Sorry to ask but, did Mr.Choson or Mr.Greg did the design too or you make the design yourself? Because I think that the blade should be plain in the back of it, just like katana. Sorry again, but in my opinion, this naginata looks like a Kwandao to me. Overall, it is nice to make one and it looks nice too. I wonder how did you sharpening it? Thanks...
Mr. Park helped me with measurements... the length of the blade, handle,... but design is mine. And you're right about the shape!!! I'm planing to make a new naginata with the blade like katana in the future.
It's nice work and I'd like to see a cutting demo but I have to point out that those measurements are way off. Practicing naginatajutsu properly with that is impossible.
Also, did you temper it and what steel did you use?
Well, if you watch some naginatajutsu videos you'd find out the blade is much smaller. What you have is closer to a chinese quandao.
Also, choson ninja isn't trained in naginatajutsu...neither am I but unlike him I've actually done research on it. By extention, the ninja weren't from the choson region nor did they practice naginatajutsu. You're choosing the worst possible source of information.
It's a very nice quick DIY job, but it's totally innaccurate.
good job. the only problem is that the steel appears to be mild steel. is this true? if so it will dull fast and wont be durable. high carbon steels are generally better for blades.
excellent job. do you watch my vids much. i do tons of armor on horseback and armor archery and kenjutsu and bojutsu in armor. and training in all aspects of ninja and samurai in the forest of mt hood. i recognize your username but havent seen comments or emials to much. just saying hi. i am jason. great job on naginata
Gosh I'm so jealous of your skills! That Naginata looks BEAUTIFUL!!!! Can you post future videos cutting with your new made Naginata! And always a good job on the "SIMPLE STANDS" that you make. They are very well made! 5 stars!
Sorry to ask but, did Mr.Choson or Mr.Greg did the design too or you make the design yourself? Because I think that the blade should be plain in the back of it, just like katana. Sorry again, but in my opinion, this naginata looks like a Kwandao to me. Overall, it is nice to make one and it looks nice too. I wonder how did you sharpening it? Thanks...
acl2311 1 year ago
@acl2311
Mr. Park helped me with measurements... the length of the blade, handle,... but design is mine. And you're right about the shape!!! I'm planing to make a new naginata with the blade like katana in the future.
NinjaStudent1 1 year ago
Great work! Looks very nice!
XkuzonX 1 year ago
it looks more lkke the chinese kwan doa
numnumnum08 1 year ago
Very nice, do you think you could make a jumonji yari spear?
SuperSmashyfication 1 year ago
Very nice, do you think you could make a jumonji yari spear?
SuperSmashyfication 1 year ago
Very nice, do you think you could make a jumonji yari spear?
SuperSmashyfication 1 year ago
normal naginata blade shape is just the same as the katana. they shape u use is chineese style
MrRik338 1 year ago
thats amazing work you should be very proud and on the sharpening its beautiful!
narutorasengan162 1 year ago
it looks more like a duan dao then a naginata
but its good and i could never make somthing like that
inthetoilet4456 1 year ago
Omg thats is really cool but don't they have smooth edges?
CoconutSeal 1 year ago
very nicely done!
5T0RML0RD 1 year ago
Very impressive. What did you use to cut the shape of the blade?
DarthNehimis 1 year ago
i made one to i got a rusty old blade some think to connect it it was like a rail shape and a pole i found and i just sharpened it
and covered it in gorilla tape so it looks better
and i used a hammer
superfreakinawesome8 1 year ago
very nice peice of work i just want to congradulate you.
dom99661 1 year ago
what type of meatal do use? and how much duz it cost? also what tools do you use for shapeing and what not? i am very interested!
pok1me2 1 year ago
realy nice
cellofal 1 year ago
Awesome!!
Izzy11215 1 year ago
hope you dont delete this video i really like it
Gizmo12121cp 1 year ago
It's nice work and I'd like to see a cutting demo but I have to point out that those measurements are way off. Practicing naginatajutsu properly with that is impossible.
Also, did you temper it and what steel did you use?
ihaterobbie123 1 year ago
Why to you think that the measurements are of? i had the measerements form choson ninja....
NinjaStudent1 1 year ago
@NinjaStudent1
Well, if you watch some naginatajutsu videos you'd find out the blade is much smaller. What you have is closer to a chinese quandao.
Also, choson ninja isn't trained in naginatajutsu...neither am I but unlike him I've actually done research on it. By extention, the ninja weren't from the choson region nor did they practice naginatajutsu. You're choosing the worst possible source of information.
It's a very nice quick DIY job, but it's totally innaccurate.
ihaterobbie123 1 year ago
will you you plz send measurements by the way amazing work my friend
micro9098 1 year ago
Thanks, i will send you pm with the measurements.
NinjaStudent1 1 year ago
will you plz send me measurements
micro9098 1 year ago
great job, looks very nice, wonder how it endurance in action....
Naproxenum 1 year ago
Thanks for your comment
NinjaStudent1 1 year ago
Absolutely beautiful piece of weaponry...I'm envious of your tool access.
germanninja101 1 year ago
Thanks for your comment!
NinjaStudent1 1 year ago
what kind of weld did you do to conect the slab with the metal bar?
heavymetalninja09 2 years ago
ARC welding
NinjaStudent1 1 year ago
he im making one but i need to know some stuff, how long is the staff portion im guessing 6 feet, and how long is the blade length
Ale7Returns 2 years ago
i sent you pm with the measurements...
NinjaStudent1 2 years ago
thank you
Ale7Returns 2 years ago
awsome, its very hard to find good kind quality homemade thigs on youtube 500 starzs!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
ps: master park is the best. I am his loyal servant.
ninjalikesweapons 2 years ago
Thanks for your comment. Yes he is the best!
NinjaStudent1 2 years ago
Whoa. This is truly genius, my friend: creativity, dedication, and skill all blended together.
And the result is one awesome-looking Naginata! It certainly seems quite sturdy. I wonder how good it cuts?
ryarod 2 years ago
Thanks for your comment. it cuts really good :)
NinjaStudent1 2 years ago
got to say you would've been a fine ninja in feudal japan since you stick to the rule "need it make it"
nice video
5 stars
Cheerok 2 years ago
Thank you for your comment!
NinjaStudent1 2 years ago
very nice. your a good craftsman. 5 stars
heavymetalninja09 2 years ago
Thanks
NinjaStudent1 2 years ago
Thats pretty handy work there. A+++++
esko23q 2 years ago
Thanks for your comment
NinjaStudent1 2 years ago
I thought its a Sword at first, because I didnt know what a Niginata is, how did you cut it out?
webdoggboy 2 years ago
I used the same tool that i used in my video "home made knife"
NinjaStudent1 2 years ago
sweet
painsey 2 years ago
awsome my ninja bro you have an eye for detils and what you want to make keep it up
kissrdbc 2 years ago
how long did it take you to finish it?
johncarloLR 2 years ago
I am impressed, that came out really nice.
SuperKixxx 2 years ago
You did a pretty nice job,
But leave it in the stand or practice katas with it, but don't go cutting with it!!!
All steel used for cutting or sparring should have a heat treatment and tempering.
Cutting with it now is really dangerous because you don't know how the steel reacts and if there are any cracks inside and stuff.
But if your a metal worker you could learn that pretty easily.
Insanesr 2 years ago
You make the thing which is much better than the toy which chosonninjya makes.
But I will say a word.
It is a Chinese design.
It is not a Japanese thing.
After all the Japanese naginata which Greg made are different.
taihuu25go 2 years ago
WOW i want one of these too^^
kakashiTheThug 2 years ago
thats so awesome :O
*bow*
JumperFrank 2 years ago
that is amazing my friend excellent work 5 stars . You are quite talented with making these weapons .
Great job
Rick
takeninjcanada 2 years ago
AMAZING WORK 5/5
Ale7Returns 2 years ago
nice, you seem to be very good with your hands, if i may ask, what kind of wood is the staff made of?
TUSENMAUG 2 years ago
good job. the only problem is that the steel appears to be mild steel. is this true? if so it will dull fast and wont be durable. high carbon steels are generally better for blades.
crazycolerogers 2 years ago
Congratulations to your wonderfully self-made naginata and the "stand" for it!
Thank you very much for sharing your video with all of us!
7 naginata stars and favorited
*bow*
angela
tayounorise 2 years ago
Wow, nice! I'll take two! :))
5*, super nice work!
TheRealXesc 2 years ago 3
Are you taking any orders?..lol :)
taigyokushodan 2 years ago 3
Very very very nice!
5 surigum stars!
ChosonMusa 2 years ago 11
very good job...
eli1967 2 years ago 3
I too would like to see a demonstration with the Naginata. I'd like to see it's durability.
5/5 Nice work.
Mulfia 2 years ago 9
thats really nice! good job!
botisonny 2 years ago 3
WOw I am so impressed you are a very talented craftsman! Very good job, The naganita looked very tough too!
SacredFireFilms 2 years ago 3
That is so EPIC
Dustinsteele1994 2 years ago 3
excellent job. do you watch my vids much. i do tons of armor on horseback and armor archery and kenjutsu and bojutsu in armor. and training in all aspects of ninja and samurai in the forest of mt hood. i recognize your username but havent seen comments or emials to much. just saying hi. i am jason. great job on naginata
MOUNTAINOUS 2 years ago 3
Very Good! Thank you for sharing this video!10 stars, a great craftsman
TelosBudo 2 years ago 3
man, nice work.
VikingNinjitsu 2 years ago 3
wow that was pretty nice and well crafted. i would enjoy some more of your craftsmanship
sigmundbalmung 2 years ago 3
excellent job :) keep up the awesome job!
mysticaldragon1978 2 years ago 3
Awesome got to try but i dont hav those cutting and welding tools :) great Vid Gambatte :D
Shinobiriz 2 years ago 3
youre really good at making weapons
NaruSilver 2 years ago 3
Excellent
tidemover 2 years ago 3
thank you for the video, peace
morotorno2 2 years ago 3
lol after sharpenning, it looked really nice.
deathbyninjastar 2 years ago 3
Great work. I thought u cant suprise me... and here we got ;]
riokuPL 2 years ago 2
great video my man it did not even cross my mind that you could make one of those
unclecow 2 years ago 2
Gosh I'm so jealous of your skills! That Naginata looks BEAUTIFUL!!!! Can you post future videos cutting with your new made Naginata! And always a good job on the "SIMPLE STANDS" that you make. They are very well made! 5 stars!
hyubgaek 2 years ago 2
Nice Weapon!
gladiatorxxyy 2 years ago 2