Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (631)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • is that bob geldoff on the far right?

  • If Waters and Gilmour decide to make a tour together my life will be complete.

  • sem palavras

  • sólo ha faltado el bueno de Rick....

  • Waters took his lithium! Makes all the difference in the world.

  • manoman i wish i was there rip rick

  • call me puss, i cried when they hugged, and when nick mason was announced.. forget it.

  • lol... i know a jason buck at my methadone clinic haha but if pink floyd did tour id have to call off my marriage and become a groupie. just sayin

  • MR NICK MASON!

  • I think this video is cool!

  • Have they kissed and made up?

  • DEMAIS O SHOW EU VOU A PORTO ALEGRE EM MARCO

  • No hug for David?

  • i have a dreams i hope soo maybe water and gilmou together in bs as argentina tour the wall march 7 ihave my ticket nice video in london

  • There is something very, very wrong with 9 people.............

  • Three out of four. Very, very nice to see them together.

    Everything they touch turns to gold, why fight?

  • roger seemed so kind and generous. i don't understand why nick wouldn't hug roger back and looked like a total sourpuss! :-\

  • Comment removed

  • Saw the Wall last night at Burswood Perth Australia. Wish David and Nick were there but glad we got to see what we did. I saw PF live 1993 and introduced my Aussie husband to the band which he got to see one fourth of last night. Thank you !

  • What a magic moment, what a heaven, what a night!!!

  • This is music and this is heaven . One and the only band ..

  • It's always good when boys can play nice.

  • I am 73 years old and know just what your feeling, some think I am crazy when they see tears in my eyes

  • 73 years old and I know well what you mean.........

  • Wow!

  • Is it just me or is Nick starting to look more and more like Yoda?

  • @ksmithdc Yoda, or Yoko?

  • oh shit. I`m crying... Thats wonderful to see them together. I`ve been in Munich Olympic Hall on 20th of June last year to see the new Wall show. It was one of the most amazing things i`ve ever seen. THX to the rest of Pink Floyd and RIP Richard.

  • the way that it should be..Wish u were here is now about Rick Wright..

  • @rastabean1 Don't forget Syd!

  • weird to see G.E. Smith after all these years on here.

  • Comment removed

  • EPIC

  • Richard Wright should have been there...

    RIP Richard!

  • Dos grandes maestros

  • CHE EMOZIONEEEEEEEEEEEE!

  • God,this brings tears...it's so good to see them together on stage again.

  • If only by mistake they could come together for a last hurray.

  • the 3 coolest old men ever :)

  • for me this is the end of the pink floyd!!! and in italian.. IO SONO TRISTE PERCHE E' FINITA UN ERA!!!!!!!!

  • r.i.p dear greatful songer richard wright!!!!

  • It is nice to see the boys get on well these days.I know they have had difficult times in the past but this shows everything has been sorted out and everybody is happy.

  • Have a look on Roger ! He can't stop to cry !

  • You are the story of music..thank's for all

  • I LOVE THIS indeed i had a tear in my eye

  • when i see ROGER WATERS i´ll always see RICHARD GERE

  •  yessssss

  • @oldboy229 Hehehe, me too! My Polish wife thinks he looks like Roman Polański.

  • @Seanus32 no, looks like Dutch luthier Rudi Blazer, hahaha

  • Rest in Peace Richard Wright.... =(

  • 7.36 "and from us" - notice the word "us". brillaint. absolutley brilliant

  • i saw this show in DC last october. it was the best show of my life... but you fuckers that got that show were the winners!!!! omg

  • Comment removed

  • What a night that was!!!!!!! An old dream come true.

  • I was there that night. What a wonderful event to have witnessed and to remember forever...

  • Hearing say roger US with David and nick togheter is 2 frOcking much thank u for sharing.

  • The day Isaw this I cry like a baby but of joy.... lol so sily and good i felt that day and today I recreated that expirience in a different way I hope for a greater good in mankind they make a new album but is all given yet but I know theres more theres another echoes there that is wishing to be play and the only one cualifite to bring that vibration in soound is u Pink Floyd so I dream on and wish good becuse u still here...

  • Priceless....

    

  • Just in case Nick reads these boards - I have a copy of Nick Mason & Rick Fenn - Profiles, which I've had ever since CDs became available. It's one of the CDs I put on and listen to from end-to-end when I need a break from everything. Thanks for that album too, Nick!

    We still have some walls to tear down, people!

    Peace!

  • Looks like Roger is having hindsight on the lawsuits!

  • This is so damned cool! RIP Richard Wright! Wish you you here!

  • I didn't know Gilmour could play the mandolin. Well I guess if you can play guitar, playing a 12 string or mandolin isn't that much different.

  • rip keyboardist.

  • Gilmour and Mason, come with Waters for the show in Brazil!!!!!!!

  • What a moment!!!!! The 3 of them together again. Pink Floyd forever!!!!

  • Πράγματι! μια πολύ μεγάλη στιγμή για τον παγκόσμιο Πολιτισμό!

  • Os gigantes da musica simplesmente emocionante

  • It's really exciting to see them playing together after their big separation...

  • RESPECT

    

  • 有点想哭,快半个世纪了,还能看到下次吗?

  • Wow. I'm 42, extraordinary cynical, and you guys are kicking tears out of my eyes......

    Thank you all for going above the personal shit.....

  • @tluedeke hey man i feel your comment. i love pink floyd. and i know roger waters is regreting all that time lost.

  • @tluedeke It's not easy banging your heart against some mad bugger's wall.

  • Quem é o cara de boina?. esquisito demais. 

  • @betynbike  g.e smith. acho que éra o gitarrista dos hall % oates. mas esquisito porque?

  • A great moment for their Fans

  • I was there, I must have been next to you or something, I had the exact same view!! It was the most incredible show I've ever seen, and I'll never forget that moment David appeared on the wall, and seeing the three of them stand together. I'm only 17, but this is music.

  • Comment removed

  • @llamagall i'm 21 &i wasn't there.

    now that makes me feel i was born in the wrong country and in the wrong era!

    thnks to utube i watched it.....and I'll never forget it either, you lucky duck! :) ;) :P

  • @llamagall what a show

    i wish i was there im 47

  • GILMOUR VENHA PARA O BRASIL FAZER UM SHOW,....GILMOUR COME TO BRAZIL MAKE A SHOW...WE LOVE YOU

  • more than beautiful!

  • DIOSES GODS!

  • Its always inspiring to see where the artist appreciates your LIVE one shot videoing.My channel has some peeps who want to censor what we [the videographers see.Artists content with there public image and sound.Which ones Pink?

  • They really just don't wanna leave the stage! I reckon they'd live there if they could.

    I guess they regret the lost years.

    Life's full of bitter lessons but it's better to swallow those bitter pills and learn than to spit them out and never have that wisdom that comes from "taking your medicine". They're pretty healthy looking (& sounding) compared to their peers.

    Long Live Pink Floyd!

  • God bless thease leaving LEGENDS!

  • they always seem to be civil onstage...non of the neil young ,steven stills crap!!!oh , and is that G.E.Smith i see next to gilmour?great guitar player!!

  • I'm gutted, I went the day before, opening nite. No gilmore that night

  • Made my day, this did.

  • Made my day, this did.

  • Imagine this was not Pink Floyd. You would say it's terrible ^^

  • who is the guy in the yellow t shirt , did he do a version of comfortably numb with roger waters , im asking because i seen a version of comfortably numb with roger singing and some guy with dark hair singing the " there is no pain" bit but i cant view it anymore because of some copyright shit and i dont know who the dark haired guy was , if anyone can help id really appreciate it

  • Didn't the guy in the hat once play guitar for the Saturday Night Live band?

    

  • INCREIBLE !!!! deberian tomar ejemplo, todos aquellos que dicen que "nunca es para siempre"... seguiremos soñando con la reunion... de 5, ya solo me quedan 3 de mis viejos.... HOY es cuando!!!

  • At 33 seconds david picks a booger.At 36 seconds david wipes it on the back of roger waters.

  • eu choro de tanta emoção, quando vejo eese caras fazendo um show

  • eu faria qualquer coisa para ver esses caras tocando, não existe nada igual a eles, tenho medo de morrer e não conseguir ver um show deles..

  • After watching this video, please watch this other: WpJKPzUtH4Y ... then think about time and what are you using it for.

  • es muy bien ver tres mostros juntos... saludos de Armenia.....

  • Jason..... you are a great lucky man, because you could see them live.

    I am only dreaming of it. 

  • To jest wspaniałe !!!

    Excellent collaboration !!! 

  • THUMBS ME UP FOR THIS  EPIC!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • With age comes wisdom... I really miss PF

  • finaqlly it happened..who sez history does not repeat itself...

  • And now I can say that I have lived. Yet we still miss you, Rick. RIP and the Floydechoes shall continue...

  • It's truly nice to see the remainder of the band together and smiling thats what music should be.

  • i love floyd....

  • i love floyd....

  • Hi I wish you success

  • they do love each other lol

  • ok best band ever right - waters, gilmour, mason, vai, satriani, petrucci, portnoy MAKE IT HAPPEN

  • Jammer dat Pink Floyd geen concerten meer geeft. Samen zijn de heren groots in muziek maken.

  • notice how David is still trying to stay away from Roger even though Roger is so nice and kind to him after all. "That wound is to deep to be healed".... David Gilmour and Nick Mason forever ! Rick Wright - rest in peace, you were magical.

  • Waters, what an incredible person/musican you are. Loved at 7:35 "and from us... Thank you". God bless the Floyd.

  • Brings tears to my eyes...Great post!

  • Comment removed

  • please do this again but in Lisbon!

  • TRE GENI!

  • happy birthday Roger Waters

  • Just love it how Roger hugs with David and Nick, his old Floyd mates.

  • Thats fuckin awesome they are cool again

  • THE best psychedelic progressive rock band of the 20th Century. One could very well say best ROCK band EVAH! and be very close to truth.

    RIP Richard Wright, and don't ever forget Syd Barrett (Wish You Were Here).

  • @Serr8d My favorite band since Dark Side Of The Moon became my favorite album in 1973 and they have REMAINED my favorite band for 38 years! Dark Side, Animals, Wish You Were Here, The Wall no better rock albums than those. The Beatles were good, so was Zeppelin, The Mac, Van Halen, Eagles, Stones and many others. But NOBODY can compare to Pink Floyd, so nice to see the three of them all together again and these little reunions. Hats off to Roger losing the bitterness, friends again! ;)

  • @STEVEMOR909  We agree on that, Serr8d. Thanks for the link. I wept. Tempus fugit.

  • Thank you LEGENDS!

  • Roger really regrets all of the years of animousity with David. God bless Pink Floyd.

  • @javelin1010 Well he has said it before, he was going through some of the worse times of his life during writing Animals and The Wall. But great music came from that, there was pain and anguish in that music as great as it was. I cannot even listen to The Final Cut anymore, but I love The Wall, Animals, Wish You Were Here, and Dark Side!

  • Well if London can do it, so can America-- lets get CCR back together.

  • Nick Mason is the man.

  • I would die to play like david gilmour but I would kill to be roger waters

  • @PINKxxFLOYD well, dying is more of a sacrifice, so gilmour wins i guess ;)

  • @PINKxxFLOYD kill yourself, become both. :)

  • 5 disliked???

  • Where you at VipvipVip Top concert?lol i can see they hand hair

  • The man with the guitar to David's left, is he the old guitarist on the SNL band from the late 80's and through most of the 90's? (sorry if it's longer but I didn't watch it anymore after that) If it isn't him, it sure as hell looks like him!

  • @Luklex2006 GE SMith before SNL he was the guitarist for this band called Hall And Oates..

  • @Luklex2006

    G.E.Smith - Yes, it is him. He's a great guitarist in his own right.

  • I have no words to describe what I feel.

    RIP Mr. Wright

  • Awesome. I have no words to describe what I feel every time I see this.

    RIP Mr. Richard Wright

  • QUIERO DEDICAR ESTE VIDEO A TODOS LOS QUE HOY (AL IGUAL QUE YO) SE QUEDARON CON LA PLATA EN LA MANO Y SIN ENTRADAS...PARA TODOS LOS QUE PACIENTEMENTE TRATARON POR HORAS DE COMPRAR CON SU TARJETA...PARA LOS QUE PUDIERON Y SOBRE TODO PARA LOS QUE UNA VEZ MAS NOS DIMOS CUENTA DE QUE GRAN ESTAFA ES EL ROCK....Y YO QUE QUERIA VER AL TIPO QUE DURANTE AÑOS ME ENSEÑO QUE EL CAPITALISMO NOS IBA A HACER MIERDA! GRACIAS LIVEPASS GRACIAS ROGER GRACIAS CAPITALISMO..PREFIERO ESTAR DEL OTRO LADO DE LA PARED

  • LOL at the SNL guitarist. That guy always cracked me up.

  • @pearlmax Ha Ha, I thought that was ge smith

  • guy at the beginning of the video looks like Richard Gere :)

  • Nick Mason looks wasted..

  • wish you were here RICHARD WRIGHT <3 I LOVE PINK FLOYD -

  • PLUS EXTRA HIPER AMAZING...

  • I wish they remained young forever.

  • When this could happend anything can happend - the World need forgiving and harmony this days

  • Amazing...

  • 4 people should either be inside the wall or against the wall.

  • This is so trippy to watch

  • @jjobie

    Maturity comes with age my friend. Sad but true.

    I checked your channel and i noticed the very fine obsession you have with guitars. I also saw you favoured Smaro Georgiadou which was puzzling to me. I didn't know she's known outside greece. Great style nevertheless.

    Have you ever listened to Dimitris Kotronakis?

    watch?v=EC_jGKtd1Q4

  • What a reunion.. My all time idols

  • Who is the guy in the hat to the right of Gilmore?

  • @caddmanful Looks like GE Smith

  • Makes you wonder if they buried the hatchett deep enough to be able to make new music together......wishful thinking????.....hope not.

  • This is just too beautiful.

  • I was there on that night. Best birthday gift ever

  • My eyes are wet, you motherfuckers... We missed 30years of real music cause you broke it up, and now this...

    RIP you Legend Richard Wright

  • @archimedesnation So true. So UTTERLY true.

    It was all so pointless... the breakup, the lawsuit, everything. It didn't have to happen. Why does it take so long for people to finally understand???

    Ah well. At least they found peace with each other, in the end.

  • @archimedesnation

    you right,absouletly

  • @archimedesnation AND SID BARRETT

  • @archimedesnation I'm moved to tears too. God bless them. RIP Rick. The boys are back in town!