yes regina is russian, so she sings in russian. but amanda is german so she said something else in german, which you can see above. she is talking to regina.
Great cover and I love the exchange of German for Russian, but I didn't "Like" it until Amanda had to stop and say that she'd fucked up - it's not a true Amanda Fucking Palmer cover until she's fucked up at least once!
I love how Amanda switched out the Russian for the German and makes it hers. She doesn't just play the song, and try to match it, she pays her respects to an amazing artist. That's what a cover should be.
@sudachinohi it wasn't just a german translation of the russian phrase. it was entirely different. the original russian piece is the first stanza to a poem by pasternak.
She played the piano very well, but her singing style clashed with the song
She rather butchered it. This is a testament to the fact that it is practically impossible to make a successful cover of one of Regina Spektor's songs.
@cashmoney21892 i know she doesn't speak russian, but she could have at least attempted a german translation of the russian passage, which was an homage to boris pasternak. it was the first stanza to one of his poems.
Does anyone speak German? Russian part wasn't Russian! Did she make that up? By the way I didn't really like her singing (sorry but this isn't your style)
I actually liked this version a lot. Her struggle with the vocal range adds a weird sort of passion to the song. Not everyone is the vocal virtuoso that Regina Spektor is. But yeah, the original is better.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
You're not supposed to be nice with the reply.
;/
I wasn't actually being serious. It was me being bored, and thinking to myself: "Hey, you know how everyone on the internet is super serious? LETS DO SOMETHING FUN LOOOL"
@juliewayiero she changed regina's russian part to her own german lyrics. deluge is french for flood ...apres moi le deluge. it means, after me, the flood.
@juliewayiero apres moi na deluge is french for after me comes the flood. and in regina's original the russian portion is the first stanza to a poem by boris pasternak. which translates to:
The German is terrible. Learn it or get out. None of this fake bullshit.
ZexionLovesVexen 6 months ago
@ZexionLovesVexen She actually speaks German pretty fluently, having majored in it in college and lived in Germany for a while.
thatguywhosaidstuff 3 months ago
omg..Regina is my favorite singer...I love this song..and Amanda is my second favorite:)
zupanicka 7 months ago
yes regina is russian, so she sings in russian. but amanda is german so she said something else in german, which you can see above. she is talking to regina.
esherrick 9 months ago
The lyrics are in Russian sillyhead. I like Amanda but her voice sounds kind of bad on this cover. I think it's cause it's live though.
amusicalnightmare 10 months ago
ITS RUSSIAN NOT GERMAN! Jesus, Regina Spektor is RUSSIAN! >: |
XXXBootstrap 11 months ago
@XXXBootstrap awesome, right? i guess ap changed it for her cover. idk, i think it's kickass!
kristanova 11 months ago
@XXXBootstrap listen closely, this isn't what regina originally sings. Amanda Palmer really sings those german lyrics here
nimoisansvous 11 months ago
@XXXBootstrap lol in original song lyrics are russian but in this cover girl sing in german.
vadimos86 10 months ago
could someone put the german part in german? thank you
retinueofmoons 11 months ago
Not a big fan of the German. Palmer is no Pasternak.
tehfreckled1der 1 year ago
She made a valid attempt but no one can top regina, it is her song after all :)
Mario12874 1 year ago
Great cover and I love the exchange of German for Russian, but I didn't "Like" it until Amanda had to stop and say that she'd fucked up - it's not a true Amanda Fucking Palmer cover until she's fucked up at least once!
4492 1 year ago
I love how Amanda switched out the Russian for the German and makes it hers. She doesn't just play the song, and try to match it, she pays her respects to an amazing artist. That's what a cover should be.
sudachinohi 1 year ago
@sudachinohi it wasn't just a german translation of the russian phrase. it was entirely different. the original russian piece is the first stanza to a poem by pasternak.
tehfreckled1der 1 year ago
@tehfreckled1der I know. You misunderstood what I meant :)
sudachinohi 1 year ago
holy shit im soo happy this exists
ice9willENDusall 1 year ago
AFP covering my fav Regina Spektor song.
I need this strength today.
morazdaful 1 year ago
This is awful.
STOPtheHORROR 1 year ago
Hmm
She played the piano very well, but her singing style clashed with the song
She rather butchered it. This is a testament to the fact that it is practically impossible to make a successful cover of one of Regina Spektor's songs.
estelaurent 1 year ago
she speaks german? what an honour for us germans! thanks, manda.
butterflypiano 1 year ago
Thanks for posting.
TheFriendlyMoosh 1 year ago
Was machst du, Amanda? :)
waverleysteps 1 year ago
the piano is sick, your voice is scary xD sorry!
amazerfulness 1 year ago
hahahahahaahh!!!!
XOIceFireOX 1 year ago
I want Amanda Palmer to go on American Idol and tell Simon to fuck off.
KatTheTroubleMaker 1 year ago
The german part is pretty difficult to understand and sometimes confusing, but she sings:
What do you do Regina?
The aged don't understand us
What do you do Regina?
The mistaken are still right
What do you mean Regina?
The coldness has valued us
What do you do Regina?
The Ice Age comes, the flood burst
littledevillaura 2 years ago 20
@littledevillaura I heard it a bit differently, honestly, I heard:
What do you do, Regina?
The old ones, they don't understand us.
What, what do you do, Regina?
The false one has judged us. (I heard "Die Falsche hat uns eingeschätzt")
What do you do, Regina?
The cold one has introduced us. (again, I heard "Die Kalte hat uns eingebracht")
What, what do you do, Regina?
The Ice Age comes, the flood shattered. (zerbrechen really could be either one, but to me "shatter" sounds better).
MrNotkewl 1 year ago
what's the german part she sings?
what does she say?
duhgrace 2 years ago
hehe she goes OH instead of ARE but it's cool :)
I love her passion in the line of french.
She's like Reginas evil twin in this song :)
But,what is the thing she says to/about Regina??
singninjasing 2 years ago
its frikin russian. wtf?
WeLuVnLt4894 2 years ago
@WeLuVnLt4894
Not Russian, she sings this part in German.
denalihedgehog 2 years ago
@WeLuVnLt4894 well shes not regina and cant speak russian...so instead of butchering the russian language she sang in german.
cashmoney21892 1 year ago
@cashmoney21892 i know she doesn't speak russian, but she could have at least attempted a german translation of the russian passage, which was an homage to boris pasternak. it was the first stanza to one of his poems.
tehfreckled1der 1 year ago
Does anyone speak German? Russian part wasn't Russian! Did she make that up? By the way I didn't really like her singing (sorry but this isn't your style)
dechenko 2 years ago
it's german ,but I don't understand it either.
SchnuddelPferdchens 2 years ago
What exactly would be the point of doing a cover of this? SO VERY MUCH LESS IMPRESSIVE than the original!
Like listening to a heifer, absolute butchering this song.
1 star!
ryko26 2 years ago
Amanda Palmer and Regina Spektor are actually really good friends. I bet she wouldn't appreciate you calling her friend "like listening to a heifer"
QueenChickie 2 years ago
@QueenChickie ...I think, secretly, she'd
a) find it hilarious
b) know it to be true
ryko26 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I think
A) You should kill yourself.
B) You should kill yourself.
loooooooooooooool
EffinPiss 2 years ago
I actually liked this version a lot. Her struggle with the vocal range adds a weird sort of passion to the song. Not everyone is the vocal virtuoso that Regina Spektor is. But yeah, the original is better.
P4ddl35 2 years ago 4
amanda has a specific independent way she plays on her keyboard. it's suppose to sound violent, and brutal, in a well put together way, which it does
Mario59870 2 years ago
Doesn't work well on a keyboard, imo. Amanda Palmer does a decent job, though.
testsubjectLILY 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Shut the fuck up.
EffinPiss 2 years ago
You, sir/ma'am, need to calm down.
testsubjectLILY 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
You're not supposed to be nice with the reply.
;/
I wasn't actually being serious. It was me being bored, and thinking to myself: "Hey, you know how everyone on the internet is super serious? LETS DO SOMETHING FUN LOOOL"
So, you passed by failing.
EffinPiss 2 years ago
Well, now I'm effin' pissed.
):<
testsubjectLILY 2 years ago
GOOD
>O
EffinPiss 2 years ago
I didn't like this at all lol.
ahhlehx 2 years ago
I love Amanda Palmer/Dresden Dolls... but Holy Shit, this is Regina's song. Didn't enjoy this.
sukieisme 2 years ago
Oh. my. god. Awesome piano, terrible version though.
gahitstoni 2 years ago
I must say that Amanda's cover is really individual X) Regina's better of course, but I like this version, too.
iamgrotesque 2 years ago
i love them both regina and amanda!!
they're great!!!
blutanz 2 years ago
i don't like her "uh". regina's is so graceful, hers is like really loud and low.
moonnugget 2 years ago
some serious over-pronunciation of the é in déluge...
and no-one can play piano like Regina.
but apart from that...
not too bad!!
Quite a good cover infact, imo. :)
notgoodwithwords 2 years ago 4
Shes awsome at piano, but i dont like her singing in this, she sings WAY to low, but at least in tune
SEXYpanda3 2 years ago
She's performing it in the same key, so is singing the same as Regina for the vast majority...?
bloodroses317 2 years ago
dude lol
regina and amanda are just my fav female artist
this is so amazing for me O_O'
(but what the hell was she singing in the russian part? and whats a deiluge?)
anyways love them soooooooooooo fricking much k3
juliewayiero 2 years ago 13
Après moi le déluge - "After me, the flood".
testsubjectLILY 2 years ago
@juliewayiero she changed regina's russian part to her own german lyrics. deluge is french for flood ...apres moi le deluge. it means, after me, the flood.
cashmoney21892 1 year ago
@cashmoney21892 i know what DELUGE means, right... i was just joking cause it sounds like she puts an extra i after 'de'... sounds like DEILUGE.
juliewayiero 1 year ago
@juliewayiero oh.... o.O my badd
cashmoney21892 1 year ago
Comment removed
mello1142 1 year ago
@juliewayiero apres moi na deluge is french for after me comes the flood. and in regina's original the russian portion is the first stanza to a poem by boris pasternak. which translates to:
Black spring! Pick up your pen, and weeping,
Of February, in sobs and ink,
Write poems, while the slush in thunder
Is burning in the black of spring.
tehfreckled1der 1 year ago
@tehfreckled1der again, i was joking cause amanda puts an extra 'i' after 'de', so it sounds like 'deiluge', not 'deluge'
about the russian part, i wanted to know what amanda was singing in german
i know the russian part, but thanks anyway ^^
juliewayiero 7 months ago
Comment removed
katherinesixteen 7 months ago
@juliewayiero mine too!:D
zupanicka 7 months ago
@juliewayiero deluge (in french)= flood, Après moi le déluge = after me comes the flood
TheKeranos 1 month ago
@TheKeranos okay x.x thanks, but i know french :p
i was just being annoying, because amanda doesn't pronounce it right.
juliewayiero 1 month ago
too butch
fudge1monkey 2 years ago
Is it just me or does the non-English part mention Regina?
CalmBlue 2 years ago
the russian part is not russian anymore! is it german?
her version is not bad... but it's not really great, there's not really a lot of nuance. Her version of On the Radio is much better, much sweeter
walbatto 2 years ago
her version is fucking fantastic! (there's no "nuance" but it's about her voice....!!
lanesousacid 2 years ago
Yes German...
mathegudrun 2 years ago
amanda and regina. what more could a girl ask for?! =D
ironcountry 2 years ago
lol *halfway through song*
fuck i fucked that up!
love this woman
elena2oo7 2 years ago
Amazing!!!
KleptHoeManiac 2 years ago