Added: 1 year ago
From: MattKoval
Views: 56,080
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (980)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • We just watched this in my English class now we have to write a 1/2 page analysis on it.

  • why is it called tenth?

  • @yashandchriscod Happend on sept 10th day before the 11th

  • Nice. :)

  • WOW...oooooo..dang!

  • i got chills

  • You're Great.

  • It took me this long to figure out why it was named "Tenth"...

  • that was so great!! Your films are AMAZING!

  • i loved this video its really gloomy but interesting.

    your such a great film maker.

    dont ever stop doing videos on youtube.

    5stars :)

  • Hey Matt! I wanted to thank you for being such a well rounded film maker, you're my hero! This short says so much to me, it well done, has such an impact on it's viewer (I stared crying the first time I saw it) and it's makes you think about how you can never truly know what the future will bring. I hope someday, (many years away) I can too can create such an impact as you have created on me, and many others. Thank you!

  • dont ever stop making youtube videos ! 

  • ...

  • @thewardude101 duh stupid how old r u not to know that I was three when 911 happened and I still knew what it looks like

  • This was really good... But sad

  • *shivers* Really...really moving. Props to you man.

  • Wow I didn't expect this, I started tearing up at the end

  • matt you deserve to be at least top 10 most subscribed

  • I started crying. This really got to me. :(

  • :( Sad.

  • This was extremely awesone film...

  • on the TV...was that 9/11? 

  • theres no such thing as perfect but this is the cloes it can get! =)

  • ISE ALANI!

  • :'[ matt u a badass director/film maker

  • Holy crap!! Thats freakin amazing

  • how come your not the most subscribed on youtube><

  • Quite moving.

  • wow

  • I dont get it

  • That was Amazing!

  • Quite a powerful short movie, I have to say. And very surprising. Didn't see the ending coming and I'm happy the atmosphere was more mysterious/haunting than emotional. Stories like this are easily overdone and overacted. Those last tines were perfect. Well done. You've got my respect.

  • Oh my gosh, I loved this... :(

  • That was amazing, but so sad :(

  • Wow this was amazing

  • its kinda off a bit...cuz the video of the real 9/11 crash wasn't shown after the day of 9/11

    cuz nobody at the time, carry a live video camera in the street on purpose unless its a news reporter and i doubt that would happened

    in the this video, u mentioned that he turned on the tv next morning, meaning its a live broadcast...

  • @Xanthosis012 it was broadcast live, and they did show footage of the terrorist attacks as they were happening, including the plane hitting the south tower

  • @StevieDisopolis how would that be possible? I mean, most of the videos were amateur taken, meaning it personally taken from video cam or phone...

    unless some of the people or government already know where the plane is heading n that it going to hit the WTC and killed thousands...then yeah,

  • @Xanthosis012 its very possible, even in 2001. News and camera crews were all over this story almost immediately after the north tower was hit. Trust me, when shit like that happens, news travels fast.

  • WAS ANYBODY HOME!

  • so she was on a flight to La, was that one of the planes that hit the towers?

  • Incredible. How did this end in your mind? Was the family home? I really like to hope something come up and they were home. I'm hoping they're alive, even though they're only characters. Maybe it's because I know this could have been anyone.

  • impact filled

  • This broke my heart because it happened. The planes really did cash. It's not like a sad fiction film in which something happens, you cry and then you forget. No, this was real.

  • This is the most powerful 3 minutes I have ever seen. This is the perfect 9/11 short because it shows that everybody was impacted in some way.

  • wow... i was expecting something funny... but this was amazing! matt, you are really talented, and apparently in more ways than one :) <3

  • I've seen this before...

  • @seaturtle69 yeah it was shown on some film festival..he got an award for it or something, i mean go figure.its awesome.

  • That's so sad.

  • Wow--that video is absolutely amazing, Matt!!!!

  • I hope more people discover this video Matt. Very powerful.

  • Almost one year later and this still makes me tear up a bit, good job, Matt.

  • holy shit i am in awe Y.Y im having goosebumps

  • WOW!!!! O____O

  • niicee.. :)

  • WERE THEY HOME D:

    

  • This left me speechless

  • That's deep. Very cool

  • i just had to watch this video twice, simply amazing

  • OMG this is soo sad u shuldve uploaded the video 2 days later

  • This was made in 2002! :O

  • Amazing short

  • this gave me chills!!

  • @gumpgirl1 what's 9/11???

  • @19zebra19 the attacks on the twin towers (11 september 2001). You can look it up on wikipedia, but im pretty sure you've heard of it.

  • @19zebra19 You really don't know what 9/11 is?? i don't bealive it.

  • @TheCua1228 i know i always see people mention it on t.v and i am like omg WTF - but i am a english girl who doesn't like history any more... :)

  • @19zebra19 well... I'm from Ecuador, I'm just 15 and I know everything about 9/11. So, been english isn't a problem. History is awsome!!

  • @TheCua1228 lool u sound super smart but i used tO LOVE history but now i am in secondary school and OMGall it is about it - this guy hurt this guy... this guy died.. etc they have made it SO boring... but i still watch horrible histories on t.v ... mwhahah xx coul du possibly tell me a brief of what it is .. :)

  • amazing.

    

  • Having just been at the world trade center site, this has more meaning to me than ever. Never had I been so emotionally rattled to the point just before tears than standing there in the eerie quiet

  • @gumpgirl1

    As matt said they were on their way to LA and apparently because the planes would be fully loaded with fuel.

  • Sad

  • wow. i have to say i almost cried

  • i knew something bad happen but what did hurt me more, i didnt know anyone but it is sad that happen :c

  • So touching!!

  • This had like the remember mr plot twist

  • MattKoval let me just say, this is a real work of art. Finally I know someone who can direct a movie and likes sad endings, because it's realistic and it's life. Not everything ends all happy, some end in the deep dark abbys that we call sadness...and that's life. It will always be like that, some in the glorious light of happiness and some in the dark cavers of sadness.

  • Was it his fault that the mom died/ did she die/ CONFUSED!!

  • @RBstationable The mother did die, the boy was sad because he didnt want her to go, he had a bad feeling. I feel bad for the boy, but that's life.

  • Comment removed

  • This was BRILLIANT... sad, but Brilliant!!!!!!!

  • Comment removed

  • i didnt expect anything of the movie to go the about it did....:(

  • thank you matt you are a inspiration to all young film makers out there.

  • ive watched this about 10 times over the past few months, makes me feel so sad every time..

    this is amazing.

  • hey maybe making a short flim related to war, will be great.

  • That was really good and very touching! But sad too. You should make some more.

  • amazing ! this gives me the chills!

  • great job

  • I almost cried when I saw this... :(

  • can somebody explin to me what happen, i kind of dont understand it. :/

  • @themexicandulce Basically, the woman that was going to the interview was on the 9/11 flight and we can assume she died. The son was upset that she was leaving. The kind of terrible part is that by the dry cleaner doing a good deed, he basically let someone die.

  • ... wow 

  • you sure got a big range in your videos. Great video

  • In 911 there were 4 planes with high-jackers on board, 2 hit the world trade centre, one was heading for the pentagon but the passengers managed to crash the plane, and the last was believed to be heading for the White house but was crashed and they never found the plane - enough info 4 ya?? By the way beautiful video matt

  • @moonface656 I could of sworn the plane heading towards pentagon still hit it....

  • @KendeII One did hit the Pentagon, i used watch a programme set after the attacks, i think it was called Threat Matrix.

    I'm pretty sure they found the one the crashed in the field, that was United flight 93, which there was a film made about - they must have found the black boxes as the film makers tried to recreate what happened onboard (unless they hypothesised it all).

  • @tanner1ie I ment to add, there was a character in the programme that lost a husband, who was in the army when a plane hit the Pentagon.

  • Omg, I'm in tears right now. Dunno wat to think, If that was me I wouldn't know if I should cry or scream- the film is beautifly done tho just so sad

  • I like this film. Nicely done. A great example of how smartly used editing, and good writing, timing and pace can overcome lower production values inherent to independent filmmaking.

    Check out my one minute film Matt, you might like it as the tone is similar.

    well done.

    Matt Taylor

  • crying right now.

  • ...

  • @MattKoval Hey I immensely appreciate your explanation - i'm not american, and not familiar enough with american history. I thought in retrospect i had asked such a dumb question, but you answering the question without any judgment is truly heartwarming! Thanks matt :) I just discovered you on Youtube and I can't wait until the next date ;) also posted this short on like all of my friends facebook walls haha. Take care, and all the best.

  • I CUMMED FROM THE AWSOMENESS

  • couldnt be better.. your work is amazing, you have a great future

  • amazing work! thats so sad but it AMAZING!!!!

  • Wow. This was beautiful!

  • Amazing...

  • Wow, it left me shocked and amazed! Completely breath taking and captivating. Please make more short films! This one was just stunning.

  • Why is this short film called, "tenth?"

  • @ScrambledGregs23 the date he let the woman and the kid in the dry cleaners was september tenth, right before 9/11

  • @ScrambledGregs23 tenth as in Sept. 10 the day before 9/11, i didn't get the title until the credits rolled

  • toronto ?

  • @Sleepercell69 WTF is wrong with you do you even have a heart how dare you pust a commet like that on this video bastard

  • it's so sad..........

  • i got goose bumps at the end :(

  • that was sad, beautiful, amazing and very very sad.

  • Damn man...that was fraking beautiful. A very deep look at how those little fleeting moments where you stop to tie your shoe and then pass an accident on the freeway that you may have missed by only a few seconds. There but for the grace of god go I. (not trying to be religious but it's a good saying)

  • GOd have pity on the souls who died on 9/11. May they rest in peace, they did not deserve to die.

  • today 65 people just don't get it... well-done Matt! do your thing!

  • Comment removed

  • Whoever disliked this are losers with no life. This video was epic, man. So sad and tragic.

  • "tenth".

    the title- that was the date of the night he let the woman in.

    this was completely amazing- and you titled it well. titles can add or detract from the story, and I can assure you this title adds.

  • I can feel tears welling up. that was amazing.

  • This video was so beautiful.

    In the three minute it was playing it touched my heart.

    It also made me cry.

    Very beautiful.

  • sad

  • I am probably too young,but I do not understand.

  • @Bramborail Its a great work

  • @Bramborail he made a small choice by letting the women come in so she wouldn't miss her flight, which lead her to 9/11

  • @B5romeo I see.

    Hopefully he does not blame himself... !!!!!!

  • Amazing idea!

  • Amazing.

  • Holy shit. I am bawling my eyes out right now.

  • what happens!!!!!!!!!!?????????????­?

  • oh tenth..... sep. tenth

  • Incredible. Thought provoking. Art.

  • 65 people never open the door for the mom and her son.

  • dude... GREAT WORK. I love it!!

  • please visit my channel.despirate for subscribers. thank you♥

  • i think ive seen this b4. is it reuploaded?

  • @berflaberab2 yes

  • Sick short!

  • This is amazing !

  • I thought that the directing and cinematography were good, but some parts of the story, like that glove, were way too cliche for me. Also some of the narration was rather self-explanatory. Nice idea though. There was even some atmosphere in it. Keep at it! :)

  • the song in the backround with piano what is that for a song? i want it bad:) Great movie. i know everyone says this but Keep it up!

  • true goosebumps film, great job

  • it's all about those moments....

  • 9-11 happend in NY, they were going to LA and it was a terrorist attack

  • i got goosebumps

  • very touching!

    great job!

  • Wow...that was amazing, gave me the chills! Great job on this Matt! You set the mood so well with your shots and music choice.

    LOVED IT! :) Hope there are more you are working on

  • This video gives me the chills. It's genius!

  • omg. that was soooo SAD! but a good film. i almost cried and nothing happened yet

  • Your a great director matt. This was such a moving film. Thank you

  • that was a piece of art. sad. but art.

  • Matt -- I posted this on my facebook page. This was a really brilliant and profound piece of art.I was deeply moved. Thank you

  • I think it's great that you can make people laugh in your Fuplers videos, but also make people think a little as well. 

  • Matt, you killed me with this... in a good way. You said more in 3 minutes about that event than most might have said in an hour. Thank you, simply thank you.

  • dude, so great i would wanna see this on friggin tv

  • This is an amazing film with a huge emotional impact. Well done

  • i cried. this is such an amazing short film. i was intrigued by the whole thing, and it had a great message and a cliffhanger ending. thank you Matt!

  • I think you're very talented and you should be given more opportunities on a bigger platform. Anyways, good luck. =)

  • this was great

  • 64 people don't have hearts</3

  • Incredible message in 3 minutes. Very well done.

  • WHY IS THIS NOT ON THE FRONT PAGE OF YOUTUBE!!!???

  • Thank You