Christina Aguilera vs. Mariah Carey (Live vocal performances)

[iMackid97]

Mariah is built for singing high notes, and angelic. Christina is built for screaming and power. But they are both AMAZING.

I like mariah though more. LOL fuck y'all

[Boulivard81]

I know there no proof this is dubbed. However EVEN in her 'prime' Squealriah has dubbed! (1996 is still prime for her I believe) /watch?v=h58W8TGWkWc&feature=m­fu_in_order&list=UL.

[kaiyno]

@Boulivard81 You're right. Aguilera has never dubbed anything, even when she sometimes sounds awful, she has never agreed to dub her DVDs.

[TheXwatts]

@Boulivard81 yes but there are undubbed versions of her dubbed shows and she still sounds better than xtina...squelariah? wtf is that....

[Boulivard81]

LEGENtina wins of course! She has raw talent, powerhouse voice, whereas CUNTriah only know how to squeal and whisper. BTW its really not fair comparison since Squealriah's performance was DUBBED and Xtina was 100% live

[kaiyno]

@Boulivard81 I have also doubted the authenticity of Mariah's Daydream tour DVD. Who knows if it was dubbed or not, but I think probably not cause she was still in her prime, she had no reason to dub this one.

[lukemichaelhenderson]

christina wins, theres no other singer who can sing like her with such power to her voice. mariah just sounds like a normal average singer recorded and edited in a studio to be pretty honest.

[kaiyno]

@lukemichaelhenderson In this comparison I don't think so, Carey was still in her prime and she did an awesome job. Aguilera did good, but not as good compared to this one.

[Stefano94x]

6:33 ends it all. The Noise could NEVER. 

[kaiyno]

@Stefano94x Too bad she can't do it anymore :[

[Stefano94x]

@kaiyno Too bad Christina has never been able to hit a decent G5, much less to achieve that type of resonance on any note. Oh.

[kaiyno]

@Stefano94x "that type of resonance ON ANY NOTE"??? don't think so, but sure.. whatever you say so...

G5s and resonance isn't the only thing to achieve a great performance, better luck next time :]

[Stefano94x]

@kaiyno It's true, no matter if you agree or not.

And Christina hasn't still achieved a decent performance. Fact. No matter praises or awards, so don't even name them. Has she ever sung something with perfect pitch from the beginning to the end? No. Has she ever sung something without ripping her larynx outta her throat? Nope. Has she ever shown actual musicianship or discipline? Never.

[kaiyno]

@Stefano94x Exaggerating her flaws and limitations won't take you anywhere. She may not have the great technique and the great vocal discipline Houston or Carey had in their prime, but that doesn't mean Aguilera doesn't HAVE THE VOICE, even though she's an IMPERFECT human being, she has pulled through with her faulty singing technique. Pushed larynx or not, this performance is legendary "no matter if you agree or not" :]

watch?v=2VfY0n8Z3OA

[Stefano94x]

@kaiyno That performance is the lowest shit ever lol.

I'm not exaggerating anything, she is just a bad technician and musician. And she has little if any musical ear. A note is either in tune or not, and Christina does not sing in tune. End of.

Having a great voice is something of no significance. Having technique, taste and musicianship is far more important. Christina has none of those qualities.

[andyortiz16]

@Stefano94x yes she has.... lift me up live

[Stefano94x]

@andyortiz16 She still strained on that performance, so. 

[kaiyno]

@Stefano94x Yeah she has to live sing absolutely perfect for you so you won't bash her & hate her that much, please give it a rest stefano, she's great and you know it, and having a great voice is very important, so is technique, taste & musicianship, all those aspects are important, and NO ONE can be perfect on all of them, and I mean no one.

[Stefano94x]

@kaiyno Nope. Many singers do. Not all the time, but they do. Christina is just too flawed on every aspect. And she is too out of tune too often to be considered a great singer. Fact. End of.

[kaiyno]

@Stefano94x And you have to focus only on her negative aspects instead of her positive ones, whether they're a lot or not, right..

[Stefano94x]

@kaiyno LOL. What are her positive aspects?

For the record: having a great voice is of no significance, so don't even mention it.

[kaiyno]

@Stefano94x There's no point in telling you which are cause you won't accept them, ever, simply because you hate her so much, so keep it up with your arrogance and hate, doubt you will get anything from it :]

[Stefano94x]

@kaiyno But the fact she has never sung an entire performance in tune during her entire career is NOT deniable. And my opinion has nothing to do with this. When a note is not centered, it's not centered. Period.

And if a singer sings out of tune so often, she is not a great singer. Fact.

[kaiyno]

@Stefano94x Your overreaction to her live performances won't help your arguments, let it go, she isn't a perfect singer.

[Stefano94x]

@kaiyno It's not an overreaction, it's a fact.

I know she isn't a perfect singer. She isn't a good one either.

[kaiyno]

@Stefano94x Funny, Rolling Stones Magazine ranks her #58 best singer of all time above Mariah Carey, and the Grammy Awards ranks her 2007 performance as #3 best grammy moments ever, wanna take that back? :]

[Stefano94x]

@kaiyno I won't take anything back. That same list ranks Patti LaBelle and Mariah Carey, who sing more in tune and have better techniques and intonations than Christina, at #95 and at #79. This proves that skill has little to do with that list, hence why it's not reliable.

In the performance you named she was straining, she has had many off-key moments and the vocals were random.

[kaiyno]

@Stefano94x For me that list is reliable cause when performing it's not only about "sing more in tune and have better techniques and intonations", it's also about bringing emotion and passion to a song, which Carey has never been good at. It's funny how two lists don't agree with your very shallow opinion :]

[Stefano94x]

@kaiyno "Emotion" and "passion" are shit for the average listeners. There's nothing objective in those things. And Christina's "passion" is what we call oversinging and lack of discipline. Oh.

[kaiyno]

@Stefano94x Sorry you're too stubborn to understand what Rolling Stones Magazine, The Grammys, me, and millions of Aguilera fans around the world do understand :]

[Stefano94x]

@kaiyno Nope, I just know about music. You don't.

Dismissed.

[kaiyno]

@Stefano94x Yeah, you know more music than Rolling Stones Mag, the Grammys, and the millions of Aguilera fans.......

[Stefano94x]

@kaiyno LOL. Aguilera fans are the EPITOME of musical illiteracy. They are just like their fav: zero musical ear and musical intelligence. LMAO.

The Grammys? Rihanna won 2 Grammy's, Lisa Fischer (incredible vocalist) won only 1 Grammy and Debelah Morgan (one of the most skilled technicians in the world) won none. Your point?

[kaiyno]

@Stefano94x What about Rolling Stones Magazine??.. oh, you had no lame excuse for that one, and not all Aguilera fans are illiterate, same for the Grammys who only did their list based on live performances at the grammy award show, not about the awards it gives out to entertainers like Rihanna.

[Stefano94x]

@kaiyno Rolling Stones? Oh gawd, the delusion. They aren't music critics lmao, they are basic journalists with little if any knowledge about music. Whoever puts Patti LaBelle (who, for the record, I don't like as a musician) at #95 and Christina at #58 has zilch knowledge over vocal pedagogy. Patti is objectively a 50x better technician.

And yes, Grammy's have little to do with your greatness as a vocalist as well.w

[kaiyno]

@Stefano94x And the Rolling Stones Mag list ISN'T about "zilch knowledge over vocal pedagogy" or "better technician", it's about who did the best live performance/moment at the grammys in terms of singing, projection, honor, & emotions, a live performance isn't only about the technical singing part, it covers many other aspects.

[kaiyno]

@Stefano94x LaBelle for me is way better technically and of vocal range than Aguilera, BUT LaBelle's live performances aren't as exciting, thrilling and emotional as Aguilera's, so I'm in perfect agreement with Aguilera being in 58 and LaBelle in 95.

[Stefano94x]

@kaiyno Can emotion be scientifically based? Nope. Feelings are subjective, hence why they are of no significance. Technique, intonation and musicianship are objective, hence why singing - which has rules - is based on them. You can be the most emotional singer ever, but if you sing out of tune and with a bad technique, you turn into a noise-maker.

Hence why Christina is just a noise-maker. A glorified and overrated one, but still a noise-maker.

[kaiyno]

@Stefano94x "Can emotion be scientifically based?"??? but we're not arguing about that, and emotions are part of human nature whether there's scientific data about it or not. For YOU, they may be "of no significance", probably cause you're a bitter cold person, but for many people who aren't like that, emotions and feelings during a performance are important cause it gives the song the touch of sense and artistry. Can't believe you have no empathy at all.

[Stefano94x]

@kaiyno The fact Christina's amateurishness and oversinging annoy me doesn't mean I have no empathy. Feelings are of no significance because they are subjective. Music theory and vocal pedagogy are objective issues. Hence why they're what really matters.

[kaiyno]

@Stefano94x Rolling Stones Mag/The Grammys DO NOT base their ranks only on "music theory and vocal pedagogy", regardless of being objective or not. Not all people think like you do and have the same preferences that you do. If you only like singers that apply vocal technique and musical perfection, then Aguilera is definitely not the right singer for you, she's vocally sloppy, raw & 100% natural, which is exactly what RSM/The Grammys, me, and millions of her fans like about her :]

[Stefano94x]

@kaiyno Again, her awards and praises are of NO significance. And the fact you enjoy her is irrelevant as well. See how musically ignorant you Christina stans are?

Music has rules, period. If you don't follow them, you are not a good singer. Christina is not only a flawed technician, she is also a bad musician. Overdoing runs, being all over the place with the vocals and singing random notes is NOT musically intelligent, whether you like it or not. No matter emotions and stuff like that.

[kaiyno]

@Stefano94x They are of no significance & irrelevant TO YOU, not to Rolling Stones Magazine, The Grammys, me and every single Aguilera fan, NOT EVERYONE IS GOING TO AGREE WITH YOU :]

Yes, MUSIC & SINGING TECHNIQUE has rules, but not preferences, and that's exactly what you're doing, you GENERALIZE the whole concept of music just to favor your preference and that's irrational and dumb. Sorry but her fans aint gonna stop loving her just cause some singing technique rules, much less her

[sandyzmz]

@kaiyno rolling stones had a few singers and music critics make that list.the real list should be made by making the public vote,then only will it be fair.and taylor swift wins 4 grammys,so anyone can.i also think that mariah was a powerhouse performer back in the 90's.although i do think that christina is one of the best around today,she definitely is not greater than mariah.mariah set some high standards,man.she was an instant legend.till today,christina still doesnt have that kind of impact.

[kaiyno]

@sandyzmz Agree Aguilera may still not have the impact Carey did in her prime, but I'm with Rolling Stones Magazine about Aguilera making better live performances than Carey, unfortunately Carey didn't last much with her amazing voice and wasn't as vocally reliable after 2000, she was very unstable and RSM eventually had to downgrade her as a live performer. Sorry but that's just how it is, and the Grammys may not be coherent with its awards, but they sure know who can perform better

[sandyzmz]

@kaiyno Carey has lasted till today, although she may not be that strong or powerful anymore, but she can still sing and perform live. i do not believe in the rolling stones hiring some 15 or 20 people to come up with a list.anyway,i respect ur opinion since u are a fan of christina.i guess all this argument wouldnt have started if christina fans didnt diss mariah first of all,u know. and watch carey's performance of You and I in 2002 which proves that she was as stable as ever even after 2000.

[kaiyno]

@sandyzmz Just watched Carey's You and I and she may have been vocally stable there but her voice wasn't at her best, she was too thin & whispery, almost no resonance or vibrato, too much growling whispery low tone, not one of her best live performances in my opinion. Sorry but I don't believe Aguilera fans began the dissin, it was Carey stans who were jealous at Aguilera when she first debuted, many began calling her "the new Mariah" and that's why Carey fans got mad.

[sandyzmz]

@kaiyno hahaha mariah's voice in that performance was no way thin or whispery, her lower register and midbelt was so powerful sounding,resonance and vibrato included. i guess u have different ears.as for the dissing,i know that christina was the first to get annoyed with all the comparison,for whatever reason.and as or the growling,we all know who does the most growling and screaming in their peformances,lol

[kaiyno]

@sandyzmz We have very different tonal preferences then, and no, Aguilera was proud of the comparison with Carey cause she used to be her idol, not anymore because of Carey's jealousy and extreme divaness towards her. Yes, Aguilera sometimes growls and screams, she evidently does it more than Carey, but we also know who does the most lipping and dubbing in their performances, lol. . . . .

[sandyzmz]

@kaiyno but her fans just keep dissing mariah just to glorify christina,hahaha thats really unnecessary.and i have never heard of mariah expressing jealousy over christina cos she is not,in fact.it was just that one time when christina showed up uninvited at mariah's party,which we have already argued about.as for dubbing & lipsyncing,christina's australian back to basics tour was 50% dubbed and editted,most people have agreed on this too.but it wl be too hard for u to.

[kaiyno]

@sandyzmz watch?v=5HBw-24qmrg

This sounds like Carey was (and may still be) jealous of Aguilera, saying: "Oh... very sexy look..".

Even if Aguilera's B2B tour at Australia was 50% lipped, that will never be compared to the excessive lipping abuse Carey did for a long time.

[sandyzmz]

@kaiyno im sure to to other ears this sounded like mariah complimented christina,but u seem to know how to over-interpret everything. anyway, my question is- how come christina's vocal ability can be validated only by trying to put down mariah?? when we talk of mariah we just say that she is great and we dont abuse other singers,but it seems that for people like u,mariah first needs to be invalidated as a singer for christina to look better.but no matter,mariah just remains one of the greatest.

[kaiyno]

@sandyzmz I believe you also over-interpret all of my comments. For your information, in this video I put in the description that my winner is Carey, that's to try to put Carey down? right.. and if I compare them by doing these videos is also to show deluded Carey stans that Aguilera is in better VOCAL CONDITION than Carey (after her prime), not VOCAL ABILITY OR TECHNIQUE. Also, in my opinion, Houston is the greatest of all time in regards to vocal ability & technique, not Carey.

[sandyzmz]

@kaiyno oh then Im glad that we agree on one thing-that whitney is the best female singer of all time,but etta,ella and aretha are the most soulful.i never said that mariah is better than christina at present,she's not.but christina fans just write her off as a lipsyncer and exxagerate the whole thing.and my point was that to validate christina as a great singer, her fans need to first put down mariah,then they are satisfied.but mariah cannot simply be written off cos shes left too much behind.

[kaiyno]

@sandyzmz Houston is an A M A Z I N G rare vocalist that we may never see another female vocalist with that incredible vocal ability and power, it's something beyond amazing, and for me, not even Carey & Aguilera together can equal that unbelievable voice she had in her prime. Yeah, Franklin & Etta are more soulful than Houston, cause houston is more into technique and vocalization than soul, but she has some in her gospel performances. Sorry I don't know who's Ella. Agree on the rest.

[kaiyno]

@andyortiz16 Don't try to convince stefano94 on anything about Aguilera, he hates her so much cause he's jealous about her. He won't accept a single good thing about her voice, ever, which is very irrational tbh.

[chesleycareystar]

@kaiyno TOO BAD CHRISTINA CAN'T GIVE A DECENT... NORMAL... PERFORMANCE...til now.

[kaiyno]

@chesleycareystar Sarcasm much? lol

[chesleycareystar]

@kaiyno #fact 

[kaiyno]

@chesleycareystar You know it's dumb to believe that. You won't see the good side of something, but you sure will see the bad side of it. Sad :[

[chesleycareystar]

@kaiyno whatever, Xtina screams like there's no tomorrow.

[kaiyno]

@chesleycareystar Keep overdoing it :]

[SuperPianogirl123]

@imafan123456 Beyonce

[Raoulirshan]

mariah of course

[shaunmike]

Her best renditions of beautiful are from b2b btw imo. She always did that nice mixed note. I will say xtina is the better performer. Carey sometimes seemed like she was afraid of performing(she was until she owned her diva later on). You could harp on how Mariah is stiff. I never see that brought up smh

[kaiyno]

@shaunmike They're good renditions, but I prefered putting one when she was younger like Carey's performance, they're both about the same age in this comparison. I still prefer and believe her #1 best live "Beautiful" performance was at CNN Heores, that performance moves my spirit like no other, the best, and yes, definitely Aguilera is the better live performer, she has so emotions and melisma going on while she performs.

[shaunmike]

ive come to the conclusion that the only people who strain more than xtina are her stans at trying to glorify her at all costs. i swear they have every carey video on hand disecting it bit by bit. happy birthday to aggie no less. <3 disciple/kaiwhatever. you guy(s?) make stan wars refreshing. i have some time off and if im bored enough will come fer yer wigs!

[db200508]

Why do people keep making these type of videos. as soon as someone says christina mariah fans start attacking us. It happens all the time.

[kaiyno]

@db200508 Because this videos were response to sociopathic deluded lambs who first began making videos comparing Carey with Aguilera, we're just replying back. And btw, Aguilera lost in this comparison, we Aguilera fans aren't deluded like many lambs.

[MrX3Darren]

Mariah Carey obviously wins. Their vocal differences are quite obvious. Mariah wins.

[antihenawhata34]

Hm hard choice, LMFAO jk, Queen Legendriah Songbird Supreme Godrey absolutely killed Straintina The Noise Flopuilera's screeching, as per usual. Anyone who isn't delusional/deaf, or as much as a flop as "IT'S" record sales and live, offkey mess would be aware of these obvious facts. LMFAO! #NEXT

[kaiyno]

@Aontiverozol Never said she became "Legendtina" only because of this performance, idiot.

And I'm no "gurl".

[kaiyno]

@Aontiverozol Contradiction? nope. I base my arguments on logic & rationality, which are very different from your arguments. A Legendtina fan that can't acknowledge Fakeriah's amazing vocal prime and her outstanding performance at the Tokyo Dome concert, isn't being rational, just like a Fraudriah fan would be if he/she can't acknowledge she's one of the biggest vocal frauds in the history of live singing, due to her long excessive lipsynching era :]

[badecnamor]

Christina!

[GoddessVoice1]

I love them both, but Mariah wins

[zusman84]

Mariah = Queen and Legend enough said.

[lawlinat0r]

Flop troll, the screaming cunt that is Floptina will never beat QUEEN Mariah. DEAD at anyone thinking she is anywhere near the same level as Mariah.

[TaylorNardone]

this one goes to miss mariah

[aapascrom96]

Christina wins!

[ILoveMcWhMj4ever]

Mariah Carey has always had an angelic Voice... Christina has a great voice, But not angelic Voice... To me Angelic means Very Pretty, Very soft, and Very interesting... And Very Unique.. And When You hear Mariah You never would have known her powerful and Phanomal Her voice is! Thats why one of the reasons I Think mariah Carey is The Greatest women singer and women legend of all Time.. CRT FOREVER

[ILoveMcWhMj4ever]

The Greatest women singer and women legend of all Time is MARIAH CAREY!!!!! My hero and #1 women singer even past the end of time and Time after that will always and Forever will be MARIAH CAREY! Christina can sing really good But not at the level that MARIAH CAREY is!!! DUH! CRT FOREVER

[ojibiza]

Mariah wins ^_^

[kaiyno]

@imafan123456 Thanks and yes, I usually get classified as a hater, but hating is not to say the truth about live performances, whether it's a bad thing about my favorite or a good thing about a singer which is not one of my favorites, it's the truth.

This Carey performance slays Aguilera because of the amazing vocal acrobatics Carey executed, which she usually doesn't do. I think she was very much at the pinnacle of her vocal prime.

It's a 'best live performance of signature song' comparison.

[imafan123456]

@kaiyno Oh ok. I just thought from our other conversation you hated her.

And I see. You should do another video of their other signature songs (Genie In A Bottle, We Belong Together, Ain't No Other Man, Vision of Love). I know it's hard find a performances of 2000+ MC singing undoubetly 100% live, but all her performances from BET Blueprint 05 are live. Just givin' ya idea's :P

Personally, I love 1992/2001 Mariah's voice and 2000/2006 Christina's voice best.

[kaiyno]

@imafan123456 It seems that I hate her because I sometimes lose my cool when I debat with some Carey stans that aren't in any way objective, that's why I sometimes call Carey "Dumpriah/lipsync queen/moo moo", it's mainly because of her stans that I call her that, I accept Carey is great on the things she is great, for example, she was great in her vocal prime, that I will support, but she isn't that great with her diva attitude, so in that I'm not going to support her.

Thanks for the ideas.

[imafan123456]

@kaiyno I'm very much the same (but Xtina stans). I can't stand how some people (XTINADISCIPLIN) are so childish and vile towards Mariah just because they're a fan of another artist. It's silly.

I find Mariah's divaness funny tbh. Maybe's it's because I've followed her more closely and 'get' her sense of humour etc, I don't know. Each to their own I guess.

[kaiyno]

@imafan123456 XTINASDISCIPLE may seem childish and vile as I also do because that's how be sometimes have to get to defend Aguilera from childish and vile Carey stans, it's actually the same thing, one way or the other.

Sorry but I don't find Carey's divaness funny at all, because that divaness caused the feud with Aguilera, see? for Carey's own personal divaness it may be funny, but when it comes to other female artists, Carey has one of the worst reputations of dissin and feuding.

[imafan123456]

@kaiyno All fans of all artists have a habit of taking it too far. I pointed out XTINASDISCIPLE because she/he is always dissing Mariah unprovoked. Other than that, I have no problem with people stating their opinion.

And I would say Xtina has a worse reputation for dissing and feuding. A lot of people who have met CA have commented on her bad attitude, including Mariah. According to MC, the reason the feud between them started was because CA turned up @ Mariah's party drunk and uninvited. 

[kaiyno]

@imafan123456 I also diss Carey unprovoked, it depends on the video I'm watching and commenting on.

Don't think so, perhaps Carey's worst and longest-running feud is with Madonna, and Aguilera doesn't have a feud that long. A lot of people have also commented about Carey's bad attitude.

Aguilera did go (not drunk) to Carey's party uninvited, but that wasn't when the feud began, it was actually the 'consummation' of the feud. Carey began dissing Aguilera first.

[imafan123456]

@kaiyno In all fairness, the feud between Madonna and Mariah was caused by Madonna calling Mariah 'dumb' and saying that she would rather be dead than be her. Mariah has only ever responded to such comments. She's never said anything against anyone without them starting it.

I don't know many people who have said anything about Mariah's attitude. Most people have praised her and said 'real' she is (including Chaka Khan and Whitney). Christina has a lot more ongoing feuds I believe.

[kaiyno]

@imafan123456 LMAO, you're deluded, can you please send me the link of the video where Madonna calls Carey "dumb"? I can assure you Carey began the feud with Madonna because she's always talking about her, she is pressed Madonna has sold more albums than her worldwide.

Yeah, Carey is very "real" about her selfish narcissistic attitude towards others, no wonder a lot of artists & people dislike her a lot, and no, Carey has more feuds than Aguilera, don't forget Eminem, J Lo, and Janet Jackson.

[imafan123456]

@kaiyno /watch?v=M9GFBi_MnLs

First off, the feuds with JLO and Janet are made up. Mariah is friends with Janet Jackson and JLO's old boss (Tommy Mottolla) stole idea's from Mariah, hence where that feud originated from. But Mariah has publicly said she holds nothing personal against her.

And Aguilera is a well established bitch. Everyone says so: Mary J Blige, Avril Lavigne, Kelly Osbourne, Charlotte Church, Westlife, Lady Gaga, Mariah, Pink, Eminem, Beyonce, Britney, Vin Disel, Miranda L...

[kaiyno]

@imafan123456 Charlotte Church, Westlife, Lady Caca, Beyonce, Spears, Disel, Miranda??? sure... PLEASE stop making things up, if you have no evidence to support these then forget it, you're dumped. I don't consider the Lavigne issue a feud, it was just a simple diss, with P!nk it probably ended. The ones that are still going feuds are with Eminem, Carey, Blige and Kellyphant Shitbourne, this last one is probably her worst feud of all.

Carey also has with Eminem, and her main one: Madonna.

[imafan123456]

@kaiyno Each one of the names I mentioned have commented on Christina being a bitch. None of those people like her. I'm not going to bother arguing with you about it because it's not a debatable issue. If you want proof, type each one of those names, along with CA, into Google (ie. CA Charlotte Church). I'm right.

There are always bust ups between celebrities because of their ego's. CA is the only one to have so many people dislike her without having a feud with them.

[kaiyno]

@imafan123456 And why are you ignoring that Carey also has feuds with Madonna and Eminem??.............

[imafan123456]

@kaiyno Because they're irrelevant. Mariah, Madonna and Eminem are no longer feuding. Neither of them may like MC, but that's their opinion and that's fine. My original point was that Christina is seen as more of a bitch. Nearly all of Mariah's diva rumours were/are written by the press who have something to gain from it, with little substance to them. That said, she is most likely a handful at times too...

[kaiyno]

@imafan123456 LMAO! Carey is still feuding with Madonna and Eminem, especially with Eminem, you're deluded.

[imafan123456]

@kaiyno In '08 Madonna said she liked Mariah's new song (Touch My Body) and Mariah said she thinks Madonna is a true legend. No feud.

In '10, Eminem said he was done with talking about Mariah and niether of them have mentioned the other since. End of feud.

And yes. I'm deluded when you're the one that refuses to acknowledge Christina's blatent bitchiness.

[kaiyno]

@imafan123456 LMFAO lets see the video where Madonna and MooMoo say that.................... good luck with that! :]

Only because Eminem hasn't talked in a while about her doesn't mean the feud is over retard, you're only trying to ignorantly get rid of all of MooMoo's feuds to try to make her seem a noble person LMAO! nice try, but you fail hard. Kellyphant's feud with Aguilera began in 2003 and things cooled down by 2005, and after a period of silence, Kellyphant reignited the feud in 2011.

[imafan123456]

@kaiyno /watch?v=zYurYOn7iq8 << Madonna praises Mariah around the 6:51 mark.

/watch?v=s73mXqnf69c << Mariah praises Madonna.

Once again, you have been proven wrong and, once again, you refuse to acknowledge Christina's blatent bitchiness. I'll leave you to simer.

[kaiyno]

@imafan123456 LMFAOOOOO! Madonna says FIRST: "Let's not talk about Mariah then...", that's to praise her? LMAOOOOO, MAJOR FAIL, and she only said "I like her records" to diss her even more, why do you think she wouldn't have said instead: 'I like her a lot', evidently because she doesn't like her attitude, what a fail.

MooMoo or the interviewer don't mention they're talking about Madonna, how do you know they're not talking about another legend and they made that video up??..... ANOTHER FAIL :]

[imafan123456]

@kaiyno I think you're the only fail if you're seriously trying to convince yourself that Madonna isn't praising Mariah (even though she quite clearly compliments her). And Mariah has said numerous times that she and Madonna are fine. In 2008, she went on Ryan Seacrest radio show and they phoned Perez Hilton who asked Mariah about it and she said "can we stop pretending there's a fight with Madonna cause I've never even met her.." So yeah. Wrong again.

[kaiyno]

@imafan123456 Stay deluded if you with, the fact is MooMoo has always had a feud with Madonna, and about that phone call, PATHETIC, MooMoo only says she doesn't have issues with Madonna because she wants to make people believe she's a noble angel awwwwww what a loser... she's contradictious when she says she has never even met her, she doesn't care to meet her because she disses her, her jealousy goes beyond her control. Madonna will always be a better legend than MooMoo, ALWAYS :]

[imafan123456]

@kaiyno The actual definition of deluded: "a delusion is a false belief held with absolute conviction despite superior evidence". Even with all the proof I have provided about Mariah and Madonna's non-existant feud, you refuse to believe any of it... It would appear that you are the deluded one, not me.

Anyway, I have long past the point of caring of what you think. You're incredibly biased and incapable of holding a civilised debate. I'm off to talk with the grown ups now. Goodnight child.

[kaiyno]

@imafan123456 LMFAO! goodnight retard :]

[imafan123456]

@kaiyno 18 Number Ones :)

[kaiyno]

@imafan123456 18 number ones doesn't make you an authentic live singer, much less to wipe out all your lipsync TALENTLESS performances :]

[imafan123456]

@kaiyno 200 million records sold worldwide :)

[kaiyno]

@imafan123456 Neither that :]

[imafan123456]

@kaiyno I didn't say they did, but it's still 170 mil more than Xtina :)

[kaiyno]

@imafan123456 So? my argument isn't about best album sales, it's about who is the best live performer, which evidently is Aguilera.

[imafan123456]

@kaiyno Actually, your argument was about Mariah being the biggest bitch.

As for the better performer, then yes, Christina is because she has a better stage presence. But Mariah is the better singer; her technique is far superior. Who has the better voice is debatable. Although, I think it's clear who both of us would choose.

[kaiyno]

@imafan123456 That was actually your argument, you began talking about that, I just followed.

You mean WAS the better singer, she HAD one of the best techniques ever and WAS far superior :] Now, all that is ancient history, Aguilera has taken the lead because it's her time to take the lead on all that, and if Carey hadn't lipped that much, she would still have my respects, but she doesn't have them because she's known as FRAUDriah :[

[imafan123456]

@kaiyno Christina should start miming if she's going to continue sounding as bad as she has recently (late 2010/2011). CA has always had a lovely voice, she's just never known how to use it; she oversings and strains and basically ruins her natural talent. Mariah, on the other hand, know's exactly how to use her voice; however, recently she hasn't been using it to its full potential (all the 'whispering').

Yes, the lipping is annoying but whatever. I will always love her voice.

[kaiyno]

@imafan123456 Nope, Aguilera doesn't like to be a FRAUD, like Fraudriah, so no thanks :]

She doesn't sound that bad for me and millions of her fans, so if you simply don't like how she sings, then don't listen to her music, Aguilera has achieved more with her voice & stage presence together than what Fraudriah has done in her 6 years of vocal prime, and Aguilera RIGHT NOW sounds a lot better than Fraudriah :]

[imafan123456]

@kaiyno Yeah, like all those millions that bought Bionic? OH, wait, it only sold 800 000 worldwide, my mistake.

Christina sounds terrible. She's strained so much that she can no longer hit certain notes, resorting to this awful grunting sound :s

MC no longer has anything to prove so she can mime all she likes. She's shown how well she can sing. CA still has a long way 'til she reaches Mariah's level.

Bi bbey gyal.

[kaiyno]

@imafan123456 Nope, up to this day, she has sold more than a million worldwide, get updated because I think that data you have is from months ago.

Nah, for me she still sounds very good and she will continue to sound like this for years. She strains and growls sometimes because she's not a perfect singer, and I prefer that that listening to lipsync performances or weak/choked/flat and off key performances from Fraudriah.

Oh, and 6 years of vocal prime doesn't compare to 12 years of lipsyncs :]

[imafan123456]

@kaiyno Mariah didn't start miming regularly til 2003.. And not every performance since then has been mimed.

Christina only has a handful of good performances. The rest are oversung, strained or both. Let's not forget that CA has done her fair share of miming too..

Obviously, as a CA fan, you might beg to differ, and that's fine. But don't knock my opinion because it's different from yours.

[kaiyno]

@imafan123456 Agree on that about 2003 when she began to regularly mime and yes, not every performance since then has been mimed, BUT the great majority, yes :]

Aguilera's performances are sometimes strained, oversung and off key because she's not a perfect voice and refuses to pretend she is by lipsynching a lot, therefore I consider her a much more respectful vocalist/singer for not doing that, and she has only lipsynched about 7 times, that's it.

I won't knock your opinion, I'll respect it.

[imafan123456]

@kaiyno That is true. Christina nearly always attempts to sing 100% live, even if she can't quite pull it off every time.

I think Mariah mimes because she's insecure. It's no secret that she's a vein person and I think this is definitely reflected in her peformances. She can't stand it when she has trouble hitting certain notes, so she tries to hide it. That said, her voice has improved since she stopped drinking. As a result, her confidence grew and she didn't mime as much.

[kaiyno]

@imafan123456 Yes, I guess stop drinking did help, still she already has some permanent damage to her cords, just like Aguilera has too. Also, the thing is that many Carey stans keep attacking Aguilera and claiming Carey is better than her because she's a perfect singer, which is false in all ways.

Carey shouldn't be afraid of failing because she's a human being, and no human being is perfect. I wish her the best, but for me, the best singer is Aguilera because she isn't afraid :]

[imafan123456]

@kaiyno Lol, yeah. I feel the same. Both Mariah and Xtina stans have a habit of supporting one and dissing the other.

I like Aguilera's voice and take a keen interest in any new music she releases. But I prefer Mariah, so it annoys me when people bash her unreasonably.

[kaiyno]

@imafan123456 I don't think I bash her unreasonably, her untalented lipsynching trail is not a lie, she did it, and that may be the only reason I bash her, mostly because of the stans that can't accept she did it.

[imafan123456]

@kaiyno In fact, scrap that. I just saw your Mariah hate video. Classy.

[kaiyno]

@imafan123456 It's not hate, it's evidence of what she did and said, are you really going to sit there and tell me she didn't say all those things about Aguilera??........

[imafan123456]

@kaiyno It's hate. And say what about Aguilera? Mariah has never said anything bad towards her in public. Mariah confronted Christina to her face when she drunkenly gate crashed Mariah's party, but that's it. And it's funny because your video provides no evidence to support your theory. She sounds friendly and gratious in all the clips you used.

Anyway, I'm not going to waste any of my time talking to such a dedicated 'hater'. Get a life.

[kaiyno]

@imafan123456 Right... I see why you're mad, but keep failing by defending your favorite pressed legend Fraudriah Syncarey, you have no evidence Aguilera was drunk when she went to that party and there's the evidence Aguilera called Carey "amazing", what good has Fraudriah said about Aguilera??............

No wonder you fail so hard :]

[imafan123456]

@kaiyno LOL, even if i had solid evidence, you'd just make up some terrible excuse as to why it's not reliable.

It's funny because you probably spend more time thinking about Mariah than I do. Get a life.

[kaiyno]

@imafan123456 Nope, I only think about Fraudriah when I make videos and when I reply to stans like you, which takes about 3% of my life's time, stay failing with your favorite autotune performer :]

[imafan123456]

@kaiyno Also, Christina started the argument between MC and her. She has a habit of crashing people's parties:

"Christina was a diva from hell and pure torture to be around. She’s so self-obsessed. She insisted her chauffeur drive her indoors into the studio so she wasn’t papped — even though there was nobody outside. Then she crashed my after-party and her bodyguard stood outside the bathroom shouting: ‘Nobody but Christina uses this toilet.’” - Rankin Wadell

I'm not hating, #justsaying

[kaiyno]

@imafan123456 No she didn't, like I told you before, the feud began before the party, and Carey was the one who began dissing Aguilera and talking bullshit to others about her.

PLEASE, Carey needs the entire studio be closed before she arrives to perform, she always gets too drunk at parties and that's probably the reason her mouth is like a sewer, she can't say something nice about almost anyone other than the people related to her. Wandell probably exaggerated things about Aguilera.

[kaiyno]

@imafan123456 With signature song I meant the most important signature song of them, which is Beautiful (Aguilera) & Hero (Carey). They have sang their signature song more than any other of their other songs, that's why it's their most important signature song.

Of course there are a lot of Carey 100% live performances, specially in her prime, and Aguilera gets slayed in many of them, but like my first comparison video of Hurt (Aguilera) vs. AYNAF (Carey), Aguilera slayed Carey in her prime.

[kelvinpyaeko]

this is actually a very nice video and comparison :)

[bfotch]

christina can be just as talented as mariah but she doesnt write the type of good songs mariah did

[Litalici0us]

ARE YOU SERIOUS ?? Mariah wins

[stardusth2o]

Mariah hit a G5 that she adlibbed herself. Xtina eluded the G5 in "Beautiful" as she does everytime she sings it.

6:24 is the same note as 2:43 but Mariah's was effortless and Xtina's was screamed. Mariah DESTROYED Xtina.

[kaiyno]

@stardusth2o Yes, Aguilera got destroyed in this comparison.

[123buffylover]

@stardusth2o the beautiful note is an F#5, beyond christina's belting range live

[JamaaJaan]

even tough mariahs high notes r technically better in ur opinion and stuff like that i think at the end of the day important is how everything sounds ... and i think that christinas way of singing is definately more intresting and its simply magic... her unique way is just undescribeable... !!! but no doubt mariah is legendary too !:)

[waders14]

mariah.



[xtinasfighter]

Christina Aguilera <3

[jakey1126]

people are forgetting that mariah INFLUENCED christina, especially in her vocal techinique.. the true Queen here is Mariah

[kaiyno]

@jakey1126 Influencing someone doesn't make that person better than the other, both Aguilera and Carey are amazing legends, but in this performance Carey was beyond amazing, flawless and very clear vocals, really amazing indeed. Carey has messed up in many other live performances, so no one is better than the other, and my favorite will always be with Aguilera no matter what.

[musicisunityandlove]

Mariah is and will always be vocally superior to CA! She was effortless in her prime. Christina's straining ass can't hit a C5 without straining

[kaiyno]

@musicisunityandlove Aguilera has hit C5 + sustained IN HER PRIME, now she strains because she isn't in her prime years. Her legendary C5 + sustained 20 seconds was at her Stripped World Tour when she performed "At Last", Carey has never sustained a C5 that long ;)

[stardusth2o]

@kaiyno That wasn't sustained. It was punched numerous times. That is not sustained. Also, it was incredibly strained.

[lc0309]

For me Christina's voice is way more beautiful than mariah so that means xtina slays

[regadooooooooo]

christina the best

[ChinaDoll1291]

They both got terrific voices but overall, Mariah hits the highest notes :P

[iSammieBie]

In the quality of the performance i think Mariah really did better.. But we shouldn't judge their voices this way though.. U cant judge who is better cus they both have different and unique voices .. CA cant be a Mariah and a Mariah cant be a CA. <3

[kaiyno]

@iSammieBie Agree. It isn't much judging, it's more of a comparison, but we do get to see some of their vocal limitations at certain performances.