@bearandwoot there's a lot of controversy as to whther he could have killed himself in the fashion he supposedly killed himself. i personally think no one could have killed their selves that way.
IMO people who suffer from serious depression are blown away by what this man was able to convey. not only was his depression obviously the most crippling and detrimental type, but he managed to EXPRESS HIS FEELINGS. Wow, that is unprecedented in mental illness, even among trained musicians. STRONG DUDE
I feel if you wanna be a little bitch and kill yourselff then do it stop wasting everyones fucking time and try to get attention if ur really man enough then jump off a bridge or pull the trigger stop talking about it and just fucking do it pussy's enough said...
@WOWurGey You don't have the mental capacity to type a readable comment on an online video sharing website which really makes me doubt your ability to understand anything behind the idea of suicide. There are Youtubers out there like Smosh & Makemebad. I think they'd be a little more on your level. Check them out, amigo.
@sethm81392 Hey i love smosh but i also have been listening to Elliott Smith for years . I got what you were trying to say but i just wanted to say that both are amazing Rip Steven
elliott smith's music is more relevant to the world today-the bittersweet memories of the past and how we, as a people, blew it. rest in peace, elliott, you were a true prophet-i wish you a fond farewell.
You can only even acuse somebody of a sin if your have 2 or 3 eyewitnesses to the sin. Otherwise YOU must be punished with the punishment that sin requires. Stop guessing and judging. Just be thankful for the music he gave us.
I believe it is impossible to stab yourself in the heart twice, the police report says (based on his girlfriends statement) that they had a row she locked herself in the toilet, heard him cry out, found him with a knife in his chest, she pulled it out.
after appeal from his family to a verdict of suicide the case was reopened and remains open. His girlfriend tried to claim rights to his estate which is being contested by his family. The case remains open after a specialist stated in deat by suicide the knife pushes the victims clothing into the body, this was not the case in this incident!
little man. one day when you grow up your gonna hate yourself for being so incredibly stupid. as a corrections officer your the type i have to save from getting raped or abused.....grow up idiot!!!!!
dude instead of fighting how about listening to the song what if this happend to some1 u love then what would u do call them emo or fag listen elliott smith dident kill himself to be emo he couldent take the pain i dont blame him for doing it because people act like little kids then he killed him self because he was depressed and doing drugs btw idc what u call me oh well words dont hurt me only people who are mean just listen to this song its a great song and its also very very sad rip elliott
@runezonerocks words do hurt. but your right. its wrong to talk shit on elliott here like really? your going to do that? bahh people are so frustrating.
To all of you...i don't give a shit if he killed himself or got hit by a fucking train. He made amazing music, left it here for us to listen to and enjoy. so just fucking enjoy his beautiful amazing songs.
lmfao nothing jesusjerkoff or the other guy said actually made sense, theyre both loners who need to intimidate people behind a screen about fucking the persons parents when theyve never even seen a girl naked unless it was on a computer.
no, you did not have sex with my parents,
no i am not emo for liking elliot smith.
i am just a normal person who has a normal life.
grow the fuck up you scum.
you have to be either by some 12 year old prick or some 40 year old virgin.
People who enjoy Elliot's music might check his videos out once every couple of weeks, and the guy who hates him views them once a day. I finally know what irony means.
Where is the memorial wall for Elliot Smith? I really enjoy Elliot Smith's music. I'm a new listener, but it didn't take me long to be captivated by his purity in lyrics. I was just wondering where the memorial wall is. I would appreciate it if you could get back to me.
Silver Lake on Sunset Boulevard in LA, I think... I read somewhere it's 4334 Sunset Boulevard, Los Angeles, California. Sorry if any of this is inaccurate...
Everyone has the right to commit suicide, so,. its not really weakness, and I would say that I don't respect him for it,. but i don't disrespect him for it. Everyone follows there own course.. he had his time, and he was lead to that choice, which was his.
Can't say I respect anyone for not fighting life the only way that one can, which is living through the shit; but I can respect the talent. Having said that, Mr. Smith, you will be missed.
I can only speak for moderate to severe clinnical depression, which I had/have- it's been a lot better lately since I figured out how to deal with it. But what do I know? I know this: 8 years of on and off counselling (with three different therapists), 3 years of Prozac, 6 months of Zoloft, 3 years of Welbutrin, countless books and information packets, personality tests and naturopathic cures.
Hands up, I'm sorry, it must be tough for you. But the difference is, you had the drugs designed to help the fight, he had the ones that made him give it up.
It's basically a test-and-try process, because no psychiatrist or doctor will know how each person reacts to each medication. Most people - depressed or not - will have depressive reactions to at least a few anti-depressants. Some depressed people are bodily-resistant to treatment, period. It sucks.
I am so glad I didn't follow the path Elliot did because I would leave so much behind I wasn't thinking about at the time. At least he was there in spirit with his music to get me back on the path I am on now.
wow this vid was added may 07 your a little late, but u know what it doesnt matter when cause tributes to one of the greatest of all is always nice. i miss him to man, but his music will always live on.
I love you and I wish you were here Elliott, XO<3
stainedglasseyes1 3 months ago
goodbye Andy. sorry i never took the chance to apologize, but i am sorry and you will be missed
MrJojeeeable 4 months ago
Miss you so much especially today on the anniversary of your death. I adored you alive and still do in death.
Mswasabi22 5 months ago 2
I went from trolling hard on other shit to coming to this and not trolling. This is not something people should fight or troll about.
bearandwoot 8 months ago 3
I've stood in front of the figure 8 wall and it is a good feeling being where this man walked. Why did he have to die?
spacebetweensound 9 months ago
@spacebetweensound Well didn't he kill himself?
bearandwoot 8 months ago
@bearandwoot there's a lot of controversy as to whther he could have killed himself in the fashion he supposedly killed himself. i personally think no one could have killed their selves that way.
spacebetweensound 8 months ago
IMO people who suffer from serious depression are blown away by what this man was able to convey. not only was his depression obviously the most crippling and detrimental type, but he managed to EXPRESS HIS FEELINGS. Wow, that is unprecedented in mental illness, even among trained musicians. STRONG DUDE
fossilfuelmusic 1 year ago
I feel if you wanna be a little bitch and kill yourselff then do it stop wasting everyones fucking time and try to get attention if ur really man enough then jump off a bridge or pull the trigger stop talking about it and just fucking do it pussy's enough said...
WOWurGey 1 year ago
@WOWurGey You don't have the mental capacity to type a readable comment on an online video sharing website which really makes me doubt your ability to understand anything behind the idea of suicide. There are Youtubers out there like Smosh & Makemebad. I think they'd be a little more on your level. Check them out, amigo.
sethm81392 1 year ago
@sethm81392 Hey i love smosh but i also have been listening to Elliott Smith for years . I got what you were trying to say but i just wanted to say that both are amazing Rip Steven
kallithus 1 year ago
a happy high and a suicide the only things u ever tried.....sad but great lyrics
chillyrooster 1 year ago
elliott smith's music is more relevant to the world today-the bittersweet memories of the past and how we, as a people, blew it. rest in peace, elliott, you were a true prophet-i wish you a fond farewell.
msrosebush 1 year ago
You can only even acuse somebody of a sin if your have 2 or 3 eyewitnesses to the sin. Otherwise YOU must be punished with the punishment that sin requires. Stop guessing and judging. Just be thankful for the music he gave us.
mgmorrell 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I believe it is impossible to stab yourself in the heart twice, the police report says (based on his girlfriends statement) that they had a row she locked herself in the toilet, heard him cry out, found him with a knife in his chest, she pulled it out.
con. below.
connolly10 1 year ago
after appeal from his family to a verdict of suicide the case was reopened and remains open. His girlfriend tried to claim rights to his estate which is being contested by his family. The case remains open after a specialist stated in deat by suicide the knife pushes the victims clothing into the body, this was not the case in this incident!
connolly10 1 year ago
Comment removed
connolly10 1 year ago
what happend him?? like how he die?
fantastic song!
flembot10 1 year ago
he got into a fight with his girlfriend and while she was in the shower he stabbed himself in the heart twice... very sad.
hscura 1 year ago
R*I*P Steven..... we love you even though we've never met you......and we all wish you were back
IntoTheAlone 2 years ago 12
@IntoTheAlone "I'm never gonna know you now but, I'm gonna love you anyhow"
WhiteRabbit926 3 months ago
RIP Jay
Hope the musics as beautiful where you are
onthinice766 2 years ago
RIP-ES
triangletheorytrey 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
fa Q!!!!
JMascisIsMyHero 2 years ago
This is a great song in my opinion. RIP-ES
triangletheorytrey 2 years ago
May he rest in peace; wonderful song ~ thanx for sharing! ^_^ xoxox
SaraMUSt 2 years ago
jesus jerkoff is a unbelievably ignorant
little man. one day when you grow up your gonna hate yourself for being so incredibly stupid. as a corrections officer your the type i have to save from getting raped or abused.....grow up idiot!!!!!
studbelly 2 years ago 4
dude instead of fighting how about listening to the song what if this happend to some1 u love then what would u do call them emo or fag listen elliott smith dident kill himself to be emo he couldent take the pain i dont blame him for doing it because people act like little kids then he killed him self because he was depressed and doing drugs btw idc what u call me oh well words dont hurt me only people who are mean just listen to this song its a great song and its also very very sad rip elliott
runezonerocks 2 years ago 11
thanks man. im glad someone realizes this stuff and dosnt jump to conclusions.
PunkAsFuck111 2 years ago
@runezonerocks words do hurt. but your right. its wrong to talk shit on elliott here like really? your going to do that? bahh people are so frustrating.
goldflakedpaint123 1 year ago
To all of you...i don't give a shit if he killed himself or got hit by a fucking train. He made amazing music, left it here for us to listen to and enjoy. so just fucking enjoy his beautiful amazing songs.
mattyconchatty 1 year ago 3
@mattyconchatty
Couldn't have said it better. RIP E.S.
sethm81392 1 year ago
lmfao nothing jesusjerkoff or the other guy said actually made sense, theyre both loners who need to intimidate people behind a screen about fucking the persons parents when theyve never even seen a girl naked unless it was on a computer.
no, you did not have sex with my parents,
no i am not emo for liking elliot smith.
i am just a normal person who has a normal life.
grow the fuck up you scum.
you have to be either by some 12 year old prick or some 40 year old virgin.
god.
bringmetheKYLE 2 years ago 2
you really piss me off. how can you think that it's funny?
rotflcoptertothemax 2 years ago
People who enjoy Elliot's music might check his videos out once every couple of weeks, and the guy who hates him views them once a day. I finally know what irony means.
hendrixvoodoo 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
top five indie bands
1. elliott smith
2. bright eyes
3. mountain goats
4. fleet foxes
5. kevin m. kirker
but elliott smith will always be #1! we miss you and love you elliott! we'll never forget you! rest in peace
astonishing00 2 years ago
wish he was still here. thanks for video
kidicarusss 2 years ago
go sign the memorial wall!
kaytizzzl3 3 years ago
Where is the memorial wall for Elliot Smith? I really enjoy Elliot Smith's music. I'm a new listener, but it didn't take me long to be captivated by his purity in lyrics. I was just wondering where the memorial wall is. I would appreciate it if you could get back to me.
triangletheorytrey 2 years ago 3
Silver Lake on Sunset Boulevard in LA, I think... I read somewhere it's 4334 Sunset Boulevard, Los Angeles, California. Sorry if any of this is inaccurate...
colin82793 2 years ago 2
Los Angeles
parasympathicus 2 years ago
4334 Sunset Boulevard, Los Angeles, California
Late reply, I know...
Av3ng3dPunk 1 year ago
@triangletheorytrey 4334 sunset boulevard , Los Angeles California
kallithus 1 year ago
...i'm crying...
ashdalte 3 years ago 2
where did you get the pic at 3:06?
roma11n 3 years ago
what an amazing human being. watch his interviews. RIP Elliott. You will be forever missed
ryaneldr 3 years ago
why aren't people more skeptical of his gf at the time?
smolo67 3 years ago
A. I'm guessing the evidence didn't support it.
B. She probably wouldn't have been able to overpower him.
Dredawg42 3 years ago
he is a ledgend, he didnt have 2 commit suicide, forever missed
chopperjoblin 3 years ago 3
Everyone has the right to commit suicide, so,. its not really weakness, and I would say that I don't respect him for it,. but i don't disrespect him for it. Everyone follows there own course.. he had his time, and he was lead to that choice, which was his.
Yihud 3 years ago 4
Amazing....just amazing
Magimon21 3 years ago
the amount of emotion put into eliott's songs is not emo by any stretch of the imageination.... it can only be described as soul. rip bud!
crimmy0204 3 years ago 4
u said it...
dilutedwithdilaudid 3 years ago 2
true talent
isolationeitheror 3 years ago 3
R.I.P C-MILL
freakshowv 3 years ago
Can't say I respect anyone for not fighting life the only way that one can, which is living through the shit; but I can respect the talent. Having said that, Mr. Smith, you will be missed.
Pyrethryn 4 years ago 2
and what do you know about depression Mr? It's not as easy as waking up and saying "shit happens".
Tonedefdom 3 years ago
I can only speak for moderate to severe clinnical depression, which I had/have- it's been a lot better lately since I figured out how to deal with it. But what do I know? I know this: 8 years of on and off counselling (with three different therapists), 3 years of Prozac, 6 months of Zoloft, 3 years of Welbutrin, countless books and information packets, personality tests and naturopathic cures.
That's what I know about depression.
Pyrethryn 3 years ago
Hands up, I'm sorry, it must be tough for you. But the difference is, you had the drugs designed to help the fight, he had the ones that made him give it up.
Good luck.
Tonedefdom 3 years ago 2
It's basically a test-and-try process, because no psychiatrist or doctor will know how each person reacts to each medication. Most people - depressed or not - will have depressive reactions to at least a few anti-depressants. Some depressed people are bodily-resistant to treatment, period. It sucks.
futureblues26 3 years ago
just accept that lifes shit and make the best of it. this current method of society sucks, so lets enjoy it the best we can.
Ihaveabenjina 3 years ago 2
This song is amazing, Eliott was and is still amazing, RIP.
RubixVF 4 years ago
veins full of disappearin' ink, vomiting in the kitchen sink, disconnected from the missin link..it's not my life. Just a fond farewell
bodiddleybodiddley 4 years ago
i wish everyday that he was still with us, but i bet hes making lots more beautiful music up in heaven, rest in peace elliott
joeburgarino 4 years ago
Very awesome. Great job.
gavinthinks 4 years ago
I am so glad I didn't follow the path Elliot did because I would leave so much behind I wasn't thinking about at the time. At least he was there in spirit with his music to get me back on the path I am on now.
GoreMan99 4 years ago 3
wow this vid was added may 07 your a little late, but u know what it doesnt matter when cause tributes to one of the greatest of all is always nice. i miss him to man, but his music will always live on.
fanboyfriedday 4 years ago
I Think you did a great job...
COW546 4 years ago
A fond farewell...rip to my big brother. Great vid.
riptaylor13 4 years ago
i love this song and the videos good
transatlanticrachael 4 years ago