Added: 3 years ago
From: newnikesho
Views: 152,856
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (174)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • dear Muslims this is not a platform to discuss our matters we are discussing it on a non Muslim platform

    i wana answer the confusion of the ppl who gave ridiculous comments

    how can u prove that this muharam procession is unethical?

    i will guide u this is ethical or unethical ?

    read out history of Hazarat Yaqoob a.s,he cried an cried untill he lost his eyesight

    just read out history of Hazarat Owais Qarni a.s he smash down his teeth in love of Our Hazarat Muhammed (PBUH)

    any many more

  • shia 4 ever

  • This is punishment from Allah towards Shias.. i.e. nobody needs to beat them, they beat themselves and will die in doing so one day inshallah... what a great punishment from Allah. Surely Allah knows how to deal with enemies of Islam...

  • these people seem to be worshipping ali than allah.. sunni is the only way to true islam...

  • this is not a mosque, its called husseiniya

  • is this the islam the prophet muhammed taught us? to shout and hit each other like animals?

    astagfurullah

  • may allah bless u ppl

  • if only u knew the reason of this would u understand what is going on in this video

  • I wonder who came up with these rituals....? ALLAH never asked us to do this, ergo to hurt ourselves and / or to carry the burden of our past beloved prophet (pbuh) and his followers and khalifas!! this is men-made - it's very clear! and sad, that there are soooo many followers.

    WAKE UP, o you Muslims.....! Let us all ONLY and EXCLUSIVELY FOLLOW THE QURAN, insha'Allah....!!

  • poor guys, this is what Hindu and Persians 'Majuss' do, NOT REAL MUSLIMS,

  • All Muslims should be allowed to practice there own variation, and we should tolerate what they are, instead if creating division. Common people wise up a little

  • is more like hindu or india (worship with torture)

    Islam are not like this

  • Shi3a are one hell of a joke !

  • why persians are soo...in all who tell them to do this from where has takken this from

  • wow.. shaitan really is doinghis job.. making muslims to fools.. and we muslims are blinded and follow the wrong...

  • you mean you muslims are blinded and following the path of shaitan. these guys are remembering the zulam performed against aimmah masoomeen as. and out of their love for them they cry and beat their chest. let me see if even your mum or dad died whether you would do the same. our parents ghum is nothing compared to aale muhammed's. i can list many things that you believe to be sunnah which the prophet didnt do. likr taraweeh prayers. or the addition in the fajar azaan.

  • can some one tell me what noha is this?

  • LIKE A BUNCH OF ZOMBIES

  • wtf are they doing??

  • its gay pride week at the Shia mosque.

  • Fully agree

  • Oh Im sorry 'Ummul Momineen' Aisha (I think thats what you call her) did Matam when the Holy Prophet was martyred therefore she must be wrong too.

  • The Prophet (صلّى الله عليه وآله وسلّم) forbade barbaric practises like maram, and he said: No harm may be inflicted on oneself.

    Allah Almighty condemns the pagans for the barbaric way in which they would worship:

    Their [pagan] prayer at the House (of Allah) was nothing but whistling and clapping of hands; therefore taste the punishment because you used to disbelieve! (Quran, 8:35)

  • And how on earth does this show respect to imam hussain? answer: it doesnt, in fact it shows complete disrespect. Shia's dont follow Islaam they follow there own made up beliefs and practices that in no way reflect real Islaam. You people are disrespecting your Masjid here, disrespecting the one your trying to show respect to, disrespecting Allaah, his prophet sallaahu alehi wa salaam and disrespecting your self.

  • this isnt islam this is matam u dumb asses this isnt part of our riligion we do this to show respect and love for IMAM HUSSAAIIINNN NABII MUHHAMEDS GRANDSON

  • @tamimi313 LOL HOW IS THIS LOVE? DO U EVEN HAVE COMMEN SENSE?

  • @tamimi313 Muhammad(Peace And Blessings Of Allah(SubhanuwatAllah) Be Upon Him) never allowed this neither did His(Peace And Blessings Of Allah(SubhanuwatAllah) Be Upon Him) grandson....so how is it showing love? also...this is going against Allah(SubhanuwatAllah), He(SubhanuwatAllah) forbid us from hurting our bodies yet u slash and cut and smash ur bodies... u dont fear Allah(SubhanuwatAllah)? wat LOVE? learn Islam.

  • The Prophet (صلّى الله عليه وآله وسلّم) forbade barbaric practises like maram, and he said: No harm may be inflicted on oneself.

    Allah Almighty condemns the pagans for the barbaric way in which they would worship:

    Their [pagan] prayer at the House (of Allah) was nothing but whistling and clapping of hands; therefore taste the punishment because you used to disbelieve! (Quran, 8:35)

  • @MuhammadAhmad1, yea many christians today do that too with all the singing and dancing at church

  • Those who oppose AZADARI are totally ignorant. In fact they do not know that even The HOLY PROPHET (SAWAWS) did weep and cry for IMAM HUSSAIN (AS) even before his SHAHADAT.

  • how can shia people call themselfs muslims?

  • Because we are Muslims. We worship God, we believe in all the Prophets, and follow the hadiths of Prophet Mohammad.

    What more do you want from us?

  • Allah (SWT) has blessed all of us with AKHL. Our Prophet (SAWW) has said 'There will be 73 sects within my ummah, of which only 1 will go to heaven'.

    Therefore it is incumbent on all of us to RESEARCH to be in that 1 sect. How many of you have actually read Shia books written by Shias about their fiqh and aqaid?

  • this is sooo out of controle...shia dont know how badly they are wrong...May Allah guide them and ´bless us all inchallah

  • this is insane. If this is Islam , then where is the religion of peace and harmony. After looking at this kind of videos no non-muslim will ever try to even read about Islam. So please read about your religion and then make decesions. May Allah Swt guide us to rite way. Amin

  • u all who are just against shia ... shame on u ppl .. if Imam Husein had not sacrifice himself nd the albeyt .. islam wudnt b existin ... i swer god guide u all to the beta part ... nd islam even says tht dont say anytin bad about anyones religion !!

  • If you notice the Shia leaders never beat themselves but encourage the dumbasses to do so.

    Also they encourage mutah but if you say to the Imam can I do mutah with your daughter they would say no.

  • i noticed in the description u wrote we do this so allah will love us actually no we do this to show we will do anything and were not beating ourselves and this aint nonsence 4 goodness sake u dont even belive in mohammed so y am i wasting my time!

  • Ignorance

  • unfortunate, deviated from the path lost on their way.

  • y they ask dead pple for help

    especialy ali y y y y ??????????

  • YA ALI MADAD!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • The Imams have knowledge of All that was given to the angels and the prophets. ( Al-Kafi vol.1 p.255 )

    The Imams know when they will die, and they only die by their choice. ( Al-Kafi vol.1 p.258 )

    The Imams have knowledge of the past and future; and nothing is hidden from them. ( Al-Kafi vol.1 p.260 )

    "Bad'ah" ALLAH tells a lie. (Al Kafi, Vol. No.1, Page No. 148. A Shia doctrine.)

  • Why ask a dead person for help ?

    Quran 1:5 "You alone we worship and You alone we ask for help"

  • My brother Jaibajran29,We Sunnis ask Muhammad PBUH not to help us .. but to ask Allah swt to fulfill our need.

    For example.. If a man came to you and askd yu for something.. yu wud hesitate to give it to him, but if yur own beloved son , daughter, mother ,, father , brothers or sisters asked you to give that thing the person wanted , yu wudnt hesitate.. therefore .. we ask Muhammad to ask Allah as his asking will be fulfilled imideately, wa ma alayna .. illalbalagulmoubeen.

    May Allah bless you.

  • 4 ur Kind information in Quraan Allah (s.a) Say Dont say shaheeds r dead They r alive and they r geting food from my side.

  • He isnt. "Ya Ali Madad" = Oh Ali Madad.

    If I say "Ya yourname" doesnt mean I need your help. Ya means Oh. So Ya Daoud = Oh Daoud.

    Also he is not dead:

    [2:154] Do not say of those who are killed in the cause of GOD, "They are dead." They are alive at their Lord, but you do not perceive.

  • did u not read the ayat, "and do not say those who are slain in the way of God are dead, no, they are alive and get rizk from God". Also, remember the ayat, Laa Asalukum Ajran illa muwaddad fil kurbah, I do not want any thanks except love for my family. who said this? Our beloved Prophet, Who are his family, me, u, definately not the first 3 Khalifas. Does Ali the 4th. fit there? His son was killed in Karbala, who is crazy now, we who mourn Him or u who support His killers. Think bhai, thiiink!

  • Have you not read the Quran where it says that those who die in the way of Allah dont count them as dead?

    Therefore Hazrat Imam Hussain (as) and his companions are not dead accoding to the Quran.

  • @Jaibajrang29 Imam Ali was the first Imam, the husband of Bibi Fatima Zehra, father of Imam Hasan, Hussain, Bibi Zainab and yes,...Hazrat Abbas..he was no ordinary man....He was born in the Kaaba....Mankunto Moula..Fahazaa Aliun Moula...just because we call for Imam Ali doesn't mean we've forgotten Allah..god forbid..it's not like one's calling for you..but for a superiour being before our time..who came and still lives..in our hearts..and in jannat....he's not an ordinary person..n not dead

  • If ali was born inside kaaba then please explain me this verse from quran.

    And when We assigned to Abraham the place of the House (Kaaba), saying: Do not associate with Me aught, and purify My House for those who make the circuit and stand to pray and bow and prostrate themselves[Qur'an 22:26]

    it never happened

    you shia's are liars and make up stuff as you go.

  • @whitemintyou so is Ali more importatnt than the prophet (pbuh)?? if not..why dont you shout Mohammed instead of Ali?? and if Ali has more privilige than the prophet (pbuh) as you claim...why wasnt ali the prophet then? why did he just follow? you shiiaa are being brain washed by Iranian liers caliming to be Ahl Albait...they are just happy to control you, get your money, and have mot'aah with your women.

  • @DSSNTC You are an idiot. Shia's shout Im Ali (A.A)'s name A) during a related religious event and B) When something bad happens because of all the suffering he and the other Imam's went through because of you self-righteous sunni's. He wasn't a Prophet because Allah's message to people was completed though the Prophet Muhammad (S.A.). Imam Ali (A.S.) and the other Imam's were there to clear things up and to continue to be an example to live by.

  • Its a Voice against Oppression and Oppressors. But is not it strange that when shia Hurt Themselves, rather than becoming happy, the Enemies of Shia become angry and disturbed. why is that? It means there is something wrong---------

  • harami w r doing right,

  • They are just doing opposite to islam..

    how idiot are they..

    allah said read quran ,hadith and do good deeds.they are just wasting their time..This is not way to repent..You won't leave this .. You will surely go to hell...

  • harami we r doing right u shit bugerz

  • To all those who have commented on this video, just remember what sacrifice Imam Hussain gave to save Islam otherwise, it would have long gone in the hands of few drunkerds. Today you are being recoginized as muslim is just because of Imam Hussain otherwise u never existed in the first place

  • i think its wrong to do this..

  • bunch of cartoons.

    may Allah give them heedayah.

  • lunatics

  • wanted to know is their reward for one to to do this? or is it no better for a muslim to establish prayer and zikr and reading of quran where speicif reward is mentioned...

  • What are you Shia's doing??!!!!!! ALLAHUAKHBAR!! Hitting yourselves in the is NOT THE WAY OF ISLAM

    "...and make not your own hands contribute to (your) destruction..." Al Baqarah, Verse 195.

    Allah does not want you to destruct yourselves with your own hands. Stop this madness.

    Stick to the Quranic teachings, and you know what is the core of Islam.

  • Shias are just following the footsteps of AISHA as she beat her CHEST after the death of the prophet according to 'MUSLIM' and 'Bukhari'

  • i'm scared

  • looooooooooooooooooooooooooool

    shia must us their brains

    they follow iran

    iran was worshping fire and graves

    but when islam came they left that

    but they still worship graves

    thats bad wake up ppl

    this is not islam

  • shia originated from Jewish munafeeqin in Muslim armies back in the Prophet's days. And that is exactly where they get all the similarities from (from ethics to morals, literally).

  • y on earth is the video playing fast..

  • At least they follow the Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) and his family instead of the British Wahabi cultists....

  • they follow zoroastro this is what they follow

  • Ya ali madad....may God guide u wahabi people

  • what does madad mean?

  • help

  • Astgafirullah.may Allah guide them

  • to all my brothers n sisters...

    1st this is not Masjid this Imam Bargah where we do majlis AHLAYBAIT.TODAY, THIS MASJID,THE NAME OF ALLAH(.S.W.T.) AND HOLY PROPHET to all my brothers n sisters...

    1st this is not Masjid this Imam Bargah where we do majlis AHLAYBAIT..MOHAMMAD(S.A.W.S), SALAT(PRAYERS) ISLAM IS THERE BECAUSE OF MY IMAM HUSSAIAN(A.S).we never forget for what IMAN HUSSAIN(A.S) gave such a great sacrifice,

  • Don't waste your time on such brainless idiots brother.

  • YA ALI (a.s) MADAD

  • ali is not a prophet nor is he a messenger he was a humble servent to allah, just like the other companions umar abu bakr, uthman, bilal, etc, we need not you to curse, no wonder why poeple see islam as a evil cult, it is because people like you cause this misconception.

    ISLAM 4 LIFE.

  • @Habbibz91 first of all go and read the history of islam and then come and say umar and abu abkr was the same as imam ali .. we love prophet and his Ahl Albait.. prophet said that i leave you with 2 things before i die 1 is the holy quran and 2 is his Ahl Albait whitch is ali,hasan,hussain. and i am shia and i dnt hit my self like that we only hit our chest very soft ony to show to imam hussain that we still remeber im and we will never for get him.

  • Read this, Sahih Muslim, vol 1 chapter 13 "A strict warning against wailing"

    Chapter 14: "Prohibition of slapping cheeks and tearing clothes"

    Chapter 15: "The dead are punished because of the lamenation of the living"

    Taken from Sahih Muslim Volume 1, compiled by Al-Hafiz Zakiuddin Abdul-Azim Al-Mundhiri.

  • and maybe one can respond to this:

    most sunnis say they have love for ahl ul bayt? where is it? how do you show your love for ahl ul bayt? by loving only aisha and hafsa? they are both critiziced in the quran. for their behaviour against nabi(s). (66:3). look up any tafsir. so wat about the rest of ahl ul bayt?

    nabi (s) said: i leave among u two weighty things, the quran and my ahlulbayt.

    most sunnis show more love to sahaba then to ahl ul bayt? did nabi say i leave among you quran and sahaba?

  • estagfirlullah estagfirlullah estagfirlullah and these people call them selves MUSLIMS cccccc What will i see further

  • i m syed the descendent of fatima ali husyaan if i cry and beat myself bcz of wat umma muslim did during karbala

    i want to ask my muslim brothers why i m not allowed to cry and be sad for wat happened to grandfather in karbla why i m not allowed to curse who did this to my family which the abusafyan maywia and yazeed they were not moman but mushriq why u question us r u allah let allah decide who is right or who is wrong

  • AZADARI & MATAM IS SUNNAT-E-AYESHA as she was the first one to beat her chest after the death of the holy prophet as mentioned in Sahi muslim and Bukhari.

  • This is pathetic but entertaining... They should definately not call themselves shia. Instead label them as a different type of religion. It is said in the quran do not harm yourself. These guys do the exact opposite. Top stuff why dont u guys just kill yourselves while your at it.

  • they must get numb nociceptors after a while so do they feel no pain after years of this practice???

  • lmao o wow this is in fast motion how smart!!!

  • to all my brothers n sisters...

    1st this is not Masjid this Imam Bargah where we do majlis AHLAYBAIT..

    2ndly.. just tell me onething when ur loved one dies what u do?? answer is simple we do cry mourn and so we do ..

    3rdly: we never forget for what IMAN HUSSAIN(A.S) gave such a great sacrifice,, HE gave just to save ISLAM N NAMAZ,, we do practice all those things,

  • who cares where the hell this is, the point is you can continue slapping yourselves like freaks and bleed while doing it if you want or you can try to find another path in your life, if our loved ones pass away we mourn but we do not slap ourselves

  • In Islam mourning is only allowed for three days, Not for life.

    Also Prophet(p.b.u.o.h) said anybody, while mourning,beats his chest & pulls hairs out IS NOT FROM US

  • 1st why u not crying about Probpht Muhammed (PBUH)

    is he not ur love one,and he's hussien grandfather if u dont know that?

    but u should a cry about some one die a long time ago in islam,make no sense

    because there's to many good people die in past time. so very one die we gonna have to cry about him???

    and tell me who save islam is god because he said in Quran وانا انزلنا الذكر وانا لهو حفظوا..صدق الله العظيم

  • shia are not muslims, they kill hussen and ali them selfs and they are crying for them every year,shai'm is nothing but culit, they are not muslim at all,they are the fitna, in islam no wonder why they are only 10% of all mulims put together

  • May peace be upon all of our Prophets, including Mohamed, and all our Sahaba, including Abu Baker, Omar, Uthman, and Ali!

  • Its pretty sad how you look at one small sect of shia's & over generalize the Shia's as a whole... Do you believe that all Shia's hit themselves when they are in a mosque? If you do you are very ignorant my friend... I hope those who watch this understand this only happens during Ashura and it is frowned down upon to take off your shirt and to hit yourself violently and ... As for comparing saints to our Imam's the Prophet(pbuh) directly said who the khalef should be after he died

  • again ur the ignorant, not me or u back than were alive,make nosense talking about the Khaleefah

    u abo bakar and omar and otham and ali are all the same and equal make no big deal the are the Propht Friends

    but who we ??? to discuss all this things now what u know to camper's or self to them

  • ey heres a thought..... alot of the prophets where touchered including prophet Mohammad (saw) when he was spreading the message, Isa, Ibrahim alot and alot almost all(saw)... sooo whyy is it only the hussein that u guys mourn his toucher !! i bet you that if ali(saw) seen this he would be truly ashamed!

  • dont tell us what ali would say bcuz he was imam husseins fathe....and imam husseinand the rest all suffered horrible deaths

  • Yes i can Prove by Saying Bismillah Arahmani Arahim....The Prophet Mohammad (SAW) said, "Pray as you have seen me praying.." Do you Shia people pray like the way he used to pray??

  • hahahahahahahahahahaaha lmao!!!!muhahaahahahahahaha

  • yet again i see more and more brainwashed wahabis trying to descredit the shia faith

    you need to first go and defend things which are said, about your lies which you have spread and turned our faith into hate campaigns for the non believers

    i will ask any wahabi scum

    PROVE US SHIA ARE WRONG?

  • want me to prove shia are wrong? mutaa has lead to the spread of HIV/AIDS in our shia community here in my suburb. how can god permit mutaa if it is leading to the deaths of so many young muslims?

  • you want me to prove shia wrong? the allowance of mutaa in shiite has lead to the spread of HIV/AIDS in our shiite community here in my city. how can god permitted something that is leading to the deaths of so many young people, and also causing dozens of children to be born out of marriage into single mother families?

  • i pity u al 4 calling shia muslims kafir.

    do u even know anything abt history of islam? obviously not. at da time of Adam dere was no islam how do u tink he obeyd Allah? Adam mentioned names of Mohammad n his family. i pity u al ignorants!

  • SUBHANNAL-LAH,WHAT INNOVATION?,OK IF MEN HAVE TO DO THIS,WHAT ABOUT WOMEN?,THEY HAVE TO TAKE OFF THEIR CLOTHS TO?? LA ILAHA ILLAL-LAHU MUHAMMADU RASULLUL-LAHI (P.B.U.H) .ALSHREEKS (INNOVATION) IS DOLLALAT ,AND ALL DOLLALAT FIIN -NARR,WA-IIYAZZU-BILAH,MAY ALLAH PROTECT ISLAM...Ameeenn

  • like the old jews and cristian, also the shia are try to chenge the what ALLAH swt has send to the menkind.

    but noooo wayyyy

    " ALLAH swt ll bee copmlate his light "

  • ur trying to be funny by making the video move faster. wats the point?

  • its just sad that some of you can not speak with a good tongue, instead you just accuse the Shiah brothers and sisters of being kufars and dumb etc....

    It shows how much fabrication is being spread within your sect...thank Umar, Abu Bakr and Osman for that :)...also...for those with titles such as 'muawiya4lyf' i feel sorry for you..hopefully you will read about how much of a Munafiqeen he really was :)

    Ya Allah, Ya Ali madad

  • all i have to say is....

    may Allah (s.w.a) guide the brothers and sisters of the Ahlul Sunnah to the right path, inshallah they will understand the reason behind azadari instead of just saying bidah and shirk...

  • God, they look possed...

  • instead of worshipping Allah in his house, like the prophet peace upon him, and imam Ali may Allah please him, did in the mosque! these shiites hit themselves thinking Allah would love them for that instaed of reading quran and praying!?!?

  • What made you think that shia's dont read quran and pray and only other do. Shias ofcourse read Quran and Pray that is farz. What you are seeing in this video is to show of love to Imam Hussain and his family who was killed in Karbala. Everyone has a style of showing love and Shia's have their own. read my other comment that explains further. You need to do good research with unbiased angle to really know the facts and reasons behind anything. Dont judge on what it appears to your eyes.

  • it is not a mosque. It is a imam bargah. we make a diffrent between those things.

    in a mosque we dont du matam and azadari

    sorry for mx English

  • shia is not islam

  • Prophet Muhammad(P.B.U.h) said: Pray as you see me praying....,where these peoples come from???/..lol

  • Shias are not ignorant but lunatic.

  • Allah says The Prophet (SAW) is more worthy of the believers than themselves, and His wives are their mothers(33:6) . According to Quran, Wives of Holy Prophet are the mothers of believers. Shias accept that Aisha(RA) and Hafsa(RA) their spiritual mothers?.If shias dont then tell me what is your position in Islam?. Deny one verse of Quran mean deny whole Quran which mean shia are still Muslim?. Please comments

  • Allah says The Prophet (SAW) is more worthy of the believers than themselves, and His wives are their mothers(33:6) . According to Quran, Wives of Holy Prophet are the mothers of believers. Shias accept that Aisha(RA) and Hafsa(RA) their spiritual mothers?.If shias dont then tell me what is your position in Islam?. Deny one verse of Quran mean deny whole Quran which mean shia are still Muslim?. Please comments

  • Allah says The Prophet (SAW) is more worthy of the believers than themselves, and His wives are their mothers(33:6) . According to Quran, Wives of Holy Prophet are the mothers of believers. Shias accept that Aisha(RA) and Hafsa(RA) their spiritual mothers?.If you(shias) dont then tell me what is your position in Islam?. Deny one verse of Quran mean deny whole Quran which mean shia are still Muslim?. Please comments

  • Allah says The Prophet (SAW) is more worthy of the believers than themselves, and His wives are their mothers(33:6) . According to Quran, Wives of Holy Prophet are the mothers of believers. Shias accept that Aisha(RA) and Hafsa(RA) their spiritual mothers?.If you(shias) dont then tell me what is your position in Islam?. Deny one verse of Quran mean deny whole Quran which mean shia are still Muslim?. Please comments.

  • Most of you giving negative comments above with authority are ignorant to a degree like Americans ignorance about Islam. The people in the video are commemorating the massacre of the prophets family. If you love Muhammad then you should love his family too. Feel the pain they went through unless you are from the side who inflicted the pain. Dont sit on the sidelines. You have to be either with the prophet's family or against it. You cant tell what is the right way to show love. Only Allah can

  • there is a way to be on the prophets peace be upon him side its the way that the prophet (pbuh) taught us, that is by making duaa and worship of Allah NOT beating ourselfs and drumming, the propets family are not the first of prophets to get murderedm if what you are doing is correct we would do this for all the prophet killed by bani-israel

  • How can you define what is the right way to show love to anyone... This depends on an individual. When someone's family is killed in Iraq or Gaza brutally, you cant tell them how to show their love. It depends on the intensity they feel. Also it doesn't matter what others do for families of other prophet as we are not from their umat. Since we are from our prophet's umat, we commorate for him and his family. By your comments it appears that you treat our prophet the same as other prophets

  • Allah through his prophet peace be upon him showed us how to show love for the prophet peace be upon him

    that is by following everything he did and doing lots of salah on him

  • i know bro but in ashura we read quran through out the first hour and pray than when they finish who ever wants to stick around and do latmiya its their choice u get it?

  • That is right. The sunnis follow the prophet peace be upon him, rather then men that were leaders a few hundred years ago. Shia reminds me of catholics-they emphasise more on 'saints' then jesus himself.

  • beating our chests is only a metaphor during the month of muharram. we want to feel at least 1% of imam hussein's pain of what he went through. this is not nonsense. you should learn more about the logical aspects of shia islam.

  • I dont think god wants humans to permamently damage their health to feel pain in order to remember a man who was not even a compainion to the prohpet. Do you shiites have ANY hadith, sunna, or quran to support your idea that you should beat, cut and mutilate yourself?

  • FEDATO3...why u worry about it ? we r damaging ourself cutting ourself and watever u said ...this is called beleive okay? and u don have to worry about it , its just the beleivers and the Allah ,Hussain (A.S),Ali (A.S), its not the matter between you and us its the matter between our beleive and oppar wala...Got my point?

  • brother the only reason there is Sunni and shia is because of political reasons and for power the shia way is the right way that's why u see these days Saudi Arabia with money and these other rich arab countries that r Sunni's and another thing i know u heard of imam Ali a.s u also heard what kinda person he was do you deny he was a good servant to allah? after what u heard about him the good stories morals?

  • i will never stand for anyone to degrade Ali radiya allahu anhu and alhamdulilah we sunnis dont curse him or any of the sahaba and that has nothing to do with greedy men in power today

  • bismillahirahmaniraheem. what happened in karbela was a true tragedy and these shias who are only showing sympathy are on the right path. you sunnis believe in ashura but you do not show your sympathy. may god bless shias

  • this isn't a mosque you GOOF its a Hussaniah.

  • the prophet (s.a.w) said hitting or hurting ur body which allah gave u is a sin.

    how could u do this in the house of the almighty allah.

  • my brother sent to syria and they do this there also. tehy ahve alot of shia there. and it was scarey just smackign their chests.

    liek in a satanic way beign hypnotized by shiytan

  • next time call me.. i will beat you all.. idiots

  • This is the Iranian olympic swimming team training for London 2012!!!!

  • this is indeed shiite nonesense

    instead of worshipping your creator, you worship a martyr

    authubillah

    this is shirk(polytheism)

    the worst sin ever

  • Can you imagine what the prophet (PBBUH) would think if he saw this?

  • Ataghfirallah, he would not be impressed.

    How does abusing the body which the Most Merciful has bestowed on us make any sense? It doesn't!

  • Yes, He would say "Long live Ya Shia ne Ali".

  • v nice comment brother...this comment teached my heart!

  • Harder!! Hey let them beat the crap out of themselves... Just tell them to not do it in the name of ISLAM! You can cut yourself, beat the crap out of yourself or mutilate yourself. I DONT CARE... JUST DON'T ASSOCIATE IT WITH ISLAM OR MUSLIMS!!!

    Beat yourselves up some more!!! Sadists.

  • I agree, but the thing that makes me more sick is that they do it in the Mosque!!!!!! makes me sick to my stomach!

  • Sunni brothers/Shia instead of echoing you Imams and calling us Kuffar go to Shia websites and search.

    It's only logical to understand are actions.

  • lol

  • come on brothers...can you imagine Prophet Muhammad (pbbuh) doing this inside a masjid. This why it is so important to read the Quran with UNDERSTANDING.

  • Sounds like Gay nude parade !!

  • BIDAH

    SAY NO MORE

  • Oh my Gog... They are praying in the name of the prophet. Didn't they know that it is Shirk. The biggest sin committed against Allah. A mosque is just for worshiping Allah alone and Don't pray in the name of anyone other than Allah, That is the first concept of Islam. If U are doing this, then what is the difference between U and Christians?. Christian pray in the name of the Prophet Issa(Pbuh).

  • hey beta listen n watch the video carefully.. they r saying tht Allah huma Salleh Allah Mohammad Wa Allahe Mohammad... aur beta find the meaning of... u the generation of abu bakar n usman even dunt kno the names of there father n abusing us... u dunt kho tht Hazrat ali's wife was the daughter of prophet Mohammad s.a.w... the problem is that u people dunt hav knowledge of it because u all r jahil n illerated...

  • are you retarded? why would they be praying in the name of the prophet?? maybe if you would open your eyes and ears and actually listen to and try to understand what shias do instead of just blindly accusing us of not being muslims, you would not think the same. it seems to me as you are being very un-muslim like; seeing as how you keep falsely claiming things, before trying to actually do the research and figure out right and wrong.

  • "Mix with them (i.e.non-shia) externally but oppose them internally." (Al-Kafi vol.9 p.116)

    they use TAQQIYA calculated deception as a tool to trick non shia into thinking they are innocent, research it

  • kuffar, IS THIS DANCING FOR IBLISS, THE IBLISS CHEER TEAM

  • Shia3 Islam=Work of the Shaytan=Biddah'=They Are Misguided and Their Scholars are Kuffrs

    They Curse At The Prophet (phuh) Campanion, Aisha...One Shia Even Compare Abu Bakr to The Shayton....

  • crazy

  • wa kullu bida'atinn dalaala wa kullu dallaalatin fi al-nar....enuff said

  • little girl in with them green top on her eatch.

  • ok first of alll we MOURN

    its not called hitting ourselves

    im not even going to cuss at you guys being a shia and all

    we ACTUALLY BELIEVE IN THE PROPHETS FAMILY

    unlike you guys

    but inshalllahh when imam-e-zamana comes

    you all will see.

  • u say believe in the prophets pbuh family, but you call his wife that he was married to for 26 years a whore! ur saying Allah let our role model and teacher keep a whore in his house for 26 years? if the prophet pbuh heard u, he would feel horrible because his family is being insulted by someone that claims they love him!

  • brother no one is saying that she was astigfirullah w**ore. Imam Ali was Allah's chosen one (Ghadeer-e-Khum) and still after Rasoolallah's death, she came on the battleground to fight Imam Ali. That's what makes every shia angry. Rasool said: "Truth is with Ali, and Ali is with truth." Check ur sunni book. It is there. Ghadeer-e-Khum is in hundreds of sunni books where rasool in accordance with Allah' command and Quran said "whomsoever I am master* Ali is his

    master too "

  • fair enough , but where in the quran does it say hit yourselves, cut yourselves?

  • where in teh Quran it says, how many rakats the salaat is?

  • where in the hadith or in the sunna of the prophet does it say to cut yourself and bleed?

  • subhanallah!

  • Who sayed we(sunnis) don't believe in the family of the prophet(P)? Don't YOU(shias) think that are the one who don't believe in the prophets family?( Denying & accusing Aisha of infidel). Isn't Aisha also a member of the prophet's family?

  • well your knowledge is very little.Read your own sect first and instead of asking use books and find out why shia accuse aisha!!? what is wrong? once you see the answer then debate on it.

  • Who sayed we(sunnis) don't believe in the family of the prophet(P)? Don't YOU(shias) think that you are the one don't believe in the prophets family(denying & accusing Aisha of infidel). Isn't Aisha also a member of the prophet's family?

  • I know Astagfurullah, prey read quran no need to beat your selves you guys dont get good deeds for this ,wasteing time ,go prey or read quran instead of screaming like animals,

  • Certain sects of catholics do the same thing, but with special little whips. Check out crazy church people video or wild ass pentacostals, they are pretty fucked up too.

  • morons.

  • Th Fuck ?! :S

  • The bad language you use in comments must one day haunt you as you will regret this. Using such language just shows the type of family you belong and my advise is that you not use it so that people think of you where you belong where you actually may not belong. Just learn to be tolerant and accpet others who may be different from you.

  • too bad these people don't use their time wisely and actually use the house of Allah the mosque to pray and read Quran, instead of doing this stupid crap where they hit themselves.

  • what looks stupid crao to you may have alot of meaning to others. Its the intensity of their love which you cant tell other people to do your way. What you and your type of people are missing is tolerance. You need to live in community where there is diversity so that you begin to understand and respect who are different from you. I live in a non-muslim country and appreciate other nations. You probably live in Muslim country with majority of them Sunni so you cant respect others. Too bad

  • actually what oelhayek is saying is true because u are labeling urself as muslim but practicing something that no prophet peace be upon them ever practiced. Hamza (rda) who was from ahlul bait was killed and the prophet never practiced what you guys do. i respect others who are true to their identity