關楚耀 - 悲哀代言人抄歌抄捉

[kahei4838]

on9 似毛

[supergif]

06年前的:

言葉『僕らがいた』

v=_OjEGEdPp9w

當我仲諗緊以上呢首歌既副歌同「悲哀代言人」十分相近時,

又發現樓主的POST,

我真係搞唔清邊個抄邊個抄邊個抄邊個

唔通咁樣旋律既副歌特別多人用?

[shing0214]

一d都唔撚似



[daniel1994514]

on99



[ka2ss501]

少少似叫抄??

[highhand]

好醒咩,搵到首得一句有d類似既就話人抄

[l0vercherry]

人地抄歌關你撚事咩

[Thefkumum]

正,佢去日本比人捉到=]抵佢死=]

[revomid]

"天下文章一大抄"

pkcopycat係咪畀關楚耀撬咗牆腳所以諗埋一邊?

香港大把歌成句歌詞完整地出現喺另一首歌

又唔見你指責佢?

DISLIKE IS GIVEN

[poker000000]

新垣結衣隻single係2008年10月15日出

而呢隻歌仲要唔係隻single同名歌曲

悲哀代言人隻碟係08年10月22日出

計埋派台時間... 都幾難抄喎

屈人都做好功課先啦

[chris10cm]

屌放呢條片果個 正on9

一句少少唔同既旋律做出黎個feel已經可以好唔同

你死屎啦, 人用youtube你用youtube

用到你咁7

玩針對都唔好玩得咁明顯嘛7頭

[kuku0v0]

甘您都up得出-,-

點解一定要新垣結衣做正版-.-?

咪傻喇呀b.

仲有兩首歌吾似囉好無-_-

[Mrfanclub123]

白痴仔啊= ='

邊fuxk似

[pkcopycat]

@tonychow1017 你耳仔無問題呀嗎,,,應post果個?

[pkcopycat]

@derekli620 what's up 仆街!

[pkcopycat]

@Ovennc on9

[zsavbt]

DD似

[cococly]

on9

[yimmanfai]

大把歌都係咁啦..唔通果d又叫抄!!??

咁你講野..打字..係咪抄人!!

你話人地抄人... 呢d唔係抄呀!!

你唔好話人地唱歌你跟人出黎唱....

[gihjklll]

不嬲創作都係抄黎抄去 難道你用嫁文字唔係抄老師所教嫁野咩?

[rkky]

both songs are good and legit

[TONYbee173]

抄抄抄 抄歌有什麼問題?

像每天愛你多一些 祝福 容易受傷的女人 不是改編嗎?

我很欣賞的

不過 作曲處要說明是 原作的名稱

[hkkwai21]

wooooooooo 抄 張繼聰首 烏龜=.=

[sorrymonkey123]

有無人可以打個日文歌名比我 因為真係好好聽 但上網搵唔到-.-

[tracytamtam]

@sorrymonkey123 新垣結衣 - つないだ手

[zxc5354]

日文歌改做中文歌 有咩出奇 ? 

[lingpakkei]

根本係得一句少少似，你就偏激地屈人係抄



[Lithie]

@lingpakkei 那你从别人钱包偷取一元，是不是都是叫偷？？

[lingpakkei]

@Lithie 我留短頭髮，你留短頭髮，那你是不是抄我？

[Lithie]

@lingpakkei

你搞錯了,剪頭髮本身不是犯法,留甚麼頭也不是犯法,因為髮型沒­有copyright.

但偷東西, 盜用, 侵犯別人的知識產權是犯法的

[lingpakkei]

@Lithie

但問題係真係唔似囉==""

[Lithie]

@lingpakkei

不過 其實如果你看我本來的comment,我沒有偏激的說這位歌手的­這首歌真的抄,只是覺得有點似, 我說的只是很多其他歌手甚至樂隊的做法...其實從其他歌曲得到­靈感甚麼的沒有問題, 但真的要注意有沒有太似, 或者有沒有涉及版權問題..畢竟香港不是應該比大陸在這方面進步­的嗎...

[KeathKong]

咁你想點,

就算抄都抄得幾好呀我覺得, 要左d 好ge 再加d 岩feel ge,

唔錯! lol

[sijdskafkad]

差好遠wo大佬-,-

隻隻音都差幾度

咁首首歌都係抄出黎架la._.

[rickycheng1994]

麻麻地似

[hojicheng]

算好ga la"....算d唔抄d咁囉"

[AtwoodCooper123]

on99

[hemokitty11]

似條毛=.=

[alienvisiting]

yup i agree. it's too similar. but kelvin's song is a more refined version for hk ktv.

[donchu911]

咁都叫抄 = =

[ragnarokice0]

日本音樂領先香港一大段, 井底之蛙會抄根本不足為奇。

[VictorLooser]

幾粒音,幾個 riff 似又話抄...好似近期Mr. 又比人話抄..

 似 = 抄 ?

[sumation1112]

開post o個個對耳生癬啊?!

[kelvinkelkellam]

全完唔似，冇抄!

[chei815]

= =下"咁講明係改編歌"有咩問題?

[edwina888]

原版更好

[hkcfon99]

我諗開呢個topic既人有問題!!!

好多歌都係似既改編嫁啦!!!

如果你咁講janice隻陰天假期抄足tim啦,

都有問題既!!!!

[zxc5354]

@hkcfon99 我都諗住講陰天假期 :D

[atypical789]

我聽晒成首歌, 個intro,verse同bridge 一d都唔似, 係chorus似, 不過唔知係巧合, 定係抄左idea

[swedcious]

邊有抄-_- 只系似

吾好詆毀作曲人既創意

如果你系針對關楚耀講呢d野

我諗你要改變一下你詆毀人既手法

因為你完全影響吾到佢 佢吾系作曲人

[jimtse]

首歌的確幾似 但我覺得無需要小題大做

作pop就係咁架啦

一定唔多唔少係抄

但係都唔應該咁抵毀D作曲人囉

作曲人都係迎合聽眾口味姐

[SIUWRONG]

係鬼抄足呀==

似之嘛....

[luisme719]

chord is similar but not identical... but yeah... can be plagiarized.. but can be not...

[ccue789]

係就係有D似,不過咁喎,我諗都係咁arm姐

[hkmoz12345]

挑

[867868768]

下?-.-

大把歌都抄架啦,fiona都有隻抄YUI啦

[swedcious]

果隻系改編歌囉-_-

[jimtse]

@867868768 你講果隻係改編...當然一樣melody啦- -

[christiantse]

copycat

[digimonsk]

關楚耀 咁似近期疑似吸毒個個?

[tearsangelz]

HE IS

[hkkwai21]

不如聽下張繼聰首烏龜既副歌先啦...

watch?v=vx7_p1OVR0A

[tat999]

又真係好似烏龜 wo

[lt510paul]

two difference song, may be the japanese is copy from mr kwan!!

[f2l0a0s0h]

only a few notes sounds SLIGHTLY similar... the rest is totally different..... I don't agree with your case man

[shummeilei]

我同意你的說法, 就是因為80年代歌曲都是改編自日本, 而歌神許冠傑也引退, 所以可以話作曲人在這年代是斷層的, 如要大製作的歌未必有唱片公司欣賞, 他們要考慮市場需求及聽眾口味的因素, 所以歌手及歌曲質素未必是下降的趨勢。

若有機會與他國家歌星同台表演, 人家一定會尊重歌手的自由選擇, 外語歌也有歌曲是相似的, 不是外國的月亮特別圓, 因有雷同實屬考合而巳。

[Lithie]

是有點似.不過都改了些...

其實覺得hk的所謂樂壇真的很大倒退.80年代香港的歌..8-­9成都是改變日本和歐美的歌曲,不過有寫明和應該付了版權費.現­在越來越多抄歌...偷曬人家的chorus..intro..­.甚至大半首歌,都扮無野還說是自己作.無他的...

不停的抄,只會令自己的歌更加上不了大場面.如果有機會和各國歌­星同台表演.我們hk的歌手就在人家原作人身旁邊唱抄來的歌嗎 ?

[kelvinkelkellam]

唔似

[hkkwai21]

就算係都係Inspired by張繼聰首烏龜啦...大家聽下個chorus啦

[kmlee714]

淨係Chorus部分既頭一、二句似姐=v=

但打把真係誇張左D...

仲有呢個世界有甘多首歌，

撞正似姐-0-

[ansonhk89]

我認為, 從2個版本,編曲和旅律都算是相似的。

但又不需要這麼激動,這些類似個案不是第一次發生吧。

[punkiedog]

respect the original work! the hook of the chorus is exactly the same, property right violation is a serious issue!!

[apple31213]

會不會是翻唱呢@@???

[harsheungtak]

旋律非常似!!

[prinhansonhh]

wow..the rhythm is the same wor..that's copy for sure.. just ignore the difference in language,focus on the rhythm..u'll find how similar it is! damn hk composer...

[siuhahaz]

似咩-3-

[jadefans]

唔似哺......

[kpyking]

Damn it, sounds very similar man. U should report it.

[jameswong0103]

白痴的都知是抄的，他妈的!

[supplierhq]

yes, it is copycat. What a shame... I am so surprise that so many viewer don't think it is a big deal ("你吾洗咁激動丫ma", "唔比改編歌咩"). WTF you people are thing?! If the song is not origianlly created by Ben, he CANNOT claim he is the creator! Feel sorry for people who give the BS excuse to deny the seriousness of the problem. pkcopycat, can you please report it to the japanese music company? thx.

[chowtszkit]

首歌係好似, 真係好似抄, 但佢都唔洗咁講野呀.. 抄歌就鬧人人渣// 扲去打把....... 冇必要gwa""

[supplierhq]

OMG, are you a teenage kid? You are missing the point, it is about "plagiarism"! Ben Tseng stole the song and claimed he is the original song writer, this is very shameful. Look at the "Related videos" on the right, Mark 雷 is another asshole who copys others. If you are the original song writer or the supporter, you have the right to express you anger. Plagiarism is very serious, if you are caught plagiarism in university, you will be kicked out from school, period!

[JOJO128]

下...

我覺得吾似wor...@@"

你吾洗咁激動丫ma????

[PLK122]

你把口咁ｇａ　咁就話人抄歌　唔比改編歌咩－．－

[francescaw418]

有幾分似既...唔當抄捉既...

[smartones888]

not 100%...like 85%

Good Job! I m proud of Ben Tseng, he shows what a Chinese man should be. We Chinese used to invent stuff, now this generation is to duplicate stuff! Ben Tseng u rock! Chinese ppl love U...especially duplicate from the japs!

[gba113mony]

好像唔係哦？