An sich interessiert mich der erwähnte Tritonus nach der 5. Minute nicht, ich vermute, dass er bereits die 12-Ton-Technik von Johannes Brahms auch voraussah. Der erwähnte 'impressionistische' Touch kam ganz gut 'raus. Nur die Nonen hätte ich gerne noch ein wenig mehr gehört...
Awesome arrangement, only one observation: at 5:31 I didn't felt the A sharp leading to the E, perhaps that chord was a little "oversaturated" although the rest of the piece is perfect, sorry for my english.
Awesome arrangement, only one observation: at 5:31 I didn't felt the A sharp leading to the E, perhaps that chord was a little "oversaturated" although the rest of the piece is perfect, sorry for my english.
@leco--and this music, as far as i know, albeit i respect your speculation that it might be austrian nationalistic music, is inspired by Mahler's love for his soon-to-be wife at the time, Alma. You can hear the daydreamy-feeling in the melody and his will to stay away from oblivion; Mahler's fifth symphony is notoriously known to be distraught, expressing his grief of his parents' deaths and other unfortunate personal happenings.
I would very much disagree that it's like brahms--he's more like the bach of 19th century; mahler is post-romantic, meaning he wrote romantic music but later (for example his unfinished 10th symphony) wrote non-tonal music that people now speculate would have become, had he not died, like schoenberg's music as we know it.
I don't think it's 'Impressionist' in the way the French composers & some like them have been called impressionist. Mahler is a 20th C. composer, but very much a Romantic composer (in a way also, the extender of the Rom. era, but that's different). This movement to me really is in the Austro-German Romantic tradition stemming from the 19th C. It's very close to Brahms, maybe not too unlike some Bruckner.
But to me, also, it's clearly nationalist, like Grieg, Mussorgsky, Sibelius and Bartok. This movement, to me, is the height of Austrian 'nationalism'.
In Mahler I really hear exactly what he is - an Austrian-Bohemian composer, though I don't think that can really be called 'nationalist', from that time where this can be called Austrian nationalist. It's certainly strong enough in Austrianness (!) to be that.
Ecco come suonano gli angeli...
Grazie!
SalMessina1 1 year ago
An sich interessiert mich der erwähnte Tritonus nach der 5. Minute nicht, ich vermute, dass er bereits die 12-Ton-Technik von Johannes Brahms auch voraussah. Der erwähnte 'impressionistische' Touch kam ganz gut 'raus. Nur die Nonen hätte ich gerne noch ein wenig mehr gehört...
rlfmoba 1 year ago
@rlfmoba
Yes, Liszt's Faust-Symphony was before Brahms...
DesAbends 1 year ago
@rlfmoba 1905 die 12 Tontechnik von BRAHMS voraussah???
boethius6 10 months ago
@boethius6 Sollte ein Scherz sein ;)
rlfmoba 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Awesome arrangement, only one observation: at 5:31 I didn't felt the A sharp leading to the E, perhaps that chord was a little "oversaturated" although the rest of the piece is perfect, sorry for my english.
armandoorque 1 year ago
Awesome arrangement, only one observation: at 5:31 I didn't felt the A sharp leading to the E, perhaps that chord was a little "oversaturated" although the rest of the piece is perfect, sorry for my english.
armandoorque 1 year ago
im interested to know if they sell this music somewhere and i want to buy it bc i play piano
benjianubis 1 year ago
@leco--and this music, as far as i know, albeit i respect your speculation that it might be austrian nationalistic music, is inspired by Mahler's love for his soon-to-be wife at the time, Alma. You can hear the daydreamy-feeling in the melody and his will to stay away from oblivion; Mahler's fifth symphony is notoriously known to be distraught, expressing his grief of his parents' deaths and other unfortunate personal happenings.
stravinskie3 1 year ago
I would very much disagree that it's like brahms--he's more like the bach of 19th century; mahler is post-romantic, meaning he wrote romantic music but later (for example his unfinished 10th symphony) wrote non-tonal music that people now speculate would have become, had he not died, like schoenberg's music as we know it.
stravinskie3 1 year ago
Gorgeous version. Thanks.
I don't think it's 'Impressionist' in the way the French composers & some like them have been called impressionist. Mahler is a 20th C. composer, but very much a Romantic composer (in a way also, the extender of the Rom. era, but that's different). This movement to me really is in the Austro-German Romantic tradition stemming from the 19th C. It's very close to Brahms, maybe not too unlike some Bruckner.
... cont. >
lecochonbleu 1 year ago 3
But to me, also, it's clearly nationalist, like Grieg, Mussorgsky, Sibelius and Bartok. This movement, to me, is the height of Austrian 'nationalism'.
In Mahler I really hear exactly what he is - an Austrian-Bohemian composer, though I don't think that can really be called 'nationalist', from that time where this can be called Austrian nationalist. It's certainly strong enough in Austrianness (!) to be that.
lecochonbleu 1 year ago
this is impresionist music? o asi se escribe mi engles es mas o menos nomas xD
raig0maru 2 years ago
O.O amazing
musicfonts 2 years ago 2
I didn´t know this version. Thank you.
Edgar1946 2 years ago 2
Any way to get the score?
iroveashe 2 years ago
Amazing performance!
natachu444 2 years ago 8