I personally like the original version better but I still think this is a pretty kick ass cover its really dark but hey, darkness is my old friend and I don't necessarily think it was over dramatized but the half time was a little overboard for me but anyone who loves this kind of music is gonna love this song the band did an excellent job transferring genres even though the original was exponentially better. Oh and very nice job with the video. I thought it was made by Hollywood till I read th
I hate this fucking movie so much. Fuck of Zack Snyder and all the other members who played in this "movie". Did you ever read the comic? Do you know what "reading" is? This version of the song is bad as hell, like the movie. I can't understand why guys think that's good. Piss off, Hollywood! Sorry for my bad english!
Without the violins this version would have no comparison to the original, but for what it's worth it's a more modern take for the busy skyscraper built cities that dominate our world rather than the original which has the aura of mysticism that could never be duplicated.
Some people here say the band missed the point of this song, but I think you are the ones missing the point. It sounds more like a tribute to the original song than a reinterpretation of the meaning of the song. It's like it's saying to everybody "remember the original song because this is how much it rocks."
@lerriano Whys that? I think the point is subjective and personal to begin with, but regardless I think its a good thing different artists reinterpret songs in their own way. I dont think that just because you didnt like this version, doesnt mean it didnt reach out to someone else. Thats just my opinion tho :)
Whether you tell me what you want me to believe the point of the song is or not, I still enjoy it and apparently so do others :) Although, thank you for your opinion.
But the original is already dramatic. That was the point of it. This is just overdone and silly. Trying to take a song as good as this one and switching its genre makes the words meaningless, as if it's all for it's own sake. Or even worse, as a filler cover for an album or a moneymaking rip-off single for a band who are clearly not S&G, but want to steal some of that limelight. And frankly I can only think of a 2 cover songs that missed the point more.
@lerriano music i means different things to different people. I don't think it is better than the original either, it could have been better if the stuck to the first 30 seconds and eliminated the keyboard licks. But this song isn't angry, and the guitars add a dark tone, though the keyboards makes it sound to uplifting. But it's a cover, and they did it their own way. Do you want covers to sound just like the original? I personally think this song could sound better, but hey, it's their cover.
Good editting. Good choice of shots -- it never feels like I'm waiting to see something, nor is anything cut too short. Also even though the high volume distorts the music, it's much beter than most videos which are barely audible in the name of HD quality.
Thanks for the feedback - the only bit I'm unhappy with I think is 2:24-2:26, I think a new shot could have been better incorporated there, but it's all a learning experience.
I personally like the original version better but I still think this is a pretty kick ass cover its really dark but hey, darkness is my old friend and I don't necessarily think it was over dramatized but the half time was a little overboard for me but anyone who loves this kind of music is gonna love this song the band did an excellent job transferring genres even though the original was exponentially better. Oh and very nice job with the video. I thought it was made by Hollywood till I read th
loliamnot13 2 months ago
Love this song and film :)
wiccanbabe23 5 months ago
Como?????
pepemaiquel 6 months ago
I hate this fucking movie so much. Fuck of Zack Snyder and all the other members who played in this "movie". Did you ever read the comic? Do you know what "reading" is? This version of the song is bad as hell, like the movie. I can't understand why guys think that's good. Piss off, Hollywood! Sorry for my bad english!
HellGreetings 7 months ago
with 3 beer this is the rain in my eays
bigboss633 10 months ago
David Gilmour once said that if everyone interpreted a song he'd written the same way, then he had failed...
I think this version is awesome in it's own right. Only idiots would try to compare it to the original, and then whine about how bad it is...
klaustopher1 1 year ago
ABSOLUTELY AMAZING!! IGNORE THE HATERS!! THEIR JUST JEALOUS BECAUSE THEY DON'T HAVE SUCH PERFECT TALENT!!
Ps2Viper87 1 year ago
Nice video, but, and this isn't your fault, the band covering this song, is just not the same and does not sound the same.
CinemaMaximus 1 year ago
Thank You.
sabat1970 1 year ago
That was amazing....
Sillygoose14111 1 year ago
Can some 1 tell the person who sings this!!!!
jokerfan777 1 year ago
Without the violins this version would have no comparison to the original, but for what it's worth it's a more modern take for the busy skyscraper built cities that dominate our world rather than the original which has the aura of mysticism that could never be duplicated.
Good video but seems random in some scenes.
sunny1r 1 year ago
Some people here say the band missed the point of this song, but I think you are the ones missing the point. It sounds more like a tribute to the original song than a reinterpretation of the meaning of the song. It's like it's saying to everybody "remember the original song because this is how much it rocks."
metalore 1 year ago
What... what the fuck is this cover ;__;
6400loser 1 year ago
ive got all le comics im a huge fan but le song is a remix it dosent sound right do you agree
robochip 1 year ago
0:33 Made an Impression on me !
NorseCreation 1 year ago
In the Comedians funeral scene the original fits in better though, it kinda sad, fits the mood
kibbadachi10 2 years ago
Your tribute is excellent i like this version of the song my fav character is Rorschach. I just got the comic book too, it´s great like the movie.
kibbadachi10 2 years ago
I love this version and think this is an excellent video :)
The original version is nice but this one just seems....more majestic
GwapoElric 2 years ago
original version is better
ktm8501 2 years ago
nice cut
sima19995 2 years ago
I like this mix
Drac39 2 years ago 2
Whoever sang this version completely missed the point
lerriano 2 years ago
@lerriano Whys that? I think the point is subjective and personal to begin with, but regardless I think its a good thing different artists reinterpret songs in their own way. I dont think that just because you didnt like this version, doesnt mean it didnt reach out to someone else. Thats just my opinion tho :)
Blindfaze 2 years ago 4
You've missed the point of the song too.
It's not an angry song, they sound sort of pissed off throughout.
And a guitar solo ffs. This song has so much meaning, and these idiots have pissed all over every part of it.
lerriano 2 years ago
Whether you tell me what you want me to believe the point of the song is or not, I still enjoy it and apparently so do others :) Although, thank you for your opinion.
Blindfaze 2 years ago 4
@lerriano it's not about anger... The guitars give it a more dramatic feel. It has a dark tone to it.
thewizardofqz 10 months ago
@thewizardofqz
But the original is already dramatic. That was the point of it. This is just overdone and silly. Trying to take a song as good as this one and switching its genre makes the words meaningless, as if it's all for it's own sake. Or even worse, as a filler cover for an album or a moneymaking rip-off single for a band who are clearly not S&G, but want to steal some of that limelight. And frankly I can only think of a 2 cover songs that missed the point more.
lerriano 10 months ago
@lerriano music i means different things to different people. I don't think it is better than the original either, it could have been better if the stuck to the first 30 seconds and eliminated the keyboard licks. But this song isn't angry, and the guitars add a dark tone, though the keyboards makes it sound to uplifting. But it's a cover, and they did it their own way. Do you want covers to sound just like the original? I personally think this song could sound better, but hey, it's their cover.
thewizardofqz 10 months ago
Agreed 100%
rocknroll015 2 years ago
@lerriano I agree,S&G`s original rocks
Alos21 1 year ago
This makes a better music video than a trailer, but its still awsome
1945redarmy 2 years ago
I was actually thinking that myself lol, but I'm just happy people like it!
Blindfaze 2 years ago
n1 job !!!!!!!
sondaschueler1979 2 years ago
beautiful
massefect942 2 years ago
Man! That was awsome! Gret work! Congratulations! THE BEST!! WOW!
adrianovb 2 years ago
Good editting. Good choice of shots -- it never feels like I'm waiting to see something, nor is anything cut too short. Also even though the high volume distorts the music, it's much beter than most videos which are barely audible in the name of HD quality.
metalore 2 years ago
Thanks for the feedback - the only bit I'm unhappy with I think is 2:24-2:26, I think a new shot could have been better incorporated there, but it's all a learning experience.
Blindfaze 2 years ago
Thanks for the comments - glad people like it :)
Blindfaze 2 years ago
Nice job man
Abno6 2 years ago
sweet man love it!
Zeuspwns 2 years ago
Awsome trailer, but who sings this?
jokerfan777 2 years ago
this remix is atrocity and originaly performed by simon and garfunkel
keiichan713 2 years ago
You may have focused on professer manhatten because he was the main part of the movie
DoctorVanncutt 2 years ago
awesome video but i prefer the original version of the song, although this one seems to fit the mood of the movie quite well
melsinki8 2 years ago