Best of American Idol 6

[BlyueMOON]

Melinda Doolite - the best ...period!!!

[notbatman1000]

Lakisha or Melinda were the best that season!

[PejaRapiLudzie]

1.Blake Lewis - 'You give love a bad name' - He's my idol, and this performance proved that sometimes in this show come person with a passion, loving the music.

2.LaKisha - 'And Im telling...' the best cover of this song; aggressive and she shows the power of voice, after the perform I was her fan

3.Gina Glockesen - 'Alone'

4.Phil Stacy - 'Every Breath...' - best choice of song, no crazy but I like

5.Melinda Doolittle 'Home' - this is it,

Soon I response on this movie.

[andyelde]

awesome

[qcdisciple]

1. Melinda Doolittle

2. Adam Lambert

3. Carrie Underwood

4. LaKisha

5. Blake Lewis

[justinchester0018]

And Im telling you should be number 1

[screamitquietly]

Melinda was the best of AI 6.

[designerskylineee]

I waited through the whole video to make sure Blake Lewis - You Give Love a Bad Name was number one, disappointed to see that it wasn't since it was such a perfect performance.

[TrillLibra93]

I think that Jordin and Melinda were the best vocalists that season! Melinda has more soul, but Jordin has a sweet voice and more range! I think that "You'll Never Walk Alone" or "A Broken Wing" (the finale performance) should've been number one, but "I (Who Have Nothing)" was good too. Melinda's "My Funny Valentine" should have beat Blake's performance. He sucked. Chris R. and Phil were the best guys.

[Ising4u93]

jordin was terrible.

[TrillLibra93]

No she wasn't!

[jonny2882]

I never liked Blake. Especially when he began to butcher all the songs he was singing with his beat boxing. i have no idea how he beat LaKisha and Melinda.

[mihnrocks]

blake = ANNOYING. HE KILLS EVERY SONG HE SINGS

[barfinger]

great compilation. It is still all Melinda and a bunch of amateurs. Can't understand how we got this one wrong.

[danzboy1]

hmmm..Blake Lewis wouldnt make my list and neither would Hayley Scarnato. It would be all of Melindas, a few of Jordins, Lakisha, Phil Stacey and that awesome performace by Sabrina Sloan to NEVER LOVED A MAN in the top 12 girls

[smileyfacedgirl1234]

Best performance that season is a Broken Wing no questions!

You'll never walk alone was really good. I guess number 1 was okay not my favorite. Number 3 was good too.

[chaser678]

phil stacy does

The Police - Every Breath You Take

^^ he sounds really bad though compared to the real Dude

[Jylanche]

I love Lakisha and Melinda!

[manouk11]

what a crap list!. but melinda ROCKS (L)

[gustavocfra]

AMERICAN IDOL is horrible, they love mocking people and everyone who wins can sing a stupid song, they dont accept anybody who has creativity or is different. And the worst part is that americans acctually find it fun

[54spiritedwill54]

Melinda rocks!!!! I love Melinda

[geckobabies]

This list is practically dominated by the top 3... 17 out of 25 of these performances come from the top 3.

[MrCossack4]

I kind of liked Hayley's "Tell Him".

[ro0kstEr5]

i think dat broken wing by jordin sparks shoulda been #1!!!

[TrillLibra93]

Me 2, but she sang it better at the finale than Top 7 week.

[tbone072892]

melinda was the best jordin was pretty good but melinda was the best

[PessimisticOptimist2]

I LOVED Somewhere Only We Know

[JasonCastroFan797]

Gina was my favorite! i loved 'I'll Stand by You'

[juliepop]

melinda got most of the best

[scoopgirl0829]

I do think Lakisha's "And I am telling you" should be positioned higher. But that might be because she was my absolute favorite on season 6. =D

[behindhzleyes18]

Compare this video to Idol this season and what is the difference?

Personality.

No shameless plugs or pimpings of certain contestants.

No overbearing stage dads.

No gasping teenagers.

Just talented, PERSONABLE, entertaining singers...minus Haley Scarnato. She was obnoxious.

Don't you dare tell me that a gasping, lip-licking precocious teenage boy is better than the likes of Melinda Doolittle.

[MILKYWAY6789]

Lakisha should be in this video more than only two times

[thosexxx]

You're missing some amazing Jordin performances... Where's To Love Somebody, Wishing on a Star, and Heartbreaker... Plus, Gina's Smile and Stephanie's crazy in Love

[watladyzneed]

Lakisha Jones' I'm Telling You I'm Not Going should be ranked A LOT higher

[LILKENNYJR]

no offense but dis is a stupid list u have no stephanie edwards or brandon all u really have is blake

[Qdubb33]

Melinda's Funny Valentine was indeed one of the most memorable performances of that season!!

[JGonzalez0788]

This brings back such good memories... Season 7 is such a disappointment

[Yashura]

It's really hard to believe Jordin is 16/17 years old... She looks older in my opinion. Plus, no teenager can have that kind of amazing voice...

[GONZAMIMI]

I never liked Blake Lewis.

[muppet48]

then again....maybe this should just feature melinda, jordin, lakisha, and chris

[muppet48]

a little too much Blake Lewis in here and there should definitely be more lakisha, chris richardson, and melinda.....but overall a good video

[Emmy616]

i loveed when chris r sang geek in the pink =].

[LaughinBeach]

I think she did a goood job with the songs for this. I think Gina should've had "All by myself" in there somewhere. "Home" should've been a little higher, i liked that one. and i think Trouble is A Women and Nutbush City Limits shouldv'e been in here. I liked how "I who have nothing" was first. that one was amazing!!! I also think Sanjaya should've had one, he was good, and did make it to the top 7. But Overall, i think you did a really good job on this!! Thanks for posting!! =)

[123airedalegurl123]

well i think blake is hot

[GRomance0804]

Jordin's Best was I Who Have Nothing

Melinda's Best was Nutbush City Limits

Gina to me was robbed because she rocked that song!!!

and Sanjaya did sing Besame Mucho really well

[bigcat1008]

i love blake to be my bf

[ringorules987]

ihrtcrissangel: Maybe I have bad taste in guys, but being be a gay teen, I never found him good looking. No, I have nothing against the man. I didn't really like him while he was on idol. I liked some of his work, but overall I preferred Melinda and Lakisha. We really did need more Lakisha in there.

[goyanks13240]

Not exactly the best choices or lineup. Too many Blake Lewis, not enough Jordin or Lakisha. and the lineup sucked, If we hold on together should have moved up, and a lot of other songs weren't where they should be in my ooinion.

[ihrtcrissangel]

FUCK all you people who are like "I hate Blake... hes gay" such and such. you know what HES NOT GAY maybe u just want him to be gay cuase then you could finally have a chance with him because u know you never could cause ur a gay little emo teen. and hes an amazing singer dont hate, compliment, and if u cant find a good part, SHUT UP

[TommyGDub]

Ugh, I hate Blake Lewis.

[orangeparade]

Amen.

[TitoBelize]

I just find it interesting how this contest turned out. Melinda was clearly the best out of all of them.

[father66]

blake isgay i think

[Lockdown377]

sorry I meant #2

[Lockdown377]

That Song that Blake song was definately no #4, that was more LaKisha's And I'm Telling You song

[orangeparade]

I realized that Jordin's vibratos are very unstable and unprofessionally done, but she sings damn well though, she makes all those high notes seem so easy.

[jimjimisback]

I didn't mark you in the negative, but nothing's wrong with her vibrato, according to the speech therapists and vocal coaches, a healthy singing voice produces a vibrato at 6x-7x per second. But I agree, she does make those high notes sound good!!!

[charm2125]

that you put the MOST of Melinda's performances...i think that only proves who is THE BEST!!! thanks for putting this up though...GREAT JOB!!! :p

[Lockdown377]

LaKisha and Melinda!! Woot!!! Lakisha's And I'm telling you should have been in a higher place.....Blake's beatboxing....eh, nothing special

[PawsoH]

coz my funny valentine should have got the 2nd. ;)

[Maximum179]

Broken wings should've been 3rd, instead of My funny valentine

[ringorules987]

"You should be dancing" shouldn't have even been on that list. Lakisha's "Stormy Weather" should have been in "You should be dancing"'s place.

"I believe in you and me" should have broken the top 10.

AND HOW THE HELL WAS "BLAZE OF GLORY" BETTER THAN "THERE WILL COME A DAY"

Thank you for putting Gina's "I'll Stand By You" in the top 10, putting that in 7th place was the perfect spot for that Glocksen performance.

[CharmedbyAaliyah]

I Love Jordin, Melinda & LaKisha!! They totally ROCK!!!!!!!!!

[footballerz08]

"Home" should have at least broke the Top 10

[251blakeishot251]

MELINDA. BLAKE. JORDIN. ROCKS!!!

[linelu235]

Melinda should have been number one.

[linelu235]

Melinda rocks!!!! I love Melinda!!!!!!!!!! =)

[lionelipavel]

lakisha rocks

[mayreawesome]

Melinda Rocks she deserved to be in the finaleee she is great and the finale have been great with her there

[Sunnydaleexile06]

MELINDA ROCKS HARDER(LOL)

[yankgirl002]

BLAKE ROCKS

[GothickareTaker888]

MELINDA ROCKS!

[jesuzfreak711]

i luved chris richardson..geek in pink!!he should have made it farther...lakisha this aint a love song...really good performance...and phil stacey was great singin the song blaze of glory and gina was pretty good at ill stand by you..and jordin was amazing at broken wing and you'll never walk alone and i who have nothing...shes always good!! and blake was amzing at u give love a bad name...thats probly my favorite song that he sang the whole season!!

[osahju914]

Am I the only one who feels "My Funny Valentine" didn't deserve third place? Where is "Heaven Knows" or "As Long As He Needs Me" or "Sway" or especially "Trouble Is A Woman?"

[osahju914]

Gina got robbed too, 9th place!

Where is Smile or Paint It Black?

[osahju914]

I honestly was not a Jordin fan, but the girl got gypped. She deserved at most 2 or 3 more spots on this list

[IQEllis]

U give love a bad name sucked, as do all of the songs Blake sings. I hate blake.

[Pokefan450]

No it didnt, and neither does blake? How can u hate blake?

[ian2813]

Remember what Simon said about "You Give Love a Bad Name?" He said half the people would love it and half would hate it. Some of us actually fall in that half who hated it. There was too much Blake on this list for me. #22 was his best, though.

I love Melinda, but #19 was her weakest performance, IMO.

[Pokefan450]

Lol, I luved it though! Majority liked, lol. But besides that, ya, 22 was one of his best. I don't think theres too much blake, i just think their were some bad blake songs in there that mabye shouldn't be there(U should be dancin was just ok)

[Pokefan450]

I think U give love a bad name should have been #1. Such a big risk, and it worked!

[osahju914]

I Who Have Nothing was a risk that worked too!

[Pokefan450]

ya, it was, but a different type of risk. Jordin did a big song, Blake almost completely changed the song, lol.But both were good

[shab2005]

good for a circus with al these tricks! Doolittle is much better, deserved the highest ranks but however, the public chose (wrongly in my opinion),

[Pokefan450]

Melinda is prob gonna get a record deal anyway, with a great company

[masterchad5]

the top 4 all get a record deal

[hpsimsoap92]

Lmao no it shouldn't! I Who Have Nothing was a million times better than You Give Love A Bad Name. The second time he did it at the finale it sucked!

[Pokefan450]

Ya, the second time was really not as good for singin, but his beatboxing was better. I mean the first time waass better. I who have nutin was good, just not my fav.

[osahju914]

WTF is IDF?

[bluewhale18]

Just interesting that the 11th best song "Blaze of Glory" got Phil booted off the show!?!?

[idolfreak43]

the order was kinda wack...but all in all pretty good. i think Melinda deserved a higher spot...but maybe thats just beacsue I'm a huge fan!

[pimpdaddy820]

this list is so retarded cuz clearly these ppl are melinda fans cuz almost all of her songs are on here.

five of the best performances were

broken wing

you give love a bad name

*this aint a love song*(my fav)

and i'm telling you

and one of melinda's they all the same doesn't matter which 1 u pick

[cheergurlxoxo1]

I can't believe Jordin is only on the list 4 times! The girl won American Idol for God's sake!!

[MrRandomPerson123]

Exactly! There should be less.

[juliepop]

1. my funny valentine..

2. a broken wing..

3. you give love a bad name

4. and i am telling you

5. im a woman

[osahju914]

what is IDF?

[masterchad5]

wow... noob

[flatspinrevert]

im suprised sunhead mustang sally didnt make it

[masterchad5]

wooo!

[MissXulia]

OOOH AND ALSO... i'm a blaker girl, but "you should be dancing" was one of Blake's worst performances. it does not deserve to be on this list.

[MissXulia]

great recap of season 6. i didn't agree with some of the positions though, esp Blake's "When I Get You Alone" being so low rated and Jordin's "I Who Have Nothing" as first cuz i HATEHATEHATE this song. "You Give Love a Bad Name" should've been the best. lmao.

[JPSexy4Ever]

Yuck at Jordin

Yay at Melinda!

[guitarfreak8906]

my funny valentine should be number one

[8daze]

Still trying to figure out how Melinda didn't win...

[mytefine]

This was a great recap of season six. Thank you so very much for posting it! Super!!

[bluewhale18]

Blake Lewis was just incredible this season.

For a winner of the competioin Jordin was reletively scarce.

[bluewhale18]

oops, I meant competition.

[PlaidBoy]

Blake Lewis at about 6:00 gave me goosebumps. lol

[PlaidBoy]

Phil Stacey was alright, I had never seen him before. I actually started to like Chris after this video too. He's got a talent (unusual, but a talent nonetheless.:) I think his career will go somewhere, but I still think Melinda is a mind-blowing talent. Jordin Sparks may have gotten the votes, but look at past winners. Jennifer Hudson took 4th, and she's still the true "winner" from that show.

[LeoGrrrr818]

Actually she placed 7th...and look at her now! But I have to say Fantasia's doing pretty good too.

[CorbinBleuFan4ever]

If there wasn't even a Sanjaya video then don't put his name in the tags cuz u jus wasted 9:36 seconds of my life, now I'm gonna run over schedule nd 4 nothin.

Also atleast everyone who made it 2 the top 10 should've had at least 1, that's not fair 2 Sanjaya or Chris Sligh.

[lovelybabymay]

Exactly!!!!

[8daze]

Not if they sucked.

[princessalways]

my funny valentine should have been #1. melinda is the best.

[looqwer]

Melinda should have won AI6

[mzzh]

my funny valentine #3???? i dont think so. that was the most beautiful song ever sung on AI.

[linelu235]

Go Melinda!

[juliepop]

it only shows that melinda shoudve won.. lots of melinda's here in this video..

[FanUruguay]

I must say that Jordin's performances such as "To Love Somebody", "This is My Now", "Reflection", "Heartbreaker", "Woman in Love" and "Fighter", just to name a few definitely outshine, almost every Blake's here, only leaving You Give Love A bad Name. Definitely better than Haley's and so many more. This is wrong.

[ladysluvar1]

I predict Jordan is going to win the American Idol this season. Watch the season finale tonight , and mark my words.

[ElvisPresleyFOREVER]

I wish someone would do a video like this but just of all Melinda's performances.

[areallygoodusername]

I agree somewhat on this list,but i think "Change the World" "Besame Mucho" and the semifinals version of "I Who Have Nothing" should've been on it.

[NYRambler]

I Can't Argue the Quality of the Top 10, but I feel that Mustang Sally, Virtual Insanity and Where The Blacktop Ends should've at least been Top 25

[OprahIsHawt]

The first 15 seemed off to me. I'm suprised that Blake isn't number 1. The majority of people at IDF seem to like Blake the most. I'm glad Jordin is number 1, even though I would have preferred Melinda.

[blakergirl90210]

yay go blake!!!

[underthebridgeEM]

wow... uhhh lots of blake here.... but lots of melinda too so im ok. : )

[acedup]

Hearing the over abundance of Melinda performances truley confirmed I could never listen her CD. She has one of those voices that grates on my nerves. More Chris R. less Blake for me. I hate to admit, but Besame Mucho was a great vocal. Thanks for making this.

[gtsanity]

I see a blake fan ....the boy cant sing

[imrad22]

i love the abundance of Blake in this list...

but having said that Change the World by Chris should have also been on this list... :D

[dkbif]

I think YOU GIVE LOVE A BAD NAME should have een number 1.

Can you tell I'm a Blaker-girl?!! ;-)

[selseliters]

cool list ;) haha. there were like 8 melinda performances, which was...weird i guess hehe. but what the heck, she's really good. :) jordin for the win, i'm happy she's number 1!! :D

[aprilstrawberry]

I like your list...except Blake Lewis' "you should be dancing"....I think that was the worst performance I've ever heard on idol. :/

[peddagunnu]

Bogus list. Where is Sanjaya? In my book, #1 = Besame Mucho, #2 = Bathwater, #3 = You Really Got Me

[jayDEEEEEE]

nice work!

yay Jordin at #1

[soccerplaeyr]

I agree with this list, Jordin deserves to be #1

[BostonBrigade]

Eh, I disagree. Besame Mucho was a wonderful vocal. Bathwater and You Really Got Me were kick ass performances. Phil had a couple other performances that were more unique than the Jordin-Blake-Melinda songs that dominate your list. You need to be a little more diverse in this list.

[ilovepeytonnelliott]

Only 2 Chris and Phil performances?

I dont like this "top 25"

[Kworb2]

I was gonna limit it to like 4 per contestant but Melinda is too awesome for that :P