Added: 2 years ago
From: LiloOfficial
Views: 193,177
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (1,066)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • haha what a joke

  • Its actually not that bad. I thought it would be a lot worse. Good Job, Lindsay!

  • gave it a chance nicks beats it in every way so that is what I will listen to.

  • Its alot better than I thought it would be ..... I still think she should dye her hair back to red .... She is way sexy !!!

  • she sounds like shes having an orgasm fucken try hard.

  • It is a hard song but she isnt hitting the high notes she is going a little lower

  • Lindsay wasn't trying to be better than Stevie lol. It's a COVER.

  • Did she sing this song during an orgasm?

  • 690 Dislikes cause your Jealous!

  • Hi everybody.  I have an opinion. Ok, bye!

  • Guys seriously, chill out. its not that bad, And im not even a fan of Lindsay Lohan...

  • Its better than I though it was gonna be lol...still prefer the original though

  • Its not bad wtf

  • This is horrible! I'm frikken 14 and I know Stevie Nicks is much better than this!!! Stevie Nicks all the way!!!

  • shit she destroy a beatifull song, fuck u lindsay lohan u sucks bitch

  • @Cessate I have my opinion, you have yours, so saying that I'm "blantantly" false is, well, false, since opinions can't be. Also, it sounds pleasing /to you/, vocal ranges are good /to you/, and yeah she's hitting the notes, but I've never liked her voice. All I'm saying is, the original is exponentially better in my taste.

  • what the hell is this this is awful stevie nicks's version is so much better this is just horrible she sounds like she is pain and its autotuned up the ass

  • wow. i didnt know she could sing D:

  • LOL. YOU FAIL, LINDSAY.

  • compared to the covers I've heard, this one is decent.

  • i'd like to hear her and bieber do a cover of "leather and lace"

  • ´Buaaahshshjshsjhshhshshsjhshs­hsjshhshsgsg!!!

  • HATEHATEHATE.

    Well.. the song is fantastic, and the cover/thing, isn't that bad... but Lohan... HATEHATEHATEHATEHATE.

  • I hope Nicks sued her for copying and mutilating this song!

    But this happens when a pop-singer covers a rock-song, because of an lack of creativity to write good songs on her own!

    DISLIKE!

  • @Austria002 dolly parton sang "i will always love you" before whitney houston. does that make whitney talentless and uncreative?

  • @curlygirly729

    Houston is definitely not talentless. She had much more talent than lohan ever could have. By the way: "I will always love you" from houston is vastly better than lohans "Edge of Seventeen" - cover. But houston wasnt a pop, but a soul-singer anyway. Thats quite another matter.

    Covering a song is a sign of a lack of ingenuity, not a lack of talent.

    A cover can even be better than the original (for example Smoke on the Water). But in lohans case, the cover is crap.

  • @Austria002 since when is covering a song is a sign of ingenuity? it is paying tribute to an artist. so many singers do covers in live concerts as well as on their own albums. lohan did ONE cover, but all of the others songs on her album are original. why is it so wrong to do a cover of a song you love and an artist you admire? you may as well call whitney houston, celine dion, carrie underwood, etc ingenuous then

  • Obviously not even comparable to Stevie Nicks, but this is way better than I expected.

    No matter how good a cover is, when a pop singer covers a classic rock song, people automatically hate it. They don't even bother listening to it.

  • She sounds like Miley Cyrus.

  • @Cessate Covers are fine, as long as they're you know... Good. This isn't. See where I'm going with this? >.>

  • @PrincessLunaFTW And how is this not good exactly? Her singing is perfectly fine, she's hitting the notes and vocal ranges pretty damned good. The music for the song has always been simple, and remains as such in this song.

    On top of all that, it actually sounds pleasing. I have little respect/like for Lohan, but this song is by every means of the word, good.

    Do you personally like it? Clearly not. But to claim the song as a whole is bad it blatantly false. Get of the bandwagon

  • i dont think this is a bad cover, her voice is great, and she looks beautiful in that pic. maybe its js something ppl get used to. theres those songs we say we hate originally but then like more and more with time. maybe this is one of those cases

  • @nevananinja it could be one of those songs, but its not lol the original was great, and if the cover was even remotely good, i would support it because the lyrics are what matter. but...i mean come on.....are we listening to the same song? lol

  • @guns1809 everyones got their tastes i guess

  • listened to this for 16 seconds, 16 seconds too long!

  • Actually, I like this. It's like someone below me said: As good as Stevie? No, but it's not horrible. Plus, she looks fairly beautiful in this picture.

  • Comment removed

  • what the fuck...

  • well done!!!

  • @steviehful your joking right?

  • @countrymusicgtavboy2 you bet!!

  • Quit yer yapping, this isn't a bad cover. As good as Stevie? No, but not bad.

  • don't like this cover... but i like her singing voice.

  • I don't think she's ready, fo' this jelly

  • YOU HAVE ******GOT***** TO BE KIDDING ME. IF YOU CAN'T HANDLE IT, DON'T EVEN TRY TO ATTEMPT IT. What a TWIT.

  • I thought it was a good cover, bit of an upbeat version. Dont get why so many people dislike it

  • she fucked up the ooh part! da fuck is this?

    

  • i like this version AND the original. i know, shock, horror, dismay.

  • Comment removed

  • This makes me sick to my stomach - I cannot believe she thinks she can sing this song - who does she think she is - and then she wants to portray Stevie in a movie - wtf? This pisses me off beyond belief - need to turn the sound down so I can't hear - many artists would probably be flattered to hear their song done by another artist, but this is not only not flattering, but not in good taste, horrible and an insult to Stevie - I can bet money on it!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • If you guys would take off your nostalgia goggles you would realize this cover isn't bad.

  • This song is seriously missing backing vocals, that is mainly why, in my humble opinion, it's not as good as the original... but its not that bad afterall...

  • she songs this song very well :)

  • this is such a disgrace to musical history.....

  • the tempo of the music sucks

  • Its not THAT bad, but its not as good as stevie nicks..my opinion

  • this is shit. i looked at this to laugh at this in comparison - its just sad it doesnt have the power that stevie nicks does.

  • come on assholes ....really ....its not that bad

  • @jmw122 ik shes hot and ppl hate on her pft

  • @jmw122 it's not, but usually there is nothing better than the original tune from Stevie

  • @jmw122 i love it!

  • Why the hell did I even click on this...

  • @SnakeBiteHearrt i'm asking myself the same question. I don't know what came over me.

  • lindsay lohan sucks compared to original

  • This is only good cause she's hot... and she makes it sound like she's getting fucked while singing this

    nothing else

  • Comment removed

  • Stevie Nicks should shoot her...

  • You children are aware that in order for an artist to do a cover, spoof, or anything of another; they need they acceptance of said artist they're covering, right? Clearly Nicks, or people who represent Nicks allowed this too happen. And you know, it's not that bad at all. As someone said in a few comments down; a cover doesn't mean it has to be the EXACT same as the original. Lohan, as much as I dislike her, managed to do the song in general justice, with her own sense of flair.

  • @Cessate while i accept that your argument is, from my point of view, infallible, the abundance of logic confuses, frightens, and encourages me. keep it up.

  • @Cessate actually you don't need approval to do a paradoy. just clearing it up since you think you are mr facts.

  • @safetydancer87 no, if you are going to record a cover song and put it on a cd, and then sell those cds for a profit, you need to get permission so the original artist gets paid their proper royalties. so why don't you check your facts first

  • @safetydancer87 I have nothing new to reply with that @curlygirly729 hasn't already told you. But I will say that there is a vast difference between a parody and a full on cover.

    Weird Al does parodies. Takes an already written song, and changes the lyrics (and sometimes instruments) to turn it into something comedic. But even then, the same rules about permission apply.

  • I think it's good. Call me crazy.. but it's a cover. Cover's don't have to sound anything like the original. And I dislike Lindsey Lohan.. however I found this quite respectable.

    All of you need to get out of your grumpy chairs and accept the fact that while yes, she is a different genre.. it's not bad. It's different. Just enjoy the damn music. I'm PRETTYY sure Lindsey isn't trying to be better than Stevie by singing ONE of her songs.

  • ergo is latin for therefore

  • ...the music is not even the same effing beat ergo harrogee is so right its not even funny.

  • im sorry you CANNOT cover stevie nicks

    this makes me hate her even more..

    i REFUSE to sing this song cause i could never do her justice

  • Okay, I'm not a huge Lohan fan and Stevie Nicks definitely did it better (no question about that), but Lohan didn't do a terrible job at this song :\ I think she got pretty close and it's not like she completely butchered the song. She still made it pretty badass, even if she's not on the same level as Nicks.

  • lol pretty nice try

  • Aw, c'mon, cut a break > I'ts not bad at all.

  • Boa tentativa mas Stevie Nicks fez esta musica perfeitamente então qualquer tentativa é inutil.

  • ok, she did a pretty kick ass job for not being in the same genre as stevie...dont hate on her..there has been a lot worse covers then this

  • EAR TRASH. Don't fuck with Stevie Nicks <3 

  • @hugboat808 She fucked with Stevie,she needs the death penalty for this!

  • I saw this in the related videos and thought "No... this can't be. They've got to be sh*tting me." I wish they had been sh*tting me...

  • That's why I don't like music of these days...

  • Pure awful.

  • Ew...she ruined this. The original is 8937598739869 times better.

  • synthesized and autotuned and this still is terrible lol....

  • @ramatirthadasa no, just no.

  • @vipersrt10x well if you can do better,sing it!

  • @ramatirthadasa

    oh gosh you must be hard of hearing.

  • i think that this is a better way than the others

  • You definatly cant beat an original, but this cover isnt THAT bad, i still personally wouldnt buy it but no bad lol

  • Surprisingly solid cover albeit straightforward in interpretation. I prefer covers that diverge from the original. Listen to "Wild Horses" by The Rolling Stones, covered by The Sundays. The original is a rock classic. The cover not only does it justice but offers an ethereal quality not found in the original.

  • are you kidding me.

  • Autotune? Yeah... subtle

  • This is supposed to be an emotional song, not a cheap skanky song.

  • this is the better version as stevie nicks !! love it <3

  • @Lulij8636

    die in hell!

  • ewww she needs to go back to prison for murdering this song

  • cara dura, copiarle un tema asi a otra cantante, y bueno seguro tampoko le deve dar mucho la cabeza

  • @BCArchimago no la copio,es un cover de la original!En ningun momento dijo que era tema de ella..todos hacen covers

  • @Thebittersweetboy Entonces que lo aclare

  • its nice that she chose a good song, but jesus christ she butchered it

  • lindsay lohan fucked up stevie nick's master piece

  • @damoonstar912 I agree.

  • yeaaaahhhhh that awkward moment when she trys to sing this song :/ uhmmm yehh not working for you lvv, completely destroyed this song, why is that any good rock song a flippin chav has to sing it grrrrrrrrrrr

  • not even in the same league. not even close.

  • LMAOO I THOUGHT SHE WAS HAVING AN ORGASUM

  • Its nice that she choose this song, i respect that but its just not working for her...!

  • She should have her artistic license revoked.

  • it was ok.... I kinda liked it, but nobody can do it like Stevie. Its a close second, but you know what they say... 2nd place is just first loser. Nice try.

  • I love this!~

  • I knew This song was Going To Get Aloy of hate

  • and Stevie ROCKS THE HELL outTTA this SONG!!!! It's on my phone listen to it in the gym ALL THE TIME, BADDASS

  • she definitely does NOT have Stevie's edge, she doesn't have a rock edge at all, this is fail but I admire her paying tribute to Stevie Nicks, this isn't terrible but this isn't ROCKING IT and Stevie ROCKS IT :-) to be quite honest, Lindsays song "confessions/daughter to father" whatever was the title got stuck in my head a few years ago, it was really GOOD, so give credit where it's due, but let Stevie do Stevie cause only Stevie can do Stevie the way Stevie does Stevie :-)

  • SHIT

  • wow are you serious you are just as bad at singing as you are at acting !

  • do not cover amazing classic songs if you cant rock it !

  • friday is better than this. 

  • I think this pic is very unflattering, but she doesn't sound awful. I'll admit she's no Stevie Nicks, but this is a pretty decent cover in my opinion. (Don't even say I'm some pop groupie who doesn't know what she's talking about. I've actually listened to a lot of Stevie Nicks and Fleetwood Mac, and I do think they are better than Lindsay, so no flames)

  • TERRIBLE. REALLY AWFUL

  • She makes it too sexual. This song is not meant to be that way.

  • Damn, this is awful....

  • Sorry.... This really is quite poor.

  • Great actress, can't sing Stevie Nicks songs. Not eveyones perfect

  • The instrumental is kinda nice, but her vocals are way off and not strong enough. The music seems to drown her out. Nice try but not good enough. :/

  • barf! I still love stevie nicks more that any other girl n ima 35 yro white boiiiiiii:) ps she has a turkey beard hahahehe

  • Was I the only one to click the link "Would you like to report this video as inappropriate?"

  • @thielees I did, and clicked "Promotes Terrorism" based on the comments.

  • Worst... cover... ever.

    (Comic book guy)

  • not bad

  • It's funny Cause a Coke head Covered a Coke Head!

  • Train wreck.

  • hahahahahahahaha drunk karaoke is always halarious

  • you know its bad when she says "my own" insteady of "mione"

  • hahahaha, NO

  • Wow....That was fucking sad.

  • Nowhere near as good as the StevIe Nicks original but as far as covers go i've heard alot worse. It's an alright effort.

  • she is really good, but stevie nicks is better by ALOT thumbs up if you agree

  • ...i love steve, she is the oirignal and th ebest..but come on guys let's not be harsh on Lindsa; I dont think she did bad

  • i like it...

    NO

    WHAT A FAIL VERSION

  • STIVIE NICKS IS BEST

  • I hate to criticize anyone's singing, since I can't sing to save my life, but she should stick to singing teeny bop pop instead of ruining a great song...

  • It would be better if she didn't sound like she was having sex the whole time. White-winged doves don't sound like their touching themselves.

  • @ColdHeartedRose1 aaahahahhahahahahahahahhahahha­hahahahahahhahah thats hilarious1!!!!! oh my goshh! i saw your comment and i almost died lafing! oh my god! hhahaahahh

  • @ColdHeartedRose1 I thought it sounded like she was trying to pinch a loaf.

  • oh my God.

  • get out of here. OH WAIT U ALREADY DID THAT

  • she cant sing this song for shyt but id fuck her brains out

  • this is horrible

  • She sounds exactly like Miley Cyrus. I can't hear anybody else.

  • nuh, this just doesn't cut it.

  • Omg....I cant believe she did this -__________-

    She has NOTHING on stevie.

  • She's got a sexy voice but not for this! Stevie is just...WAY better!

  • ooomy godd this sucks

  • Lindsay,, OMG! i want to eat you anyway baby,, cmon,, let it happen! you can sing all you want while i slide my thoughts into your ass!! mmmmmmm!!

  • "the voice of a choir"... sure, Lindsay LOL

  • Why no one cut her throat????? This is not a pornstar song!!!!

  • umm...well...it coulda been worse...but it coulda been A LOT better! D:

  • more like edge of a cocaine pile

  • @Ryanjoe090 ROFLMFAO!! so true

  • @Ryanjoe090 wrong...but I can't stop laughing...;)

  • @Ryanjoe090 HAHAH BEAUTIFUL

  • Poor Stevie :'(

  • The dove is no longer white winged after this

  • It's actually not that bad. don't be so rude.