Added: 5 years ago
From: Copyright4what
Views: 125,291
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (530)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • So much about legal processes and justice at the court. As everywhere, there the money has won...

    Only a retarded fool wouldn't notice the how unlikely similar the 2 songs are. Man, isn't there a lawyer or a judge to see this? :(

  • the saddest part is that this was legal because janne suni didnt copywright it yet

  • @JakeVideoStation hmmm, I think you can still defend yourself against this even if he did not slap a copyright on it? You only have to challenge in court and demonstrate-proove "prior art". Prove that you composed this.

    That's why you should always keep you junk reccording, old infinished draft program files, source samples, source code. If you can show all this and the copy cat can't, you are in a good position to demonstrate prior art.

  • @OBSysteme This is what I thought too. But just look at this case... Man, this kind of justice is just a big heap of crap.

  • @NmGab These demo-sceners, that make free music, they should always release their stuff on netlabels where a "creative commons copyright" stamp is clearly associated with the release of the free music. It might be that Jane is from the true oldschool? back when you would not think twice about uploading your computer demoscene music directly to a BBS or a web site, spreading it to the four winds without any afterthought.

  • @NmGab but yeah the justice system is crap... imagine a system where the law is not the only thing that count, the kind of lawyer you can afford to payfor yourself and who you are (O.J. Simpson comes to mind), can actually influence the outcome.

    also, think of all the people that get wronged but du nothing because they can't afford money and time to defend themselves.... it should not be so that justice is denied simply because it is to difficult to actually go through it.

  • @robertson1996 Timbaland is actually a great producer and I'm pretty sure it's call sampling not stealing or ripping xP this videos dumb and the person who made this is also dumb

  • @BboyChancyPants Also, you suck dicks. And your father sucks dicks in prison.

  • Before you insult someone, you fools should know a little something about music production. the melody used both by Timbaland and the totally unknown finnish guy is a demo melody from an old Casio keybord. If you purchase this instrument you can use and publish all the sounds and demo melodies it contains and it won't be no theft!

  • @wtkplt Tell us what demo from which keyboard, or are you just pulling crap out your ass?

  • @wtkplt Hmmm yes a Commodore 64 can play recordings from Casio keyboards yes yes...

  • @wtkplt Wow, you are grossly miss-informed.

    The song is a full song programmed on an 8bit computer and is entirely original composed material, the whole melody stolen (copy-pasted, no modifications) by Timbalame.

  • this video is retarded just like da guy who made it (-_-)

  • lol,love the response from amicrondelta2,btw,this group should DEFINITLY go on a tour,if they dont have contacts,hit me up ^^ and yeah,about timbo,sad sad day to hear these facts,not fiction,and imagining how janne sunni would be mad,depressed and devastated.so yeah,Harm DONE right here *BING*,i was a timbo fan,when hip-hop was hip-hop not crunk,krump or wtv,its only when u see this,that the truth hurts,hip-hop,is on the verge of dying and making way to a new breed

  • @allooo In response to your last statement, it's one thing to download "illegal pirate music" for personal enjoyment and another to use someone else's work for monetary gain.

  • Timbaland is an old school producer, not a composer, this is what he does!

    I'd like to hear what Janne Suni really thinks about this, I would never have known the name or heard the songs if it wasn't for Timbo.

    Is it stealing? sure. Does it harm anyone? Doubt it.

    It's not like Janne was just about to hit the charts with his acidjazzed evening tune when timbocame n stole it.

    Besides, people here talking shit about Timbo but at the same time download "illegal pirate music". Hypocrits, bigtime.

  • @allooo

    Actually downloading is legal in most non corrupted countries where it's not businesses deciding what is legal and what isn't. Why? Because physical objects you can steal (as in take from someone), sound you cannot. Therefore, illegal is only when you start MAKING PROFIT from sounds that someone else produced. The downloaders are just listening, we're not making profit or gaining unfair reputation. That's why TImbaland is a f*n ass.

  • A lot of stuff goes on in the Industry between Producers / Artists... For all you know Timbaland could've paid Janne Suni for the track and all the rights to the track...

  • Very nice. I come from Finland and I don't agree at all that Timbaland steals music from other people. I mean he steals music of several countries, including Finland, autotunes his voice because he can't sing, and then, he GETS MONEY FOR THAT FU**ING BULLSH**.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • i still think timberland produces good songs. yeah produces songs that make millions, others couldnt make millions , but he can so hah.

  • Anyone who produces has, chances are, stolen someones music. Really it's up to the artist to protect it. When I produce beats, I sample BUT I ALSO GIVE CREDIT. But that's just how it goes for us in the underground scene eh? Timbaland's a fucking goof and I could out produce him with fasttracker2 and some busted ass computer.. What a retartd really. Atleast have production value to your music... shhhit.

  • Apparently over a hundred people either hate metal or think Timbaland is justified. They probably steal beats too.

  • Man i almost got a seizure from this video bro lol.

  • Who sang this track?

  • @gaundmaster yeah that's what I'm asking too! Sure Timba is a douche and shouilda aknowledged that he borrowed somsthing.

    But the dudes who made this song here pug more heart into it than any timba song I've heard

  • hahahahahaha daaaamn, how broke u gotta be to make a song about another dude stealin your song!

  • this is lame if ur gonna post a plagiarism thing at least play the right music dumbass

  • Timbaland probably payed Janne Suni for his silence!

  • @TheLxir he didnt

  • who made this vid? it sounds a little bit like Metallica :-/ dont think they would care shit.

  • its wrong,just for the fact that Timbo did not gave any credit to Janne Suni.

  • @Ricanking716 Yep and the prick was claiming he never even heard of janne or the song during a radio interview .. it takes an extra dirty dirt-bag to try lying when caught red handed

  • if he uses their melody, he should go to jail. and hes not in jail, and all know he took it. so why u bother. u aint gonna change anything he will still make dope ass beats, and make millions. get a fucking life ffs!!

  • Someone should sample Timbaland's "beat" and make another song with it, and sell it. It'd be a ripoff of a ripoff.

  • it'd be an 8 bit version of his crappy songs

  • @Mwitamath

    From video game? Ok, tell me name of the game and maybe I will believe you.

    But I allready know, you wont find that name, because it does not exist. Song is made by janne suni and timbaland stole it. End of story

  • @Mwitamath

    And even if it was from videogame, he would still be stealing it

  • true

  • No it was written using the original game boy. Its called chip music. Look it up.

  • If you actually listen to Timbaland's music there's a very high possibility that you're a retard. Congrats.

  • hehe i say the same. THIS SHIT SUCKS!!!!! why the fuck would you make a metal song talking about this kind of thing? i guess the song could be cool (for other people, i hate metal) if it talked about something else. Go "steal" some other songs.

  • I guess the guy who wrote this song decided to take the less subtle approach to the lyrics.

  • probably

  • what was the end result????????

  • lol metallica sounding song dedicated to this plagiarism... talk about wtf LOL

  • seems timbaland is another vanilla ice

  • LOL: it sounds a lil like metallica

  • yeah, but usually you pay for your samples. timbaland didn't

  • @DisguiseDK usually? You know nothing of underground music. Research Girl Talk and Stones Throw records and go from there

  • @DisguiseDK it's not even a sample when you "sample the entire song".

  • @OBSysteme Cool, I didn't even know I had top-rated comment here! :D It's been for 2 years, and you're the first one to comment. Crazy world, huh?

  • @DisguiseDK what is even crazier my friend, is how fast time passes by :P

  • samping is bits and pieces of a song. NOT THE WHOLE FUCKING MELODY

  • and wat he stole is the whole fucking melody

  • how did you get a rockstar to sing this song? or was it already a song?

  • Timbaland is a fucking tool. he belongs in jail where his anus can be resized by real "gangstas"

  • this song is cool. Better than the one Timbaland produced for whatever her face is. or his. i don't know and never heard it till today and it sound exactly the same. but i like this version best.

  • this makes no seeeenseeee

    don't you undaahstanddd

    lmfao. i really don't even get what song he took that sounds like this. you shoulda had a back to back comparison.

  • 1) this is the most retarded thing i ever saw

    2)timbaland i think he should at least acknowledge janni work at least and give him a certain amount of money

    3) who doesn't sample and itza just the melody that sounds the same

  • Best song ever!! :D

  • I hope everyone who is defending Timbaland dies a horrible fucking death as well as there families, I hope that they're kids get impailed slowly on a hot iron rod. Bless you all who agree with this vid and may you live long healthy lives, I hope your kids become doctors and are successful! Bye Bye

  • This is a problem about legal rights. I understand that you get mad, but don't mix innocent kids into your hate. Please, get into the real fight. Do anyone know how this conflict ends?

  • In the end what happened is, Sunni received money (I assume a bunch), c64 gained some more popularity in the process.

  • one thing about sampling, and being completely unbiased. Yes everybody samples sometime or another, to get a right instrument/sound or whatever. It's generally OK. A very famous drumbeat sample from James Brown was used in various songs. But in this case timbaland sampled a whole melody line which he used as a basis for his song. Thats it a bit too far, so sunni deserves proper credit and royalties, esp considering how much money the song is worth.

  • this song is fag!

  • I understand your frustration!!!

  • well, hiphop sucks

  • lol does anybody find this heavy metal song funny... i get the message thats great !! but this is too funny... am i the only one here..

  • Please don`t Judge a race by 1 mans mistake.

  • dude you are wrong for saying that.. !!

  • Just like that wannabe Morganics, He didn't jack it, what a liar LOL.. the guy used a damn Dijirido and now you say he stole it... o m f gosh what a joke.. if I make a beat with a piano I hope Mozart Sebastian Bach's great grand parents don't come and jack me up! LOL.. get a life man, you are no Timberlake.. Become a real artist like Ronald Jenkees!

  • What's up people, check out my song, I promise you won't be disappointed. It is fiyah! Take a chance on me and check ya boi out. All I ask is that you subscribe me if you like it. If not, tell me to kick rocks. Thanks, peace.

  • If janne cares about the money, is he then any better than timbaland? Cool tune tho'. It had that typical finish sound.

  • he cares that some dude from america got way too famous for something he stole, and probably want's the cash he should have..

  • dumb white boy who does not understand sampleing ???

    thats a bit harsh dont you think so?

    Real Musicians write and Perform their own songs not just use OTHER peoples hard work/Samples!!!

    HAHA even this track here shows more talent than Timbaland and his Puppets will ever have!!!

    PS. Mr.bronzxstyleultra, It`s Sampling not sampleing.

  • I agree,he didn't copy 5 exact bars.

    He copied a lot more.

    No need for insults,the prove is all over you tube.

    .

  • lolll almost all his songs are stolen,especially the ones with middle eastern or egyptian melodies.he doesn't work anything out.Dammmnn

  • I agree completely......Cool Song !

    Bernie from Munich

  • i love the way this video trat about this problem. i think just that timbaland just make lot of time to try to built a name.

    jail is not the answer but just let know to people that he is just a fake is more hard for him.

    i think that people sometime pay a big price just for little change.

    He go to be the same for him , even if he has a real talent today everybody just remmber that is is not the guy he want to be.

  • FUKEN THIEF!!

  • People? dont u knw ny1 can pay the person to re-make a song. Just have to compromise with the original song writer. idiots......

  • He didn't pay the guy or compromise with the guy.... we all know this already. He didn't get his permission... he just ripped the guy off.

  • Fuck me mate, if anyone is the idiot here its you for making a comment before truly understanding the situation.. Just go fuck off you fuck knuckle.

  • Timbaland should go to jail for this. I mean if a blogger can go to jail for leaking GNR songs, then this crap certainly deserves jailtime.

  • can any one tell me how did timbaland get access to this song??did he send it in as a demo and he stole it?cuz i have sent sum music in to him now im kinda of worried

  • LOL

  • load of american retards in here who equate making money with personal glory and intetgrity lol

  • Wow, you must be the biggest idiot here. How do you feel if I profited from your work and don't give you any credits huh? Just because you're famous, it doesn't give you any right to plagiarize.

  • You can really start to see the average audience of Timbaland with comments like yours because they are always the same misinformed arrogant selfish fly by night moronic buy any bullshit you are fed comments. I can now understand why Timbaland is so famous, and its not because he is good but because there are more fuckwits in the world than there are smart people.

  • oh no! thats so terrible! his career is over lol. (dumbasses)

  • janne is a normal finnish man/boy name but it can sound like a girls name in english but it is really a man name

  • whats the song on this called or did you make it?

  • janne is man name but when you say it in english it sounds maybe like girl name

  • you fucking stupid janne isn't girl name! you just read it in english. if you read in english "yanné" that should sound like janne in finnish

  • anyway fuck all of em. that timberman is complete shite, who no matter what he does will never sound that good, learn a few chords on your piano and fuck off. and the scandinavian is a miserable arse who needs to lighten the fuck up, but being from scandinavia will be pretty impossible.

  • ALL HAIL TO THE COMMODORE GENERATION !

  • secondly he cant go to jail for this... the most he wil be forced to do it pay a fine, which im sure he can afford.

  • its funny how people with obviously no experience with music production think they know everything about the music industry.sampling is legal and in certain situations the original artist recieves NO credit.try sitting in a studio with nothing but a metronome as inspiration,and create a hit song from that.impossible.theres too many possibilities of what to do with the song.Sampling confines the producer to a key,rhythm and style allowing them to create a much better and more organized song.

  • Only if you have no imagination.

  • you've obviously never sampled a song... let alone composed one... u can have your opinion.. but dont start saying things about others if you dont know what your taking about.

    when you make an original song... send it to me... id love to hear it =).

  • ok then. obviously i have'nt done these things. Its not hard sampling..it is hard, however, using your brain. but i prefer doing the latter cos im not a thieving nigger.

  • so now were making fun of african americans? i cant stand that ignorance. if you have a point to prove, do it without bashing a whole group of people. that comment you made was completely unnecessary. im all for a civil debate, but keep race out of it.

  • Not making fun of no race or no one, just stating an obvious truth of modern black music. Long gone are the days of James Brown, The Temptations, Quincy Jones, Millie Jackson, Creative Source, Teddy Pendergrass, Herbie Hancock, Funkadelic, Gil Scott-Heron, Marvin Gaye, Tammi Tarell. etc. Where these artists are original and pure. Point proven?

  • no... not really. there is plenty of modern black music that is original. just put the time in to find it. NO mainstream music these days is original. no matter what style. if you really care so much about the "original music" go to the underground scene. unsigned artists of all races bring new, fresh and original ideas to music everyday. the reaason you dsont hear originality on the radio is beacause originality doesnt sell, and record companies dont want to take risks.

  • wow i was with you a bit until you said that what happened to the intelligence..guess you only had a lil bit !!hahaha! dumbass!

  • learn to read and to use correct syntax so i can at least try and work out your babble, i never once mentioned anything about intelligence. anyway...fuck off

  • Its funny how people who never used a C64 to make music cant understand how difficult it can be when you are limited to 3 channels of 8 bit sound with the additional requirement to learn Assembly Language programming to produce that music. Now lets compare arranging a song through Assembly and just simply mixing samples!? Sampling is one of the easiest methods of making music and far from complex in comparison.

  • I Agree with everything you just said,i know full and well how difficult composing music is because I compose music myself and i do NOT sample. Even in my previous comment i said that sampling makes the production task EASIER. And no i havent used a C64 (Commodore 64?) but i have produced on an ensoniq eps and found that difficult. so i cant imagine 8 bit 3 track! dont come at me like im stupid please. re-read my original comment if you have to.

  • Fair enough mate i respect what you are saying and i respect you even more for actually knowing what you are talking about so i do appreciate the civil feedback despite mine being somewhat negative towards that of yourself. I have not produced music on the C64 either ( yes, its Commodore 64 :) but i have friends that do ( mostly made tracks on the Amiga myself ) so yes it IS difficult! I apologise for misrepresenting you :(

  • Very few (if any) c64 musicians nowadays code their music using assembly. There are a bunch of trackers (like protracker) and the track in question was also composed using one.

  • ...you are dorks!

  • All the while Janne Suni doesn't make a buck off his own song while Timbaland makes millions...

  • its one song with the same music,same words only in different languages.You get fucking tired of listening to the same fucking song in several languages...

  • big deal this is bullshit where i come from evrybody steals songs from turkey.the song goes to Bulgaria (the same song in bulgarian) then it goes to,Serbia,Kosovo,Greece and the rest of the Balcan...

  • so what everybody steals samples or rip somthing

  • This is more than a sample, and those who sample large parts of songs credit it or get permission.

  • its just 16secs.

  • This is classic case of dumb nigger stealing from talented white. Happens all the time.

  • Well.. I don't like Timbaland. But what I hate more is racist comments!

  • Oh whatever. Political correctness has infected the whole world, even scandinavia, it seems, or wherever the hell you're from.

  • classic case of dumb ass racist infecting smart people happens all the time !

    p.s. if he aint mad why r you sounds like BROKE HATERS!!!!!

  • wikipedia

    Janne Suni

    Janne Suni posted the following comment regarding the copyright status of "Acidjazzed Evening" on January 15, 2007:

    "...I have never given up the copyrights of Acidjazzed Evening. I also have never authorized commercial use of the song

  • Timbaland fukin sucks

  • You actually made a song out of it =D

  • Check wikipedia for Janne Suni: "The conflict seems to have been resolved according to Janne Sunis official page."

    I prefer the original version.

  • Great video, I heard he got paid royalties in the end... so well done!

  • ive never like timbaland as a producer, and hell of a lot less of a rapper. his old beats were ok now they all sound the same.

  • What? I thought this video was extremly creative! Especially at 0:50, best part!

  • FUCK TIMBO.

  • DJ Premier, J Dilla, RJD2, Madlib, Blockhead, Celph Titled, RZA, DJ Muggs, Bronze Nazareth, Stoupe>Timbaland. (Just to name a few)

  • yo damn right.

    what rza,premier and especially stoup are doing is sampling.they're creating a new piece of art out of already written music.

  • No, You are wrong. When you sample something, you use a part of it, and change it to make it your own. All timbaland did was rip off the song. It sounds exactly the same, except he added something over the ringtone version. and the nelly furtado song sounds exactly the same, same beat and everything the melody is just a little different.

  • Accually, upon listening to the commodore 64 version. They arent very different at all, total rip off

  • ey man go fuck urself.. u wouldnt do the same shit if timba was white wouldnt u? get a life outside ur KKK living u dipshit

  • Once again a lot people with little education reply on this because they are big supporters of Timbafag...

    He Took credit for a song that he didn't produce, He should've at least have given credit to the Original Artist... The fact is that he didn't... so of course he should get sued... btw most of Timbalands songs have used samples from other songs... the funny thing is that in the Radio interview he constantly claims that hes "Too Good" hmm he should create his own music then...

  • Sannela26, when was it resolved? Haven't heard anything about that! *checks google*