bakhtiar entertainment rulezzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz all .11111111111111111111111111111.persian and proud.
bakhtiar entertainment rulezzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz all .11111111111111111111111111111.
in music adam gosh mikone yade irane ghadime ba safa miofte yadesh vaghean bekheyr .... man az ruzi mitarsam ke mesle vigene aziz va hamsale ishun honarmnadhaye khob to ghorbat bemiram . man arezoo daram ghabl az marage khodam azadye irano bebinam va to khake pake iran jam bashe . payande iran va iranian aziz ( F )
To delshaadam and alike : The truth hurts ( in your case,and not everyone ) BUT IT IS THE TRUTH .
If this song is nice you enjoy it .Why should you get annoyed because it was taken from BEAME-MUCHO ? What kind of silly attitude is that. Are you a baby or mature?
آیا واقعاً امواج این صدا در آن هوای مقدّس میشود بمیرد. بوسیدن امواج این صدا محتاج سرهای عاشقان ایران، عاشقان هوای وطن، آن هوای مقدّس است. میلیونها نفر این صدا را با سر، با عقل و خرد خود در عالم تفکر نه یک بار بلکه همیشه میبوسند. و بقول سعدی بزرگ در هر نفسی که فرو میرود. مرا ببوس، برای آخرین بار که میروم بسوی سرنوشت. آخر همیشه شروع آغازی است. صدای کثافت است که با هوای ظلم و بوی گند حماقت از دهان خارج شد آخر با کود در زیر زمین دفن و همراه میشود
because the lyrics to Lalai is by Karo, Viguens brother and he wrote it just for him at a night when they were sitting alone and talking. the actual poem is much longer and Viguen sings only half of it.
I dont know how you used to sing it before it was written.
I Agree totally with CIROYOUTUB. mara-beboose is a total influenced song from BESSAME_MUCHO . And here we are talking about music not lyrics or else.Why some of you guys get down & see the reality? We are not discrediting the Persain music .
The explation from "Az1columbi " regarding Golnaraghi and D minor are both accurate .I don't undrestand how stubborn and deaf tone these other writers who claim so much knoledge of music the songs resemeblence to beseme mucho is. I have never been able to convince any of the know it all,good luck with your ignorance.
Vigen the beginning and end of an era in Iran, A SOCIETY WITH HONOUR ,SENSITIVITY AND IDENTITY has been replaced with a reality of corruption,oppression,moral decay ............
To all interested:Mara-Beboose is a highly influenced song by Besame-Mucho.which is written by pianist & songwriter CONSUELO VELAZQUEZ in 1940.Tino Rossi from France sang it in 1945.Beetles,Elvis-Presly & many major singers sang the song.Mara-Beboose was made in 1950s.Research&ducumantation shows this not my saying or my hearing.I know&researced this.Listen to Besame-mocho by Andre-Boceli singing this he has the same arrangement as Vigen.Top right Related video.You will see .
seems that the argument is taking too long, and sadly i never asked the king himself if this song was influenced by Besame Mucho. based on the research i have done so far it is not so. but i was thinking of asking the master Ataollah Khorram. what do you think?
i agree with you...there is a striking simliarity in the tempo and the octaves used....maybe the dissenters don't play instruments? im a guitarist so maybe my ears are a lil more tuned to this stuff and as you said you are a music historian which automatically trumps out everything else lol but good observation...even though i dont understand the song Besame-Mucho i just put Vigen's lyrics in!!!
@ciroyoutub I am not sure what kind of drugs you are on, but I am listening to Besame Mucho as I am typing, and there is not a grain of similarity between the two songs. The melodies are so far apart that even a monkey cannot mix them up. Instead of worthless research, just focus on the divinity of the message in lyrics by Sarhang Siamak who was sentenced to death by criminal regime of Mohammad Reza Shah
@ciroyoutub everytime I have the pleasure of listening to this beautiful song and music,and then read the ciroyoutub's comments I feel irritaded . It is nowhere nohow influnced from BEME-MUCHO.PLEASE REMOVE YOUR MISGUIDED COMMENTS.
@ciroyoutub everytime I have the pleasure of listening to this beautiful song and music,and then read the ciroyoutub's comments I feel irritaded . It is nowhere nohow influnced from BESEME-MUCHO.PLEASE REMOVE YOUR MISGUIDED COMMENTS.
Here is the translation of "Besame Mocho" You be the judge.
" Kiss, please, me Kiss me a lot , As though it was this night the last time Kiss, Kiss me a lot , As I'm afraid to be lost by you again At me you wish to be very close To look at me in your eyes To see you together with me He thinks, that's probably tomorrow I already will so far Very far from you. Kiss, please, me Kiss me a lot , As though it was this night the last time Kiss, Kiss me a lot , As I am afraid to be lost after that
@gaara1351 you somehow translated the lyrics of Bessame-Mucho and asked people to be the judge! What do you want them to judge? The discussion and dispute is about the song,THE MUSIC, of Bessame-Mucho relating to Mara-Beboose not the lyrics .I agree with CIROYOUTUB .
@gaara1351 HORRIBLE TRanslation and You are very off!!!!! Please take the many errors out of this translation. I will try to post an accurate one later. Just plain bad translation....
@ciroyoutub you are right but this is not Mara-beboos which is influenced from Besame-mocho .. i forgot the name of that song ,but vigen has another song which is 99.99% persian copy from Besame-mocho
@az1zcolumbi I agree with your version of events,as who sang this song and how widely it became so popoular,nationwide over fifty years ago. I also know that vigen took this song and westreizd it and that is where " CIROYOUTUB " is SO SO CONFUSED .Some know it all.. thanks for informed people like yourself
Eversince this song came out ,there has been numorous rumors about it's politic and now about the music.The original singer's ( Golnaragi) Music was and is in persian form. However as we know vigen's form always tend to be more westernized. even that does not sound anything,like Beseme Mucho.
Hi Yooshij:Just because you don't think Mara-Beboose is highly influenced by Besame-Mucho it doesn't make it so.Again you are being defensing like many others .I am a music historian I know what I am talking about & I don't want to insult you but get real .This doesn't mean anything against Persain music which has roots thousands of years in the past.Listen to Andre-Bocelli singing Besame-Mucho .
Part4-It should be noted that this song is sang by major number of prominent singers in the world and all of them sang it as Besame-Mucho except in Iran they took the music& called it Mara-Beboos & Iranians get annoyed when you point out the reality .Finally this is a very beautiful song listen to both songs and enjoy and don't be mad at me either I just discussed the origins of 2 songs thank you.
Part3-As you said "the artists were inspired by preceding art" Besame-Mucho was made way before Mara-Beboos and if right now you listen to Vigen singing this song & after look up on your right side at suggested songs similar (thanks to you-tub)on top you'll see Andre-Bucelli singing Besame-Mucho.I want any anyone to click that song&listen without any bias&see what I mean.Listen to both songs see if Marabeboos isn't INSPIRED"Siavash doesn't like the word COPY"
I dont think Mara -beboos and this besame - mucho song sounds anything alike.....perhaps there is a problem with your hearing buddy.....switching batteries ;-) ....Seriously i do not see any kind of resemblence......and i am not a guy who denies reality when i see it.....i have seen some pretty good iranian songs being ripped of other singers......But in this case i dont see that or should i say hear that
... Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying that the possibility of this song being copied/inspired takes away from the song itself. In fact, quite the opposite is the case.
However, I think it's important for us to recognize the roots of many persian songs that iranians perceive to be wholly of iranian origin (such as this song).
This is a great manifestation of the idea that iranian music has been heavily influenced by music outside of iran, be it the 40s, 50s, 60s, or even today ...
SiavashAtabaki - You had a very solid and convincing argument.
Prior to reading your comments, I had not heard the spanish song Besame Mucho. After listening to it, though, I have to say that I disagree with your argument (as persuasive as it was).
The rhythm and lyrics in the two songs are extremely similar - too close, I'd say, for a mere coincidence. I'm none to judge and vigen is doubtlessly fantastic, but the songs sound unreasonably close ...
This song is copied from the famous Mexican song called BESAME MUCHO ( meaning: kiss me much. ).Besame Mucho is composed in 1940 by CONSUELO VELASQUEZ. and sang by all the major singers of the world.Of course each singer singing it in thier own style. So all the rumers about the general or about the Tudeh-Party or any thing like that is only rumers.This is a very beautiful song so enjoy it .You should also listen to Besame-Mucho sang by Andre Bucelli and compare .Enjoy both songs
Part 2- Using the word copy is a giant leap confusing inspiration vs. copy. I have listened to several versions of the song Bésame Mucho (Kiss Me a Lot) by Mexican songwriter Consuelo Velázquez. Ive particularly listened to the 1940s versions of the song presumably available during the time Mara Beboos was released. I give the benefit of the doubt and assume that the musician had actually heard Bésame Mucho prior to writing Mara Beboos.
Part 3- No impartial listener can recognize anything more than the slightest hint of inspiration from one song to the other-if that. Suppose Mara Beboos was in fact inspired by Bésame Mucho. What a genius to take some inspiration and turn it into an original all-time classic! The only similarities I can detect are: both are sentimental ballads with solo piano starts and a few common words in lyrics. This is no more than inspiration.
Part 4- The fact is most art, including most that are considered original, have been inspired by some preceding art. This fact is clearly evident in all art forms- paintings, movies, architecture, music, etc. Inspiration is the jump start to artistic creativity.
Part 5- I was going to argue whos to say it actually wasnt Velázquez who was inspired by Mara Beboos to write Bésame Mucho, but after a brief research I found that in an interview Velázquez had said in writing Bésame Mucho she was inspired by a Spanish 1916 opera!
Part 6- As another observation, notice the significant difference between the lyrics. Mara Beboos's touching story vs. Bésame Mucho's short, repetitive, and even simplistic words.
Part 7 (Last part)- We may never know whether Mara Beboos was in fact inspired by Bésame Mucho or not, but what difference would that make? Enjoy both beautiful songs in all their many versions and I am sure your experience will be different on the spectrum from "I find no similarities at all" to ciroyoutub's "it's a copy".
Dear az1zcolumbi; By mentioning rumers about the song,I meant as a whole the same thing as you say.However as I mentioned Marabeboos is a true copy of Besame-Mucho.Different singers improvise the song and sing it thier style.But if you get a musician listen to both songs they'll agree with me.This song was made in 1940 by Velasquez in Mexico and is sung in all major languages including Chinese.Rumers are made easily & conveniently spreads.Enjoy the music.Good luck
hello my friend...the political rumors that are around about this song, is not about the music, is about the lyrics. they say the lyrics are by a general who was to be hanged which is not true. the lyrics are by Hale.
and you are right, the music is very close to Besame Mucho, and Viguen used to sing Mara Beboos and Besame Mucho together in his concerts, but they are not the same.
Dokhtare ziba an barghe negahe to chehre bigonahe to roshan konad shabe man ahhh mara beboos mara beboss baraye akharin bar,tora khoda negah dar ke miravam be sooye sarnevesht~ I wish you would never go for ur destiny...<3
The first thing in the lyrics is : Kiss me, kiss me, kiss me for the last time...and then he talks about he getting old and that he is past his time..
This was written by Hasan Golnaraghi for his daughter and is speaking to her, while awaiting execution in Shah's Ghasr Prison. He was one of the 50 or so high ranking military officers who were rounded up and executed by firing squad, following the CIA coup, fall of Mossadegh and Shah's replacement on the throne.
Tnx for your nice words concerning the afghan pearl Ahmad Zahir.
As a matter of fact he was killed by communists in 1978 because he was against them. And to make things worse, the Taliban blew up his tomb in 1997. Just like the had blown up all the treasures of our land (Bamyan Buddha statue etc)..
They took away every kind of cultural treasure we had.
May noone go trough the misery our country and people went trough the last 30 years.
nice,nice for ever very nice. one of my dad Song
SherkoSaschalutfulla 2 months ago
very nice
very well
my dad sing
hdeziany 5 months ago
i don´t understand a single word but i love it :D
dontobby89 6 months ago
this is real voice , this is real song , this is real singer
roxanairavani 7 months ago
En serud yek roozhaye jevunii mara be yad miyara.Khoodoyo!dige un roozo boz nemigarde.EFSOOS!
tavhid1 8 months ago
bakhtiar entertainment rulezzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz all .11111111111111111111111111111.persian and proud.
bakhtiaresfandiari 8 months ago
bakhtiar entertainment rulezzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz all .11111111111111111111111111111.
bakhtiaresfandiari 8 months ago
chord ?==== CM-FM- G7------- YEDONE Eb VASATESH HAST AHANGE BESYAR ZIBAIE ALBATE AGE KEYFIATE KHOBI DASHT MISHOD BEHTAR ACHORD HAA SHOO DAR AVORD GOOD LUCK GUYS.
13shahin 9 months ago
in music adam gosh mikone yade irane ghadime ba safa miofte yadesh vaghean bekheyr .... man az ruzi mitarsam ke mesle vigene aziz va hamsale ishun honarmnadhaye khob to ghorbat bemiram . man arezoo daram ghabl az marage khodam azadye irano bebinam va to khake pake iran jam bashe . payande iran va iranian aziz ( F )
6payam 9 months ago
delam atish migire, khateratamo talangor mizane ....:((
majidbk 11 months ago
khoda rahmatet kone vigen, ei marde bozorg....ta hamishe javedani....dar ghalbe mardom...
autali 11 months ago
To delshaadam and alike : The truth hurts ( in your case,and not everyone ) BUT IT IS THE TRUTH .
If this song is nice you enjoy it .Why should you get annoyed because it was taken from BEAME-MUCHO ? What kind of silly attitude is that. Are you a baby or mature?
parssi99 1 year ago
NAZ E NAFASET. YOU ARE FOR EVER
vartansako 1 year ago
آیا واقعاً امواج این صدا در آن هوای مقدّس میشود بمیرد. بوسیدن امواج این صدا محتاج سرهای عاشقان ایران، عاشقان هوای وطن، آن هوای مقدّس است. میلیونها نفر این صدا را با سر، با عقل و خرد خود در عالم تفکر نه یک بار بلکه همیشه میبوسند. و بقول سعدی بزرگ در هر نفسی که فرو میرود. مرا ببوس، برای آخرین بار که میروم بسوی سرنوشت. آخر همیشه شروع آغازی است. صدای کثافت است که با هوای ظلم و بوی گند حماقت از دهان خارج شد آخر با کود در زیر زمین دفن و همراه میشود
IranFaith 1 year ago
i wonder who put thumbs down??? jeeez
AssyrianKing4ever 1 year ago
@AssyrianKing4ever
probably a dirty basiji
vhemmati 1 year ago
Comment removed
delshaadam 1 year ago
Comment removed
delshaadam 1 year ago
Comment removed
delshaadam 1 year ago
@delshaadam
hi my dear friend!
what do you mean by Your song loloie??
az1zcolumbi 1 year ago
@delshaadam
Well, what your are saying is kinda strange!
because the lyrics to Lalai is by Karo, Viguens brother and he wrote it just for him at a night when they were sitting alone and talking. the actual poem is much longer and Viguen sings only half of it.
I dont know how you used to sing it before it was written.
az1zcolumbi 1 year ago
Comment removed
delshaadam 1 year ago
I Agree totally with CIROYOUTUB. mara-beboose is a total influenced song from BESSAME_MUCHO . And here we are talking about music not lyrics or else.Why some of you guys get down & see the reality? We are not discrediting the Persain music .
parssi99 1 year ago
Vigen with his perfect velvet voice will live forever!
Gregory10000000000 1 year ago
Vaghean Rohet Shad Ke Che Sedaye Delneshini Dashti Ke Adam Dardo Faramosh Mikard
995kiana 1 year ago 2
The explation from "Az1columbi " regarding Golnaraghi and D minor are both accurate .I don't undrestand how stubborn and deaf tone these other writers who claim so much knoledge of music the songs resemeblence to beseme mucho is. I have never been able to convince any of the know it all,good luck with your ignorance.
delshaadam 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Viegen yaani khaterate koodaki
Vigen yanni khatereye koochebaghhaye shemroon
Vigen yanni khaterate norooz wa sizdehbedar
Vigen yani asre tabestoon too hayat labe hoz wa khatereye madarbozorg
Vigen yani iran wa irani
WAQWAQSAHAB 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Viegen yaani khaterate koodaki
Vigen yanni khatereye koochebaghhaye shemroon
Vigen yanni khaterate norooz wa sizdehbedar
Vigen yani asre tabestoon too hayat labe hoz wa khatereye madarbozorg
Vigen yani iran wa irani
WAQWAQSAHAB 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Viegen yaani khaterate koodaki
Vigen yanni khatereye koochebaghhaye shemroon
Vigen yanni khaterate norooz wa sizdehbedar
Vigen yani asre tabestoon too hayat labe hoz wa khatereye madarbozorg
Vigen yani iran wa irani
ESMALLPANJOOL 1 year ago
Vigen the beginning and end of an era in Iran, A SOCIETY WITH HONOUR ,SENSITIVITY AND IDENTITY has been replaced with a reality of corruption,oppression,moral decay ............
arzoyan 1 year ago 14
@arzoyan ...don't forget terrible pop music
busessuck1 1 month ago
This amazingly beautiful song/music expresses so much about the Iranian people and its quest for a world of freedom
arzoyan 1 year ago 8
I agree fully with ciroyoutub, Mara Beboose is totally influenced by Bessame-Mucho.
parssi99 1 year ago
That is very ver goooooooooooooooooooooooooooooood..
Iran4001 1 year ago
رفته است.......دستهایم که هیچ...دیگر سوسوی چشمهایم هم اورا نخواهد یافت
nimaazdk 1 year ago
Me too. Zendeh bad IRAN. Rohet shad Vgen Aziz.
zorrro1967 1 year ago
many memories ... i cry each time listen to this song :=( .
WineRedX 1 year ago 2
Comment removed
ciroyoutub 2 years ago
Comment removed
delshaadam 1 year ago
I listened to Besame mucho, I did not find any similarity !
shahinpar 2 years ago
I agree with your conclusion. The only similarity might be the sound of horn.
delshaadam 2 years ago
To all interested:Mara-Beboose is a highly influenced song by Besame-Mucho.which is written by pianist & songwriter CONSUELO VELAZQUEZ in 1940.Tino Rossi from France sang it in 1945.Beetles,Elvis-Presly & many major singers sang the song.Mara-Beboose was made in 1950s.Research&ducumantation shows this not my saying or my hearing.I know&researced this.Listen to Besame-mocho by Andre-Boceli singing this he has the same arrangement as Vigen.Top right Related video.You will see .
ciroyoutub 2 years ago
Hi my dear friend..
seems that the argument is taking too long, and sadly i never asked the king himself if this song was influenced by Besame Mucho. based on the research i have done so far it is not so. but i was thinking of asking the master Ataollah Khorram. what do you think?
i will let you know his answer!
az1zcolumbi 2 years ago
i agree with you...there is a striking simliarity in the tempo and the octaves used....maybe the dissenters don't play instruments? im a guitarist so maybe my ears are a lil more tuned to this stuff and as you said you are a music historian which automatically trumps out everything else lol but good observation...even though i dont understand the song Besame-Mucho i just put Vigen's lyrics in!!!
persianprideeliar 2 years ago
Comment removed
delshaadam 1 year ago
@ciroyoutub I am not sure what kind of drugs you are on, but I am listening to Besame Mucho as I am typing, and there is not a grain of similarity between the two songs. The melodies are so far apart that even a monkey cannot mix them up. Instead of worthless research, just focus on the divinity of the message in lyrics by Sarhang Siamak who was sentenced to death by criminal regime of Mohammad Reza Shah
RadicallyHonest 1 year ago
Comment removed
delshaadam 1 year ago
Comment removed
delshaadam 1 year ago
@ciroyoutub everytime I have the pleasure of listening to this beautiful song and music,and then read the ciroyoutub's comments I feel irritaded . It is nowhere nohow influnced from BEME-MUCHO.PLEASE REMOVE YOUR MISGUIDED COMMENTS.
delshaadam 1 year ago
@ciroyoutub everytime I have the pleasure of listening to this beautiful song and music,and then read the ciroyoutub's comments I feel irritaded . It is nowhere nohow influnced from BESEME-MUCHO.PLEASE REMOVE YOUR MISGUIDED COMMENTS.
delshaadam 1 year ago
Here is the translation of "Besame Mocho" You be the judge.
" Kiss, please, me Kiss me a lot , As though it was this night the last time Kiss, Kiss me a lot , As I'm afraid to be lost by you again At me you wish to be very close To look at me in your eyes To see you together with me He thinks, that's probably tomorrow I already will so far Very far from you. Kiss, please, me Kiss me a lot , As though it was this night the last time Kiss, Kiss me a lot , As I am afraid to be lost after that
gaara1351 10 months ago
@gaara1351 you somehow translated the lyrics of Bessame-Mucho and asked people to be the judge! What do you want them to judge? The discussion and dispute is about the song,THE MUSIC, of Bessame-Mucho relating to Mara-Beboose not the lyrics .I agree with CIROYOUTUB .
parssi99 10 months ago
@gaara1351 HORRIBLE TRanslation and You are very off!!!!! Please take the many errors out of this translation. I will try to post an accurate one later. Just plain bad translation....
docsocal31 9 months ago
@ciroyoutub you are right but this is not Mara-beboos which is influenced from Besame-mocho .. i forgot the name of that song ,but vigen has another song which is 99.99% persian copy from Besame-mocho
morti453 6 months ago
well, it seems that we have a big argument about this song and it might be my mistake for not putting enough info about the song!
the original version was:
performed by Hasan Golnaraghi
composed by Majid Vafadar
lyrics by Heydar Reghabi (Hale)
Violin by Parviz Yahaghi
Piano by Moshir Homayoun Shahrdar
Enjoy!
az1zcolumbi 2 years ago
@az1zcolumbi I agree with your version of events,as who sang this song and how widely it became so popoular,nationwide over fifty years ago. I also know that vigen took this song and westreizd it and that is where " CIROYOUTUB " is SO SO CONFUSED .Some know it all.. thanks for informed people like yourself
delshaadam 1 year ago
Eversince this song came out ,there has been numorous rumors about it's politic and now about the music.The original singer's ( Golnaragi) Music was and is in persian form. However as we know vigen's form always tend to be more westernized. even that does not sound anything,like Beseme Mucho.
delshaadam 2 years ago
They dont sound the same at all. Some dude thinks they sound the same, and he is free to to think what he wants.
Leroyjohnson124 2 years ago
Comment removed
delshaadam 2 years ago
Hi Yooshij:Just because you don't think Mara-Beboose is highly influenced by Besame-Mucho it doesn't make it so.Again you are being defensing like many others .I am a music historian I know what I am talking about & I don't want to insult you but get real .This doesn't mean anything against Persain music which has roots thousands of years in the past.Listen to Andre-Bocelli singing Besame-Mucho .
ciroyoutub 2 years ago
Strange! I was going to mention that this song is similar to Besame mucho. Then I am not the only one who thinks that.
afshin1977 2 years ago
Comment removed
delshaadam 2 years ago
Part-1- This is in response to SiavashAtabaki in reference to Mara-Beboose&Besame-Mucho.
ciroyoutub 2 years ago
Part4-It should be noted that this song is sang by major number of prominent singers in the world and all of them sang it as Besame-Mucho except in Iran they took the music& called it Mara-Beboos & Iranians get annoyed when you point out the reality .Finally this is a very beautiful song listen to both songs and enjoy and don't be mad at me either I just discussed the origins of 2 songs thank you.
ciroyoutub 2 years ago
Part3-As you said "the artists were inspired by preceding art" Besame-Mucho was made way before Mara-Beboos and if right now you listen to Vigen singing this song & after look up on your right side at suggested songs similar (thanks to you-tub)on top you'll see Andre-Bucelli singing Besame-Mucho.I want any anyone to click that song&listen without any bias&see what I mean.Listen to both songs see if Marabeboos isn't INSPIRED"Siavash doesn't like the word COPY"
ciroyoutub 2 years ago
I dont think Mara -beboos and this besame - mucho song sounds anything alike.....perhaps there is a problem with your hearing buddy.....switching batteries ;-) ....Seriously i do not see any kind of resemblence......and i am not a guy who denies reality when i see it.....i have seen some pretty good iranian songs being ripped of other singers......But in this case i dont see that or should i say hear that
yooshij 2 years ago
Soothing........
Gregory10000000000 2 years ago 2
... This is important for iranians to realize .
Hoomanmohammadi76 2 years ago
... Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying that the possibility of this song being copied/inspired takes away from the song itself. In fact, quite the opposite is the case.
However, I think it's important for us to recognize the roots of many persian songs that iranians perceive to be wholly of iranian origin (such as this song).
This is a great manifestation of the idea that iranian music has been heavily influenced by music outside of iran, be it the 40s, 50s, 60s, or even today ...
Hoomanmohammadi76 2 years ago
SiavashAtabaki - You had a very solid and convincing argument.
Prior to reading your comments, I had not heard the spanish song Besame Mucho. After listening to it, though, I have to say that I disagree with your argument (as persuasive as it was).
The rhythm and lyrics in the two songs are extremely similar - too close, I'd say, for a mere coincidence. I'm none to judge and vigen is doubtlessly fantastic, but the songs sound unreasonably close ...
Hoomanmohammadi76 2 years ago
my dear friend...they are both in D minor...any two songs in the same position could sound the same, but they are not.
Enjoy
az1zcolumbi 2 years ago
Comment removed
delshaadam 2 years ago
yad va khaterye in honarmande geranghadr gerami bad
sadafeQuagmire 2 years ago
Allah yerhamak ( Khoda be rahmat shoma )
bastech2 2 years ago
u are no 1 for ever
the best of best
aivensimonian 2 years ago
Ciroyoutub, cool it!
Just because both Consuelo and Hossein say "Kiss me" does not make it a copy.
You want a definition of a copy research Joe Satriani's "If I Could Fly" and Coldplayy's "Viva la Vida".
az1zcolumbi, motchakeram baraye post'etoon, na nadare!
Then we can talk.
StrsimirK 2 years ago
This song is copied from the famous Mexican song called BESAME MUCHO ( meaning: kiss me much. ).Besame Mucho is composed in 1940 by CONSUELO VELASQUEZ. and sang by all the major singers of the world.Of course each singer singing it in thier own style. So all the rumers about the general or about the Tudeh-Party or any thing like that is only rumers.This is a very beautiful song so enjoy it .You should also listen to Besame-Mucho sang by Andre Bucelli and compare .Enjoy both songs
ciroyoutub 2 years ago
Part 1- This is in response to comment by ciroyoutub declaring This song is copied from the famous Mexican song called BESAME MUCHO.
YouTube has a 500-character limit in postings, so I had to break up my comments into a few parts.
SiavashAtabaki 2 years ago
Part 2- Using the word copy is a giant leap confusing inspiration vs. copy. I have listened to several versions of the song Bésame Mucho (Kiss Me a Lot) by Mexican songwriter Consuelo Velázquez. Ive particularly listened to the 1940s versions of the song presumably available during the time Mara Beboos was released. I give the benefit of the doubt and assume that the musician had actually heard Bésame Mucho prior to writing Mara Beboos.
SiavashAtabaki 2 years ago
Part 3- No impartial listener can recognize anything more than the slightest hint of inspiration from one song to the other-if that. Suppose Mara Beboos was in fact inspired by Bésame Mucho. What a genius to take some inspiration and turn it into an original all-time classic! The only similarities I can detect are: both are sentimental ballads with solo piano starts and a few common words in lyrics. This is no more than inspiration.
SiavashAtabaki 2 years ago
Part 4- The fact is most art, including most that are considered original, have been inspired by some preceding art. This fact is clearly evident in all art forms- paintings, movies, architecture, music, etc. Inspiration is the jump start to artistic creativity.
SiavashAtabaki 2 years ago
Part 5- I was going to argue whos to say it actually wasnt Velázquez who was inspired by Mara Beboos to write Bésame Mucho, but after a brief research I found that in an interview Velázquez had said in writing Bésame Mucho she was inspired by a Spanish 1916 opera!
SiavashAtabaki 2 years ago
Comment removed
SiavashAtabaki 2 years ago
Part 6- As another observation, notice the significant difference between the lyrics. Mara Beboos's touching story vs. Bésame Mucho's short, repetitive, and even simplistic words.
SiavashAtabaki 2 years ago
Part 7 (Last part)- We may never know whether Mara Beboos was in fact inspired by Bésame Mucho or not, but what difference would that make? Enjoy both beautiful songs in all their many versions and I am sure your experience will be different on the spectrum from "I find no similarities at all" to ciroyoutub's "it's a copy".
SiavashAtabaki 2 years ago
Comment removed
delshaadam 1 year ago
5*****
polopolak 2 years ago 2
Thats 25 stars
Amirnake 2 years ago 3
Dear az1zcolumbi; By mentioning rumers about the song,I meant as a whole the same thing as you say.However as I mentioned Marabeboos is a true copy of Besame-Mucho.Different singers improvise the song and sing it thier style.But if you get a musician listen to both songs they'll agree with me.This song was made in 1940 by Velasquez in Mexico and is sung in all major languages including Chinese.Rumers are made easily & conveniently spreads.Enjoy the music.Good luck
ciroyoutub 2 years ago
Comment removed
ciroyoutub 2 years ago
hello my friend...the political rumors that are around about this song, is not about the music, is about the lyrics. they say the lyrics are by a general who was to be hanged which is not true. the lyrics are by Hale.
and you are right, the music is very close to Besame Mucho, and Viguen used to sing Mara Beboos and Besame Mucho together in his concerts, but they are not the same.
Enjoy...
az1zcolumbi 2 years ago
Aaw I love this song, my dad used to sing it to me every night when I was a kid.
leylMZZ 2 years ago 14
manam harvaght in ahango gosh midam mese alan hamash geryam migire mano yade mamanam mindaze
nsdap1365 1 year ago
har vaght in ahango goosh mikonam boghzam mitarake.........bozorgtarin hedieye ma PEDAR
ninatrendy 2 years ago 8
Comment removed
snr1231 2 years ago
Comment removed
snr1231 2 years ago
Comment removed
snr1231 2 years ago
Dokhtare ziba an barghe negahe to chehre bigonahe to roshan konad shabe man ahhh mara beboos mara beboss baraye akharin bar,tora khoda negah dar ke miravam be sooye sarnevesht~ I wish you would never go for ur destiny...<3
wildcatme25 2 years ago
i love this song but i soo wish i knew wat the lyrics ment :[
ararat426123 2 years ago
Comment removed
MEHRANTOUFANI 2 years ago
The first thing in the lyrics is : Kiss me, kiss me, kiss me for the last time...and then he talks about he getting old and that he is past his time..
yarre123 2 years ago
if my memory allows me to remember correctly the song was written for his daughter befroe he was executed.
306310h 2 years ago
yes you are right
beautyful song
bigmoosavi 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
This was written by Hasan Golnaraghi for his daughter and is speaking to her, while awaiting execution in Shah's Ghasr Prison. He was one of the 50 or so high ranking military officers who were rounded up and executed by firing squad, following the CIA coup, fall of Mossadegh and Shah's replacement on the throne.
snr1231 2 years ago
thte one and only king of persian rock .bless his soul
agheli 2 years ago 3
the taliban didn't even exist when AZ was killed...
the communists did kill hi ;)
Majam88 2 years ago 2
oh, i am really sorry, i do not know why did i make that mistake.
You are right!
God bless his soul.
az1zcolumbi 2 years ago
Salut to this greatness.. !!!
This Afghan brother (AWM) is proud of you brilliant Iranian singer.
You are one who gives me the same feeling as Ahmad Zahir (afghan's pearl).
Very very nice.. talented person. TOP !!!
AWM
awm001 2 years ago 2
I know All of Ahmad Zaher's songs...
He is the Viguen of Afghanistan...almost the same style, brought something new and has sang more than 300 songs...
Sometimes i wonder how would it be if Taliban did not kill him..
Peace.
az1zcolumbi 2 years ago
Dear bro,
Tnx for your nice words concerning the afghan pearl Ahmad Zahir.
As a matter of fact he was killed by communists in 1978 because he was against them. And to make things worse, the Taliban blew up his tomb in 1997. Just like the had blown up all the treasures of our land (Bamyan Buddha statue etc)..
They took away every kind of cultural treasure we had.
May noone go trough the misery our country and people went trough the last 30 years.
Best regards..
AWM
awm001 2 years ago 3
Proud of him. He is brilliant, beyond briliance!! 1000000 thanks. rohesh shad.
sedabram 2 years ago 2
Khoda tora negah dar
keh meravam besuyeh sarnevesht ...
BAH BAH I love this song so much.
check9264 2 years ago
it is like i know this song for 1000 yrs
ashkan16 2 years ago 2
man ham tora miboosam baraye abad
golisade 3 years ago 4
King of Persian Music
rivaldoamir 3 years ago
roohet shad
benzalibaba 3 years ago
hezar rahmat be rohe pake shadrawan vigen....
trkosh 3 years ago 3
1000 THANKS, I LOVE IT
EDWARDBADAL 3 years ago 2
this is extremely nice however nothing replaces the original by golnaraghi
pupushkapumpuska 3 years ago 3
pushka!
Cosmos0 2 years ago
bedoone to zendegi kheili sakhteh
ruhat shad
baryanpour 3 years ago 3
rouhete shad vigen.
jasmina8219 3 years ago 3
seda va avazash dar tarikh mosighi iran javedane ast va mano be yad salhayi javani va
shore asheghi miandazad.!
kabotar1234 3 years ago 5
Be yaad oon Shaba to "DarBand"
Peymaster13 3 years ago 5
Be yaad oon Shaba to "DarBand"
Peymaster13 3 years ago 3
be yaad oon Shaba to "Darband"
Peymaster13 3 years ago 3
akheey khoda rahmatesh kone
m63a999 3 years ago 5
Khoda Bebakhshesh Vigen janeh.
Afg388 4 years ago
Thanks
Ferhat2535 4 years ago