Added: 4 years ago
From: RedHearse
Views: 594,852
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (3,544)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • No one can replace Heath Hedger! Heck his performance is WAY BETTER than Jack Nicholson!

  • @SkyLineZ26 different, but not better

  • are they having joker in the new batman movie? cause I know Bane is gonna be in it

  • @TheTobi117 No

  • @Felizdakat okay

  • Heath Ledger is the real Joker. He ruined Batman by stealing the Joker role then died knowing that nobody else could measure up.

  • daniel day lewis is a great actor and i think he would actually make for a great joker ... but it would be different ...it would be lame and it wouldnt be heartfelt if he placed it trying to copycat heath ledgers performance because we know it is not heath but then if he does make it his own... it would be odd because the joker in part 3 isnt the joker were seeing from part 2 ...heath owned this role and it ends with him ...maybe lewis can play the joker in a reboot that way it wont suck.

  • noone can replace heath as the joker i just can not be done

  • Not true but it's not a bad idea.

  • This ISN'T true.

  • If you guys are really a big fan of Joker I suggest watching TheJokerBlogs.

  • honestly i think DDL would be a really great joker, he could play him if they did a movie where its like 10 to 20 years down the line on joker and what he would be doing and what he looks like. DDL is a pretty amazing actor and he would rock the shit out of the role just like Heath did in TDK.

  • instead of johnny depp being riddler he should be joker

  • Daniel Day Lewis is the right man for the job, but you cant take away heaths performance, fcking outstanding

  • OMFG DAIL DAY LEWIS WILL PLAY AA GREAT JOKER

  • I think Benicio del Toro would be a pretty decent Joker. That's who I thought might have gotten it before Ledger.

  • richard lewis needs to play the joker

  • there wont be another Joker like Heath, he was hands down the best. if he hadnt have died however, there is no doubt in my mind that Chris Nolen would have brought back the Joker in the next movie because the Joker never died at the end of teh Dark Knight, just left hanging upside down. he would have then been sent to Arkham where he meets Harley Quinn and that is what the new Batman would be about. i wish they would still bring back Harley though

  • Jack isnt shit compared to heath's portrayol. I know jack was first and is classic but heath definitely blew him out of the water.

  • Am I the only one who thinks, okay, yeah, he's pretty decently old-ish now, but Mark Hamill could definitely have played a live action joker.

    He already has the voice for it.

    It just wouldn't have been as serious a Joker as Ledger's(which, admittedly, I wasn't a fan of[the seriousness, I mean. I like the fun Joker of TAS]).

    Stalone still tried to do movies and he's bloody ancient by now.

    Just sayin'...

    I'm a huge Hamill fan...

  • @PerfectSaga

    I am as well, but it wouldn't have worked.

  • Jim carrey actually has a shot at replacing heath

  • @vicdarockstar I thought the same.

  • No Heath, no Joker....

  • u cant replace heath ledger

    

  • what about jim carrey... and johhny depp. they could be good jokers!

  • @darkerise2 Jim Carey already portrayed Edward Nigma, or The Riddler, in a previous Batman movie. And as for Depp...no.  Just no. His funny-psycho roles always turn out way to forced for him to ever take on The Joker.

  • its the voice it throws it off hes just not insane enough

  • jack is better

  • heath sucks

  • Onision should play the new Joker

  • uhh Wow It could work With Lewis as The New joker but Thats going to be Hard tho I mean He got the "Joker" Face and smile a lil Bit But Who Knows..

  • The Joker,The Joker,The Joker.What about Harley Quinn?I so want to see her in a movie.

  • maybe the guy from the joker blogs should replace heath but the joker died with heath RIP

  • @TheSeanKelleher I totaly agree. But it would be nice to have Heath Ledger to play the joker still.

  • @TheSeanKelleher I'm not sure I can agree. That guy is great, but not nearly as intimidating in those.

  • @TheSeanKelleher everyone says that b/c he looks like heath the closes and does a pretty good job at sounding and being the joker. maybe when they do the reboot he'll be in it.

  • The Joker luckily isn't Heath Ledger, it's whoevers good enough to portray such an enigmatic character. It was once Jack Nicholson just as it was Heath, and Daniel Day-Lewis would be a prime candidate in the future. Life goes on!

  • Comment removed

  • daniel day lewis might actually be a good joker...but sadly no one will every replace the heath joker

  • Heath is the Joker. Heath is dead, the Joker is dead.

  • A seriously tough act to follow but Daniel Day-Lewis is the shit so maybe?

  • Maybe they can make a hologram of Heath Ledger.

  • In honor of Heath Ledger, delete this video.

    An another actor should not copy Heath Ledger and do is own way of acting.

  • c'mon ppl, yea Heath did a GREAT performance as the joker, but the joker must live on, just because Heath did amazing joker doesn't mean another actor can't. Comic book characters are immortal, but actors are not.

  • He wouldnt do the same job as heath. but i say thro leo dicap in there.

  • You shouldn't even bring him back into the series. No one can do the Joker like Ledger did.

    If they ever reboot Batman they can use another actor, but NEVER in the same series.

  • that could work

  • Daniel Day Lewis is going to nail this. Why? He's possibly the best mainstream actor out there.

  • How can nobody like the idea of the Daniel Day-Lewis as the Joker, fucking brilliant actor and his role in Gangs of New York as the Butcher proves he's more than a match for heaths Joker. Also anyone who can only says Heaths role as the Joker is outright the best has clearly never watched the older batman with Jack Nicholson. Don't get me wrong Heath Ledger was a legendary actor but people need to stop clinging to him as the only possible actor that could play the Joker.

  • Daniel Day Lewis is 57, and I'm not sure if that would fit the younger look they'll probably be going for. Since they want to work in the Justice League storyline, in the new films.

    Daniel Day Lewis I must admit would be great in any role you gave him whether it was as Batman, the Joker, a tree, a park bench.

  • Heath was a horrible joker, he seemed more like a henchman than anything, and after all, did any of you actually pay attention to his lines? "Im an agent of chaos" and i think he also said hes a messenger, they can use that and say he was sent ahead of the actual joker to cause as much issues as possible. cause Heaths joker was just so off from the lore of joker. and no i dont mean the acid bath.

    and with the new joker they need to do something else than just clown make up,

  • The Joker should not be in another Batman movie until enough time has passed.

    Maybe in a decade or two, and Joker should only be used if they adapt A Serious House on Serious Earth, the Arkham City novel, because Joker is more psychotic and sick in the book, which offers a new performance from a new actor.

  • massive boots to fill, gotta be pretty daunting. but if anyone can pull it off he can

  • @adlufc1141 not really that massive... only reason why people saying heath was good, is cause he is dead, he was decent at best for joker.

  • DDL is such a method actor he'll probably go on a killing spree in order to 'understand' the character.

  • @JDELUX237 u r so damn right about it ... i have read about his character understanding .... he locked himself to get into the character.. that is the reason of his phenomenal performance in his films

    peace

  • why dont they just have gary busey do it?

  • no one is a better actor to play the joker than Heath ! R.I.P Heath <3

  • NO daniel dayy lewis is the only one on this palnet that can! AND Im sure Heath ledger would want it that way unless of course there is some kind of curse on this role!!

  • if they were going to show the joker in tdkr i think they would have just shown him for a brief moment. not for a main villian

  • I think most of the people saying Daniel Day-Lewis is incapable of repeating the incredible performance of Heath Ledger really do not know the sheer talent of DDL, he is, unquestionably, the greatest actor of our time. The intensity of his performances is unrivalled, and he commits 150% to his character so you know he will do justice to it. He's won two Oscars and will probably set a new record winning his third in 2013.

  • Daniel Day Lewis could do the Joker, and even (PLEASE DON'T COME FLYING AT ME WITH DAGGERS) take the role to new levels, he seriously could and own it and give us the same joker we had before maybe a little old version is all.

  • yes! so they are gonna continue the character? does any1 know? if its true

  • I love Heath Ledger as the Joker but i love the Jocker more. I want him back in the same costume no changes and the actor needs to be good. Otherswise, im not watching the sequal.

  • People need to stop being nerds. Daniel Day-Lewis is a fine actor. Please stop being so nerdy "nobody can replace Heath" you guys sound like a bunch of 12 year old girls who like some boyband. If there is ever is a return of the joker and this man can DDL can do it.

    P.S. Stop being so attached to somebody who pissed away his life.

  • @JACKOTACO Agreed. Lewis is the best actor alive right now in my view. Ever see There Will Be Blood? Lewis is a ridiculous talent. Heath played this one role and he did great but all the rest I could careless about.

  • Great choice ..the Joker can be anyone! RIP Heath you were great the show must go on

  • In all honesty Heath was an amazing joker but if there where no joker i would find myself almost incapable of watching batman though no one else could ever do as amazing a job as Heath

  • IF anyone HAD to replace Ledger, I do feel Lewis is the best possible choice. 

  • @opsocftw I agree, it's not they replace Heath cause they wanted to. Hes dead, that's life. At least they got a actor who could also do the role justice instead of some wash out. I dnt like the fact that the Justice League movie will have all new plp in it. The guys who played Batman and Superman are still live how come they not in the movie? Lets get mad about that.

  • MAN! i really wish heath ledger were here to play as the joker again, hes an amazing actor.

  • You do know that it's been confirmed that the Joker won't be in the 3rd film, right?

  • Just for the record, i hope you guys know that as far as I've been told, they've retired the joker and that no one can ever play the part again. Which leads me to believe it had something to do with Heath Ledger death. And he's job in acting the part.

  • I hope he can come up with his own style... no one will ever b like Heath Joker

  • so i say we got about 5 years until a genius director casts jim carry as Joker...

  • Batman 3 will have Catwoman and Bane as the villains. End of story.

    Video is bullshit.

  • He might pull it off, IF...he puts in the effort Ledger did.

  • Daniel is good...It CAN be done. However we just don't want it to be because Heath was fantastic. But pretend he is alive and just refused to do the part. They'd have trouble but would eventually replace him like normal. They would use a very good actor, though who acts different. But, I'm sure people would be comparing and choosing a favorite too. People compare Rachel Dawes for example...but on that note, no one likes Rachel and Maggie gets my vote because her Rachel died.

  • they need to bring back jack nickelson

    

  • Do not bring the joker back. It cannot be done.

  • Niggas highly underestimating the acting capabilities of mister lewis...

  • No way dude. he might be a great actor , but i don't think he can pull it off. Ledger I don't believe can be replaced........ Maybe Johnny Depp and thats a big MAYBE

  • OH OH shit I got an idea how bout knowbody replaces heath! He was the one and only

  • It has been confirmed that there will be no joker in the new movie.

    The director said it would dishonor his memory as well as the joker's.

  • i think that if they can find the right person making a new movie with the joker would be fine..sides i want to see harly quinn

  • Now that we've gone Heath we can never go back, they'll lose more money than they'll make if they replace him

  • it's nice to dream isn't it?

  • I dont think hes coming back in norlons batman movies

  • I think Joker died with Heath Ledger, noone can ever replace him just as noone can bring Heath back to life. Both characters are gone, they should make a movie about Heath Ledger making the Joker.

  • @djeskolive

    really the only way you could bring the joker back is to start a new batman franchise and re invent the joker again.

  • @fennifer2005 Only in a very very long time. Personally i wouldn't appreciate it if they made a new joker any soon. They need to wait at least some years to pass for a new story to take place, since joker didnt die in the movie he was only captured, they can make something new. But not soon. It would be disrespectful to Heath's brilliant performance to replace him so quick.

  • @djeskolive

    completely agreed. it would have to be our next generation making the movie,  like the gap between adam west's batman to jack nicholson's or jack nicholson's to the dark knight.

  • @djeskolive until jack Nicholson dies the joker will be alive

  • @djeskolive although the death of Heath Ledger as the death of anyone, was a tragedy, the caracter of the joker was written before he was even born, and the joker has been interpreted by an Oscar winning actor such as Jack Nicholson, so to say that no one could replace Ledger in the role of the joker is laughable, especially if Day Lewis is considered for the part, as he is one of the best actors that have ever lived, where as the late Heath Ledger was a decent performer, at best.

  • @Cagliostro85 Im not saying there are not better actors than Heath. Day Lewis is great but Heath managed to bring the joker to another level. So i think it's gonna be very difficult for someone to replace him. Everyone loved him. Call me stupid but i personally prefer Heath over Nicholson as joker anytime. I won't say Nicholson was better over respect, he was different. Heath gave him personality in a different way. Jim Carrey can be crazy serious too, like in "23". Think about it.

  • @djeskolive i dont completely disagree with you but its not like he's the only one who could play it. and ur kinda right in the sense that nobody's gonna be man enough to actually try to replace him even though it can be done

  • @djeskolive stupid

  • @djeskolive Cept Heath never had the claimship of the Joker in the first place. That title goes to Jack Nicholson

  • @djeskolive Ofcoutse he'll return. He's definitely going to be in the reboot.

  • @djeskolive I second that

  • @djeskolive Two words: MARK HAMILL. Joker died with Heath Ledger? Don't make me laugh. He was amazing in Dark Knight but when I read comic books I hear Mark Hamill in my head not Ledger.

  • @djeskolive In The Movies, Yes. BUT In Other Media (AKA Arkham Games) Mark Hamill Does A Good Job

  • No one can replace Heath..except for maybe Heath...

  • @BoredandUnorganized Actually, Daniel Day Lewis could do it. Heath was great, but they are both great. Or were, in Heath's case, may he rest in peace. They look enough alike, too.

  • @PtFurious What's sad is that it is a legitimate claim to say that because D-Day Lewis is such an extraordinary actor, he could overshadow Ledger

  • @PtFurious Yes, I agree, but I suppose it might be time to just move on. Heath Ledger was the originally, let the joker die with him..it was his and Jack Nicholsons Character, NO ONE ELSES! Haha, ahhh yes, I love them both.

  • @BoredandUnorganized Only Jack and Heath were the ones I liked. I don't know how I felt about Jim Carrey as the Riddler, though. Thoughts on who should play the Riddler?

  • @BoredandUnorganized I want to revise something I said. Mark Hamill is still my fave joker, but he's the animated one, and from the best toons.

  • WHY SO SERIOUS 

  • no 1 can out on the performance that heath did. it'd b pathetic if they even tried, but christopher's got more brains than 2 do sumthing like that

  • u ass for this

  • onision all the way!!

  • @blackeagle1289 ikr? XD Onision looks so close to the Joker XD

  • i think lewis black could make a great yet older joker, any thoughts? lewis black is insane and angry enough to pull it off.

  • i almost died laughing at the ''seamless transition''

  • @NEMZOOO

    lmao, I know it's so obvious. But hey, he don't look half bad.

  • Dude there is no sequal for Joker the new one is with BANE Joker is in Arkham laughing his ass off with Harley AH!!AHAHAHAH!!

  • @MrBoondock1 Look at when this was uploaded.

  • @L3phili3Tjosh lmao woah what a loser then

  • @MrBoondock1 yup lol

  • I can't wait to see Day-Lewis play Lincoln. Spielberg picked the perfect mand for the job. He's so friggin intense!

  • I think he would be an excellent choice.

  • Heath ledger was not that great of an actor...I believe he was raised up and over rated because he was stupid enough to kill himself. He died as a coward.

  • @aubhar

    Can't tell if trolling or just stupid

  • @aubhar Are you trolling or Mentally ill? Heath Ledger was an AWESOME actor and he was NOT a coward.

  • @aubhar He accidentally over dosed on meds, happens all the time.

  • Those are some big shoes to fill. I wish him luck- I admit I wouldn't have the audacity to attempt it.

  • LOL at 0:26 ahahahaha

  • no

    

  • Spoiler: he drinks Batman's milkshake.

  • Daniel Day Lewis would surpass Ledger as the Joker, his role in GONY as the Butcher has very similar mannerisms to The Joker. wow

  • ahmadinejad is a perfect role for jocker

  • Daniel could act the shit out of that role more than anyone else, but I'm afraid people would hold an animosity towards him for "replacing" Ledger.

  • to be honest i said will smith cuz lets face it he could do ANY ROLE

    but this oculd be done right with this fuck nugget

  • YOU'RE A BASTARD IN A BAT CAPE!

  • Bane and Catwoman. The Joker is finished. They will not replace him.

  • @alexcraig07 The Joker can't go away. He is always there. Haven't you read the comics or seen the animated series?

  • @snyp3rseth I haven't read the comics or animated series but this is the last Batman that Christopher Nolan is making and he said he wont bring the Joker back into this film because of two reasons. 1: He kicked Batman's ass in the last film, and two, he doesn't want to replace the actor.

  • If anyone can match the performance Heath Ledger did, its Daniel.

  • Daniel Day Lewis playing a crazy killer well? Nothing we haven't seen before. Lewis is one of the best actors of our generation.

  • when i saw lewis i thought Lewis Black that would be interesting to see

  • I want Willem Defoe as the Riddler

  • how bout jhonny depp for joker?? he could be the best joker..

  • @blo0dsh0t420 agreed

    

  • They chose Daniel Day-Lewis, one of the most famous current method actors, to play The Joker?

    Are they fucking mad?

  • @cuteasarhino umm dude, this is old news, there is noi joker in the new film, its cat woman and bane, and bane will most likely break the batman

  • @gitarguy06 Oh sorry dude :L

    I don't really watch the films, but was feeling weird having DDL playing a psychotic madman :L

  • @cuteasarhino I agree, Heath played a role that NOONE can ever duplicate. Would be like saying they could duplicate Nicholson's Joker....just can't be done. Once you've reached perfection, why look to make it anymore perfect? Just sayin...

  • @Orion13622 Agreed, they should create a new persona for the Joker, once you've perfected one persona of a character, it's incredibly hard to duplicate it ;)

  • Day Lewis is a perfect choice. He draws himself into the charecter.

  • I think that Heath Ledger did a number on Joker that people will have a hard time getting past that one. I mean, he brought a Joker into the light that we never saw coming (well, some of us did, lol). I hope that if Nolan does have a movie with Joker, whoever plays Joker does just a good a job as Heath did.

  • God, I hope not.

    The only other guy who could continue it is Scott McClure....

  • mark hamill...end

    

  • Daniel Day Lewis would play a convincing SpongeBob Square Pants in a Civil War Movie. He's the best actor in the game. Case closed.

  • I don't think the joker charicter is in the third movie?

  • heath ledger

  • Heath Ledger was THE BEST joker. Replacing him would be super disrespectful. The joker is not in the Dark Knight Rises

  • @codlegofailvideos Im not sure if youve ever seen daniel day lewis act but honeslty, if anyone can do it, it's him.

    As an australian im all for heath, he was amazing bla bla bla but seriously, check out Daniel day lewis's other big roles before commenting

  • @codlegofailvideos How? HE DIED, sad. Tragic. But that doesnt mean i never want to see the joker again

  • hes too old, but to be honest I think he would be better. Im gonna put it out there, i didnt care for heath ledger as the joker, his vocal intonations annoy me and come across unwatchably unrealistic, Aaron Eckhart I thought was the better actor in the supporting role slots plus he got to make out with Maggie Gyllenhaal and not her brother like Heath did. Daniel Day Lewis may be the best actor living at the moment, but he so rarely take roles that people forget about his awsomeness.

  • honestly, i think if anyone would replace the joker, daniel day-lewis would be a good bet

  • No way will someone ever be able to replace the work of Heath Ledger as The Joker

  • @qQuickscopezp thats what ppl said about Jack Nicholson.... untill Heath Came along.. So never say never! There might bee an even better joker out there

  • he got the same bone structure he might be able to pull it off depending on his body language and of course the voice more importantly the laugh..

  • No way Lewis takes this, he doesn't need to ride lesser actor's coat tails.

  • are they gonna lock this guy in a room and make him crazy so he dies too?

  • Check out my twist on the recently released trailer on my channel, including Catwoman, Talia al Ghul, and Bane!

    

  • I...joke...your...milkshake!!!

    ( I know, they can't all be gold )

  • The Joker will not be returning according to Chris Nolan (director)

  • In a recent press release, Lewis had this to say to those who say he'll never live up to Heath Ledger:

    "I. Drink. Your. FAN-TEARS! *slurps* I Drink them up!"

  • Daniel lewis would never play in a movie like Batman its just not him. He prepared for about 6 years between roles, Daniel day lewis is by far the best actor alive and probably in the top 10 of all time best actors Heath ledger is a pill popping idiot just another mainstream hollywood scum he. Daniel lewis is a legend and the most saught after actor today.

  • @jacobfbrown

    I will agree that Daniel is probably the best actor alive and one of the best of all time, but even he respected Ledger's work in his last few movies, especially Brokeback Mountain. As such, it doesn't help your credibility much calling Ledger scum.

  • @jacobfbrown I would be careful if I were you. According to most of the comments on any video about a new Joker, seems you are out number. Also had you done real research instead of just going by magazines you would know, yes he was on meds but family and close friends said he would NEVER committed suicide, he loved his daughter too much to leave her. Think what you want about who you want, but in this case keep it to yourself. It's called RESPECT. Learn it.

    <3 R.I.P Heath,

  • @GOTHICA3000 Its called a point of view actually and im intitled to one!!! RESPECT IT BITCH! O and you say im out numbered just look at the likes on this video,... How many people like your idea? HAHAH Heath is a joke.. Heath killed him self in order to be another wannabe james dean. FAGGOT

  • @jacobfbrown I do respect that you are allowed your own point of view but I will not respect talking such slander against a person you, nor I, don't know. But actually read the statements from friends & family and they all say he would never kill himself, not as long as he had his daughter. There's a difference between liking a video and agreeing with slander. Oh yes I'm a BITCH and using exclamation points and caps lock does not scare me. You're weak, hence the bashing. Grow up and don't reply.