星光史上最难分高下的终极对决!安东尼对孙自佑,双双得25分满分!!!

[angela86024]

你們很專業嗎??若不是專業的 請不要隨便批評人 當然 每個人都有自己的想法 但你們講到塞錢 就太過分了!!

[hses83081]

我是第一次聽這兩位唱歌，無意間找K歌之王找到這裡的。我覺得以­這兩位的水準來說，論技巧，孫自佑確實把一首不好唱的歌，技巧重­現地很好很完整(就像評審說的)；倪安東則是把一首很不好唱的K­歌之王唱得好像不需要技巧，很自然而然就唱完，卻很有他個人的味­道(評審的說法是誠懇)。平心而論，評審的講評還挺中肯的，兩人­確實各有特色，不相伯仲，但談到分數，我不覺得這兩個人有到滿分­的程度，大概還是節目效果居多吧。

[iknowican951]

孫自佑有一段怪怪的 耗盡了力那邊

[kobeatnba]

沒有很高的技巧靠一把天賦的聲音和真誠的態度感動了大部分的人,­不爽嗎?又能怎樣^^呵呵............

[gary88254]

9.33 太正了

[kobeatnba]

@gary88254 我對她的印象也挺深刻....@@笑

[UtotheJ]

seriously?

Can't say anything else, but just this performance, the first guy sounds like any karaoke junkie... no range or control at all... How is he in the same class as the second guy?

[TheBillows]

@UtotheJ totally agree :)

[kpfing644]

不禁懷疑塞錢



[iknowican951]

@kpfing644 塞錢對面就不會滿分了

[brady820830]

那些批評安東尼的人是沒聽到小玲老師說的嗎 他唱的是他的誠懇雖然他沒有太多技巧但是會讓人感動!!

[kpfing644]

@brady820830 吃屎吧

我根本感受不到

別跟我說他是評審所以他感受的道

他出專輯又不是唱給評審聽的

塞錢就塞錢啦

[ttiiyy]

倪安東唱得有特別好嗎?????

[chianhenglee]

我覺得除了相對客觀的"唱的好不好", 個人魅力, 表演的感染力應該也是很有關係的, 這當然應該是評分鐘很重要的一部分吧?

[thencamespeedster]

一次也色泽 Dampnessproof Happy Song

这是非常普遍的在欧洲

[3yeser]

星光大道真是一年不如一年了,安东尼这样的之间都跑音,高音多出­破音居然也可以得到25分?!想象星光大道第一届杨忠伟和林宥嘉­也只有一两首哥得过25分而已,而那几首哥可以说比原唱都要好.

孙自佑唱功还可以,但声音就,唱不同的歌不同的嗓音,这是模仿秀­么?即使模仿秀的能力也远远那不如侒嘉!这样的选手居然也会得到­25分?



[huhuhaha2008]

倪安东真一般。

[oscarjengoo]

孫自佑明顯比較好阿

倪安東不太穩

[jesleneoh]

I like both of the song ! They both sing out the feeling from the bottom of their heart it is nice and when I close my eyes and listen I feel so comfortable and peace . Whenever I feel sad I would listen to this song and my feeling will be back to normal . But if can choose I like the second song more than the first song . Hope all of you can watch his video and incease the number of people viewing this video . Thanks alot , like this programme a lot ! 

[e2525222568]

評審看他帥 想挺他吧 我個人真ㄉ覺ㄉ不值得25分[個人感覺 不需要砲我]

[brady820830]

@e2525222568 妳唱阿廢物

[951sobad]

我相信 可能現場和 我們看影片 的差別應該很大吧!!

[kit33389]

haha haters, he is successful now...

[Sorry86873727]

我覺得反而是安東 跑音的地方 更活化了他的情感 他的演唱 也是成功的

他如果他太注重完美 可能會無法展現他真實的情感 我覺得有加分的 =ˇ=

很完美!!!!!!!! 

[TCTCTC21]

爛節目,爛評審!! 明顯看的出誰比較強吧?

倪安東唱的一堆地方都穩,有些低方還跑音!

[TheBillows]

@TCTCTC21

同意，這大概是星光越播越爛的主要原因

[ironmanla0112]

我也跟大部分人的看法相同..沒有覺得很好聽

這是每個人的感覺不同...沒有要批評的意思~~

那些歌手沒有被批評的呢?~蔡依林?周杰倫?

但是"看"他唱歌有一種穿透性...

而現在評審不是挖掘歌唱高手或天才..

是要挖出有明星光環的歌手~這樣才能賺錢...

[himhim1026]

倪安東不少音都上不到..就算感情補足,也不會25分吧?

[cindyzoehh]

那些批評倪安東的人

有種你們自己唱阿

自己上去阿

還愛模仿勒king990400

你自己也不是會模仿

[tidus1804]

@cindyzoehh 如果自己是九官鳥的話,就只會去模仿

言歸正題

我個人感覺是兩人不分軒輊

[KmusicGod]

我覺得唱的也沒有那麼好 為什麼會給滿分

不是我要批評 評審的標準在哪裡 是看人給分數嗎 這樣其他參賽者很吃虧耶

[bz790502]

奇怪 倪安東 有些地方走音實在有些嚴重耶...

評審怎麼給了滿分= =

[jackhung0226]

@bz790502 會不會影片關係呀

[king990400]

妮安東愛模仿

[chanchengfui]

总觉得倪安东唱这首歌唱的不太好……

[goo6132]

哪有 他很帥-/-

[spp198245]

感覺倪安東在混血兒裡面算醜的= =....眉眼太垂了..很像沒精神...不過倒是看起來超級善­良的哈@@

[tasuki93212]

@spp198245 就是有得垂垂地，有點可憐無奈，討人喜歡耶

[henrysley]

@spp198245 醜得過你@@

[lunaatnyu]

way too many people can sing technically well but only few people can sing with their heart

I love Anthony!

[omfgbanana123]

还是比较喜欢倪安东，唱歌很诚恳

孙自佑太多小动作，不喜欢

[nina70303]

天啊 我第一次看到有人的眉毛比我八欸XD

[lee3]

#LOL @ 9:27

[Rmzizou]

there is a difference when u compare american music and asian music. I myself is from hong kong but i live in the US. The thing about asian music is that everyone is trying to sing high pitch notes...and they think if they can sing really high pitch songs they're really good and blah blah...whereas american music can really careless about the pitch..they simply dont care...but as long as the feeling of the song is right and the lyrics really reflect on sth...the song can be a classic hit.

[egg1080]

安 東尼眉毛好醜..垂垂的

[flora1997811]

咁都有25..

[c3333333335]

安东尼在外国人里不算最帅的,但是很有个人魅力

[love19921213]

@c3333333335 大歌 是倪安東 不是安東尼

[love19921213]

@c3333333335 大哥 是倪安東 不是安東尼

[fantasy6420]

@love19921213 lol what are you dumb? his english name is anthony that's 安東尼 in translation.. lmao

[ahflyy]

倪安東其實真係唔係唱得好好, 只係佢真係好有感染力..

[hewittzhong]

星光6班更厉害吧

[diloluen]

唱得唔係幾好jar wor the one who sing K歌之王

[dwsc1968]

This competition is just about how well u sang but the way u gave to the song. Too much technic or too many high notes, the judges will criticise u. What the juges are looking for are personality and feeling each competitors put into each song. Listen carefully towards the end, that's what the judges are looking for.

[carollamha]

pitchy pitchy.

Love Anthony though.

[Freeze123789]

9:34

超正

[fangfy]

I honestly prefer anthony's voice. I feel that it's richer. (:

[xcheeb]

I think it's unfair for you people to say Anthony didn't sing well. It's because Eason set a very high standard for this song, so it's very hard for the others to sing as nice, which will make people thing their singing sucks.

Anthony is very good, just that not as good as Eason. Definitely still worth the 25.

[on9honkie]

may be you don't have many friends but I know lots of people either singing the same level or better than me.

[xcheeb]

What has singing better than you gotta do with Anthony singing well? Unless you are Anthony. Your friend singing better than you, only either shows that you can't sing well, or they can sing better than you. However it doesn't say anything about Anthony. I don;t see any comparison made there.

[on9honkie]

sorry typo there is "him" rather than "me"

[BKKyan]

@on9honkie "him" or "me" you statement above still didn't say anything about Anthony's voice. I agree with you, Anthony is kinda shaky at the higher part. His voice might not make for such range. However, you only stated his technical mistakes but forgot about the positive characteristic in his voice. Your statement about how American singing contest disregard people background is completely irrelevant to Anthony. Did he miss pronounce his words? Did he not understand his lyrics?

[ericyiphk]

咁都有25分? 我敢大膽說如果呢兩個參賽者晌星光一、二比賽....同楊宗緯, 林宥嘉, 梁文音等人比, 會即刻被比下去.....實情, 星光已經五了, 一蟹不如一蟹已經係好明顯既事實, 還要舉行到幾時呢....

[nelsontio]

我觉得按东尼还可以，孙自又就差远了，我比他还利害，哈哈，开玩­笑。本人觉得还是杨宗伟最厉害。

[kittencat1983]

@ericyiphk 比不上星光1就要停舉 ???

這個比賽的意義在於發掘新秀

俾新人一個舞台和機會去發揮

點可以咁樣剝奪左佢地既機會???

[on9honkie]

This is my first time see them but based on this clip that anthony dude cannot sing high key and miss some pitch through out the song ..... and it's very obvious .... how come the judges cannot get that ??

[leo1300177]

they(judges) know the problem, but his voice,the "pure-heartedness"(诚恳度) & feel very nice, and also he can express the meaning & feeling of this song. this is most important thing which the judges listen to. This is only my opinion.

[dwsc1968]

@leo1300177 Agreed. This guy can't hit high notes that well but it the feeling that he gave to each song. Kindly search for the song "Blowers' Daughter" the song itself is a very low key production easy to sing but the feeling that Anthony gave was attention grabbing.

[Whackydoodle]

i guess the what the judges looking for is the message, he sang with his heart and never designed the song at all, actually its quite nice,

[schoolkid23425]

@on9honkie : the fact that he can sing in a foreign language decently is already amazing. Some people can't even speak chinese without heavy accents. He sings without a terrible accent and he gets most of it right so does it matter whether his pitch is right or not? Kudos to him for performing this song as well as he did.

[on9honkie]

if that's the case then it's not fair, it's about skill and not racial background. if you participate the american singing contest and cannot even pronouce the lyrics right, the judges would not give a damn whether your mother language is english or not.

[schoolkid23425]

What I am saying is why can't we just enjoy how well he sings in Chinese instead of criticizing it like heck.

[on9honkie]

it's a singing contest, not a singing show

and the comment is fair and judge, only stubborn people would take it as criticize.

[remirap]

@on9honkie CUZ HE IS WHITE