I am also French and I understand every word (which is not always the case with French singers). I have also seen her on stage and it's certainly the best Carmen I have ever seen.
Oh my god she is horrible. As a French speaker I can't understand most of the words she is saying. There is more to singing than just hitting the right notes!
it's a miracle in musical history that bizet put all his incredible talent in his few works. bravo agnes baltsa, james levin, and all the performers with metropolitan opera
Yes, absolutely terrific. Maria Ewing Grace Bumbry and Julia Migenes - I also like these three more than other famous Carmens - but Agnes Baltsa is ABSOLUTELY
Absolutely a terrific Carmen, great voice, great acting chops, the work. Baltsa is one of my favorite Carmens along with Grace Bumbry, Maria Ewing and Julia Migenes Johnson. The Deutsche Grammophon studio recording of Carmen with Baltsa and Carreras is simply electrifying!
I dont know why but seeing people who are such talented dancers always makes me cry.... its just so beautiful to see that expression through movement!
shes very powerful, the chesty low B and then the nice high G# at 3:38 are beautiful. Its kind of funny though, shes totallyl ike, guessing where those tambourine hits shes playing go, the one at the end is like, such an obvious mess up haha
Tengo que decir algo, no escuché hasta ahora, una Carmen como Baltsa, Como arrastra la voz, es interesantísimo lo que hace, como si hablara como si gitaneara el habla de Carmen, el canto. GENIAL
Espectacular y maravillosa Carmen la Baltsa, una voz perfecta y potente combinada con un buen desempeño escénico reflejado en la psicología del papel en esta producción.
rsklav i agree with u but it would be better to have her to ur side.but just forget it i now she have a lot of work.i'd like go visit her one day(if she can speak greece and haven't forget them;)
Dioas Mío! No conocía a esta mezzo soprano...Acabo de escucharla y todavía estoy temblando, completamente impactada! K VOZ INCRIBLE! El color, la potencia...es MAGICA!!!!
Impresionante versión. Muy bien Agnes, magnífica coreografía. Hermosa la música de Bizet (y eso que no era español) y muy buena la orquesta. Envidio a los que fueron al MET esa noche...
I think the way she dances isnt sensual enough for Carmen, plus she should have learnt to pronounce french better, cause you really get the feeling she doesnt understand the text perfectly
LonelyElle what a thing to say. Her french is wonderful you need to listen to it and you also need to listen to her spoken French. watch the opera in its entirety. She is very sensual and sexy with her French. She is Greek and if anyone understands Carmen in is Agnes Baltsa.
no solo por la calidad de su voz; sino por la forma en encara el personaje y nos hace ver a la verdadera carmen; Agnes Baltsa se vuelve una de las mas grandes interpretes de carme; admas las producciones de MET Opera siempre son geniales.
Excellent - this always leaves me craving more. Baltsa is my all-time favourite mezzo; I don't think that anyone else has that 'tang' in their voice. I don't think that I'd like to see her do Carmen now, however, she has developed into the most amazing Klytamnestra in Elektra - if you like Baltsa, this is a must!!
PS - has anyone noticed one of the dancers making a faux-pas at 4:40/1? Poor thing!
@Otellogv i know that poor lady but she handled it very professionally! she got o the ground at the same time as the others... I could only tell after looking for it several times:-)
Carmen es una opera qeu laegra y llega al alma. Por mas ignorante que uno sea en cuanto a la musica clasica, es pieza de arte le llega y gusta a todo el mundo. Que maestro Bizet
Myra Merritt teaches at Bowling Green State University. That's where I go to school for vocal performance. She's the nicest lady EVER! She's so sweet. She doesn't sing anymore though :( She hasn't done a faculty recital since 2001.
It's very interesting to hear what some of these singers do now. I found another clip of her singing in L'italiana in Algeri with Marilyn Horne on here. Ironically, she is with Diane Keslng again!
If you guys looking for these certain opera DVD's live in the New York City area, go to the Metropolitan Opera shop located inside the Met Opera House at Lincoln Center. They have all types of operas, especially those done at Lincoln Center. Also, get this DVD of Carmen with Jose Carreras and Agnes Baltsa. She is so perfect in this part!
Maria Kallas was Greek... Baltsa is Greek... I'm so proud to be Greek!
mapage7 1 month ago
sounds interesting even i dont understand
genovevatrimarchi 2 months ago
She`s a perfect Carmen.
Rospaint 3 months ago in playlist Opera
I am also French and I understand every word (which is not always the case with French singers). I have also seen her on stage and it's certainly the best Carmen I have ever seen.
Tusson07 3 months ago
she is amazing! this is an excellent performance.
ahoire 3 months ago
Oh my god she is horrible. As a French speaker I can't understand most of the words she is saying. There is more to singing than just hitting the right notes!
DeanAMacd 4 months ago
@DeanAMacd I'm also French and I understand perfectly what she says. Something must be wrong with your ears.
Rachegotter 3 months ago
Brava Agne Mpaltsa
nonnopirro52 4 months ago
it's a miracle in musical history that bizet put all his incredible talent in his few works. bravo agnes baltsa, james levin, and all the performers with metropolitan opera
lincolnyu 5 months ago
@CorporalHicks7 for sure it is.
lincolnyu 5 months ago
She's not terribly sexy in this role. It comes across a bit like Carmen as "drill sergeant".
trschaefer 6 months ago
Esto es lo que me hace sentir que vale la pena YouTube.
This is the reason why i think YouTube is great!
titatus08 7 months ago
Yes, absolutely terrific. Maria Ewing Grace Bumbry and Julia Migenes - I also like these three more than other famous Carmens - but Agnes Baltsa is ABSOLUTELY
TERRIFIC.
Rospaint 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
É o êxtase, conheço quem tenha o DVD desta ópera, e ADORO.
MIRPAO 7 months ago
É o êxtase, conheço quem tenha o DVD deste ópera, e ADORO.
MIRPAO 7 months ago
where can I find this performance sub in spanish?
TheAndres209 7 months ago
Absolutely a terrific Carmen, great voice, great acting chops, the work. Baltsa is one of my favorite Carmens along with Grace Bumbry, Maria Ewing and Julia Migenes Johnson. The Deutsche Grammophon studio recording of Carmen with Baltsa and Carreras is simply electrifying!
OperaMystery80 7 months ago
I have this version on DVD. she is one of the most passionate Carmen I've seen!
StardustValentine 11 months ago
Carmen!!!
cotufagu 11 months ago
Excellent video.
coreygallai 1 year ago
Thats why Carmen is a role for mezzos and not for sopranos!!
spyridon77 1 year ago 3
definitly one of the best performances of Carmen I´ve heard. Love her!
Feantur1 1 year ago 3
non solamente assolutemente estaspatucar, ma anche really Nice Stuff!
8269998 1 year ago
This performance is what got me into Opera ^.^ Of course I didn't see it live but on laserdisc... but still Agnes Baltsa has an amazing voice!
scarebear83 1 year ago
Strong and manly Carmen.Her performance let me guess meaning of live.
kiyomi012 1 year ago
She IS Carmen!
Lindoron 1 year ago 2
Agnes!
mooremw 1 year ago
perfect french !!!
2loperadeparis 1 year ago
I dont know why but seeing people who are such talented dancers always makes me cry.... its just so beautiful to see that expression through movement!
Babs22h 1 year ago
Agnes Baltsa-is multiorgasmus in Carmen
yukka8violin 1 year ago
I adore how well Balta expresses Carmen's mischievous and flirtatious personality, and on top of that she has an excellent voice!
BaccioDiMaschera 1 year ago
Magnifique!!She has a powerful voice!
Fetosh07 1 year ago
shes very powerful, the chesty low B and then the nice high G# at 3:38 are beautiful. Its kind of funny though, shes totallyl ike, guessing where those tambourine hits shes playing go, the one at the end is like, such an obvious mess up haha
skitzo429 1 year ago
MAGNIFIQUE INTERPRETATION
marianne6427 1 year ago
Baltsa una gran personalidad,y Carmen tambien!!! Brava!
pharaohwood 1 year ago 3
she has a good voice and I really loved the interpretation, but I really dislike such exaggerated vibrato.
BringinSexyBach 2 years ago
i dont think i would call it exagerated, not any more so than most operatic mezzos
skitzo429 1 year ago
Please - maybe you have some video or cd from her Fedora? And also Santuzza - on stage, in Vienna?
Thank You!
Greetigs from Russia.
RosebaThePainter 2 years ago
just love love Baltsa, great performance!
Phersephoie 2 years ago 2
la voce della baltsa è adatta all verismo e nella carmen da il meglio di se
luigipavabartolotti 2 years ago
the best.W Agnes
luigipavabartolotti 2 years ago 2
Me encanta Baltsa en este papel, la tenia en CD, ahora veo el video y me aumenta el aprecio.
davinken 2 years ago
genial!!!
chillerbanane 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Vocally she can certainly sing the part. As an actress, however, it's a little COLD.
trschaefer 2 years ago
Tengo que decir algo, no escuché hasta ahora, una Carmen como Baltsa, Como arrastra la voz, es interesantísimo lo que hace, como si hablara como si gitaneara el habla de Carmen, el canto. GENIAL
Anibaal 2 years ago 2
Pues te diré...
coreliandude76 2 years ago
bueno decime, he escuchado carmenes y abundan las cantantes prolijas. Baltsa pone cierto verismo en esta parte. hablo de esta parte.
Anibaal 2 years ago
No... no me convence. Pero cada quien sus gustos.
coreliandude76 2 years ago
Absolutamente espectacular!
titatus08 2 years ago 21
quelle voix superbe ,un timbre si faccille à reconaitre at une technique magnifique!
Diana.
dianacroitoriu 2 years ago 8
My favorite part of the opera! Way to go Agnes Baltsa!
AmadeusMozart99 2 years ago 3
Espectacular y maravillosa Carmen la Baltsa, una voz perfecta y potente combinada con un buen desempeño escénico reflejado en la psicología del papel en esta producción.
rigcelli 2 years ago
my favourite rendtion of this song is sung by geraldine farrar, recorded in 1912 or so. she was born in 1881 or so lol
blackhoumor 2 years ago
Agnes Baltsa, la mejor Carmen que he visto y escuchado...!!!
IngeFlordeLoto 2 years ago
VERY NICE 5 STARS ☆☆☆☆☆
ErikaRagazzi 2 years ago 2
yes she is a mezzo soprano.i heard that from my sister who have met her in france
mpaltsas96 2 years ago
rsklav i agree with u but it would be better to have her to ur side.but just forget it i now she have a lot of work.i'd like go visit her one day(if she can speak greece and haven't forget them;)
mpaltsas96 2 years ago
I wish I could sing like Agnes Baltsa. She's fantastic!
novice1959 2 years ago 2
Dioas Mío! No conocía a esta mezzo soprano...Acabo de escucharla y todavía estoy temblando, completamente impactada! K VOZ INCRIBLE! El color, la potencia...es MAGICA!!!!
eskapulita 2 years ago
Una de mis versiones preferidas de Carmen es la de Julia Midgenes...Inceríble voz y gran actuación!
eskapulita 2 years ago
ripped from the DVD?
voldemort2123 2 years ago
Wonderful singing!
mpaltsas96,
you're damn lucky to have a grandmother like her!
rsklav 2 years ago
yes it's true
mpaltsas96 3 years ago
how long now seen her on greece.when i born she wasn't there to see me.
mpaltsas96 3 years ago
if you can see my profil is mpaltsas u now she's from greece and she's my grandma
mpaltsas96 3 years ago
Is this a Bulería?
Y2H 3 years ago
I wonder if Anna Netrebko will ever do Carmen?
MRDEREVKO 3 years ago
Ive been wondering the same thing! She really is the best one for the role right now!!
Y2H 3 years ago
She never will becoz shes a soprano while Carmen is a mezzo-soprano.
Y2H 3 years ago
Your completely right, I had forgotten, Shame! she would make a wonderful Carmen.
MRDEREVKO 3 years ago
Yes. It is really rare to find a beautiful woman playing Carmen, which really is irritating!
Y2H 3 years ago
I jes read she was a mezzo-soprano.
Akee1990 2 years ago
فن ... رائع ... فن ... جميل.. فن ... مدهش ...
Agnes Baltasa
Bravooooooo
SaifRiyadh 3 years ago
Good voice but not enough passion.
profling 3 years ago
My favorite Carmen by far!
MakoThunderbird 3 years ago 4
Mine too!
LaMostraESopra 3 years ago 2
carmen should be sexy... i saw a very very good version 1 or 2 years ago ... but i cant find it T_T
wunderwald 3 years ago
You...don't...think...she's...sexy. I'm stunned. You've proved it - there is no accounting for taste.
Caoilfhoinn 3 years ago
Impresionante versión. Muy bien Agnes, magnífica coreografía. Hermosa la música de Bizet (y eso que no era español) y muy buena la orquesta. Envidio a los que fueron al MET esa noche...
solensegunda 3 years ago
great, amazing ,so sexy
adamsoul 3 years ago
Baltsa migliore Carmen di sempre!
LeonardoEulero 3 years ago 2
I think the way she dances isnt sensual enough for Carmen, plus she should have learnt to pronounce french better, cause you really get the feeling she doesnt understand the text perfectly
LonelyElle 3 years ago
LonelyElle what a thing to say. Her french is wonderful you need to listen to it and you also need to listen to her spoken French. watch the opera in its entirety. She is very sensual and sexy with her French. She is Greek and if anyone understands Carmen in is Agnes Baltsa.
NART65 3 years ago 2
Also Herbert von Karajan said that.
Aetion 3 years ago
Baltsa had the perfect voice for Carmen
MarquisDePosa53 3 years ago 32
great, amazing
baikalkim 3 years ago
It's amazing....wow!
Santuzza01 3 years ago
no solo por la calidad de su voz; sino por la forma en encara el personaje y nos hace ver a la verdadera carmen; Agnes Baltsa se vuelve una de las mas grandes interpretes de carme; admas las producciones de MET Opera siempre son geniales.
Luisopo123 3 years ago
perfect!
mikisfun 3 years ago 2
perfect!
mikisfun 3 years ago 2
Excellent - this always leaves me craving more. Baltsa is my all-time favourite mezzo; I don't think that anyone else has that 'tang' in their voice. I don't think that I'd like to see her do Carmen now, however, she has developed into the most amazing Klytamnestra in Elektra - if you like Baltsa, this is a must!!
PS - has anyone noticed one of the dancers making a faux-pas at 4:40/1? Poor thing!
Otellogv 3 years ago 3
@Otellogv i know that poor lady but she handled it very professionally! she got o the ground at the same time as the others... I could only tell after looking for it several times:-)
Babs22h 1 year ago
great voice
smiljianic 4 years ago
Great voice!!! but when speaking about performance on stage I prefer Maria Ewing´s version of Chanson Bohéme
Nuncamuere 4 years ago
Carmen es una opera qeu laegra y llega al alma. Por mas ignorante que uno sea en cuanto a la musica clasica, es pieza de arte le llega y gusta a todo el mundo. Que maestro Bizet
alwox 4 years ago 2
Nice choreography, great opera!
GREAT VIDEO!
singinginachurch 4 years ago
Myra Merritt teaches at Bowling Green State University. That's where I go to school for vocal performance. She's the nicest lady EVER! She's so sweet. She doesn't sing anymore though :( She hasn't done a faculty recital since 2001.
bowgrefal 4 years ago
It's very interesting to hear what some of these singers do now. I found another clip of her singing in L'italiana in Algeri with Marilyn Horne on here. Ironically, she is with Diane Keslng again!
Otellogv 4 years ago
If you guys looking for these certain opera DVD's live in the New York City area, go to the Metropolitan Opera shop located inside the Met Opera House at Lincoln Center. They have all types of operas, especially those done at Lincoln Center. Also, get this DVD of Carmen with Jose Carreras and Agnes Baltsa. She is so perfect in this part!
hotwriter36 4 years ago
Met shop is too expensive compared to others like virgin records. Even better is buying online at Amazon. You will save a lot in price and get more.
gtelloz 3 years ago
However, one can steal in perfect conditions at the MET shop. There's only a couple of very old ladies selling and virtually no security.
dntpntr 3 years ago
Does anyone out there have a video of her O don fatal from Don Carlo at the Met? The most exciting performance of the role I'd ever seen or heard!
protopresvyter 4 years ago
yeah..I was looking for that too... thei already had it on youtube but it was taken away due to the copyright....
creidhe 4 years ago
It´s still here on youtube. Search it under "O don fatale".
I´ve found it 5 minutes ago.
canzonettasullaria 4 years ago
thanks!! they must have put it back on....
creidhe 4 years ago
love it post more if you can
dancingprincessmj 4 years ago
who plays the frasquita and mercedes?
hillevifan 4 years ago
Frasquita: Myra Merritt
Mercedes: Diane Kesling
ManonLes88 4 years ago
LOVE it!, Love her!! =)
This was my first opera!, the one (and the singer) that made me dream about this wonderful world!
Thanks Manon... =D*
LaBelleHelene 4 years ago