New Moon Book Recap: Chapter 14 "Family"

[betosrose]

UM, NO OBVIOUSLY HE WOULD HAVE BIT OR EVEN KILLED HER IF HE WAS A "REGULAR" VAMPIRE.....DUH!

[craazzycaiity]

She couldnt - Edward found it hard enough to be close to her and he is normally almost emune to human blood. If he actually fed on humans then it would be impossible for him to be around her, so she wouldnt have the chance to be with him.

But if none of this was true, i dont think she would. She gets really depressed when she thinks of the Volturi killing people and when she thinks about herself being a vampire she always worries that she will kill innicent people. So i dnt think she would.

[loveandrockets23]

I don't think that she would stay with Edward if she knew that he was a "typical" human-killing vampire. I think the red sign would come up and the instinct of staying away from this dangerous thing would've went off. Even though if she did go with him we all know that her smell for him was already to much for him in the beginning that he probably would've killed her in the first book.

[RosannaYMiller]

The Twilight Movie is astonishing ! I watched it two times at this site twilight-now/./com

[TVrockschick]

Well, the way Bella is probably maybe cause she loves him and she's crazy. haha. jk

[DNBStylez]

then Edward would have either killed her the day they met or stayed away... so i don't think so..

[Bestbebest12]

I don't think they would have met because he would have killed her or he wouldn't go to school

[8a9crrre]

she would have never met him, and would have ended up with Jacob.

[kagome1417]

Probably they would of never met, Edward would feed off humans at night time, and Bella wouldn't even know about vampires beacause Edward wouldn't have gone to school

[mrsashleylautner]

if i was her i would stay with the HOT werewolf jacob just sayin'

[ek123488]

i think she'll still love him because they have that chemistry plus she not scared of him being a vampire so she wouldn't be sccared about that either

[cheekyterier]

well first, look at it this way, if edward fed on humans, he wouldn't go to school, he'd be like the american nomads (feast at night and never staying in the same place for too long.) so bella would never have met edward. But if he was able to resist, she would know he could resist.

[Striketeam2009]

no

i think she whould not of stayed with edward

[greeneyedgirly1]

maybe she would have to really trust him though and he would have to be alot more careful around her but if i was in her shoes i probably wouldnt stay with him because just knowing that i just wouldnt be able to fall in love with him in the first place

[tigerwoman444]

I think she will if Edward was able to keep alive

[monkeyrocks13]

Yea, she would! You can tell :)

[MrCrm3]

yes bc she cant resist him either way

[twilightfreakt21]

She probably would have still loved him, but would and could he have resisted the urge to drink her blood if he was a normal vampire, and hadnt been resisting for 80 odd years? thats the real question.

[deryan15]

i think she would have stayed with him even if he killed humans because knowing Edward he would only kill scum

[nanny496]

no she would have not cuz she would have been scared out of her mind to ecen be around him.

[Lossan93]

I think that if Edward did killed human

Bella would have died because she smell so good to him

[raddderz]

She definetley would have stayed with him even if he killed a humen in front of her!

[cuteemma1997]

bella told edward that she doesnt care what he wad and that she unconditionally in love with him before she ever knew that he only drinks animal blood but as "myimmortalluv4u"said they will be more and more carefull

[jamaalspancake1]

They would have stayed together obviosly!!!!!!!!!!!

[totallymoah]

I think not, because let's face guys it's being a "vegeterian" vampire that makes him be the way he is; compassioned and everything. If he were like the others he'd just kill her without hesitation because she'd be just another meal to him. ( unless he hesitates beceuse he notices he can't read her thoughts.) So since being a vegeterian vampire helps him build his personality and i'm guessing she likes a lot his personality, she wouldn't be into him if he were wild and ...not "vegeterian".. .

[brittanirocks22]

i think that if Edward wouldnt have been able to resist. if anyone ever read Midnight Sun, edwards version of twilight (on stephinie meyers page) you know that it was hard enough for him to resist then, and he was a vegetarian. he ould have just bit her!

[TheTwilightfan411]

i think no

[teamedwardcullen1717]

First of all awesome shirt! I think she still would of stayed with him. If i recall correctly in the first book Bella goes to Edward before she finds out he doesn't eat humans so they would stay together in my opinion.

[myImmortalluv4u]

Of course! But their love will not be the same. There will be a lot of hesitations and carefulness. Maybe Edward will try his best so she'll not kill Bella. He'll be good for Bella's sake. That's how much Edward loves Bella.

[rainbowdino77]

I think Bella would stay with Edward if their love strong

[pluver99]

he would fukin eat her wat kind of relationship is that?????

[CuteGirl632]

Edward is better than that he wouldn't do that, but if he did, Bella would run out of where ever she was as fast as she can.(i think)

[serenaflora]

I live boys who turn into giant wolves!!!.... like the shirt though.

[Gokittys355]

She would be out of her comfert zone, but she would still love him

[xXHildiXHostileXx]

She would be less comfortable but I'm sure she would still love him. :)

[lilcheynestoke]

well duh she woke up screaming everynight for him i think they would've stayed together

[trickeynick10]

yes she would stay with him

and no too

their in luv but if he fed on humans theres a better chance he'll kill her, as much as he might not want to. and bella would be afraid

[XoAnGiiE92oX]

i think bella would of stayed edward even if he fed on humans because of the love they have for one another .

[Sims2Geek4ever]

Of course they would stay together, they're love was so unnaturaly strong...

[DancingAddiction]

Yes. Love is something can't really be controlled. And it is quite obvious that she loves him more than her life; they are eachother's lives. With out the other they are only half a person. Due to the uncontrollable factor about love, i do think that Bella would stay with Edward no matter the circumstances.

[dragonflyi3]

no her conscious is to strong for her to be with him when he is bad

[sporty685]

i think that it depends. Yes,because if Bella loved Edward that much, yeah...... No, bella would have been DEAD if Edward fed on her.:(

[endraka]

yes cause she loves him so much

[jump5freak90]

hmm...well i'm more of a Team Jacob fan...but I would say that yeah, Bella would probably still love Edward.

[maddieanne14]

I think that even if Edward fed of humans she would still love him. Bella loves Edward unconditionally and no matter what he does she will love him just the same because she knows when she is with Edward she is safe

[magicalgal99]

erm i think yes, if she loved him the way that she loves him now! but then again maybe the whole 'vegetarian' thing gave her some reassurance! but Edward being a veg is a choice he made himself and so that could have been broken with the snap of his teeth, and he killed humans, well fed off of humans before so technically he WAS a human-killing vampire.....and Bella still loved him, and if their love was true then it wouldnt run away........

[tina242424]

hell yeah bella love him and that will never go away Edward a killer or not

[twilightnight16]

The question was if Bella would stay with Edward not the other way around.

I think Bella would have tried to stay but if Edward loved her enough to not kill her he would have run away the instant he realized this and never come back because of the danger he would be putting Bella into.

Bella is a little bit stupid and wouldn't have cared about the danger so I think that she would still have tried to stay with him but she would have died in the first book so it doesn't work out.

[twlightaddict1]

No she would totally break up with him!

[jesusfreaksupergirl]

i know lots of people have said this... but yeah, if he was a typical red eyed vampire Bella would be dead. to a vamp without control, blood is more important than the person.

[amynoel123]

hell yeah, there love was strong enough that even if HE took a snap at her she would still love him

[DazzledbySpunkRansom]

i <3 boys that sparkle too :)

[wonderdee]

That is a really silly question. With the way that Edward wanted to kill her the first time he smelled her, she would have been dead a loooooong time ago.

[rinphie]

bella wouldn't be alive if edward preyed on humans....

[sesata101]

JACOB IS SO HOT!!!

[puccaXrocks]

i think so cuz she loves him really badly & im sure if he loved her more than now he wouldn't hurt her maybe he would try not to eat humans & become a "vegetarian"

PS cool slow motion transformation with his head changing first

[CurvesRsexy08]

if he was a human blood drinking vampire, bella would be dead

[TerrificTwiTina]

If he fed on humans, she'd be dead.

[megerz06]

yeah she would have stayed because before jake told her that he didnt kill those people she was still going to try and be his friend. she just wanted to know why he was doing it. and how she feels about edward is way beyond how she feels about jacob. she loves jacob but says that she wishes he was her brother. her feelings for edward are incredible. enough to travel the world to save him even though he left her. enough to end her own life to be with him forever. so yes she would stay with him :)

[BenjiXAddictX4Ever]

Hmm, Well I Think Bella Would Have Stayed With Him But Would Have Wanted Him Not To Feed On Humans Anymore. And Even If Edward Did Regularly Feed On Humans If He REALLY Loved Bella He Wouldn't Kill/Feed On Her. Plus Remember What She Told Jake In When She Thought HE (Jacob) Was Killing/Eating Those People In The Woods? That There Were Other Ways To Survive.

BTW Joslyn You Forgot The Blueberries Muffins Emily Made! =O

[4twilighter]

Why do you guys do this stupid thing???

you guys say "Spoiler alert" at the beginning, thats this is for people that already read to books, but if you already read the books, whats the point of watching this???

[TerrificTwiTina]

I've read the books and I watch it,

[puccaXrocks]

@4twilighter

i watch it cuz sumtimes there's pics & i watch cuz i like being reminded of the chapter

have u eva read a book over & over again? if u did then wats the point uv already read it

if u have read over & over u would understand how i feel about watching this

[TheQueenMariam]

Hmmm....I don't think she would, I mean she freaked out when she thought Jake was hurting humans.

[PotterPuppetPals4]

stayed because she didnt know yet but she wanted to stay

[tishi1988]

edward would have eaten her if she knew he fed on humans, hed be used to drinking their blood and he would have killed her eventually

[deque92]

she would have stayd but it did not have any ting between them because if he was drinking human blood, he could not go on school, and Edward would have killed her before they got the chance and get to know ichother because she smells so good

hun ville ha blidt men det hadde ikke blidt noe av fordi hvis han hadde drikket menneskeblod kunne han ikke ha godt på skolen og Edward ville ha drept henne før de fikk sjansen til og bli kjent fordi hun lukter så godt

[differentme123]

Bella would problably have stayed, but Edward would have killed her.

[miglekal]

If Bella would be alive, she would love Edward the same way.

But indeed, she would have died the same day she moved to Forks, because if Edward wouldn't be a vegetarian, he would have killed her. That's my opinion.

[ecarodiaz]

i think she would never been close to him cuz he probably had kill her sooo in the end she would have stay but maybe as a vampire and not human

[bethrosegirlxx]

Yes, but she would have pressed becoming a vampire on him even more to stop him having even more apin around hear but it would be very risky when he would bit her.

[littlemissattitude10]

I think she would've! BTW, Jocelyn on Team Edward now??? do u notice that or is it just me?

[strangegirl1]

yep.

[sigridsimmen]

I think she would have stayed. She was in love with himbefore she knew he was a "veggie" anyway,,,

[XxSweetLady]

i think she would.

[roloqween]

love conquers all so yeah

[KLishotterthanRP]

I'm sure that she would have stayed, she's just smart like that...

[casandra34]

I think she would stay with Edward even if he was a regular vampire, because she loves him so much.

[StarCelebrities]

I really wish Kristen Stewart wouldn't strip in Welcome to the Rileys. Sigh.

[ParamoreFan208]

Of course she would stay with him because their love is strong and didn't Edward go off by himself for awhile and drank human blood, she knows that and she doesn't care.

[mffn1989]

yeah i think she would have. due to the fact they are in love and im sure he would have stopped feeding on humans after he met bella

[MsSkux123]

i think she would because shes TOO in love with him and i think she wouldnt even care if he killed humans just for fun !

[robomex55555]

i hate the commercials!!

[camillalpz]

I think she would stay with him.Like she said in Twilight "I don't care"

[TwilightxxxxFanpire]

obsiously she would she even said that she didnt care that edward has killed people before and she probably wouldnt now

[edward4evr1373]

lick many have said, if you love someone so much, your not going to stop loving them just because they're dangerous. You have no control over it

[reyy101]

idont like th factt that bella keeps sending jacob signs that she likes himm.its teasing him. and for what?jusst for her to go crawling bak to edward wen she gets the chance?uggh!

[StarCelebrities]

@reyy101 Actually, they're best friends... :D

[AbbzToYou]

I would hope that she would but knowing Bella I don't think she would have liked the idea of the person she loves to be killing innocent people.

[Clau7627]

obviously she have stayed with Edward! What they have or "had" was a strong love!!! And I know that (obviusly) she still miss him a lot!

[raidersfan760]

i hope she wud so i can keep jacob all 2 myself lmao

[CuteLilBlondie527]

she would've stayed.

[starmal8]

i think she should ditch edward and go to jacob. jacob is warm blooded and kind and much better for bella. and more her type. I LOVE YOU TAYLOR <3

[lemonblossoms5]

yes because she loves him and wants to stay with him

[CullenLovato81396]

i dont know cuase if he were like everyone else she would probably be dead

[C1audiaAr]

if Edward was a typical vampire, Bella would be dead

[Yay4Yana]

I don't think Bella should stay with Edward at all and I think she'd be better off with Jacob. Go Team JACOB!!!!!!!!!!!!

[samisakevinjonasfan]

nope

[gal4twilight]

yes i think bella would stay with Edward even if he fed on humans

[Colombiangirl626]

she would not care because she luvs him and when she does know she still stays with him

[Notebook32833]

if you have read the first chapeter of midnight sun, a person would know how much edward craves bella's blood... had he been a typical vampire he would of consumed her the fist time he meet her, but then had he been a normal vampire i doubt he would be attending school in the first place and they never would have met

[LadyParis123]

even if edward drank human blood, he would probably not be at school and bella would never had met him, but if they were dating, he would kill her even if he loved her, but she would probably still love him... just syaing

[Kidgenius13]

Actually, I doubt Bella would have ever gotten the chance to find out if Edward was a typical vampire; the way they described the incredible attraction of Bella's blood, Edward probably would have sucked her dry first chance he got.

[AMCoromandel]

This is one of my fav chapters in the book!! :D

ONE of them :D

[quayah724]

yes of course

[Janetanet20]

if Edward was a killer, she would have never had the option of choosing to live or die. edward would have killed her first chance, if he was even in forks at the time she was and if they ever met. because if he was a killer, he would have never settled in a coven and he would have never had to pretend to be human

[daolumachine]

oooo that's a good one! i really don't know i'm the not the kinda fan that has an over complicated analysis or opinion on edward and bella's relationship because i'm team jacob and i really can't stand either one of edward and bella. i personally would think she'd still be with him because imo bella is crazy!

[dcbabe13]

ya i do think she would have stayed with him b/c she loves him unconditionly and even when he broke her heart she still felt the same way for him and so ya she would stay with him as long as he didnt kill her

[enchantedmistress06]

If Edward drank human blood he wouldn't be able to resist drinking Bella's blood. She'd be dead.

[musiclover429954]

duhh if u knew ur bf was a murderer but u still luved what does it matter in the end love conquers all

[girlygirlbri04]

i would have to say yes . . . she probly wouldnt like it in the beginning but i dont think she could have stayed away from him

[DivaChicluvsCena]

I say she would...but he would gradualy change if she asked him 2 stop cuz there luv is that stong n if he can have control with her..he should have control around other humans or something like that.

[BellasLullaby100]

Yes because she said im here i trust u in the 1st book.

she knew that he wasent going to harm her

[OeCdGuRl]

Oh yeah she is in love... i can't blame her cuz i wud too!!

[henry1729]

yes she would...she loves him 2 death

[cullenkid4eva]

Yes their love is that strong. But that doesn't mean she won't keep asking Edward to change his diet.

[candyrox1231]

Love your shirt!!!!!!!!

[luvbabyv1]

Hell yes! Bella was already in love with him by that time and she was SO deeply in love that she didn't care whether or not he fed on humans.

I love them!! They are so cute!

Go Team Edward.

Go Team Bella.

xoxo Naty

[CammonTwiGirl]

I tried to post my VR but it's not up :|

[RamenSushi]

yes and no

yes, because their love is very stronger than steel in my eyes

and no because since bella's blood sings to edward, he would have killed her before she could even make that decision, if he couldn't control it

[icechocolat]

bella would still stay with edward even knowing he's a vampaire. she did say that she'll "rather die than stay away from him"

[nadiavhs3]

edward doesn't kill humans, and like in twilight, she talks to him alone, risking it all, when she knows he's a vampire but she doesn't know he's a "vegetarian"

[kkkaylaxox]

She would defenetly take the risk of staying with him because her love for him is way to strong and i know, she would know too that eward loves her soooooo much, that he would keep the temptation away and not kill her because they love each other soooo much! (and i Love u ECullen!!!!!!) LoL :D

[serenaflora]

She wouldn't have gotten the chance to love Edward because he would have more than likely killed her. Remember her blood sings to him. he wouldn't have been able to control himself.

[kimmycub758]

love d shirts

[junglebookgirl101]

yes cause in twilight she says it dosen't matter what he eats

[sincererucker]

of course she would they have real love just because of that she would for give i thank

[PrincessHv101]

love ur outfift joslyn. I think bella would stay woth him. She loves him soooo much, that I think nothing could destroy it. Except that edward is making a mistake by leaving......she would definetley stayed with him!

[ashleygranger53]

lol Play close attention?

[ohmylautner]

Yes because in twilight he says "are you afraid" and she says no and then he asked her what they eat and she says"i dont care

[myspace029]

i think she would ecause she knew he would never hurt her

[Apeksha2403]

she couldnt cuz he wouldnt be there if they were noramal human-killing vampires. the cullens wouldnt be able to stand being between so many humans

[Dogzrock2468]

the quality was bad i have to wait forever and i have a mac

[XOGERARDVILLALBAXO]

Hope So..She Would Be Better With Jacob!

I LOVE Jacob ,is it true he's going out with taylor swift?

[spunkransom1989]

in twilight she says "it dosnt matter" what he is.. she still loves him and that was before finding out he didnt kill humans, so yes she would of stayed with him..

[MariaVysnia]

yes, she would've stayed with him no matter what !!!

[Mrstwilightfreak16]

I think she would of because as she said in twilight "I dont care" After he said "I've killed people before. He once did kill people but then stopped about 70 years before he met Bella. She loved him and what he was or is didn't matter to her

[college87]

i do not know if she would stay with edward but once she first saw him she was already inlove with him. so i think maybe she would have

[xxejbxx]

Pah.

Course she would have stayed with him.

If he didnt drink her blood first.

[beautiful192]

i don't think Bella would've stayed

[WMSProduction]

omg!!!

[jayjayfoged12]

i think she would've stayed with him,

she wouldn't have know about "vegetarian" vampires and would've just thought it was all he could be,

the love is real:)

...........even though i'm team jacob:L

[JCP15music]

omg love ur show

[Adelle911]

i just finished rereading this chapter!~

[CammonTwiGirl]

ha ha =( it's in bad quality!

[JCP15music]

woow 2 comment yay i love twilight

[Adelle911]

woohoo! 1st!

[kadmon15]

omg im first

[kadmon15]

@kadmon15 y was my comment get 2 thumbs down?