I'm completely in love with her musical expression. It's utterly genuine, and it is the highest representation of modern vocal jazz. The only way I could improve on this would be to bring back Michael Brecker for the tenor solo...
This is OK, but she seems so affected, maybe it's the pressure of the venue. I still prefer Astrud Gilberto's version--where Monheit tries too many mood shifts and nuances Astrud just gives you the continuous innocence of true love. But I am eager to hear the Flora Purim and Willie Bobo renditions recommended earlier here.
@Canal138 I agree completely. Too many young singers today seem to resort to "vocal pyrotechnics," inordinate attention to stage presence, make-up, and clothing than singing a song simply, but beautifully. She strikes me as more of a theatrical singer than a jazz baby.
@pauldershem And being a "jazz baby" is different from merely "jazzing up" a bossa nova song. Viewing the vid again, I do hear her talent more than b4--but is it augmented or cheapened by the frills, whether the way she funkifies some of the phrasing, strays an already paradoxical song (I'd let you go away / If you'd take me with you) into extraneous echos, pats her breasts, perms her eyelashes, or pushes back a wave of her hair. But there is an inspired jazz-baby moment at 4:37.
When you hear Jane Monheit you almost take for granted his incomparable vocal technique .. because you are struck by a so unique and original interpretation that touches all the registers of the human soul ... and her incredible technique passes in second floor
Tho I adore Jane, her colorful, sweet and lyrical voice, her sultry persona and her humble finish to this tune, no one will quite capture this tune like either Flora Purim or Willie Bobo. Flora's is dreamy and evocative and Willie's...well you'll just have to listen to his version and use your own adjectives - it escapes me how to describe Willie. Vibraphone seems to pair with this Jobim tune, Dindi. Tempo must be slow.
Sultry is exactly the word to describe her... her voice is nothing short of phenomenal... pheromones for the ears... irresistible... it doesn't hurt that she's VERY easy on the eyes, too...
@michaelteter:
Well, I guess that's just too bad for you then, isn't it?
Sincerely,
The Saxophonist Who Actually Played The Tenor Solo, Joel Frahm.
saxnova 1 month ago
I'm completely in love with her musical expression. It's utterly genuine, and it is the highest representation of modern vocal jazz. The only way I could improve on this would be to bring back Michael Brecker for the tenor solo...
michaelteter 4 months ago
I'm completely in love with her musical expression. It's utterly genuine, and it is the highest representation of modern vocal jazz.
michaelteter 4 months ago
This is OK, but she seems so affected, maybe it's the pressure of the venue. I still prefer Astrud Gilberto's version--where Monheit tries too many mood shifts and nuances Astrud just gives you the continuous innocence of true love. But I am eager to hear the Flora Purim and Willie Bobo renditions recommended earlier here.
Canal138 4 months ago
@Canal138 I agree completely. Too many young singers today seem to resort to "vocal pyrotechnics," inordinate attention to stage presence, make-up, and clothing than singing a song simply, but beautifully. She strikes me as more of a theatrical singer than a jazz baby.
pauldershem 1 month ago
@pauldershem And being a "jazz baby" is different from merely "jazzing up" a bossa nova song. Viewing the vid again, I do hear her talent more than b4--but is it augmented or cheapened by the frills, whether the way she funkifies some of the phrasing, strays an already paradoxical song (I'd let you go away / If you'd take me with you) into extraneous echos, pats her breasts, perms her eyelashes, or pushes back a wave of her hair. But there is an inspired jazz-baby moment at 4:37.
Canal138 1 month ago
She's beautiful, sassy and a fantastic singer... Goosebumps time!!!
PSYLLA2020 6 months ago
who would dislike that for fuck's sake??
fadyyosuif 7 months ago
When you hear Jane Monheit you almost take for granted his incomparable vocal technique .. because you are struck by a so unique and original interpretation that touches all the registers of the human soul ... and her incredible technique passes in second floor
AlessandroFortarel 10 months ago
For me and for all Brazilians, listening this song like this, is the same that see someone making shit on Jobim´s Head!
maiararbelli 1 year ago
@maiararbelli Certo. Jane Monheit tem uma linda voz, mas este é arranjo prá gringa. Jeito brasileiro não tem nenhum.
npmaker 1 year ago
Tho I adore Jane, her colorful, sweet and lyrical voice, her sultry persona and her humble finish to this tune, no one will quite capture this tune like either Flora Purim or Willie Bobo. Flora's is dreamy and evocative and Willie's...well you'll just have to listen to his version and use your own adjectives - it escapes me how to describe Willie. Vibraphone seems to pair with this Jobim tune, Dindi. Tempo must be slow.
durgaaa 1 year ago
Love, love this song. It's beautiful.
nobleday3 1 year ago
Beautiful improv at 4:22. I'm not even a jazz fan and absolutely love this whole performance.
richmonksgtr 1 year ago 3
@richmonksgtr You mean at 4:37!
Canal138 1 month ago
@richmonksgtr You mean at 4:37! (4:22 is rather ordinary.)
Canal138 1 month ago
AMAZING LADY, INCREDIBLE TALENT!
ricogarci1023 1 year ago
Finally! Done with raw sensuality instead of pretentious corn.......Bellissima!
terrryc 1 year ago 2
wooow me encanta esta mujer!!! tiene una voz tan dulce que hace viajar a un mundo romanticista!!! wooow!!!
davidayala0404 1 year ago
This is unbelievable! Gorgeous.
LeftofLife 1 year ago
PERFECT!
grotti 1 year ago
Incredible woman and singer.....
shimasamba 1 year ago
Sultry is exactly the word to describe her... her voice is nothing short of phenomenal... pheromones for the ears... irresistible... it doesn't hurt that she's VERY easy on the eyes, too...
Tyrandosaurus 2 years ago
I've never heard this song sung quite so beautifully. This is gorgeous.
Aviva2121 2 years ago 7
@Aviva2121 I agree!
alparet 2 years ago