joel's original is so much more soulful and always puts me in a contemplative, almost melancholy mood. He created one of the greatest modern odes to New York.
The sheer xenophobia of some of the comments here is breathtaking. Most performers would be thrilled to have their songs covered, but here it's treated as "foreign" competition. How odd.
A pretty rendition of a great song, and a fitting homage to a truly international town.
Her pronounciation's decent, i like her interpretation of the song. She makes New York sound more lively, while Billy Joel's bluesy vocals makes New York cool. Maybe, if she ever did go to new york, her experience in New York was a blast?
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
The song is about Billy's home town, New York, from a New Yorker's point of view. How could some Japanese singer who can't even speak English correctly ever catch the essence of such a song?
Most of the water molecules in my body came from the Hudson or its tributaries. This is a wonderful version of this song. I can picture myself sipping a Manhattan in a jazz club with these artists performing.
Billy is great, this version is close...but Oleta Adams does the definative version. Because of the theme of the song, it requires that standard/blues incarnation that Billy and Tony Bennett tried, but Oleta Adams knocks out of the park (Yankee Stadium)
She has a great voice......Great version....The best version is Mel Torme's...Others may not agree....I went to see Billy Joel in London....He did not do this song....Went to see the show to see if he could top Mel's version......Slightly disappointed in the show in that respect !!!!!
She is a talented good singer with good musicians with her, very nice voice and the main thing is that I believe New York State Of Mind. All that jazz!
at least you said please. But seriously, artists who cover the originals are paying homage to the composer. It is a win/ win situation. Billy Joel gets a royalty and the artist gets exposure. This singer did not do so bad. She reached notes even BJ could not hold. Don't get me wrong , I love Billy's compositions and performances but this singer belted this very well.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
This song is dud. And Billy Joel has no talent compared to Neil Young,Dylan and Elvis Costello like Robert Christgau suggested. Listen to real music faggots.
pretty good, I wouldn't say amazing. She def. has a soft sulty jazz voice, and shouldn't push it too hard and the NY pronunciation needs to be worked on....The last raspy scream needs to be cut out, she doesn't have the vocal strength, huskyness or depth to be making such sounds.
She should stick to the more sulty softer jazz repetoire, and stay away from the ones that require a stronger voice.
Wow, this is what I see for the first time. She is very good as always. I love Junko for a long time. Junko san, I would like to hear your beautiful voice once again!! Please come back!!
I would love to have met her in person. The closest I got to here was three or four rows from the front of her concert in Nakano Tokyo 1987 before I could speak Japanese. She had made a fantastic contribution to music and my life over the years.
発音は、完璧どころか、かなりカタカナ英語です。
jiggyteraga747 1 month ago
やはりアメリカに住んでるだけあって英語の発音が完璧。歌も上手いし。この曲はJAZZ風にアレンジするとかなりいい。H.コールにもカバーして欲しい。
takaten17 8 months ago
純子ちゃんは、日本人のVocalistの中でもSランクですね!
applelovesjun 9 months ago
Holy crap that was awesome!
sgtzippy 11 months ago
純子ちゃん!
kojika2001 1 year ago
Shes better than most of the foamdomes on Broadway.
ugha323a 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
歌声に「艶」が出た様に感じます。
Davesque 1 year ago
Wow excellent piano- excellent voice!
Raymond09871 1 year ago
すんげーうま
rihannagoodbad2007 1 year ago
ブラボー!最高です!
tktmp 1 year ago
Beautiful singing!
Coobecaf 1 year ago
Comment removed
fsubang 1 year ago
声が美しいな、相変わらず。
腹から声でてる。どこまででも伸びる声。
外人と歌ではり合える日本人ってこの人くらいなんじゃないかなあ。
mikifirdaus 1 year ago
Comment removed
mikeinn 1 year ago
すばらしいね!
7n4get 1 year ago
Great job on the piano and sax, great instrumentals.
platinumplusenter 1 year ago
I agree - she has good technique and sings with passion. But a vastly different interpretation. Billy Joel's original is so much more soulful and always puts me in a contemplative, almost melancholy mood. He created one of the greatest modern odes to New York.
nooyawkfun 1 year ago
I loooove her voice.. But the way she sings has something I do not like
Fanoulita 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Fanoulita fuck u my mom is a saint so fuck ur hand you fag fuck face break your fuckin back so u can lick ur own asshole
moorparker40 1 year ago
She's wonderful. I love this version. Great voice and a lot of passion. :)
wandawong 1 year ago
this is great, she has a good technique.... But i think i like the laid back, cool and rather gloomy new york state of mind better :)
kamubegoakujuga 1 year ago
Love it !!
070522 1 year ago
Excellent.
KnightOwl2006 1 year ago
...... props!
stairwy2heven 1 year ago
she amazing ,but billy joel's has the new yorkers zing !though she did an excellent job ! i give
stairwy2heven 1 year ago
ahh this is just what i needed.
not too hot, not too cold.
♥
slightliestupid9 1 year ago
凄っ!!
サックスの音に引きずられること無く
音程を保てるなんて!!
「さすが」 の一言です。
mblue3819 1 year ago
Love it! Only heard her for the first time today, but really like her. Thanks for posting!
amylNRG 1 year ago
The sheer xenophobia of some of the comments here is breathtaking. Most performers would be thrilled to have their songs covered, but here it's treated as "foreign" competition. How odd.
A pretty rendition of a great song, and a fitting homage to a truly international town.
artofpoetry 2 years ago 5
@artofpoetry some people just can't spend their time without being idiotic
sternaparadisea 2 years ago
Very nice voice, and feelling too
huszakzsoka 2 years ago
Her pronounciation's decent, i like her interpretation of the song. She makes New York sound more lively, while Billy Joel's bluesy vocals makes New York cool. Maybe, if she ever did go to new york, her experience in New York was a blast?
ninjamole89 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
The song is about Billy's home town, New York, from a New Yorker's point of view. How could some Japanese singer who can't even speak English correctly ever catch the essence of such a song?
getsallad 2 years ago
have you tried considering, that maybe she is from New York, or that she's lived there for a significant amount of her life. Either or.
slightliestupid9 1 year ago
No, I haven't.
If that's true, she didn't succeed in conveying that feeling to me.
getsallad 1 year ago
lmao
ursack 2 years ago
Her accent is pretty good, I actually really like this version :-)
dekoboko 2 years ago 3
yeah, ill stick to billy joel version.
rahnyc4 2 years ago
Most of the water molecules in my body came from the Hudson or its tributaries. This is a wonderful version of this song. I can picture myself sipping a Manhattan in a jazz club with these artists performing.
cpbfox 2 years ago
Can't listen to this. The foreign accent and enunciation just can't cut it.
nooyawkfun 2 years ago
Billy is great, this version is close...but Oleta Adams does the definative version. Because of the theme of the song, it requires that standard/blues incarnation that Billy and Tony Bennett tried, but Oleta Adams knocks out of the park (Yankee Stadium)
weevie99 2 years ago
She has a great voice......Great version....The best version is Mel Torme's...Others may not agree....I went to see Billy Joel in London....He did not do this song....Went to see the show to see if he could top Mel's version......Slightly disappointed in the show in that respect !!!!!
eaglestirreth 2 years ago 2
Very nice interpretation.
She is a talented good singer with good musicians with her, very nice voice and the main thing is that I believe New York State Of Mind. All that jazz!
yourCarlotta 3 years ago 11
This comment has received too many negative votes show
im in an asian state of mind...lol :)
not bad, but not great. She gets a bit flat on mind, and every ee sound is so nasally...kinda made me wanna wring her neck but not terrible :)
crazybeeiscrazyme 3 years ago
It's the accent that makes the E sound nasally.
Mugen123456789 3 years ago
英語圏の人は、多少のなまりを感じるのかもしれないけど,批評を書いている人は外国語の歌をこんな風にちゃんと歌えるのでしょうか。
ビリー=ジョエルより音楽として聴きやすいと思いました。
yourin333 3 years ago 12
@yourin333 普通のアメリカ人はこの人は第二言語を使っていることにさえ気がつかないと思います。
こんな薄いなまりで、間違いと言うより、『味がある」と言える。。
(ちなみに日本語が第二言語で、間違いをお許しください。)
yorinagak 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
elevator Billy joel. This is horrible.
dkshotwell 3 years ago
leave the singing to billy. please.
daznpartypooper 3 years ago
hahahahahahahahahahahahaha ur funny and right
dking2022 3 years ago
haha tell em!
dont mess with the BJ[;
smokinballa415 3 years ago
at least you said please. But seriously, artists who cover the originals are paying homage to the composer. It is a win/ win situation. Billy Joel gets a royalty and the artist gets exposure. This singer did not do so bad. She reached notes even BJ could not hold. Don't get me wrong , I love Billy's compositions and performances but this singer belted this very well.
terestoye 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This song is dud. And Billy Joel has no talent compared to Neil Young,Dylan and Elvis Costello like Robert Christgau suggested. Listen to real music faggots.
everlastingEve 2 years ago
Billy joel has his own talent so dont try compare thats pretty dumb in my opinion !
locosmusic 2 years ago
good rendition.
what a great voice!
theonlyhrv 3 years ago
pretty good, I wouldn't say amazing. She def. has a soft sulty jazz voice, and shouldn't push it too hard and the NY pronunciation needs to be worked on....The last raspy scream needs to be cut out, she doesn't have the vocal strength, huskyness or depth to be making such sounds.
She should stick to the more sulty softer jazz repetoire, and stay away from the ones that require a stronger voice.
ChicLink 3 years ago
lovely voice
RevolutionaryJam 3 years ago 2
Sugoi jouzu! That was great. Done very well all around.
Thanks for the good listen.
musicforte 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
voice is okay...but you can still hear her accent. fucking annoying as hell.
elkeevono 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
She's Asian, what the hell do you expect?
Frostmourne79 3 years ago
Can you sing it better?
rafalweb 3 years ago
hell yes i can
daznpartypooper 3 years ago
Wow, this is what I see for the first time. She is very good as always. I love Junko for a long time. Junko san, I would like to hear your beautiful voice once again!! Please come back!!
blstonee 3 years ago
this is an awesome redition i've ever heard. this is great. LONG LIVE BILLY JOEL- A NEW YORK STATE OF MIND!
bethay12 3 years ago
The best version I have heard, and Ms. Yagami is not even a New Yorker.
blurchin 3 years ago
Wow, 50 seconds in and she's about as close as most people get to being at Billy Joel's level of singing.
Great voice. 5/5
elderscroll4mii 3 years ago 2
ビリージョエルの歌もいいけど、八神純子の歌声もなかなかですね。こんな映像があるとは・・・ありがとう。
sobukoro 3 years ago
Fantastic!!!!
Linda voz e magnifica interpretação.
Parabéns Junko Yagami
Ao pianista e ao saxofonista ótimo acompanhamento. Parabéns a todos.
PrecySP 3 years ago
wow. amazing. at first when i cliked on it, i thought it was a translation. but turns of its great. its just the accent.
thepianolover4ever 3 years ago
Very good rendition. Love the song. Great job!
Brazzle 3 years ago
very nice!!!! i love your voice
MrCrooner99 3 years ago
歌声に「艶」が出た様に感じます。
avon1965 4 years ago
She is my sons friends mother. Her personality is as beautiful as her voice!
robertofredlands 4 years ago 2
I would love to have met her in person. The closest I got to here was three or four rows from the front of her concert in Nakano Tokyo 1987 before I could speak Japanese. She had made a fantastic contribution to music and my life over the years.
billsensei12 4 years ago
beautiful voice!
kiyorose 4 years ago
Great pronunciation かんぺき
aussiemanjp 4 years ago
素晴らしい!完璧だわ up有難うございます。
ice5562 4 years ago