Nightwish - Bye Bye Beautiful - Live at YeboTV

[cosmoscoupons]

Annette needs more lungs :)

[R0xil]

Oh my god, what's happend them...

It's horrible.

[nannebd]

No, it's not. Horrible is your English ;)

[Martuccia79]

che schifo

[Francue]

Me parecio a mi o Tuomas le pifió un acorde en 3:44?

Listen to that chord choir. I think he made a mistake.

[bubbaplay]

Tarja and anette are two of the best live singers i've ever heard

[Falahk07]

you really need to listen to more music

bubbaplay

[bubbaplay]

or i'm allowed to have an opinion... or i realize that many singers are bad live and was pointing out how i think that the vocalists from nightwish are good live.

[kotopoulo13]

but tarja is one of the best live singers!she is rarely out of tune and she knows how to hide her illness when she is ill

[sheronalaskey]

mm I love them!! NOT stuck up at all!! Me and tuomas shared some of his red wine after the show, and talking about edward scissorhands lol :D

[eccentriceivar]

(anette dances) + (bandmates headbang) = balanced performance! :)

[chowderbaby88]

I notice a lot of people complain about Anette's dancing..I find it rather cute! I get the impression that she's a fun person who's enjoying her performance.

[corizomb]

I love her dancing too! It just shows she's not a stuck up bitch -- she has fun playing and that is something I like to see.

[gino101911]

So are you saying that Tarja's a stuck up bitch for not dancing? She put in some motions as she sang. Lol maybe you're the stuck up bitch who can't realize good talent when you see it. It would be really nice to see Tarja do this song although it would sound horrible. Also, I'm pretty sure that Anette's younger than Tarja so she's still got some spunk to dance. I love her style in dancing and her choice in clothes however Tarja's clothes were cooler. tee hee...by the way, who's jukka?

[kotopoulo13]

no,she is older actually but she wants to look younger...

[Piripichongo]

jukka? isnt him a children of bodom guy?

[bagpus92]

annette is 38 tarja is 34

[diana17rock]

tarja is 32 this year on august 17 th sorry for my bad english

[Quarell2]

A little slow

[karoboro]

well i dont like her moves,and voice also but we cant demand from her to be the same as tarja.its not posible.she was the only one.

[darkblackshadow]

i agree not even the guy wants to sing lol and dame i dont like how she sings its not that rockish anymore i like tarja i miss her

[eccentriceivar]

rockish huh?? tarja never sing rockish, she sings classical opera

[GreyMusicLord]

Haha, watch the drummer, he points to the sky with his stick so much. It's cool ever once and a while, but after every beat?

[00ReignShadow00]

Lol. xD

[cookysvidz]

thats called bein interesting an not playin ike 99% of most drummers in the world

get a life

[nightwish4l1fe]

this is jukka's style he does it alot so dont diss it

[xxUltraFreakxx]

Shake that ass Anette XD!

[kingdom1444]

my opinion is you should not hate either singer. they both rule (and are quite attractive in my opinion)

[crvenokosa19]

this is sucks!!!!! tarja come back!!!!!

[plutoniangirl]

Tarja come back and sing this song, ja?! LOL *shrudder*

[nannebd]

y que estas haciendo viendo videos con anette si cree que ella es una "mierda"?

[Kallinzor]

She's great. <3

[pippirippi89]

i like them better live, they sound much better and she sings better

[justanamehere]

Uh, this IS live. You like this sort of stuff?

[pippirippi89]

you retard. i know that im saying they are better live, MAYBE you should sort your stuff

[kukasmonster]

no one is best, anette is totally diferent to tarja. tarja her self made a lot of mistakes live with nightwish too. dont compare.

think its just that they dont have the amplified sound that they used on bigger stages and bcoz of that it sound so empty.

[justanamehere]

"tarja her self made a lot of mistakes live with nightwish too. dont compare."

Oh really? Point out just ONE video on YouTube with the precise point in the song where Tarja makes even just ONE fucking mistake.

[operawithapickle]

At least Tarja always sang the songs the way she sang on the album..Anette sings even her own songs lower and when she cant sing high she either uses head voice or screams..Dont waste your time talking to fanettes,There zombies and just like The nightwish boys blinded by there own words.Tarja is better of without 4 retards and 2 faced fans..If tarja came back(she never will) i would like to know how many would still love there dear Nettie.

[kukasmonster]

no no no...with tarja (after once album) they always plays some songs 2 tones lower than the original so tarja can sing them comfortable

[operawithapickle]

What songs?

[justanamehere]

"What songs? "

kukasmonster is probably confusing Anette for Tarja, as NW certainly DOES drop the pitch to give Anette any chance of trying to sing the old songs.

[justanamehere]

"no no no...with tarja (after once album) they always plays some songs 2 tones lower than the original so tarja can sing them comfortable"

If true it'd be because she trained her voice to go higher and with a different key she could hit higher notes than originally.

I'd have to hear the two versions though to believe you, because a lot of Tarja haters love to spread lies and utter bullshit about her in order to make Anette appear to be more acceptable.

[kukasmonster]

u r wrong, baby, i love tarja, im tarja's fan, but im real, not like other tarja's lovers that put tarja on a trone like a god or something, i will miss old nightwish, but now i love the idea of having a tarjas album, tarja's music style, tarja's thinking, tarja's creativity. just on her own

[justanamehere]

"with tarja (after once album) they always plays some songs 2 tones lower than the original "

Bullshit.

[operawithapickle]

The only mistakes ive ever heard Tarja make were with some words and In 2005 she said her voice was acting up and i think this is obvious..but when Tarja sings live..she sounds better than on the album! AND Tarja is smarter than the guys she refuses to tour non-stop..Protecting her voice and proving she isnt in it for the money...Master passion Nightwish????

[justanamehere]

Yep, they really sound pathetic struggling through a song they wrote solely to bitch about Tarja.

It's a Karma thing I think.

[kukasmonster]

end of an era - bless the child

even she confess (this is real comedy) that when she was making chenge of cloth "the siren" began and she doesnt even finish, she came out in the middle of the song...

tarja is a good singer, a great musician, totally a diva but not GOD

[justanamehere]

"even she confess (this is real comedy) that when she was making chenge of cloth "the siren" began and she doesnt even finish, she came out in the middle of the song..."

Uh, which concert was that? I've never seen what you're talking about on YouTube.

And no, Tarja is neither God nor a diva. Just because Tuomas called her one in a nasty letter he wrote doesn't make it true.

[kukasmonster]

she CONFESS it on end of an era DVD documental and she confess it like a real thing to make fun of it

yes tarja is a real metal diva because of her goood work not because tuomas said so

[justanamehere]

"she CONFESS it on end of an era DVD documental and she confess it like a real thing to make fun of it"

Well you must have a different End of an Era DVD than I have, because all I see on mine is the concert. Do you mean this happened when she performed "The Siren" during the End of an Era concert? I know it didn't happen there because not only do I have the DVD but there's at least a few clips of it here on YouTube.

[SmudgeFish]

well then there's something wrong with ur end of an era DVD. On mine (and most people's) there is a doco. "there's at least a few clips of it here on YouTube." :P

In the doco, when they have written questions and answers superimposed over the behind-the-scenes videos Tarja indeed says that there was a particular concert in which the next song began playing and she was only half changed, and eventually came onstage half way through.

[justanamehere]

There's a documentary on the DVD I have but it doesn't contain what you say. Are you saying that there's a song on the DVD where Tarja doesn't come out when she'd supposed to?

I didn't notice anywhere on the DVD where that happens.

[SmudgeFish]

no. i'm not. like i said in my previous comment, this is part of a written Q and A that is super imposed over the doco. stuff like "favorite moments on tour" and things like that. it is meantioned there.

[justanamehere]

Jesus Christ, she can't even sing her own songs. This sucks, and is just Karma coming back at them for trying to destroy Tarja.

[EnviedCure776]

Her voice sounds strained and not warmed up, so does Marco's! WTF IS WRONG DAMMIT!

[Weepith]

Anette could stop that dancing...

[nikeguru]

I dont like marco in this video....

[madziarra2009]

Marci is funny!!! Anette is THE BEST!

[madziarra2009]

KOCHAM NIGHTWISH Z ANETTE!!!

[Doum92]

When you listen Marco in End of an Era, and him now..there is a big difference :S

[cookiesandslipknot]

is it a gd difference? COS I BLOODY THINK IT IS

[madziarra2009]

I LOVE ANETTE!!!

[lordcendejas]

El sonido no les ayuda mucho pero esta cancion suena poca madre.

[yagamiori2006]

es cierto

[madziarra2009]

KOCHAM ANETTE OLZON I NIGHTWISH!!!

[madziarra2009]

SUUPER! I LOVE ANETTE!

[herej3freak]

this is not the video to judge anyone,they where all sick as fuck,marcu did terribly and anette did so so,but iv`e heard other live performances of the new nightwish and they are quite good,and like i said in the biggining if you keep in mind that they where sick and that the soun tech desserves a horrible and painfull death,they did prety good

[oocoooco]

some of you still criticize Anette's voice live and reproach singing out of tune for her, but please hear Marco in this video. Why noone jeers at him??? his singing is really crap there but everyone likes him so takes no notice of it...

[SkullChained]

I'm hearing the same song as you and I think both Anette and Marco sound awesome!

[WokSz]

Tarja is history. Forget her. Like annette she is WAY better.

[justanamehere]

"Tarja is history. Forget her. Like annette she is WAY better."

I bet you're a big William Hung fan too, eh?

[martyfriedman86]

let's be honest

the record sounded nice.

but her voice live is very weak

she cant hold notes correctly and needs to change a lot of vocal parts to be able to sing them live.

like it or not it was definitely not a good change in nightwish...

her voice may be clearer that tarjas, but she definitely doesn't have a wide-enough vocal register.

she should at least take some lessons as tarja did

[nannebd]

why in this world you think that your opinion is everyone's opinion? well, if the guys think she is good to the band and want to make music with her, there's nothing you can do.

[martyfriedman86]

It's not my opinion it's just what I listen when I hit play on this video.

I'm not saying "she sucks" or "i don't like her"

I'm pointing out things she fails to ahieve and that you can listen and admit them if you want or lie to yourself.

If you listened to this imparcially you would agree her singing isn't great. And that she is another singer in the studio than she is live.

[MuderByDeath]

I totally agree with what you said.

[happyhead64]

and I agree with both of you. Thats why in the studio they have lots of technology to make ANYONE sound like a singer, but live, you get the real feel for the person and hear their real voice and emotions. I think "a little off key" is a good thing, it shows that they are real. I think Anette is just great. I hope she doesnt read these bad comments about her, they would probably upset her, she IS doing her best.

[QueenVirus]

annette rocks, I don't want another Tarja/ridiculous diva!!!!!

[busylovingyou2]

yeah she suks alot i don`t realy like her voice but the song is great i love how Marco sings !! she suks !

[nannebd]

she doesn't.

[Alifve]

Really good song, good voice....but Anette's Live-performance is more like a Popstar. I sure hope she will work on that ^^°

[nannebd]

i like it.

[StoneRevival]

Stage is too small for them!

[motorade]

It was good :)

[wagwagwigwam]

To all that moan about her sounding "shit" live...

at least she (unlikd tarja) doesn't go overboard on the opera shit...

example: the end of Planet Hell at end of an era...wtf was THAT?

[xxxthoughtlessxxx]

The last high note of the song. DUH! And Anette doesn't go on Opera-overboard because Anette CAN'T sing Opera!

[uncrusader]

Disgusting!

[ricsi007]

MARCO Rules! :D:D

[Rune4power]

Perfect live sound quality.. a bit too perfect when Marco sings making it earie "bye bye beautiful"

[loucomballa]

looks like a rehearsal with this sound

[CelyMclean]

Definitivamente la voz de Tarja es mucho mejor en vivo que la de Anette... Uhm... creo que Anette no es el estilo de Nightwish, nimodos... no hay nada que hacer

[nannebd]

Y yo creo que este concierto no es nada comparado a otros más recientes...

[dragonmisfit]

kool band, never heard of that one

[EmppuRocks]

Check them out, it's worth it.

[tigerprince]

nightwish is fucking nuts man. this band rocks so hard. this song is from there new cd called dark passion play. this is there new singer who in my opinion is better.

[EmppuRocks]

Oh yeah! They do rock! Totally and completely. They are totally a band which hasn't let fame go to their heads (stealing a friend's phrase here ^_^)

Okay, man, I'm wondering why in the world Dragonmisfit has -2 on his/her comment. They're discovering a new band, can you demote them for that?

Meh, whatever. People confuse me.

[tigerprince]

lol yeah...anette is really hot too and shes 36 yrs old lol she staed in shape. goes to show you dont have to have a beer belly like most people start to get Haha

[xxxthoughtlessxxx]

Just don't look at pictures of Anette with blonde/"orange" hair. haha. But yeah. I agree.

[scott2008]

Dont forgget she also had a child

[nannebd]

And what does the hair has to do with the voice?

Really, you're pathetic.

[xxxthoughtlessxxx]

I never said Anette's hair had to do with vocals. Read again. S-L-O-W-L-Y. I meant she looked hideous with blonde/orange hair.

[nannebd]

Yeah, and?

[xxxthoughtlessxxx]

That's it. I just think she looks bad with orange hair. Her voice was/is still amazing.

[alucied]

and maybe we are lucky we don't have to see you... I don't get it... you are listening to a band because of their look?

[xxxthoughtlessxxx]

Um no. I loved Alyson Avenue. No matter what Anette looks like, no matter what Nightwish look slike I will always love their songs.

[War292004]

Wow, considering the shit set-up they were given and since they were all sick, they did really good o_O

[christienadia]

someone tell her to stop dancing and start headbanging.

[nannebd]

tell that to tarja too, son!

[christienadia]

I'm a girl and btw tarja does headbang sometimes. i just cant stand anette dancing. not against her though. love the way she sounds in dark passion play.

[nannebd]

sorry, dear!

i love anette own way to move on the stage... as i love the tarja's way.

i don't hate tarja or anything like that

but tarja dances more than anette haeuoaeuoaheoa

[grenade310tri]

anette shouldnt shaking her body too much, and should used to headbang.

[Marsito130590]

jAAJAJAJAJA

THIS IS A VERRY VERRY BAD PRESENTATION

WITH TARJA THIS THINGS DON'T HAPPEND

[nannebd]

your english is the worst i've ever seen.

[wagwagwigwam]

i second that

[DarkSideOfLove]

oh its a really bad live performance

[goddessmystra]

Christ, kill the tech already.

Given the shitty setup and being sick, they did really good.

[ValerioMean1990]

i reLLY, REALLY, REALLY LOVE ANETTE

[LasgalenOsten]

<3 ANETTE, she is the best!!!!

[Naula93]

"and they lived happily ever after after all" ^^,

[Haleth20]

Anette sings wonderful, really. I don't like Marco live though.

Overall, it's very good, but someone did mess up the sound.

[strobelightening]

Yeah, they struggled with an unusual sound setup here. Way too vocal, they actually pulled it off pretty well considering

[marcocallisto]

Annette the best!!!

[wishmaster1974]

someone please murder the sound technician! [2]

I agree...the guy is the worse...

[seriousx9]

someone please murder the sound technician!

[skylinegt311]

yea i know lol horrible job

[imaginary92]

love her love her love her...every song i hear i love her more...especially live...she's greaaaaat!!!really...love anette...

[ImmortalxBitch]

I think Anette's voice works with Nightwish music. Tarja was good, but I personally like Anette better. And she sings awesome live!

[Sidderzx]

Anette and Marco are great! ^___^

[Marczarc]

Great job Marco and Anette! :D

[Shoessssssssss]

Anette > Tarja

Real Nightwish fans accept this.

[themetalcloud]

She is doing great considering she has a cold as well