Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (44)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Comment removed

  • This isn't Beyonce's style, but I respect her for being young, and paying homage to Barbra. Though I didn't like the performance, her look was Funny Girl inspired, and she obviously has good taste in music. :]

  • Nice try, but you can't match the One and Only. Intonation is all wrong.

  • Don't get me wrong, I like beyonce, but she shouldn't sing these kinds of songs, they just aren't for her. Her voice doesn't match! Love ya Barbra !!! ♥ No one should try to be better than Barbra.. It just wont happen, no one can beat her !! ♥

  • THE MOUTHING AND THE FILM ARE COMPLETELY OFF..

  • Beyoncee was chosen because of her obvious comparison to Barbra, A women who was thought never to have what it takes to become the pinnical of her craft.....these two women beat the odds and have risen to to the top of their profession. They are both box office power houses. Who could be Barbra's equal? Nobody.....but today Beyoncee is the closest. A minority girl with a voice and a powerful entertainment presence. Barbra's other strengths will be celebrated in other arenas.

  • Some people should just say "NO" when asked to do this kind of song and has a voice like Beyonce's... her voice type is not ment for this style of music

  • She just butchered my favorite barbra song!!! Damn it Beyonce!!! you're a great singer but some styles are just not for you

  • who the hell told beyonce to sing showtunes.....she just kiled a classic

  • @chinabby18 OMG right? this chick needs to get it straight!!! she'll NEVER be Barbra!!!

  • Guys, Barbra gave Beyonce the "Head nodd" If its good enough for Barbra fucking Streisand it should be good enough for you.

  • When I heard awhile back that they where getting Beyonce to play Barb's part in the remake of "A star is born", I cried! Beyonce can sing I give her that but she is nothing, nothing, nothing, nothing compared to Barb!!!!! Beyonce cannot act, and is an embarrassment, to women who have and appreciate thier talent! She overacts, and has to be the center of attention! I HATE HER!

  • Not that good. Kinda a boring cover. Barbra, Aretha, and Gladys all did it in there own unique way. As for Beyonce, she tried to do it just like Barbra. It was a boring cover.

  • Sie singt es gut - aber kein Vergleich zu Barbra.

  • i cant listen to any other singer ,,,BARBARA IS ALEGEND i love her sooo much i grew up with her great songs ,,,,alot of people love her in saudi arabia...bless her heart.

  • If I had been her, I'd have been a nervous wreck singing this lengends song in front of her.

    She's a brave woman, I've got to hand her that.

    Or vain enough to think she can pull it off.

  • @8mycrab Very VAIN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • i can't believe it. there is a beyonce song which actually doesn't sound good. i thought that could never happen.....

  • I don't feel like anyone could ever considered Beyonce a great singer, or even a legend. Personally, I see a disconnect there.

  • man, I think Beyonce is over rated, she should have never left Destiny's Child.

  • haha!! ummm overated my friend is when someone like britney spears who can't sing worth a dime is just everywhere!! but, whenever someone with real talent like beyonce is getting her due then she's overated?? call it what you want but, I call it justice not overated!!

  • @Beyoncefan1000 I give beyonce props for being able to sing! But no artist this generation should attempt to remake any of the "legends" via Barb's music! Beyonce cannot compete with Gladys, Barb!! She is overrated in the since that she overacts, tries to hard, has to be the spotlight "remember Destiny's Child"? Kelly Rowland was better!! Beyonce just shouldnt attempt this! She not Barb, shes just not!

  • @vinniesacura don't be mad with Beyonce just because millons of people out there realizes that she's the real deal unlike those other fake ass broads like rihanna,shitney spears,and xtina aguilera!! she's not overated; it's just that you scared that beyonce's career will bring your favorite aartist career to the ground!!

  • @Beyoncefan1000 Not once did I say that Beyonce cannot sing!Childish though the way ignrant people react to correct criticism!As I said Beyonce has an amazing voice however in my opinion takes it to the head!Its the way she acts and gives live performances as if she is better than everyone that makes me dislike her!Im not mad that she sang the song I would prefer that the movie a star is born not involve her!

  • @Beyoncefan1000 Agree Britney Rihanna cant sing!Christina n my opinion blows Ms.B away as far as vocals go!Christina is another artist who takes it 2 the head!Oh I speak 4 EVERYONE self included, opinions r like assholes everyone has 1!It takes an ignorant person 2 think that their opinion rains over every1elses I can see your educated by the way u type so how about acting like it and having a little respect for others and how they feel whining like a lil bitch that was totally uncalled for!

  • @vinniesacura I'm sorry for the rudeness and I respect your comment!!

  • @Beyoncefan1000 I get so tired of people hating on this woman. It's sad when people can't give credit, when credit is earned. I think she is the best singer EVER! She knows when to give and to take away, only perfection! I LUV BEYONCE!

  • like all the rest......adequately good version. she doesn't transcend.....but a respectable job.

  • and I would have to say, I agree...

  • she did a good job. not as well as barbra though ;)

    babs was a good sport about it. :)

  • I am getting tired of Beyonce. She sings as every single awards show and tribute show.

  • @eric251982 quit whining like a lil bitch and appreciate the fact that beyonce has the talent to do what she does best which is sanging her butt off!! atleast Legends such as Tina Turner,Diana Ross,Anita Baker,and Barbera acknowledges Beyonce as an artist who'll have longevity in the music industry!!

  • @eric251982 I hate that fat bitch Beyonce.

  • @eric251982 That's because Beyonce can actually sing live and in tune.

  • I just finished puking in the alley behind my house......I will cry Barbra's tears after my puke.....Beyonce is a good singer, but somehow managed to rape this song. I feel sorry for Beyonce and Barbra as I watch this....for Beyonce to realize that she can't sing everything and for Barbra that her song was raped.

  • first of all barbera herself picked beyonce to cover that song just in case you thought that the honerees don't have a part in picking who they want to honor them!! and for the record you're the only sick one around here so please stay in your alley and don't come out until you're better lolz!!

  • This is one of the best performances Beyonce' has done.

  • You spelled her name wrong. It is Barbra not Barbara. Just sayn'

  • it's out of sync or sth.. even looks a bit fake...

  • For some reason every clip of this performance that I've found seems to be out of sync.

  • Maybe because everytime somebody uploads it, it's from the same raw thing..

  • god bless you beyonce you made me proud to be a fan for life you are the best

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more