Yes, Elton John, Scotty Mccreery versions of this song are good. Subjectively, this version is THE BEST!! Ronnie Lane seals the deal, playing bass and adding background vocals. Very cool. Peace:)
Scotty Mcreery's version is better than Rod's and Elton John's version. I like Rod Stewart's style, but Scotty sings this song with more emotion on American Idol, and the country vibe is better with his voice.
@shimokita2 .........Why wouldn't they like each other , they been mates since they were in there teens ....I'm sure there were more than a few late nights , I have a DVD ~ The Faces with Keith Richards ! it's great ......Ciao
@cash1115 Of course he wasn't in Faces !!! I said i own a DVD ~ The Faces with Keith Richards ..............He was a guest at the show as if the title didn't do it for ya READ the message before making an ignorant comment
@baby69ization hey dick head a little hostile arent we . with a name like baby 69 you think you'd be a little less angery . or it could be your sexual preference and favorite position with ... so suck it faggot !!
@cash1115 And with a name like Cash you would know a little more about music you Fucking Punk , Punks that talk like only in writing are usually just wimps so kindly Fuck Off and come back when you grow up !! What's hostile about telling you your wrong and I own a DVD Chill out Punk !!!
@baby69ization i know more about music than youll ever know faggot o'm 46 and have been playing in bands since i was 15 .and it was you that said i made an ignorent comment when i simply said its ron wood not keith richards. so i would love to fucking kick you metro sexual emo ass girl boy ! as far as being a wimp i'm 6' 4" and 250 lbs biker from p.a. and i dont wear womens cloths to look cool like your faggot ass so go fuck yourself metroboy
@cash1115 "Metroboy" haha 6' 4" and 250lbs. and your wearing women's underwear hey ? Bring it on Punk !! I'm done with your fruity ass ! So kindly Fuck Off !! you know more about Fuck all !! zzzzzzzzzzzzzzz Your a boring little fucker hey ?
I think it's ludicrous to compare the two versions - Rod & Elton. The interpretation is so different. Rod has that soul/suave delivery & Elton just punches it out the way only Elton can do. I own both albums & they're both *superb*! Do yourself a favor & listen to the song on the cd before trying to make *any* comparisons off You Tube...there are none!
no way rod has heaps more heart to it than eltons eltons version is okay but noway has the feelings of rods i love drinking green ginger wine and singing to this really loud in my backyard lol
@LaddAirr The other voice belongs to Harry Reynolds, who is my dad; a retired musician who spent many years in the company of many big names and never quite got his own big break. Ref: Silver Metre/Ashman Reynolds
actually, I'll make it . . I still got a couple weeks and I'm gonna make . . prob'ly have it up before Christmas . . lol .. it really is a pretty song. . .
Oh, Grandma's farm...fresh produce, chickens, cows, pigs, fruit trees, a barn we should have died jumping out of...and nothing like grandma's homecooking!
Thanks for the cool reminder of theold days, although im use to hearing Eltons Connections album its been awhile since i heard this version w/ Ron wood on guitar. Thanks ! Best Regards Thomas
@Miniermotte hate to argue but rod does give it that country feel.. a voice I would die 4. and a lovely chilled out arrangement. music is a vice with no drawbacks
ron wood e rod stewart just match
dropeff 2 weeks ago
Sorry, Elton. I prefer Rod. Great rendition. Classic.
probrojeffro 3 months ago 2
What if Paul Mcdonald choose this song instead of scotty, maybe he did it well too since he sounds like Rod Steward.
SuperWintry 3 months ago
Ronnie Laine I guess, thanks
dogcplayers 4 months ago
who sings the backup harmony at the end of this> thanks
dogcplayers 4 months ago
@dogcplayers - Ron Wood.
klingoncelt 1 month ago in playlist All Things To All People 5
Yes, Elton John, Scotty Mccreery versions of this song are good. Subjectively, this version is THE BEST!! Ronnie Lane seals the deal, playing bass and adding background vocals. Very cool. Peace:)
jimbopta 5 months ago
Muswell Hills finest export till the Gforce came along.!!!!!!!!!!!!
colonelofcork 5 months ago
Haha an American Idol contestant trump Rod Stewart? "What kind of facts are those?"
-Jay Z
sirius613 8 months ago
Country comforts and the road that's going home. Don't get no better than that.
majicray2112 10 months ago
Scotty Mcreery's version is better than Rod's and Elton John's version. I like Rod Stewart's style, but Scotty sings this song with more emotion on American Idol, and the country vibe is better with his voice.
scooterinnc84 10 months ago
rods heaps better, puts more feeling into the song...
yendor44 11 months ago
what a legend
timlaarveld 11 months ago
all you stupid ppl sayin eltons is better next laught rod all the way
kirkmava 1 year ago
I have both versions and I like Rod's version better
VenusInPisces 1 year ago
This rendition is the best one of all.
unclewalt56 1 year ago 10
Rods voice gives it the edge for me.Great song
dfcsussex 1 year ago
rex allen jr.'s version is the best, and the original one, i guess
TheRyskwic 1 year ago
@TheRyskwic - do you know if Keith Richards likes Rod Stewart?
shimokita2 1 year ago
@shimokita2 that's chipper singing back up.
TrishtheDishNY 10 months ago
@shimokita2 .........Why wouldn't they like each other , they been mates since they were in there teens ....I'm sure there were more than a few late nights , I have a DVD ~ The Faces with Keith Richards ! it's great ......Ciao
baby69ization 9 months ago
@baby69ization KEITH RICHARDS WAS NOT IN FACES IT WAS RON WOOD . SORRY WRONG GUITARIST
cash1115 6 months ago
@cash1115 Of course he wasn't in Faces !!! I said i own a DVD ~ The Faces with Keith Richards ..............He was a guest at the show as if the title didn't do it for ya READ the message before making an ignorant comment
baby69ization 6 months ago
@baby69ization hey dick head a little hostile arent we . with a name like baby 69 you think you'd be a little less angery . or it could be your sexual preference and favorite position with ... so suck it faggot !!
cash1115 6 months ago
@cash1115 And with a name like Cash you would know a little more about music you Fucking Punk , Punks that talk like only in writing are usually just wimps so kindly Fuck Off and come back when you grow up !! What's hostile about telling you your wrong and I own a DVD Chill out Punk !!!
baby69ization 6 months ago
@baby69ization i know more about music than youll ever know faggot o'm 46 and have been playing in bands since i was 15 .and it was you that said i made an ignorent comment when i simply said its ron wood not keith richards. so i would love to fucking kick you metro sexual emo ass girl boy ! as far as being a wimp i'm 6' 4" and 250 lbs biker from p.a. and i dont wear womens cloths to look cool like your faggot ass so go fuck yourself metroboy
cash1115 6 months ago
@cash1115 "Metroboy" haha 6' 4" and 250lbs. and your wearing women's underwear hey ? Bring it on Punk !! I'm done with your fruity ass ! So kindly Fuck Off !! you know more about Fuck all !! zzzzzzzzzzzzzzz Your a boring little fucker hey ?
baby69ization 5 months ago
@revlaz I think that's pretty much what I said?
Gingerjake2 1 year ago
I think it's ludicrous to compare the two versions - Rod & Elton. The interpretation is so different. Rod has that soul/suave delivery & Elton just punches it out the way only Elton can do. I own both albums & they're both *superb*! Do yourself a favor & listen to the song on the cd before trying to make *any* comparisons off You Tube...there are none!
Gingerjake2 1 year ago
rod brings more heart to it by far
yendor44 1 year ago
I don't like how he butchered the lyrics..
CommodorePB 1 year ago
GREAT SONG
jimmyfrancicone 1 year ago
What a song. My god. Thank you for this hymn!!!!!
beebeef 1 year ago
One of Rod's best interpretations from one of his best LP's. Thanks for sharing!
Gerry50ify 1 year ago
Rod's version has more soul, both great
stephen732 1 year ago
no way rod has heaps more heart to it than eltons eltons version is okay but noway has the feelings of rods i love drinking green ginger wine and singing to this really loud in my backyard lol
talentscout27 1 year ago
@talentscout27 I love Rods version the best,he puts more of a stronger sound,Eltons is more country,Rods is more rock...
60srecords 1 year ago
Is that Ronnie Wood on guitar? Such a Great song...."that aint natural, old man Grayson says...."
incident85 1 year ago
@incident85 Yaman i think Ron Wood played in Faces with Rod for a while, could be mistaken though.
cantarooots 1 year ago
@cantarooots yes he did ronnie was lead guitar of faces
danielstuartblues 1 year ago
これが一番スキです。ありがとう。
naoshi11 2 years ago
This is the version that i only heard of ,until i heard eltons
60srecords 2 years ago
Never heard this version. I love it. Thanks for posting it.
bulbheadmyass 2 years ago
Who's the other voice we hear on this?
LaddAirr 2 years ago
This is Ronnie Lane who sang background in this version, piano played Elton John. First record is a live bootleg with the Faces.
mojomanofroyal 2 years ago
Comment removed
zozo4170 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@LaddAirr The other voice belongs to Harry Reynolds, who is my dad; a retired musician who spent many years in the company of many big names and never quite got his own big break. Ref: Silver Metre/Ashman Reynolds
zozo4170 1 year ago
Nice version . . I'll have my version (solo acoustic guitar) up within the month . .
GregERobertson 2 years ago
Yeah...Right...
sohappyIcouldshit 2 years ago
actually, I'll make it . . I still got a couple weeks and I'm gonna make . . prob'ly have it up before Christmas . . lol .. it really is a pretty song. . .
GregERobertson 2 years ago
i CAN;T WAIT
sohappyIcouldshit 2 years ago
very beautiful song. thank you,
Aaron. Excellent lyrics.
many thanks, to you. ~ Roses
rosesredvioletsblue 2 years ago
CANCION DE 1970
jorgealbertobaron 2 years ago
If anyone who has had a grandma who lived on the farm like I did this song has special meaning.
Haagr4152 2 years ago
Oh, Grandma's farm...fresh produce, chickens, cows, pigs, fruit trees, a barn we should have died jumping out of...and nothing like grandma's homecooking!
sherylrb 2 years ago
I'M NOW PUSHING AGE 70 .
I saw him in concert @Lexington,Ky.when I was in my 50's.
I have loved Rod Stewart for years.
This is a great "Reminder Song"..Love it!
eucomparis 2 years ago
This s a great tune. Rod Rocks it!!!!!!!!!
woody6995 2 years ago
thanks
amazondoobie 2 years ago
GOOD SONG!
setenteromusic 2 years ago
Comment removed
sherylrb 2 years ago
hm, i like elton's better. but rod is good good !
leaha401 2 years ago
Thanks for the cool reminder of theold days, although im use to hearing Eltons Connections album its been awhile since i heard this version w/ Ron wood on guitar. Thanks ! Best Regards Thomas
tmobil8 3 years ago
Lacks the feel and atmosphere of Elton John's original!
leonardoboy2 3 years ago
Totally agree with you. Elton brings more heart to it.
But Rod's version is nice though!
Miniermotte 2 years ago
Cool! You know what I mean!
leonardoboy2 2 years ago
@Miniermotte hate to argue but rod does give it that country feel.. a voice I would die 4. and a lovely chilled out arrangement. music is a vice with no drawbacks
bigmowbs 1 year ago
what a song!!!! Have loved Rod for years, turned my kids on to him, and they love him too!!
chickndixie78 3 years ago
I totally agree with you, aerosmithdu17.
As far as I´m concerned Rods version is much better.
rodrocksforever 3 years ago 7
@rodrocksforever
Just a touch of Mick Taylor (former Stones) is missing in the back!
ALB437 9 months ago
pourrais tu me dire ce qui ne vas pas dans mon commentaire pour avoir mis -1??? merci
aerosmithdu17 3 years ago
I agree. Rod is the man, great version.
karzon89 3 years ago
Thanks for the post, I really love the music that Rod was performing at this time.
montonman1 3 years ago
wow excellent song,as far as I'm concerned better than elton
aerosmithdu17 3 years ago