The reminds me of when it was used as background music in a Monty Python sketch...then it turned out to be a phonograph on the seashore that kept skipping.
I wish somebody that goes there would do a recording of the actual sounds made by the waves at the location so we can compare the inspiration to the final product.
They're masterpieces: musical composition--and cave! This overture has probably been the best visitor calling card for a landscape anywhere. People want to experience perhaps a bit what Mendelssohn went through--
Yes, I was a bit disappointed when I went for the first time, just last summer, the sea was as flat as anything! Was a beautiful day though, virtually cloudless
Some cynic once called this wonderful description of the journey to Staffa in an open boat "the best musical description of sea-sickness". You feel the waves lifting you up and down and the boat rocks hard when a short, steep wave hits it.
My wife and I did the trip in a motor launch from Iola years ago- we shal never forget.
Yes I made the trip myself this summer - the sun was high, the sky almost cloudless, the sea like a mirror. I almost wish it had actually been more stormy as in Mendelssohn's depiction!
@thelightisahead nice to read that. We took off from Iola, it was end of July and some kids were in the water- fully clothed! Maybe for fun or because the water was so cold.
The sky was full of towering white clouds, a stiff breeze was blowing and the boat danced up and down the waves. Our skipper must have been a magician, he steered a course almost parallel to the big waves, and not a single drop of water came over its sides. Nevertheless we did not dare going into the cabin just in case...
Well worth going to see. Very interesting boat trip over and the caves themselves were absolutely amazing. Not long back. I would definately recommend a visit.
Can you guys remember what it was like to be 21 and then think of writting music like this at that age???? Wow!!! Thank God some people have such talent so the rest of us mere mortals can enjoy it for years to come.
The conductor is fabulous and has such a great touch with tempo - a lot of conductors like to really slow down wherever the orchestration gets thin, not realizing that it thins the piece out TOO much, and that Mendelssohn has written it in such a way that it needs very little tampering on the part of the conductor. (Or at least that's my opinion.) This conductor seems to really respect Mendelssohn's work and just allow the piece to flow in its natural, organic form. Brava!
We've played it for contests. It's a rather enjoyable piece, one I enjoyed greatly. Our teacher was to the point of tearing his hair out with us...But yet, we pulled it off quite well for a high school orchestra.
can anyone tell me where exactly the pictures where taken, used in the video? I'm thinking about going to the hebrides and just stumbled upon this, making me very curious
yea our high school orchestra played this...butchered it, our teacher wasnt as devoted as we were. it sucked. I loved it though, personally i was able to play it. =]
Great isn't it :) amazing he wrote it when so young! (though ofc it was revised later). You have a very interesting channel, I like it! I see you like Greensleeves, always good to know a fellow worshipper of that timeless melody XD actually I wrote 16 variations on it because it's so great :p
Hehe, ah it's nothing that special. I just wish I knew the first thing about harmony, counterpoint etc. so I could compose properly! Do you ever write music?
Thank you for the track and the lovely accompanying photos. I hope you will include tne name of the performers in future descriiptions of your postings. The Long Beach Symphony is a professional orchestra. But this is the kind of piece also played by what are called "community orchestras" in the USA. That is an orchestra made up of players of all levels and ages who reharse and perform for firends, family, and the local community. It's a wonderful place to learn how to play in an ensemble.
I love this song, we're playing the original version of it in Orchestra class. It IS rather hard...Obviously, with all the runs. But if done with the right dynamics and right notes, we can sure sound like a professional orchestra. (: I hope so!!!!
And wonderful images, I would like to see Fingal's Cave whenever I can travel.
This conductor must have had a date after the concert, so was speeding up some parts ;-). The "uptempo-version" gives a new view of this piece. more water, less stone...
Magnificent, stirring music, and beautiful photography.
Thank you for uploading this, @thelightisahead.
quizman1967 6 months ago
The reminds me of when it was used as background music in a Monty Python sketch...then it turned out to be a phonograph on the seashore that kept skipping.
Sylderon 10 months ago
I wish somebody that goes there would do a recording of the actual sounds made by the waves at the location so we can compare the inspiration to the final product.
sgtredbluered 1 year ago
0:30 - I've been there! That's Port of Ness isn't it?
WonkyTonkBotty 1 year ago
@WonkyTonkBotty
Really can't remember to be honest!
thelightisahead 1 year ago
They're masterpieces: musical composition--and cave! This overture has probably been the best visitor calling card for a landscape anywhere. People want to experience perhaps a bit what Mendelssohn went through--
windstorm1000 1 year ago
@windstorm1000
Yes, I was a bit disappointed when I went for the first time, just last summer, the sea was as flat as anything! Was a beautiful day though, virtually cloudless
thelightisahead 1 year ago
and of coruse theres one jackass out there who has to ruin it by disliking the song
kshin882002 1 year ago
Written 1830, revised and then premiered in 1832 in London...Mendelssohn died in Leipzig in 1847 from a series of strokes; he was only 38 years old.
dirtyratmiller 1 year ago
Some cynic once called this wonderful description of the journey to Staffa in an open boat "the best musical description of sea-sickness". You feel the waves lifting you up and down and the boat rocks hard when a short, steep wave hits it.
My wife and I did the trip in a motor launch from Iola years ago- we shal never forget.
Jeansschwimmer 1 year ago
@Jeansschwimmer
Yes I made the trip myself this summer - the sun was high, the sky almost cloudless, the sea like a mirror. I almost wish it had actually been more stormy as in Mendelssohn's depiction!
thelightisahead 1 year ago
@thelightisahead nice to read that. We took off from Iola, it was end of July and some kids were in the water- fully clothed! Maybe for fun or because the water was so cold.
The sky was full of towering white clouds, a stiff breeze was blowing and the boat danced up and down the waves. Our skipper must have been a magician, he steered a course almost parallel to the big waves, and not a single drop of water came over its sides. Nevertheless we did not dare going into the cabin just in case...
Jeansschwimmer 1 year ago
I'm off to see Fingal's Cave tomorrow! :D
thelightisahead 1 year ago 4
this song is giving me goosebumps
cyberk25 1 year ago
Thank you for posting this. A great gift for such a short time of this man.
Psyche777able 1 year ago
Well worth going to see. Very interesting boat trip over and the caves themselves were absolutely amazing. Not long back. I would definately recommend a visit.
HazelAgnes48 1 year ago
woow, is awesome music
BUKO158 1 year ago
Absolutely one of the best pieces of music ever - some nice pics too.
TheWall2000 1 year ago
It's a semi-tone lower than a Berlin recording!
bratwurstle 2 years ago
Can you guys remember what it was like to be 21 and then think of writting music like this at that age???? Wow!!! Thank God some people have such talent so the rest of us mere mortals can enjoy it for years to come.
I would love to see that cave once in my life....
GabrielKish 2 years ago 9
I know! And Schubert in his 18th year wrote a symphony, over 140 songs and other stuff besides!! I've got a lot of catching up to do ;) hehe
thelightisahead 2 years ago
@GabrielKish You really should. I've been there this summer and it's Magnificent with a capital M.
snipperbes 5 months ago
The conductor is fabulous and has such a great touch with tempo - a lot of conductors like to really slow down wherever the orchestration gets thin, not realizing that it thins the piece out TOO much, and that Mendelssohn has written it in such a way that it needs very little tampering on the part of the conductor. (Or at least that's my opinion.) This conductor seems to really respect Mendelssohn's work and just allow the piece to flow in its natural, organic form. Brava!
flutenerd 2 years ago 2
In the last edition of National Geographic magazine there is an article about Hebrides, if anyone is interested ...
vladotepesh 2 years ago 3
Got it! Great pics in the mag....that's why I'm looking for travel about it on youtube...
salm37 2 years ago 2
Its a wonderful piece of music. Thanks for this.
j0andc0 2 years ago 2
Wow! Great playing from Long Beach! Thanks for posting this.
sliphorn88h 2 years ago 2
hey there dude, are u British or American ??? xoxo
dudychicken 2 years ago
British! Well, English technically ;) hehe
thelightisahead 2 years ago
My orchestra will be playing this piece in September, and I am so excited!
branquela82 2 years ago 2
We've played it for contests. It's a rather enjoyable piece, one I enjoyed greatly. Our teacher was to the point of tearing his hair out with us...But yet, we pulled it off quite well for a high school orchestra.
I wish you luck. :3
HylianTwilight 2 years ago
can anyone tell me where exactly the pictures where taken, used in the video? I'm thinking about going to the hebrides and just stumbled upon this, making me very curious
H0ndje 2 years ago
I'm afraid I don't know, I found the pictures merely by using Google Image Search :S
thelightisahead 2 years ago
@H0ndje if your wanting to go to Staffa, you can get a days boat trip from Oban on the main land and you also go to Iona.
rachybaby13 1 year ago
@H0ndje A few around Staffa, but the standing stones were definitely from Calanish on the west coast of the Isle of Lewis.
Inquisitor53 1 year ago
yea our high school orchestra played this...butchered it, our teacher wasnt as devoted as we were. it sucked. I loved it though, personally i was able to play it. =]
bigalex6393 2 years ago 6
who performed this recording?
elmmegan 2 years ago
Hi, it was JoAnn Falletta and the Long Beach Symphony Orchestra
thelightisahead 2 years ago
I love this.
ladynightwatchman 2 years ago
Great isn't it :) amazing he wrote it when so young! (though ofc it was revised later). You have a very interesting channel, I like it! I see you like Greensleeves, always good to know a fellow worshipper of that timeless melody XD actually I wrote 16 variations on it because it's so great :p
thelightisahead 2 years ago
thank you!! yes, I love Greensleeves.
16 varations!!! Wow, that's incredible :D
ladynightwatchman 2 years ago
Hehe, ah it's nothing that special. I just wish I knew the first thing about harmony, counterpoint etc. so I could compose properly! Do you ever write music?
thelightisahead 2 years ago
goodness no, I could never do that!!! admire you for doing it though, it's great :D
ladynightwatchman 2 years ago 2
Hehe, thanks, well, it keeps me busy!
thelightisahead 2 years ago
Thank you for the track and the lovely accompanying photos. I hope you will include tne name of the performers in future descriiptions of your postings. The Long Beach Symphony is a professional orchestra. But this is the kind of piece also played by what are called "community orchestras" in the USA. That is an orchestra made up of players of all levels and ages who reharse and perform for firends, family, and the local community. It's a wonderful place to learn how to play in an ensemble.
BeBopElmo 2 years ago
I love this song, we're playing the original version of it in Orchestra class. It IS rather hard...Obviously, with all the runs. But if done with the right dynamics and right notes, we can sure sound like a professional orchestra. (: I hope so!!!!
And wonderful images, I would like to see Fingal's Cave whenever I can travel.
HylianTwilight 2 years ago
You should post a video .. good luck trying to get a high school orchestra to sound completely like a professional orchestra. :P
ThaSchwab 2 years ago
genial
ANTONIOJOSEGONZALEZG 2 years ago
I love this piece!
Pianist1991 2 years ago
This piece is amazing! I'm playing a modified version on piano, but the full orchestral piece is fabulous :)!
daisychain2409 2 years ago
Yes, so descriptive! I love the rushing cellos near the start being like the waves going up and down :)
thelightisahead 2 years ago
This conductor must have had a date after the concert, so was speeding up some parts ;-). The "uptempo-version" gives a new view of this piece. more water, less stone...
nichtraucherbus 3 years ago 2
who is this recording done by?
da2ndlevyashin 3 years ago
Hey, it's by JoAnn Falletta and the Long Beach Symphony Orchestra, from a disc entitled 'Impressions of the Sea'. Quite an aptly named orchestra!
thelightisahead 3 years ago
JoAnn Falletta and the Long Beach Symphony Orchestra
thelightisahead 2 years ago
@thelightisahead I like Ms. FAlletta---she broke down the old boys composers club. Also was conductor for my old home town, Milwaukee Sym. Orchestra
windstorm1000 1 month ago