Alaina Whitaker Hopelessly Devoted to You American Idol

[ilOvesmiChaeljaCksOn]

2:07 ! noooooo. besides that, it was pretty good

[namniekib]

The high notes are off but also what happened to the dynamic range?Those verses should be softer with more air behind it.She should save her louder volumes for the chorus.

[andyelde]

great alaina i love you u were robbed !

[MsDeathguardian]

Can't believe she beat David Cook in a local talent competition in Tulsa

[americanidolkid]

From 2:02 till the End, It was a distaster :( I still like her though!

[DeVoRaDoR39]

I sounds better

[actsgrlz13]

Shes really talented and i will DEF. but her album

[Danklin24]

I really wish she would have come back this season. i think she could have as she didnt make top 12.

[musicdude2009]

No once you make the top 24 like she did that year you can no longer come back.

But yeah she is pretty talented.

[mcph7415]

She is so beautiful and was seriously robbed.

[eaglesgirl2788]

She was good, but she got voted off b/c of her ego, hands down. Doesn't have the likeability factor, as they would say.

[BrianJooRocks]

she is ok she sounds a little shacky

[Peacekeeper1234]

Sadly she sang it much better the next night on the night that she was eliminated.

[connorlver4EVA]

hey i kknow her!! she goes to my sschool (metro) im gunna see her tommorow! and i have her cell # and her email!! :D

[cutieallyp]

liar.

[Marshell21]

She sings brilliantly and she's really pretty!!

[Amarrag]

I didn't think she was bad...at all. She was good, maybe a little pitchy but ...I thought she was overall good.

[Zetapie]

Oh wow... way to screech one's way through a classic. The beginning was actually good, but the big notes were too much for her.

[mkxylplk]

her take on it was good. I especially liked her changing the tune when she sings the verse, ..."I'm out of my head..." But those high notes, wow. I'm not a musician/singer myself so I wouldnt know what to suggest on how to approach to hit those high notes. Other than that, it was a great effort. I wished she had made it further too

[Bernerker]

her high notes were kinda sour

but she does have a nice voice and range

[jaydog954]

she sounded okay, not great on "this song" but i think it was still good enough to make it further, also if she went through this round she could have shown how great she is cuz she was a really good singer! :)

[anonymoussstar77xo]

I love Alaina so much!!

:)

[hotlikeasaunax3]

yeahh I agree with Randy - her notes were deff sharp

and he was trying too hard

[loveupskirts]

all these shows are rigged, its not a free contest its a rip off

[actorpd]

Great job, Alaina.

[iRocker85]

lol i think the reason she got voted out was because people were voting for kady thinking it was alaina

[ash4evagrl]

i thought she was incredible! i had her as being at least in the top 6! top 20 is not good enough for her, she was amazing!

[RoadKill700]

Don't worry, Alaina. It was the song choice :)

[filedrawer99]

the high notes didn't sound good...... sounded like she was shouting......

[leviathanXXX]

better than the original!

[majjsu]

She shouldn't have been voted off so early. I love this song by her.

[pinksnow42]

I'm the same way with my food lol

[rynapostol09]

she had a great voice but the high notes are pitchy lol not tryin to sound like randy

[fuzzyduck163]

the sound stinks....

[sunshineidol]

she had some charm. more than kady. she should have made it a little farther

[cheyennestar]

She is really pretty, and I like her voice too. I think she sounds better than Brooke. What happened here??

[bnrockstar365]

I am not American but if I was they should've kept Alaina and booted Jason! And kept Michael too but the worst booting in AI history was the booting of Carly Smithson what's happening to AI?

[thesneak8]

I AGREE 1,000,000%!!!!!!!!!!!!! I mean I though Carly or Michael would be at like the top 4!!!!

[rodneylover31795]

alaina should still be on the show!!!!

[Dukar32]

Alaina is amazing!! i cant believe she got voted off. hopefully she'll make a cd. does anyone know if she can try out for american idol again?

[thesneak8]

i think she can!!!!!

[Run4est928]

I think if you have ever been in the top 24, you can't re-enter. The people who try out repeatedly only made it to Hollywood Week at the latest. I could be wrong, though.

[dslsabbat]

no ur right

[dslsabbat]

unfortunatedly, not.

if you get into the top 24, you can't try again...

[twentin08]

didn't alaina have her "journey" video??? omg......

[dslsabbat]

yeah, she had!

[twentin08]

really?? why isnt it shown in this clip? and where was it shown?

[dslsabbat]

well, this video is not from the performance she was eliminated..

[twentin08]

ohhh.... yeah. sorry. i was thinking of another video i've watched where there was no journey of alaina.

[qg6ff]

she got the lowest votes that night and amanda wasn't even in the bottom! what's that tell ya

[DonnieDog13]

She had the second lowest number of votes that night, Alexandrea was voted off first that night.

[qg6ff]

no, because when kady and alaina were standing on stage together he said one of them got the lowest number of votes, and the other was part of the bottom 3 but is safe.

[jewelblackwell]

Alaina was my favorite girl on this year's American Idol. I expected her to be in the top 5 at least. She's a very sweet girl and a great singer, especially for someone so young. I hope to see/hear her again on AI or on CD.

[remmiws21]

shes really good but i have nevver even heard of her...she sounds cocky tho..

[misschuckbass]

to me she's miles better than kristy lee cook.

[fabprincess1212]

her food video thingy is so weird!

[AllAboutCarrie]

GUYS wake up: she got voted off because nobody liked her personality! She's cocky!

[rodneylover31795]

i cant beleive she got voted off!!!! she is soooooo good!!!!

[ny11764]

ug i was so mad when she got kicked off. And i was right the show isnt the same. She was my fav for the girls! If anyone Amanda or Kady should have went home!

[bigbilly2006]

I couldn't agree with you more. To me, both Amanda and Kady should've gone home that day!

[DavidArchuleta17]

i get to know things about alaina before anyone else because alaina is my moms boyfriends daughters best friend and that makes me happy

[tuesday197]

i actually really liked that this is one of my favorite songs but she had a few pitch problems but i agree she shouldnt have been kicked out she should be in the competition nd kristy lee should be gone!!

[RandomnessRoxx508]

SHE SOO SHOULDNT HAVE WENT HOME! I WANT TO KILL ANYONE WHO VOTED IT WAS SOOO SAD (srry it made me mad)

[snakemalfoy]

nice one, but I can't hear a thing. The sound is so low!